Key Takeaways
- Flat revenue masks real progress: Top line was flat YoY despite dispatch growth from 65,000 to 69,000 tons, because a shift to ex-plant dispatches pushed transportation cost onto dealers via a discount, lowering net realization.
- EBITDA margin surged on fuel, not efficiency: Margin jumped 408 bps to 34.38%, driven almost entirely by lower fuel prices; power consumption remains inefficient at ~110 units per ton vs an industry best of 50-55.
- Solar is the current profit engine: Of ~INR11.7 crores in quarterly EBITDA, ~INR8 crores came from solar, and the board has approved expanding the plant from 37 MW to 40 MW peak.
- Capex timeline is set, ramp-up is gradual: Trial production for the new 0.1 crore ton cement line is expected July 2024, but management targets only 50-55% utilization in FY25, reaching 70% by FY27.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the pre-election pricing dip materializes after staying absent so far, progress on the 3 MW solar expansion order, and any update on new market entry planning for Pune and Bangalore.
The Ex-Plant Shift & Top-Line Optics
- Delivery model change compressed revenue: By moving to ex-plant dispatches, the company stopped bearing transportation costs and instead gave dealers a discount, so net realization on the P&L fell even as naked cement prices actually rose.
- Volume growth was real: Dispatches grew from 65,000 to 69,000 tons YoY, and capacity utilization reached 76% in Q3, but the accounting treatment of the delivery model switch made the top line appear flat.
- Strategy is conditional on market acceptance: Management is pushing ex-plant wherever possible because it improves margins by shedding logistic costs, but the mix ultimately depends on consumer preference and market sentiment.
Venkatesh Katwa: "Even though our quantity and capacity utilization has reached 76% because of the lower, not exactly lower net realization, because of too large extent avoiding the transportation, the top line has appeared very flat, which is why you will see that your margins have increased drastically."
Profitability: Fuel Windfall vs Structural Efficiency
- EBITDA per ton transformed by fuel prices: Cement EBITDA per ton rose from INR155 in Q3 FY23 to INR460 in Q3 FY24; for the full nine months, it reached INR250 vs just INR60 in the prior year.
- Power consumption is the hidden drag: The plant consumes ~110 units per ton of cement against an industry best of 50-55 units, meaning roughly 50 units per ton that could have been sold externally for profit are instead burned inefficiently in-house.
- Upcoming capex targets consumption, not just capacity: The new cement line is expected to bring a new fuel consumption pattern, shifting the EBITDA driver from input-cost luck to structural efficiency.
- Post-expansion EBITDA ambition: Management targets INR600-650 per ton in FY25, rising to INR900-1,000 per ton by FY26, assuming current prices hold.
Venkatesh Katwa: "Even though we are consuming the power from our solar plant 100%, what inefficiently we are utilizing. For example, let us say, we are consuming about 110 units per ton of cement, whereas the industry best is about 50 to 55 units. So, ultimately that 50 units what we are consuming here could have been better sold outside and generated profit, which is not happening right now."
Solar: The Quiet Earnings Backbone
- Solar dominates current EBITDA: Out of ~INR11.7 crores in quarterly EBITDA, ~INR8 crores came from the solar segment, with full-year solar EBITDA expected at INR33-34 crores.
- Expansion underway: The board approved an increase from 37 MW to 40 MW peak; the first 3 MW order is being placed imminently with a supplier already finalized, targeting commissioning around April 2024.
- Capex is supplier-financed: The INR8.5-9 crore solar expansion cost will be funded by the supplier via long-term payment, requiring no immediate cash outflow.
- Post-cement-capex solar strategy: Once the new cement line commissions in July, existing solar power will be consumed captively by the new plant to avoid cross-subsidy charges, while the existing plant (with government incentives) will be free to sell power externally. Further solar capacity additions will be evaluated only after the cement plant stabilizes.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So, yes, there are plans as of now, no capacity or anything of that sort is finalized, but the management is on the way of adding more solar capacity after our cement plant has stabilized completely."
Demand & Pricing Environment
- Q3 demand was robust: Post-monsoon demand stayed strong, with the dealership network of 500-600 retail points intact and Q4 already continuing the trajectory.
- Karnataka pricing held up better than national trends: While cement prices softened heavily elsewhere in India, the Karnataka region saw only minor correction, which management says is commensurate with fuel cost reductions and not a negative signal.
- Election dip has not materialized: A pre-election demand slowdown was expected but not observed so far; January was strong, and management anticipates only minor price correction through the election period and perhaps one quarter after.
- Housing and government infrastructure intact: Both segments continue to underpin demand, and in Karnataka some projects that had stalled after local elections have now picked up again.
Capacity Expansion & Ramp-Up Timeline
- Trial production set for July 2024: The ongoing cement capex (expanding and modernizing to 0.1 crore tons) is expected to begin trial production around July, which falls in Q1 of the next financial year.
- Ramp-up is deliberately gradual: Management targets 50-55% utilization in FY25 (500-550,000 tons), ~65% in FY26, and ~70% from FY27 onward, eventually reaching 75-80%.
- Fund deployment on track: Of the INR125 crores raised, nearly INR100 crores will be utilized by end of June FY25, with ~46 crores from production and the balance from bank facilities.
- New market entry is post-commissioning: Management will begin evaluating outside markets like Pune and Bangalore only after the new plant commissions; currently only planning, no actionable work done.
- Confidence in capacity absorption: Management is very confident of deploying 80-90% of capacity without significant issues, citing the small plant size and localized demand catchment as advantages.
Venkatesh Katwa: "For a small plant like ours, it should not be a major challenge at all. If we had about maybe 0.2 crore or 0.5 crore tons capacity, there is a certain need to worry because cement is one product where you cannot sell it very far from the manufacturing location because of low value to weight, kind of product. But yes, to answer your question, management is very confident that we will be able to deploy 80% or 90% of our capacity without very, very significant..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Cement capex trial production | Trial production for new 0.1 crore ton line to commence | July 2024 (Q1 next financial year) |
| Solar expansion (3 MW) | Order placement and commissioning of additional 3 MW | Order placed imminently; target April 2024 |
| Fund utilization | ~INR100 crores of INR125 crores raised to be deployed | By end of June FY25 |
| FY25 capacity utilization | 50-55% of expanded capacity (500-550,000 tons) | FY25 |
| FY26 capacity utilization | ~65% of expanded capacity | FY26 |
| FY27 capacity utilization | ~70% of expanded capacity, trending toward 75-80% | FY27 onward |
| FY25 EBITDA per ton | INR600-650 per metric ton on average | FY25 |
| FY26 EBITDA per ton | INR900-1,000 per metric ton (assuming current prices) | FY26 |
| FY27 revenue | INR300 crores (conservative estimate INR330-340 crores at 65% utilization) | FY27 |
| Pricing outlook | Minor correction possible through election period and one quarter after; no significant change expected | Q4 FY24 through Q1 FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income | ₹34.36 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹11.69 cr, +12.47% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 34.38%, +408 bps YoY |
| Net profit | ₹3.97 cr |
| Net margin | 11.46%, +748 bps YoY |
| Earnings per share | ₹2.52, +117% YoY |
| Cement revenue share | 79.3% of total revenue; solar and other sources 20% |
| Cement dispatches | ~69,000 tons, up from 65,000 tons in Q3 FY23 |
| Capacity utilization | 76% |
| Cement EBITDA per ton | ~₹460, up from ₹155 in Q3 FY23 |
| Solar EBITDA contribution | ~₹8 cr of the ₹11.7 cr total EBITDA |
| Volume growth (9M FY24) | +2% YoY; full-year target at least 5% |
| FY25 volume target | 500,000–550,000 tons, 50–55% utilization of expanded capacity |
| FY25 EBITDA per ton guidance | ₹600–₹650 (blended average) |
| FY26 EBITDA per ton target | ₹900–₹1,000 |