Key Takeaways
- Cement pricing crushed margins: Realization fell ~10% YoY, pushing cement EBITDA negative and overall EBITDA margin from ~32% to 12.44%; solar was the only reason the company stayed EBITDA-positive.
- New capacity is built but idle: Civil and mechanical work finished October 3rd, but commissioning waits on a government 110 kV power line delayed 6-8 months, now expected mid-December.
- Management held FY26-27 EBITDA guidance: ₹80-90 crores FY26 and ₹120-150 crores FY27, but only if prices recover; at current ₹3,300 realization, FY26 EBITDA would be ~₹60 crores.
- The balance sheet has breathing room: ~₹90-95 crores of depreciation carry-forward means only 15% MAT for 4-5 years, and solar cash flows are covering expenses while cement bleeds.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the government substation actually arrives by mid-December, whether cement prices lift off the September floor, and whether the 15-day kiln tie-in shutdown disrupts Q4 dispatches.
The Margin Collapse: Cement Pricing vs Solar Support
- Price-volume mismatch: Dispatches rose 10-11% YoY in H1, but net realization dropped from ₹3,480 in Q1 to ₹3,290 in Q2, fully offsetting the volume gain and pushing cement EBITDA negative.
- Pricing floor called: Management believes prices plateaued by early September and that this is the bottom beyond which no cement plant can operate; Q3 has shown stabilization or a slight uptick but no meaningful recovery yet.
- Solar as the lifeline: Solar delivered ~₹7 crores EBITDA in Q2 and ~₹14 crores in H1, keeping overall EBITDA at ₹11.11 crores while cement was negative; solar cash flows are covering other expenses.
- Margin recovery bet: If analyst-predicted price increases to ₹3,700-3,800 materialize in Q4, EBITDA margins could return to ~30% as soon as Q4 FY25; if prices stay at ₹3,300, margins stay at ~12%.
- Cost-side relief emerging: Pet coke prices reduced slightly in October after being stable in Q2, with a downward trend over the last two months; raw material costs had otherwise remained intact or risen with inflation.
Katwa: "So, even in spite of having this kind of bad pricing, it is the solar which is making sure that cash is building up to take care of all other expenses."
Capacity Expansion: Built, But Waiting on a Power Line
- Project complete, externally blocked: All civil and mechanical work for the new plant finished by October 3rd; the 110 kV government power line from Chandragutti Bhanu Station, originally due 6-8 months ago, is now expected mid-December.
- Workaround in play: The company is discussing increasing capacity on the existing 33 kV line to run the entire plant if the substation slips further.
- Commissioning timeline: Management expects to start new capacity from Q4 FY25, with full ramp-up by January 2025 contingent on power availability; FY26 will be the first full year with the new capacity operating.
- 15-day shutdown planned: A 15-day shutdown is needed to hook up the new kiln; enough clinker stock has been built to avoid dispatch disruption.
- Kiln utilization gap: Current kiln capacity is 0.18 crore tons but only 0.1 crore tons of cement capacity is being set up; reaching full kiln utilization requires another ₹80-100 crores of crushing and grinding CAPEX, optimistically around FY28.
- No fixed-cost drag from idle kiln: Management stated the kiln is suitable at the lower end of its capacity range, so no significant fixed costs are weighing on the P&L from the unutilized portion.
Demand Environment: Waiting for Government Spending
- H1 headwinds: General elections followed by monsoons made Q1 and Q2 sluggish for cement demand nationally; the company still grew dispatches vs prior periods.
- Recovery thesis: Management expects 7-8% industry growth in FY25, driven by government infrastructure spending and the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (3-floor housing units); past cycles show pent-up demand returns as extreme high-demand bursts.
- South India price war: Tier 1 brands have cut prices to ~₹300/bag (from ₹400-410) and are pushing into Shri Keshav's areas due to sluggish demand; management calls this temporary and expects reversal when government and housing expenditure pick up.
- Location advantage as defense: Proximity to Goa, South Maharashtra and North Karnataka gives a transportation cost advantage of ~₹800-850 vs tier 1 players' ~₹1,900 to Goa, yielding higher naked cement prices.
- Limestone belt barrier: The region can only support small capacities (0.1-0.2 crore tons), so no major new capacity is coming in, limiting competitive pressure.
Katwa: "See, typically what happens, we have seen this in the past many years back, when there is a dip in cement consumption, the capacity what is unused or rather that demand does not go off. It has to come back again in extreme high demand, as an extreme high demand case."
Solar: The Stabilizing Engine
- Scale and growth: Total solar capacity reached ~40 MW after commissioning an additional 3 MW plant at Bisarahalli, Karnataka; the segment delivered consistent ~₹7 crores EBITDA per quarter.
- Pricing cycle: Solar pricing is expected to increase again in April 2025, providing a tailwind for the segment that already carries the company through cement downturns.
- Strategic role: Management frames the solar-cement combination as a "double-engine" model where solar provides the financial boost that funded the cement debottlenecking and now covers cash needs during the price trough.
Katwa: "solar has been giving the financial boost in the coming, for last many years, which is why we have taken up the work on debottlenecking of cement plants so that cement and solar together can run like a double-engine sarkar."
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Debt repayment timeline: Debt taken in 2023 for CAPEX begins repayment from October 2025; older debts from 2017 will be repaid in the next 6-7 months; management will consider prepayment once sufficient profits and cash are generated.
- Interest coverage at lower EBITDA: If EBITDA reaches ₹60-65 crores, interest plus repayment will be ~₹40-42 crores, leaving a thin but positive cushion.
- Tax shield: Carry-forward depreciation loss of ~₹90-95 crores means the company will pay only MAT at 15% for the next 4-5 years, preserving cash during the ramp-up phase.
- Credit rating upgrade: Secured an upgrade to IVR BBB minus, stable outlook, on facilities totaling ₹223 crores.
- No acquisition approach received: No bigger player has approached the company for any deal, though management would look positively at any opportunity that improves shareholders' wealth given the plant's location advantages.
Katwa: "I would say like as a cement division, if there is something which is going to come in the perspective which will help improve the shareholders' wealth, yes, the management will always look at it in a positive manner."
Operational Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 | Q1 FY25 | Q2 FY24 | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net cement realization (₹/ton) | 3,290 | 3,480 | — | 3,070 |
| Capacity utilization | 57% | 69% | 54% | — |
| Overall EBITDA margin | 12.44% | — | — | ~32% |
- Utilization driven by sales, not kiln issues: Q1 utilization improved to 69% from 62% YoY and Q2 to 57% from 54% YoY; lower absolute levels reflect sluggish sales, not operational constraints.
- Government supply clearances secured: Quality departments have given clearances for cement supply to various government projects, though contracts are not yet being executed.
- Sales team expansion: Additional sales and marketing people were hired from the beginning of Q2, contributing to higher employee benefits expense.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| New capacity commissioning | Start operations from new plant | Q4 FY25; full ramp-up by January 2025, contingent on power line by mid-December or alternative arrangement |
| FY26 EBITDA | ₹80-90 crores, assuming 3% price growth from FY24 levels; drops to ~₹60 crores if prices stay at ₹3,300 | FY26 |
| FY27 EBITDA | ₹120-150 crores, same conservative price assumption | FY27 |
| Capacity utilization target | 70% of 0.1 crore ton capacity | 1.5 to 2 years |
| Full kiln utilization (0.18 crore tons) | Additional ₹80-100 crores CAPEX for crushing and grinding | Optimistically around FY28 |
| EBITDA margin recovery to ~30% | Conditional on cement prices rising to analyst-predicted ₹3,700-3,800 range | As soon as Q4 FY25 |
| Debt repayment (2017 vintage) | Full repayment of older debts | Next 6-7 months |
| Debt repayment (2023 CAPEX debt) | Repayment begins | October 2025 |
| Tax rate | MAT at 15% on carry-forward depreciation of ~₹90-95 crores | Next 4-5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Total income | ₹25.36 cr |
| Total income (H1 FY25) | ₹56.6 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹3.04 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 12.44%, down from 26% in Q1 FY25 and 32% in prior year |
| EBITDA (H1 FY25) | ₹11.11 cr |
| EBITDA margin (H1 FY25) | 20.23% |
| Solar EBITDA | ₹7 cr in Q2; cement EBITDA was negative |
| Solar EBITDA (H1 FY25) | ₹14 cr; cement EBITDA was negative |
| Net cement realization | ₹3,290 per ton, ex-plant excluding taxes and logistics, down from ₹3,710 in Q2 FY24 |
| Cement volume sold | ~52,000 tons, up from 49,300 tons in Q2 FY24 |
| Cement volume sold (H1 FY25) | ~115,000 tons, up from 105,000 tons in H1 FY24 |
| Cement dispatches growth (H1 FY25) | ~10% YoY increase; prices decreased ~11%-12% YoY |
| Capacity utilization | 57%, up from 54% in Q2 FY24 |
| Gross debt | ₹223 cr, reduced from ₹235 cr as of September |
| Solar average selling price | ₹6.09 per unit, down from ₹6.36 in Q2 FY24 |
| Total solar capacity | ~40 MW, after commissioning additional 3 MW at Bisarahalli |
| Credit rating | IVR BBB minus, stable outlook, on facilities of ₹223 cr |
| FY26 EBITDA guidance (if cement price stays at ₹3,300) | ~₹60 cr (per an analyst's math), versus original ₹80-90 cr guidance based on FY24 prices |
| FY27 EBITDA guidance (if cement price stays at ₹3,300) | ~₹62-65 cr (per an analyst's math), versus original ₹120-150 cr guidance |
| Carry forward depreciation loss (income tax) | ₹90-95 cr, enabling MAT-level taxation at 15% for next 4-5 years |