Key Takeaways
- Price collapse wiped out volume gains: Capacity utilization jumped 800 bps to 70%, but a 12% price decline (~₹500/ton) meant revenue stagnated and cement EBITDA collapsed to just ₹75 lakh for the quarter.
- The business is a solar company with a cement turnaround attached: Solar contributed ₹8.1 crores of the ₹8.85 crores total EBITDA this quarter; the capex cycle underway is designed to fix cement's structural cost disadvantage and bring it to industry-par profitability.
- Capex is the entire thesis: A new kiln, commissioning by end-Q3 FY25, targets a reduction in power and fuel consumption from 50-60% above industry standard down to competitive levels, with management targeting ₹900-₹1,000 cement EBITDA per ton post-capex.
- Debt is high but optically worse than reality: Most debt is tied to the solar investment that already generates ~₹35 crores annual EBITDA; excluding new capex debt, cement-only debt is ~₹30-₹35 crores, and legacy term loans roll off by March 2026.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the new kiln commissions on time (end-Q3 FY25 target), any sign of cement price recovery in the southern region, and the pace of dealer network expansion once capacity doubles.
The Quarter: Price Destruction Meets Structural Cost Pain
- Volume up, revenue flat, profit gone: Capacity utilization rose from 62% to 70% YoY, but a 12% price decline meant the ~62,000 tons dispatched generated no incremental top line, and the lost revenue flowed straight to the bottom line since other costs were fixed.
- Cement EBITDA nearly vanished: Out of ₹8.85 crores total EBITDA, cement contributed only ₹75 lakh; the rest was solar. The core cement business is currently unprofitable at the operating level when power and fuel inefficiencies are accounted for.
- The cost problem is structural, not cyclical: Power consumption is 50-60% higher than industry standard and fuel consumption is similarly elevated, which is why cement EBITDA per ton was only ~₹200 last year versus an industry average of ~₹1,000. The entire capex program is designed to close this gap.
- Market conditions were hostile: Management described the cement market as "pretty depressed" and "almost a buyers market," with Q1 further disrupted by elections, making it a poor quarter to add dealers.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So, 12% dip in the pricing is almost like INR500 per metric ton. So, for about 62,000 tons what we have dispatched, losing top line here is like losing bottom line itself."
The Capex Turnaround: Fixing Cement's Cost Structure
- New kiln is the catalyst: A replacement kiln, not originally planned, is being installed with design capacity to support future brownfield expansion to ~0.18 crore tons. Commissioning is targeted for end-November or early-December 2024 (flag end of Q3 FY25), taking total capacity to 0.1 crore tons per annum.
- Fuel consumption target: Post-capex, management expects to reach 750-850 kilocalories per ton, a dramatic improvement from current levels, though still above the best-in-class ~680 kcal that management disputes as an industry average anyway.
- Power self-consumption to jump: Currently only 35-40% of generated solar power is used for captive cement production; post-capex, nearly 95% will be self-consumed, directly lowering the cement P&L's power cost.
- Location advantage provides a margin cushion: The plant's proximity to consumer markets gives a logistics cost advantage of ~₹1,200 per ton versus larger players shipping to the same destinations (e.g., ₹1,000 vs ₹2,200 to reach Goa), a structural benefit that survives any price cycle.
- Brownfield option exists but is unfunded and unscheduled: The new kiln can support expansion to 0.18 crore tons by adding grinding and crushing equipment later, but management has no roadmap or timeline for that decision and is focused on completing the current project and reducing debt first.
Venkatesh Katwa: "When we will take it up I do not have an answer nor do we have a roadmap as such. For now, we are sticking with completion of this project and making sure that our debt starts coming down before adding new capacity in cement as well as in solar."
Solar: The Real Earnings Engine
- Solar is the business today: Last year, solar contributed ~₹35-36 crores of the ~₹42 crores total EBITDA; this quarter, it was ₹8.1 crores out of ₹8.85 crores. The cement turnaround story is essentially funded by a stable solar annuity.
- Capacity expanded to 40 MW: A 3 MW plant was commissioned on August 14, 2024 at Bisarahalli, Koppal, Karnataka, at a cost of ₹13.57 crores, financed by the supplier with a 5-year EMI repayment starting next year. It is expected to add ~45 lakh units of generation annually.
- Regulatory benefits are locked in: The pre-2018 plant enjoys no billing or banking charges for 10 years; the 2022 plant has no transmission charges for 10 years. These are material, non-recurring cost advantages.
- Interest-free government loan partially trapped: ₹22.46 crores was sanctioned, ₹18.5 crores received, but it is currently deposited as 100% margin for a bank guarantee. Management is working to get the guarantee sanctioned at 25% margin, which would release 75% of the amount for use. No timeline given.
Margins: The Path to 35%
- Current margin is not representative: The 26.5% EBITDA margin in Q4 FY24 (and implied worse in Q1 FY25) reflects the pre-capex cost structure where cement is barely breaking even. The entire investment case rests on the post-capex margin profile.
- Target: 35-37% EBITDA margin by FY26-27: Management expects the cost reduction from the new kiln and higher captive power consumption to drive margins into the mid-30s, with some beginning visible by Q1 FY26 and a "high jump" during FY26.
- Cement EBITDA per ton target: ₹900-₹1,000 (excluding solar): This is the apple-to-apple comparison with other cement companies, assuming power purchased at market price. Including solar benefits, total EBITDA per ton is targeted at ₹1,250-₹1,300.
- Teething issues expected: Management cautioned that full margin may not be visible in the first quarter post-commissioning; the direction is 34-35% if not 35%, but "eventually we will have to get there."
- Solar EBITDA provides a floor: The ~₹35 crores annual solar EBITDA will continue to accrue, meaning overall financials should show ~₹100 crores total EBITDA (cement + solar) once the cement turnaround matures, per an analyst's math.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So, overall, that's a direction we are going. If not 35%, maybe we will be in the range of 34%, 35%. But eventually, we will have to get there."
Balance Sheet & Debt: Manageable but Constraining
- Debt is optically high because of solar: Total debt appears large relative to the cement top line, but ₹90-₹95 crores is attributed to the solar investment that already generates ~₹35 crores annual EBITDA. Excluding new capex debt, legacy debt is ~₹125 crores, with only ₹30-₹35 crores from cement.
- Legacy repayments roll off by March 2026: Termloan 1 and 2 (~₹6 crores/year) plus the GECL loan (~₹5 crores/year) total ~₹8-₹9 crores/year in repayments that will be completed by early-to-mid 2026. These will be replaced by new debt repayments from the capex cycle, so cash flow remains fairly constant while revenue and EBITDA increase.
- Finance cost has trended down: From ₹19.2 crores in FY22 to ₹16.9 crores last year, though management expects a slight bump this year due to the new capex.
- Tax rate is erratic and will stay that way: Huge depreciation carry-forwards from the solar investment (where asset return ratios are extremely low) mean the tax rate will remain unpredictable through FY26. No specific guidance was provided.
- Land bank provides hidden value: The company holds 215-220 acres; one 40-acre plot on a highway where a township is developing is estimated at ~₹1 crore per acre, though management declined to value the entire land bank.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So, if you look at the math, our actual cash flow is going to remain fairly constant, whereas the revenue and EBITDA and profitability will increase."
Market Strategy & Competitive Position
- Going deeper, not wider: Management's strategy is to increase market share within the existing 200-300 km radius by deepening relationships with current retail outlets rather than aggressively adding new dealers or expanding geographically. The brand is known in this radius and capacity is insufficient to push further.
- Dealer network expansion is on hold until post-capex: Q1 was not a good quarter to add dealers due to elections; the plan is to target bigger dealers and institutional/government contracts once longer-term pricing and quantity commitments become feasible with higher capacity.
- Partnership approaches exist but nothing concrete: The company has been approached by larger plants for some kind of partnership (possibly white labelling), but no deal has been confirmed. Management is open to such arrangements if they make business sense.
- Consolidation seen as a tailwind, not a threat: Management believes industry consolidation will bring pricing discipline that benefits smaller, cost-competitive players like Shri Keshav, giving them better margins rather than squeezing them out.
- New hires for market expansion: The company has hired experienced people to reach deeper into Maharashtra and south Karnataka, and has already begun sending sample products or initial cement shipments to those regions.
Venkatesh Katwa: "We are more thinking of going deeper, increasing our market share. Since our brand is known in this 200 to 300 kilometer radius from our plant."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| New kiln commissioning | Total capacity reaches 0.1 crore tons per annum | End of Q3 FY25 (Nov/Dec 2024) |
| Cement EBITDA per ton (ex-solar) | ₹900-₹1,000 per metric ton | Post-capex (no specific quarter) |
| Total EBITDA per ton (incl. solar) | ₹1,250-₹1,300 per metric ton | Post-capex (no specific quarter) |
| EBITDA margin | 35-37% | FY26-27; some visibility by Q1 FY26 |
| Legacy debt repayment | Termloan 1, 2 and GECL fully repaid | By March 2026 |
| Solar capacity | 40 MW total (3 MW added Aug 2024) | Commissioned |
| Captive power self-consumption | ~95% of generation used for cement | Post-capex |
| Fuel consumption | 750-850 kcal per ton | Post-expansion |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated total income | ₹31.24 crores |
| EBITDA | ₹8.06 crores |
| EBITDA margin | 26.5%, down from ~30% average last year due to 12% price decline |
| PAT | ₹1.78 crores |
| PAT margin | 5.71% |
| EPS | ₹1.14 |
| Cement sales volume | 63,772 tons, +12% YoY from 55,991 tons in Q1 FY24 |
| Cement production volume | ~63,000 tons |
| Capacity utilization | 70%, up from 62% in Q1 FY24 |
| Current cement capacity | ~0.03 crore tons (300,000 tons) |
| Naked cement rate (plant gate) | ₹3,475 per ton, down ~12% YoY from ₹3,950 in Q1 FY24 |
| Total solar capacity | 40 MW, increased from 37 MW after commissioning 3 MW on Aug 14, 2024 |
| Solar EBITDA contribution | ₹8.1 crores out of total ₹8.85 crores EBITDA |
| Cement EBITDA contribution | ₹75 lakh out of total ₹8.85 crores EBITDA |
| Total debt | ~₹190-200 crores, including ~₹80 crores new capex debt |
| Annual finance cost (last year) | ₹16.9 crores, down from ₹18.7 crores in FY23 and ₹19.2 crores in FY22 |