Key Takeaways
- Solar carried the quarter: Solar contributed ~INR 8 crores of the INR 8.96 crores total EBITDA, while cement remained margin-starved at INR 326/ton, underscoring why the modernization project is now the central thesis.
- The fix is fully scoped and costed: A technical feasibility study is complete, the expansion targets a capex of just \$25–\$30/ton vs. an industry \$150, and management expects cement EBITDA/ton to jump from ~INR 300 to over INR 1,000 post-completion.
- Cement EBITDA improved QoQ without fuel help: Per-ton EBITDA rose from INR 184 to INR 326 by shifting the mix toward slag-based cement and manually segregating high-quality clinker, a workaround that is not generalizable until modernization is done.
- Solar cash flows are the bridge: With a consistent INR 7–8 crore quarterly EBITDA run-rate and a declining cost of production now below INR 2.5/unit, solar provides the muscle to fund and de-risk the cement turnaround.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Q4 groundbreaking for the modernization stays on schedule, any firming up of fundraising terms, and whether the October demand uptick translates into sustained H2 volume and price improvement.
The Cement Problem: Why Modernization Is Non-Negotiable
- Cement barely contributes to EBITDA: In Q2, cement generated only ~INR 1.5 crores of the INR 8.96 crores total, with per-ton EBITDA of INR 326 against an industry benchmark of INR 1,500, a gap management attributes to old technology and operational inefficiency.
- Small scale caps the market reach: Low cement margins make logistics costs prohibitive beyond a tight radius, so the company cannot economically push into larger markets like Pune or Bangalore until per-ton profitability improves.
- The QoQ improvement was additive-driven, not structural: Shifting to more Portland slag cement using slag at INR 1,500–1,600/ton instead of pricier clinker lifted per-ton EBITDA from INR 184 to INR 326, and the team manually segregated high-quality clinker for use with higher additives, a process that cannot scale without modernized equipment.
- H2 cement EBITDA expected to hold at Q2 levels: Assuming stable fuel prices, the Q2 per-ton run-rate should continue, with a full shift from coal to petcoke providing additional support in the second half.
Management: "In this particular quarter, out of EBITDA of around INR 8.96 crores, almost INR 8 crores is contributed by solar itself. So cement, I would say, unless we fix the operational efficiency issues given the capacity utilization also will remain a little restricted."
The Modernization Plan: Scope, Cost & Timeline
- Technical feasibility study is complete: The plan targets increasing cement capacity to 0.1 crore tonnes per annum by modifying the kiln section and adding balance equipment, with no new land, grinding equipment, or raw material grinding equipment required.
- Capex advantage is structural: The project is expected to cost \$25–\$30 per metric ton versus the industry standard of ~\$150, precisely because the existing asset base eliminates the need for major new installations.
- Operational efficiency is the core lever: The modernization focuses on reducing power consumption and incorporating alternative low-cost fuels like municipal waste and rice husk to a certain percentage, directly attacking the cost structure that keeps cement margins depressed.
- Plant stays online during construction: The new grinding unit is independent of the existing one, and the new preheater tower will be built adjacent to the current kiln, requiring only a 20–25 day interconnection shutdown for which sufficient stocks will be built to avoid sales disruption.
- Waste heat recovery is deferred: The current project prioritizes a 6-stage string connection preheater cyclone and using waste heat for coal drying and mill efficiency improvements; WHR may be considered later.
- Groundwork has begun: Basic civil foundation work has started for some small areas, with final RFQs from technical consultants awaited; quotations from suppliers are expected within 3–4 weeks of receipt, then order placement, with major civil work targeted for Q4.
Venkatesh Katwa: "Typically, we are able to execute this project in around between \$25 to \$30 per metric ton, as compared to industry standard of around \$150. This is again mainly because of the fact that we don't have to purchase new land. There's no additional grinding equipment or raw material grinding equipment required."
Solar: The Cash Flow Engine
- Solar EBITDA is now the dominant profit pool: Q2 solar EBITDA was ~INR 8 crores out of INR 8.96 crores total, and the run-rate is expected to remain consistent at INR 7–8 crores per quarter, implying an annualized INR 28–30 crores.
- Revenue surged on new capacity: H1 FY23 solar revenues jumped over 300% to INR 10.44 crores because a 12-megawatt peak plant commissioned at the end of the last financial year brought total capacity to 37-megawatt peak, and solar now contributes 18% of overall H1 revenues vs. 7% previously.
- Cost of production keeps falling: Solar cost per unit was ~INR 4 in 2018 due to interest and O&M; it is now below INR 2.5 and expected to decline further, creating a widening margin tailwind.
- Realization is rising too: Average realization hit INR 6.92/unit in Q2, up from INR 6.66 in Q1 and INR 6.28 in FY20, with the latest month touching ~INR 7 as discoms added fuel escalation surcharges of up to INR 1 on bills.
- Indirect savings from captive use: By using self-generated solar power for cement production, the company avoids the ~INR 1 per kilowatt-hour fuel inflation cost that state discoms are now charging, a saving that flows through without a separate line item.
- Post-expansion, solar goes almost entirely captive: Once cement capacity expands and power demand rises, management intends to consume virtually all solar power in-house, with perhaps less than 5% sold outside.
Management: "We have solar to back it up, which no one can take away from us. In fact, when you send up a solar plant in 2018, the cost of production was around INR 4 because of interest and O&M costs. Today, the cost of production is less than INR 2.5, and that will continue to keep going down. So I'm pretty certain that EBITDA margin only because we have a solar plant, we will not only continue, we expect to improve it further."
Demand & Market Position
- Demand turned in October: The monsoon was moderate and not very encouraging, but October showed a good positive change with demand and prices rising versus the same quarter last year, and further price increases are expected in November.
- Rural markets deliver the best realization: Given the company's small scale and pricing constraints, it focuses on rural markets where it captures the highest net realization, while also supplying government departments like NHAI and, starting this month, one major RMC firm under a three-month contract.
- Geographic footprint is tight: The target area is within a 200 km radius covering Belgaum, Hubli, Dharwad, and Gadag, with a South Maharashtra presence in Ichalkaranji and Kolhapur that has not been significantly expanded.
- Post-modernization, the map opens up: Once cement EBITDA per ton crosses INR 1,000, management plans to serve bigger markets like Pune and Bangalore at its doorstep, targeting capacity utilization of around 90%.
- Industry demand backdrop is supportive: Management cites government spending, real estate, and infrastructure schemes driving an 8–9% CAGR in infrastructure from FY22 to FY27, with urban and rural housing contributing ~8% CAGR over the same period.
Management: "Typically, what is being a prohibitive factor for us right now is being still a very small capacity, our reach is not happening beyond a certain geographical area because in the limitations of our margins on the cement, logistic cost to be heavy cost on the cement because cement is a product with a very low weight rate ratio, which means that you need to have a sufficient EBITDA margins to push it further on geographical location."
Financial Position & Fundraising
- Revenue and EBITDA grew, but the mix tells the story: Q2 FY23 revenue rose 4.84% YoY to INR 24.84 crores, EBITDA grew nearly 24% to INR 8.96 crores, and EBITDA margin expanded over 540 bps to 36.07%, driven by cost pruning and the solar contribution rather than cement strength.
- Finance costs are trending down: Finance costs fell ~15% in Q2 due to continuous repayment discipline, and management expects a better credit rating on current cash flows to cut interest costs further.
- Debt will not be prepaid ahead of schedule: For at least the next year until expansion is complete, debt will reduce only per the existing bank repayment schedule of ~INR 20 crore/year; prepayment may be considered once sufficient post-expansion EBITDA and cash balances exist.
- Fundraising discussions are live but not finalized: The company is negotiating with banks and investors, with promoters prepared to invest internal funds; the split between promoter equity and bank debt could range from 30:70 to 50:50 depending on negotiations, and private equity or placement is also being explored.
- Additional outside debt for capex is estimated at INR 70–75 crores: This would take total outside debt to ~INR 226 crores, but capacity and EBITDA are expected to increase roughly threefold, keeping leverage ratios manageable.
- Tax position benefits from solar depreciation: The quarter's tax provision is MAT of INR 90 lakhs, not regular income tax, because high depreciation from solar creates an ~INR 90 crore income tax depreciation loss carry-forward; actual income tax is not expected for the next 4–5 years, and MAT paid is refundable or adjustable against future taxes.
Post-Expansion Financial Picture
- Top line scales disproportionately to costs: The expansion studies indicate a three-fold increase in top line against only a 30–40% increase in costing due to economies of scale.
- At 80–85% utilization, gross sales target ~INR 550 crores: Net sales are projected at ~INR 450 crores, with cement EBITDA margins improving drastically on fuel and power efficiency gains.
- Management is cautious on margin forecasts: While CMI data suggests post-expansion EBITDA margins well above 40–43%, management notes that power and fuel costs two years out are unknowable; if current costs hold, the expectation is INR 120+ crores of EBITDA on ~INR 400 crores of sales at 80% utilization.
- Cement EBITDA per ton target is over INR 1,000: This would close most of the gap to the industry standard of INR 1,400–1,500, transforming the cement business from a marginal contributor to the primary profit engine.
Management: "No, my CMI data shows it is going well above 40% to 43%. But I would not like to stick to that figure because two years done I don't see what -- I don't know what is going to be the power cost or I don't know what is going to be the fuel cost."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Modernization groundbreaking | Major civil work to start | Q4 FY23 (Jan/Feb) |
| Modernization completion | First brick to first bag: 14–15 months from start; entire capacity in hand | By March 2024 (FY24 end) |
| Cement EBITDA/ton post-expansion | Improve from ~INR 300 to at least over INR 1,000 | On project completion |
| Post-expansion capacity utilization target | ~90% | After modernization, serving larger markets |
| Post-expansion gross sales at 80–85% utilization | ~INR 550 crores gross, ~INR 450 crores net | Post-expansion ramp-up |
| Post-expansion EBITDA at 80% utilization | INR 120+ crores, assuming current power/fuel costs hold | Post-expansion ramp-up |
| Additional outside debt for capex | INR 70–75 crores, taking total outside debt to ~INR 226 crores | During expansion phase |
| Debt prepayment | No prepayment for at least one year; per existing schedule (~INR 20 crore/year) until then | Until expansion complete |
| Solar EBITDA run-rate | INR 7–8 crores per quarter (~INR 28–30 crores annualized) | Ongoing, no significant changes expected |
| Income tax cash outflow | MAT only (~INR 90 lakhs/quarter); no regular income tax | Next 4–5 years |
| Cement H2 EBITDA/ton | Q2 levels expected to continue, with full coal-to-petcoke shift adding support | H2 FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹24.84 cr, up 4.84% vs preceding-year quarter |
| EBITDA | ₹8.96 cr, up nearly 24% |
| EBITDA margin | 36.07%, higher by over 540 bps |
| Profit after tax | ₹1.16 cr, after deferred tax liability of ~₹84 cr |
| Finance costs | down ~15%, on continuous repayment schedule |
| H1 FY23 revenue | ₹58 cr, vs ~₹50 cr in H1 FY22 |
| H1 FY23 PAT | ₹27.61 cr |
| H1 FY23 solar revenue | ₹10.44 cr, up over 300% from ₹3.54 cr in H1 FY22 |
| Solar revenue share of H1 revenue | 18%, vs 7% in H1 FY22 |
| Cement volume | ~46,000 tons |
| H1 FY23 cement volume | ~105,850 tons |
| Cement EBITDA | ₹1.5 cr, vs ₹92.44 lakhs in Q1 |
| Cement EBITDA per ton | ₹326, vs ₹184 in Q1 |
| Solar EBITDA | ₹7.46 cr, vs ₹8.44 cr in Q1 |
| Average solar realisation | ₹6.92 per unit, vs ₹6.66 in Q1 and ₹6.28 in FY20 |
| Solar generation | 1.12 cr units, captive consumption 46 lakh units |
| Outside debt | ₹156.9 cr as of Sep 30, 2022, down from ₹199 cr to ₹169 cr earlier |
| Modernisation project cost | ~₹121 cr, ~$26 per ton |
| Post-capex gross sales target | ~₹550 cr at 80–85% utilisation |
| Post-capex EBITDA expectation | ₹120+ cr on ~₹400 cr sales, assuming current costs and 80% utilisation |