Key Takeaways
- Solar masks a broken cement P&L: EBITDA of Rs.10.27 crores came almost entirely from solar, while the cement division struggles below Rs.100/ton versus an industry norm of Rs.1,000/ton because a 1980s-era kiln burns ~50% more fuel and ~60% more power.
- The fix is funded and underway: A new 0.1 crore ton kiln, preheater, cooler and vertical roll mill are on order, backed by Rs.80 crores of Canara Bank debt and a preferential issue raised in April; commissioning is targeted by June 30, 2024.
- Fuel switch delivered a 440 bps margin jump: Moving to 100% petroleum coke lifted EBITDA margin to 32.36%, and management says the benefit of softening fuel prices is still to come because Q1 consumption reflected higher-cost October-November purchases under FIFO.
- Utilization was election-damaged but the demand thesis is intact: Capacity utilization fell to 62% as Karnataka elections pulled labor off construction sites from mid-April to mid-May; management targets 70-75% in coming quarters and cites the pre-election year demand cycle as a tailwind.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether utilization rebounds toward the 70% target, the pace of debt drawdown as the Rs.80 crore project loan begins to flow, and any evidence that the cement division’s standalone EBITDA per ton is improving ahead of the new kiln.
The Cement Problem: An Obsolete Kiln
- Old kiln is the root cause: Originally a 200 ton/day line modified to ~800 ton/day, it consumes ~1,100 kcal/kg of clinker versus an industry best of under 700 kcal/kg, and uses ~60% more power than modern plants. The kiln cannot be modernized further.
- Cement EBITDA is near zero: The division generates less than Rs.100 per metric ton against an industry benchmark of ~Rs.1,000, meaning the entire reported EBITDA of Rs.10.27 crores is effectively solar profit.
- Solar is the bridge: The 12 MW solar plant, commissioned April 2022, is now running at over 99% capacity utilization and contributed Rs.6.03 crores from external sales plus ~Rs.4.5-5 crores of power consumed internally that would otherwise have been a cement-division cost.
- Post-expansion integration: Once the company stops selling solar externally and feeds all power to cement, the cement division’s EBITDA per ton will rise beyond Rs.1,000 because that figure currently excludes power cost.
Venkatesh H. Katwa: "Industry is giving almost Rs.1,000 EBITDA per metric ton, but we are struggling with less than Rs.100 EBITDA per metric ton. The only reason we are making a healthy EBITDA of the balance sheet is because of solar generation and sale of solars."
The Expansion: What Gets Built and When
- Scope: A new kiln, preheater, cooler and vertical roll mill that will add 0.1 crore tons of cement capacity, roughly doubling the current base and lifting the company toward the 1-million-ton threshold where its price delta versus Tier-2 brands begins to close.
- Funding: Rs.125 crore total project cost, with Rs.80 crore of debt sanctioned by Canara Bank and the balance from a preferential issue and warrants raised in April 2023.
- Timeline: Machinery orders are placed; first equipment arrives November/December 2023; commissioning will proceed in phases with the kiln as the final piece, targeted by June 30, 2024. Management later narrowed this to "Q2 of 2024."
- Shutdown risk managed: The old kiln will require a 20-25 day permanent shutdown for realignment during the tie-in, but sufficient clinker stock will be built beforehand so cement sales are not disrupted.
- Debt trajectory: The Rs.80 crore loan will be drawn over 4-5 quarters; interest will be capitalized until commissioning, so it does not hit the P&L as a finance cost during construction. Existing debt already declined from Rs.180 crores to Rs.165 crores in Q1.
- Alternative fuel optionality: The new CAPEX design includes civil structures and platforms to accommodate alternative fuels (bagasse, municipal waste, dry items) for 20-25% of fuel needs, though the machinery itself will be added later.
Margins: The Fuel Switch and What Comes Next
| Margin driver | Detail |
|---|---|
| Fuel switch to petcoke | 100% petroleum coke since June/July 2022, replacing higher-cost coal; this drove the ~440 bps EBITDA margin expansion to 32.36%. |
| FIFO tailwind still to come | Fuel consumed in Q1 was purchased in October-November at higher prices; as lower-cost inventory flows through, margins should continue improving even without further price declines. |
| Power cost trajectory | Solar power currently costs ~Rs.1.80/unit, of which Rs.1.60 is interest cost on the solar plant debt. As that debt repays over 3-4 years, power cost is expected to fall below 25-30 paise/unit. |
| Management’s margin ambition | Targeting 40-42% EBITDA margin (from 32%) based on current cement realizations and raw material costs, and expects to "significantly improve" margins by 20-25%. |
Venkatesh H. Katwa: "Yes, it is likely to be sustainable because even these EBITDA margins we are able to get it with the fairly high cost of fuel, because the fuel consumed in this Q1 based on FIFO method comes from when we have purchased fuel in October and November. So, with the reduction in fuel prices, we're expecting to continue or even better the EBITDA margins."
Demand and Utilization
- Q1 utilization was election-damaged: Capacity utilization fell to 62% against an expected 65-68% because Karnataka’s mid-May elections slowed construction activity and pulled labor away from sites from mid-April to mid-May.
- Recovery target: Management expects to reach 70% utilization this year, rising to at least 70-75% in coming quarters, supported by post-monsoon demand pickup and the pre-election year construction cycle.
- Demand thesis: Historically, election years deliver very high cement growth; robust rural housing demand is expected to sustain through the fiscal year-end.
- Competitive positioning: The plant’s location within 200 km of its market means cement is delivered fresh and drier, avoiding the moisture degradation that occurs when larger plants store bags in godowns. The company is Tier-3 (under 0.1 crore tons) but competes with Tier-2 brands, and the price gap should narrow once it crosses 0.1 crore tons.
Market and Brand Strategy Post-Expansion
- Geographic reach: The primary market remains within 200 km of the plant, but with new capacity, Pune and Bangalore enter the supply zone. Management flagged that cement’s low value-to-weight ratio means logistics costs constrain how far the radius can stretch.
- Dealer network: Plans to expand from 600 dealers to 800-1,000 post-expansion.
- Institutional and government entry: The company already holds clearances from all government departments (dam, canal, institutional projects) but has been limited by low EBITDA margins and a thin marketing budget. Post-expansion, it intends to bid for large government infrastructure contracts and deepen relationships with logistics providers, institutional buyers and big contractors.
- Marketing spend: Management promised a "huge change" in marketing and sales budget once the new CAPEX is in place, with deeper end-market connections.
- Market share ambition: Aims to increase market share by at least 2.5x from current levels.
Venkatesh H. Katwa: "Even with the new capacity, Pune and Bangalore could be in the range of our supply zone. However, cement is a product with very low value to weight ratio, which means that logistic cost do weigh down on the product."
Balance Sheet and Credit Quality
- Existing debt declining: Reduced from Rs.180 crores to Rs.165 crores in Q1.
- New debt treatment: The Rs.80 crore Canara Bank project loan will be drawn over 4-5 quarters; finance cost is capitalized until commissioning, so it will not appear as an expense until the new plant is operational.
- Credit rating upgrade expected: Management anticipates an improved credit rating due to better financial ratios; if achieved, it would reduce interest cost by another 50 bps across all loans.
- Loan cost outlook: Management expects the cost of the Canara Bank loan to decline over time based on discussions and RBI rate movements, though no specific timeline was given.
- Land fully owned: All land for both the cement plant and the solar installation is entirely company-owned, with no lease or acquisition risk.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| New kiln commissioning | 0.1 crore ton capacity addition; kiln as final phase | June 30, 2024 ("Q2 of 2024") |
| Capacity utilization | Reach at least 70-75% | "Coming quarters" |
| EBITDA margin | Reach 40-42% (from 32.36%) | No date; based on current realizations and input costs |
| Power cost reduction | Fall below 25-30 paise/unit (from Rs.1.80) as solar debt repays | 3-4 years |
| Dealer network | Expand from 600 to 800-1,000 dealers | Post-expansion |
| Market share | Increase by at least 2.5x | No date |
| Credit rating improvement | 50 bps interest cost reduction on all loans if achieved | Conditional on improved ratios |
| Plant shutdown for CAPEX tie-in | 20-25 day old kiln shutdown; sales unaffected via pre-built stock | During commissioning phase |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income | ₹31.74 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹10.27 cr, +10% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 32.36%, +440 bps YoY |
| Net profit | ₹2.68 cr |
| Net profit margin | 8.42% |
| Cement division revenue | ₹23.31 cr |
| Solar division revenue | ₹6.03 cr |
| Cement sales volume | 55,981 tons, ~62% capacity utilization |
| Cement production volume | ~56,300 tons |
| Solar capacity utilization | >99% |
| Total debt on books | ₹165 cr, down from ₹180 cr in Q4 FY23 |
| Outside debt to banks | ₹140 cr |
| Debt-to-equity ratio | <2.5, down from <6–7 in FY23 and >9 in FY22 |
| Average cost of existing debt | ~9.85% |
| New Canara Bank loan sanctioned | ₹80 cr at 9.5% interest, for capacity expansion |
| Retail touch points | 600 dealers |
| Sales team size | ~18 people |
| Quarterly marketing budget | <₹25 lakhs |