Key Takeaways
- Capex is the story, not the quarter: Q2 was a low-price, high-cost trough. The 0.1 crore ton expansion, due by June 2024, promises a 25–30% production cost cut and a path to ₹900–1,000/ton EBITDA, a structural reset that dwarfs near-term noise.
- FIFO accounting masked the fuel tailwind: Pet coke costs fell in recent months, but Q2 consumed inventory bought at the peak, while cement prices hit a seasonal low. Management expects Q3 to reflect the lower input cost, improving margins even before the capex benefit arrives.
- Solar is a high-ROI, self-funded margin lever: A 3 MW addition to the captive solar plant uses existing land and infrastructure, is entirely supplier-financed over 4–5 years, and sells power at ₹6.80–7/unit, directly boosting profits.
- Capacity utilization is stuck in a margin trap: The plant runs at only 63–64% because high production costs prevent the discounts needed to sell more. Management argues the capex breaks this loop, not a sales pilot today.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Q3 margin improvement from lower FIFO-layer pet coke materializes as promised, and any update on the loan rate re-pricing from the current 10.45%.
The Capex Reset: Cost Structure & Timeline
- The core problem: The kiln consumes ~1,100 kilocalories per ton versus an industry standard of ~700, a gap of 400 kilocalories that, at ₹1.60 per kilocalorie, costs roughly ₹600–650 per ton in excess fuel alone. Power and limestone are the other two legs of the 90% cost base, but fuel is the variable that breaks competitiveness.
- The fix: The 0.1 crore ton expansion replaces the inefficient kiln, targeting a 25–30% production cost reduction. Management expects this to lift EBITDA to ₹900–1,000 per metric ton, up from current levels, and expand the margin to around 35–36%.
- Timeline and shutdown: All major equipment (95%) is ordered; civil work is on track. A 20–25 day interconnection shutdown is planned for the beginning of the rainy season (June 2024), with clinker inventory built to keep grinding and dispatches running. Commercial production starts July 2024.
- Post-commissioning ramp: FY25 will be a transition year: Q1 runs old capacity, Q2 faces teething issues, so management expects subdued 50–55% utilization and a top line of roughly ₹175–200 crores or above. The full benefit scales after that.
- Funding: An ₹80 crore term loan from Canara Bank is sanctioned, with ₹15 crore disbursed by September 30. Management expects the interest rate to fall 50–60 bps from the current 10.45%, with clarification due in a couple of weeks.
Katwa: "So that huge difference is only because our fuel consumption is around 1,100 kilocalories per ton, opposed to industry standard of 700 kilocalories. So that saving of 400 kilocalories at a cost of INR1.60 per kilocalories, we'll save around 600 kilocalories to 650 kilocalories just on fuel consumption."
Q2 Performance & the FIFO Distortion
- Price vs. volume: Dispatches rose 7% YoY, but cement prices fell 2–3% YoY, reflecting the seasonal monsoon trough. A price hike implemented at end-October is already benefiting the current month.
- FIFO masking the turn: Pet coke prices declined over the last 3–4 months, but because the company uses FIFO accounting, Q2 consumed inventory purchased at the highest cost. The combination of peak input cost and trough selling price compressed margins artificially.
- Q3 margin tailwind: Assuming the same sales quantity as Q2, management states Q3 results will be "much better" as the lower-cost pet coke layer flows through the P&L, even before the capex benefit.
- H2 demand outlook: Demand normally picks up post-monsoon; management expects the second half to be "more opportune for healthy expansion in financial performance." With prices rising and EBITDA margins improving, the company can offer discounts and push utilization higher.
Katwa: "So Q2 typically showed the results where cement pricing is the lowest because cement pricing is shown on the Q2 results as it is. Whereas the consumption of raw material is depending on FIFO method."
Solar Power: The Silent Margin Engine
- Current position and addition: The captive solar plant currently stands at 37 MW; the Government of Karnataka last week approved an increase to 40 MW. The 3 MW addition uses existing land, transmission lines, and infrastructure, yielding a high ROI at a selling price of ₹6.80–₹7 per unit.
- Why only 3 MW: Available land within the existing plant premises limits the addition. Expanding further would require changing transformers and additional government clearances, which would forfeit certain existing incentives.
- Funding structure: The solar expansion is entirely funded by suppliers, with payment spread over 4–5 years, requiring no upfront capital from the company.
- Post-expansion power allocation: Once the 0.1 crore ton cement capacity comes online, the cement plant will consume most of the solar power. The company will either stop selling externally or supply only 4–5% to the grid.
- EBITDA contribution: The existing solar plant is a key reason management claims "one of the highest EBITDAs per ton of cement in the industry," with the H1 FY24 EBITDA margin at 31.68%. The 3 MW addition is expected to boost profits further.
Market & Brand Strategy
- Existing geography is enough: Current sales territory (South Maharashtra, Goa, North Karnataka) can absorb the full 0.1 crore ton capacity once deeper retail penetration is achieved. If needed, the improved EBITDA margin post-capex makes it viable to reach larger markets like Pune and Bangalore.
- Sales infrastructure build-out: The company will hire more sales and marketing people, create new departments to reach the smallest retail points, and work with consultants on a broader plan covering retail expansion, institutional buyers, and government bulk orders. Significant marketing and sales promotion starts three months before commissioning.
- The brand leap: Crossing the 0.1 crore ton threshold moves the company into "Tier 2 branding," where pricing is better. Management plans to invest in brand equity and hire top-notch consultants to support the transition.
- Demand backdrop: India's per capita cement consumption is expected to reach ~150 kg by 2028–2030, against a world average of ~500 kg, providing a long runway. Cement remains a key product for infrastructure.
Historical Context & Execution Risk
- The 2008–2014 struggle: The company's biggest setback came after purchasing a cement plant that had been shut for 25–30 years. The old kiln consumed 1,500–1,600 kilocalories and 200 units of power per ton; many modifications over the years brought it down to the current ~1,100. The capex is the final step to reach industry-standard efficiency.
- Utilization ramp precedent: When capacity was last expanded from 0.01 to 0.03 crore tons (2016–17), it took about 1.5 years to reach 63–65% utilization. The same ramp patience applies to the new capacity.
- No near-term equity dilution: Management has no current plan to infuse capital via rights or market issuance in the next six months.
Katwa: "So most of our failures came in 2008 to 2014 when we struggled with the project with the old kiln very high, extremely high. Today we are talking about 1100 kilo calories but there was a time when we were consuming around 1500 to 1600 kilo calories. Even the power we were consuming 200 units per ton. But that is all the past."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Cement expansion commissioning | 0.1 crore ton capacity commercial production start | July 2024 |
| Production cost reduction | Cut by 25–30% from current levels | Post-capex commissioning |
| EBITDA per ton target | ₹900 to ₹1,000 per metric ton | After capex |
| EBITDA margin target | Increase to around 35–36% | With capex benefit |
| Q3 margin improvement | "Much better" results vs Q2, assuming same sales quantity | Q3 FY24 |
| Solar capacity addition | 3 MW added to existing 37 MW plant | Approved; timeline per supplier funding schedule |
| Loan interest rate | Reduction by 50–60 bps from 10.45% | Clarification expected in "a couple of weeks" |
| FY25 revenue expectation | ~₹175–200 crores or above, at 50–55% utilization | FY25 (transition year) |
| Marketing and sales promotion launch | Significant push begins | Three months before commissioning (~March 2024) |
| Equity dilution | No rights or market issuance planned | Next six months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹25.76 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹7.95 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 30.84% |
| H1 FY24 EBITDA | ₹18.22 cr, comparable to H1 of previous year |
| H1 FY24 EBITDA margin | 31.68% |
| H1 FY24 net profit | ₹2.75 cr |
| H1 FY24 net profit margin | 4.78% |
| H1 FY24 EPS | ₹1.84 |
| Revenue mix: cement | ~77% of revenue |
| Revenue mix: solar and other | ~23% of revenue |
| Cement capacity utilization (H1) | ~63% |
| Cement dispatches growth | ~7% YoY |
| Cement price change | down 2% to 3% YoY |
| Cement price hike (October) | ₹300 to ₹400 per ton |
| Solar plant capacity | 37 MW, permission received to increase to 40 MW |
| Solar power selling price | ₹6.80 to ₹7 per unit |
| Cement expansion project cost | ₹125 cr, ₹46 cr raised via preferential allotment |
| Cement expansion timeline | June 2024 expected commissioning |
| Loan sanctioned for capex | ₹80 cr, ₹15 cr disbursed as of Sep 30 |
| Interest rate on loan | 10.45%, expecting reduction of 50-60 bps |
| Expected post-expansion EBITDA per ton | ₹900 to ₹1,000 |
| Expected post-expansion top line (FY25) | ₹175 cr to ₹200 cr and above |
| Expected post-expansion EBITDA margin | ~35% to 36% |
| First-year post-expansion utilization target | 50% to 55% |