Key Takeaways
- EBITDA surges on solar, not cement: EBITDA jumped ~88% QoQ, but the 25–26% margin is driven entirely by the solar segment; cement operations alone generate less than ₹50 EBITDA per ton against an industry ₹700–800.
- New kiln is the margin bridge: A new kiln commissioning in March promises to slash power and fuel consumption per ton, targeting EBITDA per ton at par with South peers (~₹422) even before any price recovery.
- Cement realizations remain the drag: Realizations fell 8–9% YoY, volumes dropped 14% YoY in Q3, and capacity utilization sat at ~65% through nine months, keeping PAT low despite the headline EBITDA surge.
- Price recovery bet rests on consolidation: Management argues the consolidation phase is almost over and price discipline will return, expecting an upward trend in FY26 because current prices are unsustainable.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the new kiln switchover completes on schedule and delivers the promised per-ton cost reduction, and whether Q4 dispatches and realizations actually improve as guided.
The Solar-Cement Margin Divide
- Solar masks cement weakness: The reported 25–26% EBITDA margin is solely attributable to the solar business; cement operations alone are generating negligible margins because realizations have fallen 8–9% YoY.
- Structural power-cost advantage: The company achieved 100% renewable power consumption in 2018, a first in India, with generation cost below ₹1.50 per unit versus DISCOM power above ₹7, providing a durable cost moat.
- Solar revenue to shift captive: As the new cement plant ramps to 50–70% utilization, solar power will be consumed captively rather than sold, shifting the EBITDA benefit from solar revenue to lower cement power costs.
- Solar expansion under discussion: The board is considering adding more renewable capacity but nothing has been finalized; Karnataka's renewable policy remains supportive.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So, for example, our pricing compared to nine months last year and compared to now, the realizations have gone down by almost 8% to 9% for us. And this has been an industry standard. But the biggest difference is the EBITDA margin exclusively on cement, what the major plants are generating is upwards of Rs. 700 to 800 whereas in our cases it is less than Rs. 50."
New Kiln: The Margin Reset Mechanism
- CAPEX complete, switchover imminent: The new kiln is ready and the government power line was received by end of January; switchover is planned for end of February or first week of March and will take 20–25 days.
- Switchover delayed by demand uptick: Management chose not to disrupt dispatches during the switchover window because utilization had suddenly improved to 90–95%, a delay that cost the company a lower-demand opportunity last quarter.
- Targeting South-parity EBITDA: With the new kiln reducing power and fuel consumption per ton, management expects EBITDA margins at par with South players (~₹422 per ton) assuming current prices continue, plus additional benefit from solar not counted in those margins.
- 50% utilization targeted for FY26: The expanded capacity of 10 lakh tonnes per annum is projected to run at 50% utilization in FY26, with teething issues expected initially.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So, with the new kiln, what we are going to expect is the power consumption will go down, the fuel consumption will go down and then we will have similar EBITDA margins like what we see in the industry level."
Cement Pricing & Demand Environment
- Realization collapse: Cement realizations fell 8–9% YoY, with Q3 and the nine-month period particularly bad in the South, where EBITDA margins fell ~40% per ton QoQ.
- Volume underperformance: Q3 volumes dropped 14% YoY (68,610 to 58,960 tons), while nine-month volumes were nearly flat, held back by elections, monsoon, and delayed government spending under the new political dispensation.
- Capacity utilization shortfall: Q1–Q3 utilization ran at ~65% against an 80% target; Q4 is already showing promise and management expects to beat trends.
- Industry-wide pressure: Sudden capacity additions and consolidation-driven market-share capture have pressured EBITDA across the industry, with South India's Gulbarga and Tadpatri regions particularly concentrated.
- Prices stopped falling: Prices stabilized in Q3, and Q4 is showing improved volumes, though prices have not increased significantly yet.
Venkatesh Katwa: "cement prices are going to be showing an upward trend in FY26 because current prices are definitely not sustainable. Consolidation has almost is almost done. So, there is going to be a price discipline."
Operational Metrics & Working Capital
- Inventory and working capital at par: Inventory levels run 150–160 days and the working capital cycle is 20–25 days, in line with industry norms; larger brands may operate 10–15 days shorter.
- Solar generation up: A 3 MW solar capacity addition in August 2024 drove a ~10.4% increase in solar generation.
- No acquisition plans: Management confirmed no acquisition is planned in cement and no renewable acquisition is imminent, though they would be keen if a seller appears.
- No government incentives: The company receives no specific company-wise incentives for solar; Karnataka's renewable policy remains positive and offers scope to add capacity.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| New kiln switchover | Switchover to begin; will take 20–25 days | End of February / first week of March 2025 |
| Capacity utilization | 50% utilization of 10 lakh tonne capacity | FY26 |
| Cement EBITDA per ton | Reach parity with South players (~₹422/ton) assuming current prices | After new kiln ramps |
| Top line | Reach last year's level or a little higher | FY25 |
| Bottom line | May improve on Q4 volume growth; no huge uptrend until new kiln starts | FY25 |
| Cement price trend | Upward trend expected; consolidation-driven price discipline | FY26 |
| Government spending recovery | Spending to resume, aiding demand | Q4 FY25 and Q1 FY26 onwards |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Total income | ₹29.04 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹7.38 cr, surged ~88% QoQ |
| EBITDA margin | 26.26% |
| PAT | ₹0.64 cr |
| PAT margin | 2.2% |
| EPS | ₹0.36 |
| 9-month FY25 total income | ₹85.64 cr |
| 9-month FY25 EBITDA | ₹20.17 cr |
| 9-month FY25 EBITDA margin | 24.29% |
| Cement revenue share | 76.34% of total income |
| Solar energy revenue share | ~15% of total income |
| Cement dispatches growth | 12.6% QoQ |
| Turnover growth | 14% QoQ |
| Cement volumes | 58,960 tons, down ~14% YoY from 68,610 tons |
| 9-month FY25 cement volumes | ~1,73,600 tons, flat YoY vs ~1,74,000 tons |
| Naked cement price | ₹3,302, down 8% YoY from ₹3,761 and down 1% QoQ |
| Cement capacity utilization | 65%, vs 76% in Q3 FY24 and targeted 80% |
| Solar generation growth | ~10.4% (3 MW added in August 2024) |
| Solar installed capacity | 40 MW |
| Solar captive consumption | ~50% currently, expected to rise to 90–95% after new plant |
| Cost of renewable generation | less than ₹1.50 paisa per unit, vs DISCOM power cost upwards of ₹7 |
| Inventory levels | 150–160 days |
| Working capital cycle | 20–25 days |
| EBITDA per ton (cement) | less than ₹50, vs South industry average of ₹422 in Q3 and ₹463 for 9M FY25 |
| South industry EBITDA per ton (9M FY25) | ₹462, down from ~₹750 in 9M FY24 |
| National industry EBITDA per ton (9M FY25) | ~₹800, down from ₹1,064 in 9M FY24 (top 18 plants, 80% national capacity) |
| New cement capacity | 0.1 cr tons per annum, up from 0.03 cr tons |
| Projected utilization for new plant | 50% in FY26 |