Key Takeaways
- Operating leverage arrives, masked by cleanup: Excluding a Rs. 4 crore one-time provisioning, the iServeU business broke even at the EBITDA level this quarter, the first tangible sign that the model can scale profitably.
- GTV volumes surprised even management: Gross transaction value growth "went through the roof" as the enterprise channel strategy, 18 months in the making, began delivering volumes that grew every month.
- Take rate mix shift is benign: Gross take rates fell from 42 bps to 36 bps as lower-payout enterprise GTV share rose, but the net take rate only slipped from 10 bps to 9 bps, and new products carry higher net take rates.
- Balance sheet reset underway: Rs. 4 crores in provisions closed the chapter on pre-2020 unreconciled bank balances and aged retail receivables; a Rs. 80 crore fundraise and a new Rs. 15 crore credit line position the company to scale its lending book.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Rs. 117 crore loan book delivers revenue in Q2 as promised, the pace of prepaid card adoption with the first partner, and if the EBITDA loss gap contracts as guided.
The Enterprise Pivot Is Working
- Strategy took 18 months to fire: The first six months of the enterprise push were "extremely disappointing" with only tech integrations and no visibility on volumes; now every month is bigger than the previous month.
- Enterprise channel share rose: Contribution to GTV moved from 60% to 62% QoQ, driving the headline GTV surge that surprised management.
- Receivable quality improved structurally: Enterprise partners carry much shorter receivable cycles with no recoverability issues, a sharp contrast to the legacy retail receivables that required provisioning this quarter.
- Existing clients are enough for the next leg: Management is confident of hitting the 1 lakh target without acquiring new clients, by going deep with roughly 800 existing partners, some of whom have 400,000 to 600,000 retail outlets each.
Tashwinder Singh: "I'll be honest, the first quarter, the kind of numbers we've got in terms of the GTV, etc. also surprised us a little bit, right? We obviously knew we will get the growth, but the volumes just went through the roof"
Profitability Mechanics
- Operating leverage is now visible: Revenue net of fees and commission expenses improved to Rs. 8-9 crores while employee costs held at Rs. 5-6 crores, compared to FY23 when revenues were Rs. 5-6 crores and employee costs Rs. 15-16 crores. Headcount stayed flat QoQ.
- Leverage sits at the indirect cost level: Direct costs are a fixed payout to retailers; as volumes rise, net revenue grows in absolute terms while indirect expenses do not rise proportionally.
- Adjusted EBITDA loss widened on two one-offs: The loss moved from Rs. 0.6 crore to Rs. 4.3 crores because of the Rs. 4 crore provisioning cleanup and roughly Rs. 2 crores in cloud expenses to prepare server space for the prepaid card launch.
- Tech expenses are on a step function: No increase beyond current levels is expected for the next couple of quarters; Rs. 1 crore to Rs. 1.5 crore of tech expenses should be reduced over the year as Google credits and efficiencies kick in.
- Device sales decline was deliberate: The company moved away from a closed-loop, key-injected device model after chip supply issues, opening the network to work with any device. Managing device logistics was "a headache and not much money anyway."
Tashwinder Singh: "Yes, I would think so. The numbers are there for you to see, right? If we had not taken the provision, we would have broken even this quarter itself, right? It's just math, right, at an EBITDA level, I'm talking at an EBITDA level."
Take Rate Dynamics
- Gross take rate fell, net held up: Gross take rate contracted from 42 bps to 36 bps because enterprise channel GTV share rose; enterprise carries lower merchant payouts, so the net take rate only reduced from 10 bps to 9 bps. A one-off item in Q4 FY23 had artificially bumped up the prior quarter's take rate.
- New products carry higher net take rates: The 9 bps figure reflects existing products (Micro-ATM, AePS, DMT). As prepaid cards, UPI, and other new products launch with higher net take rates, management targets a steady-state net take rate of 9-10 bps.
- Cash out is low-margin but necessary: Cash out, which contributed 40-43% of GTV this quarter, carries significantly lower margins but is essential to keep the wallet business functioning. Float income from money staying in wallets partially offsets the lower transaction revenue.
- Average transaction size contracted 29% QoQ: This was driven by the mix shift toward incremental products like UPI, which carry smaller ticket sizes.
Lending Business Build-Out
- Loan book growth was back-ended: The Rs. 117 crore book's revenue benefit will show up in the coming quarter, not the one just reported. The target is Rs. 250 crore by FY24 end and Rs. 500 crore next year.
- Partnership-led underwriting model: Niyogin uses networks like Khatabook to access differentiated data for underwriting while holding the pen on credit models; partners are closer to client information, which also defrays collection costs.
- MSME lending yield expected at 16-18% monthly: This is for unsecured business lending, with technology integration enabling products like EDI (instead of EMI), supply chain financing, and term loans with POS-based repayments.
- Leverage is negligible today: On Rs. 160 crore of equity deployed, only Rs. 13 crore of leverage is drawn. A Rs. 15 crore credit line from one bank is in place, with multiple conversations ongoing. Scaling to Rs. 500 crore would require roughly 2x-2.2x leverage, which management believes is achievable.
- Chief Risk Officer hired: A CRO from the street joins in September; the CTO also came from a lending background, signaling the build-out of lending capabilities.
Tashwinder Singh: "There is significant opportunity in the lending space. You go and talk to five MSMEs, do you want to take money? Four of them will say yes, right? But doesn't mean that all 4 of them deserve the credit, right?"
New Product Pipeline
- Prepaid cards are the nearest catalyst: The first partner is onboarded; cloud expenses of roughly Rs. 2 crores were incurred this quarter to prepare server space. Management expects to share numbers by next quarter and says the benefit will start coming without significant additional tech cost.
- UPI sits in "others" at 6-7% of revenue: Niyogin is on both the acquiring and issuing side; a separate breakout will come once numbers stabilize. Some regulation change has occurred in that business.
- NiyoBlu just launched: The lending origination platform is very new; management declined to give targets, citing nervousness about putting numbers ahead for freshly launched products.
- Credit card stack still in build phase: No functionality has been built around credit on UPI; the focus is on the prepaid card proposition with RuPay.
- Insurance corporate agent license on the discussion board: The application has not yet been put in, but management believes IRDA would be keen to look at corporates like Niyogin. Kotak was announced as an insurance partner.
Tashwinder Singh: "Every time you do a new product launch, right, I'm a little nervous about putting too many numbers ahead, which is also the reason why I don't give any numbers for our prepaid card business for example, right, because it's just been launched."
Balance Sheet & Capital
- Rs. 4 crore provisioning cleans up legacy: Roughly Rs. 1.3 crores relates to retail receivables that moved beyond 365 days, where recovery efforts continue. The balance covers historical unreconciled bank balances from 2019-20 transactions where reconciliation was completed and residual amounts were deemed unrecoverable. Management calls this a one-time event not expected to reoccur at this extent.
- Rs. 80 crore fundraise via warrants: 25% (Rs. 20 crore) arrives in the next couple of weeks; the balance comes over 18 months. The capital shores up the balance sheet for the lending business and provides a war chest for potential acquisitions during the funding winter.
- Inorganic opportunities remain on the radar: The company came close to a couple of deals that made sense but could not cross the line due to diligence or other reasons; management remains optimistic.
- New marquee investors came on board during the quarter.
Tashwinder Singh: "It's sort of closes a chapter as far as I'm concerned on the older unreconciled balances with banks, which again, we have cleaned up."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA breakeven | Breakeven at EBITDA level, absent one-off provisions | Next 1-2 quarters |
| Loan book target | Rs. 250 crore on-balance-sheet book | FY24 end |
| Loan book target | Rs. 500 crore on-balance-sheet book | Next year (FY25) |
| Top line target | Rs. 500 crores | FY25 |
| Tech expense reduction | Rs. 1 crore to Rs. 1.5 crore reduction from current levels | Over the year |
| Tech expense stability | No increase beyond current quarterly level | Next couple of quarters |
| Net take rate steady state | 9 bps to 10 bps base net take rate | Steady state (undated) |
| Prepaid card disclosure | Share numbers on prepaid card proposition | Next quarter |
| 1 lakh target | Achieve without acquiring significantly new customers, by going deep with existing ~800 partners | Next year |
| Vision document | Next 3-4 year vision document with targets | Sometime in next quarter or so |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue ex-device sales | ₹45 cr, up 38% QoQ and 85% YoY |
| Consolidated revenue | ₹45.5 cr, up 25% QoQ and 66% YoY |
| Adjusted EBITDA loss (ex-ESOP) | ₹4.3 cr loss, widened from ₹0.6 cr loss in Q4 FY23 |
| Non-GAAP PBT | negative ₹6.2 cr, versus negative ₹2.3 cr in Q4 FY23 |
| ESOP charge | ₹90 lakhs, versus ₹1 cr in Q4 FY23 |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹89.9 cr as of June 30, 2023 |
| Net worth | ₹297 cr as of June 30, 2023; ₹317 cr pro forma for 25% of warrant proceeds |
| Gross Transaction Value (GTV) | ₹9,893 cr, up 70% QoQ and 266% YoY |
| GTV run-rate in July 2023 | ₹3,600 cr processed in July 2023 |
| Transaction volumes | 3.4 cr transactions, up 140% QoQ |
| Average transaction size | ₹2,943, contracted 29% QoQ from ₹4,159 in Q4 FY23 |
| Gross take rate | 36 bps, contracted from 42 bps in Q4 FY23 |
| Net take rate | 9 bps, reduced from 10 bps in Q4 FY23 |
| Enterprise channel contribution to GTV | 62%, up from 60% in Q4 FY23 |
| BaaS partners | 796 as of June 30, 2023, up 20% YoY; 64 partners added in Q1 |
| Loan book | ₹117 cr, up 28% QoQ |
| Loan book target for FY24 | ₹250 cr give or take by FY24 |
| Financial professional network | 5,238 as of June 30, 2023, up 4% YoY |
| LTD loans processed through network | 12,741 loans in Q1 FY24, up 232% YoY |
| Provisioning for ageing receivables and unreconciled balances | ₹4 cr one-time provision in Q1 FY24 |
| Cloud-related expenses for new product launches | ₹2 cr incremental tech expense in Q1 FY24 |
| Capital available for lending | ₹160 cr equity deployed; ₹180 cr pro forma after ₹20 cr warrant proceeds |
| Leverage drawn for lending book | ₹13 cr drawn as of Q1 FY24; additional ₹15 cr credit line obtained |