Key Takeaways
- A brutal year, but the turn is visible: EBITDA per ton collapsed to under ₹100 from ~₹350, crushed by fuel costs that peaked in Q2–Q3. Q4 brought the first softening, and Q1 FY24 fuel costs are falling further.
- Modernization is the margin story: The company is finally catching up on efficiency investments peers made a decade ago, targeting a power consumption drop from 1100–1150 kcal/kg to 750–760 kcal/kg, which management says would add ₹800–1,000 per ton to EBITDA at current fuel prices.
- The balance sheet got a reset: ₹45 crores raised via preferential issue and ₹24 crores of promoter debt converted to equity, cutting outside debt by ~₹36 crores and setting up interest savings from April 2023.
- Solar is the quiet stabilizer: 12 MW of captive solar commissioned in FY23 kept total EBITDA flat despite the cement margin collapse, and post-expansion the company expects to use ~90% of that generation.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the falling fuel-cost trend holds through Q1 FY24, the pace of capacity expansion execution toward the June 2024 commissioning target, and any sign that post-election Karnataka demand is rebounding.
The Fuel Shock & Recovery
- FIFO amplified the pain: Q4 production cost on the books reflected petcoke purchased at Q3's higher prices, making the cost appear worse than the spot trend. That accounting drag should unwind as cheaper inventory flows through.
- Fuel mix switch contained the damage: The company moved to 100% petcoke during FY23; coal prices rose even more sharply, so the switch prevented an even worse outcome, though petcoke prices also increased.
- The turn is already underway: Fuel costs peaked in Q2–Q3 FY23, began softening in Q4, and have fallen further in Q1 FY24. Management expects costs to "go down drastically" if the trend continues.
- Normalization target: Another 20% decline in petcoke prices would bring costs back to Q4 FY22 levels.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So now last year we reduced the outside debt from 168 to 148 crores. That is only pure land repayment and conversion of standard debt to equity, we reduced around 36 crores last year. So, this year since the fuel cost has already come down and if it continues to come down, we will wait till the end of the financial year and if it continues to generate extra cash, the management is looking forward to cutting down the debt ahead of the schedule."
Modernization & Capacity Expansion
- The project: Capacity is expanding to 0.1 crore tons (0.1 crore tons) in FY24, with the kiln and pre-heater being modernized or replaced while most other machinery stays intact.
- The efficiency gap: Current power consumption runs at 1100–1150 kcal per kg of clinker; the target post-expansion is 750–760 kcal, a step-change that larger players achieved roughly a decade ago.
- The margin math: Management estimates the modernization would add ₹800–1,000 per metric ton to EBITDA at current fuel prices, taking margins to ₹1,100–1,200 per ton if the plant were complete today.
- Timeline slip: Commissioning is now expected by June 1, 2024, delayed from March because the fundraising closed in April rather than December–January.
- Funding secured: The bank has sanctioned the remaining CAPEX beyond the ₹45 crore preferential issue and has begun disbursing.
Venkatesh Katwa: "So, what we are doing right now is nothing new or nothing miraculous. It is just that what others have done about 10-15 years back we are doing it now. In fact, now we have a better technology and better understanding of machinery. So, we are entering even though it is late but now finally we are putting those machinery and modernization to improve EBITDA margins."
Demand & Volume
- Q4 was election-hit: Sales volume dropped to 56,000 metric tons from 69,000 in Q4 FY22, a loss of ~14,000 tons, as Karnataka state elections slowed government projects and labor became scarce from February onward.
- Realization improved but couldn't save the quarter: Average realization rose to ₹4,210/ton from ₹3,930/ton, driven by marketing and brand-building, but the fuel cost surge consumed the benefit.
- Post-election rebound expected: With a stable government and full majority in Karnataka, management expects cement demand to improve significantly in its operating area.
- Industry tailwinds intact: Management cited 9% demand growth for FY24, driven by government infrastructure spending, the housing sector (60–65% of India's cement consumption), and Union budget allocations for roads, housing, and sanitation.
- Market expansion ambition: Once EBITDA margins improve, the company plans to push into Pune and Bangalore, where consumption outstrips its current production by 10–20 times.
Venkatesh Katwa: "India is still one of the lowest per capita consuming countries amongst SAARC countries itself. In fact, our average consumption is still less than I say 200 kgs whereas the world average has reached over 550 to 600 kgs with China going much higher than that."
Competitive Position & Pricing
- Tier-III leader, Tier-II aspirant: Management claims market leadership among Tier-III players, who typically follow its pricing and marketing model, and says it already competes most with Tier-II brands.
- The Tier-II prize: Reaching 1-million-ton capacity would allow the company to move into Tier-II branding, which management expects would improve pricing.
- Captive power as differentiator: Management stated the company is "probably the only cement plant in the country to run power generation from our internal resources," referencing its solar capacity.
- Freight advantage: Meeting rising local demand saves freight costs because of the ready market in its area of operation.
Venkatesh Katwa: "The EBITDA standards of cements today the larger players are having over Rs. 1000 EBITDA margins whereas our average EBITDA for the last couple of years has been around Rs. 300 on account of the modernization which we have not undertaken yet in the past."
Balance Sheet & Capital Moves
- Preferential issue completed: ₹45.98 crores raised, with all investor commitments received in full.
- Promoter debt converted: ~₹24 crores of promoter debt converted to equity at the same price as the preferential allotment; the conversion executed in the last week of April 2023 but reflected in the March balance sheet per Ind-AS. Interest savings begin from April 2023.
- Debt reduction: Outside debt fell from ₹168 crores to ₹148 crores, with the total reduction including equity conversion at ~₹36 crores.
- Deferred tax note: A ₹24.79 crore deferred tax charge appeared in Q4 FY23 due to an Ind-AS adjustment; it is a one-time, non-cash item.
- Interest cost relief ahead: Management expects a possible 50–75 basis point saving on interest costs after a review by end of October.
Solar Business
- 12 MW commissioned in FY23 out of a total 37 MW planned, and the contribution kept total EBITDA flat despite the cement margin collapse.
- Post-expansion utilization: At 80–90% capacity utilization of the expanded cement plant, the company would use ~90% of existing captive solar generation because power requirement rises only two times while capacity triples.
- No near-term solar expansion: Management will consider adding solar capacity only after the cement plant is commissioned.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity expansion commissioning | Modernized plant at 0.1 crore ton capacity online | June 1, 2024 |
| Power consumption target | 750–760 kcal/kg clinker, down from 1100–1150 | Post-expansion commissioning |
| EBITDA per ton improvement | ₹800–1,000/ton added to current margins from modernization savings | Once expansion is online |
| Debt reduction | Cut debt ahead of schedule if fuel costs keep falling and generate extra cash | By end of FY24 |
| Interest cost saving | 50–75 bps reduction expected | After RBI review by end of October |
| Market expansion | Enter Pune and Bangalore markets | After improved EBITDA margins and cash flow (undated) |
| Tier-II branding | Move up from Tier-III pricing bracket | Once 1-million-ton capacity is achieved |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹32.42 cr |
| FY23 revenue | ₹125.37 cr, up 8% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹8.5 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 26.22% |
| FY23 EBITDA | ₹37.02 cr |
| FY23 EBITDA margin | 29.43% |
| FY23 PAT | ₹2.91 cr |
| FY23 PAT margin | 2.32% |
| Cement sales volume | 56,000 metric tons, down from 69,000 in Q4 FY22 |
| Average realization per ton | ₹4,210, up from ₹3,930 in Q4 FY22 |
| EBITDA per ton (cement) | Less than ₹100, down from around ₹350 last year |
| Solar business revenue (FY23) | ₹26.64 cr |
| Cement business revenue (FY23) | ₹93.20 cr |
| Petcoke price delivered at plant | ₹18,000–19,000 per ton (Q3 purchases consumed in Q4), down to ~₹14,000 as of May 2023 |
| Total borrowings reduction (FY23) | ~₹36 cr reduction, outside debt from ₹168 cr to ₹148 cr |
| Capacity expansion CAPEX | ₹125 cr, ₹45 cr raised via preferential issue |
| Target capacity post-expansion | 0.1 crore tons per annum, threefold increase from 0.036 crore tons |
| Expected commissioning of expansion | June 1, 2024 |
| One-time deferred tax adjustment (Ind-AS) | ₹24.79 cr in Q4 FY23 |