Key Takeaways
- Margin reset underway, Q4 was the trough: EBITDA margin fell to 10.1% in Q4, hit by one-off employee costs, dual-running expenses from the distributor transition, and elevated fuel/logistics costs. Management calls this the worst and targets a ~14% EBITDA margin for FY23.
- Bakery is the growth engine: The bakery segment grew 26.8% YoY in Q4, with both retail and institutional channels in high teens, while biscuits grew just 4.3% as the company deliberately cut market stocks to improve efficiency at peak raw material prices.
- Distribution transformation is a near-term drag with a structural payoff: The shift from company-employed salespeople to a distributor-led model (ADSRs) created dual running costs in Q4, but the new model is 30–40% cheaper and those one-off costs will roll off.
- Price hikes are catching up to inflation: Gross margin declined only 50 bps YoY in Q4 (vs 335 bps for the full year) as quarterly price increases closed the gap, though some hikes in CSD and institutional channels are still pending.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 14% EBITDA margin target starts materializing as one-off costs fade, pending price hikes land, and the new sales IT system (Field Assist) goes fully live in June.
Margin Walk: What Broke and What Fixes It
- Gross margin held up: Q4 gross margin declined only 50 bps YoY to 44.9%, a sharp improvement from the full-year drop of 335 bps, because quarterly price increases progressively recovered raw material inflation.
- The real damage was below the gross line: EBITDA margin fell 300 bps YoY to 10.1%, driven by a ~2% increase in other expenses. Power and fuel rose from 4% to 5% of sales, logistics from 7.5% to 8.81%, and distribution expansion costs kicked in as ADSR count ramped from 65 to 266.
- Employee cost spike was partly one-off: Employee cost hit 14.5% of sales in Q4 (vs 13.9% YoY). Management estimates 0.6%–0.7% of sales was non-recurring: dual running costs of company salespeople and ADSRs in training, plus certain incentives booked in the quarter.
- The fix is structural: The distributor-led front-line model is 30–40% cheaper than company-role employees. As the transition completes, dual costs disappear and the savings become permanent. IT tools (Field Assist) are expected to drive further efficiencies.
- Fuel and logistics remain a wildcard: Higher fuel prices and transportation costs were a material drag, and management expects inflationary pressure to continue for the next two quarters due to geopolitical concerns and supply chain disruptions.
Anoop Bector: "We have always looked at a 14% which is the right number for us and we will stick to our numbers of 14%. You have already seen we came to at a 12.4% this was actually the worst off for the time we faced and it took us time to increase our prices, so still we would work towards the 14%."
The Distribution Overhaul
- What changed: The company shifted from a company-employed sales force to a distributor-led model using ADSRs (distributor sales representatives). ADSR count jumped from 65 to 266, and distributor count rose from 527 to ~543.
- Why it hurt Q4: The transition created dual running costs: company employees were still on the payroll while ADSRs were being trained and deployed. This overlap is temporary and will unwind.
- Why it matters going forward: The new model is structurally 30–40% cheaper. Once the old staff is redeployed or attrited, employee cost is expected to see a "considerable dip."
- Sales digitalization hit a bump: The previous sales tool ("Parry") was discontinued in February when the small vendor stopped support, causing disruption in data capture. The new system (Field Assist) went live in May, with full rollout expected in June, providing outlet-level data on sales and reporting time.
- The bet: Management expects "good numbers" from the combination of increased distribution reach and IT system investments in sales digitalization.
Segment Performance: Bakery Leads, Biscuits Reset
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Bakery | ▲ Strong growth | Q4 revenue grew 26.8% YoY; both retail and institutional channels grew high teens. Segment is up 40.8% vs Q4 FY20. B2B business crossed pre-COVID levels, adding new companies and products. |
| Biscuits (domestic) | ▬ Moderate, improving | Q4 grew higher single digits; full-year domestic sales declined ~5–7% because FY21 had abnormally high COVID pantry loading, but two-year CAGR over FY20 was 13.5%. |
| Biscuits (exports) | ▬ Flattish in Q4 | Q4 was flattish due to shipping logistics issues, but full-year FY22 exports grew 17%. Container availability has now normalized. |
- The deliberate stock reduction: Management chose to reduce market stocks in biscuits during Q4 because raw material prices were at a peak, prioritizing system efficiency over primary sales. Secondary sales were much higher than primary sales in the quarter.
Anoop Bector: "It was very important to reduce your stocks in the market and work towards bringing in better efficiencies in the system... our secondary sales are much higher in the quarter than our primary sales, so there has been an effort by the company that since we are at the peak of the raw material prices we should not be having excess stocks in the market."
Pricing and Raw Material Strategy
- Unprecedented frequency of price action: Management noted this is the first time in company history that prices have been adjusted every quarter rather than once annually, reflecting the severity of raw material inflation.
- What is still pending: Certain price hikes are happening in Q1 FY23 and should be completed by end of June. CSD (Canteen Stores Department) price rises are still pending and expected to take another ~3 months (Q2 FY23). Beyond that, no further hikes are currently anticipated as costs are covered.
- Wheat is locked and competitive: Wheat costs for the year were booked in May; the cost effect is known and will be passed on. Management expects price rises to happen in line with competition since wheat prices are similar for all players.
- B2B pricing is annual and predictable: Institutional customer pricing is reset once a year in Q1, with raw material blocked for the full year to provide predictability. Final discussions on price rises were expected to conclude within days of the call.
- Institutional retention risk is low: Management cited 25-year relationships with key partners and contracts built on "right price, right quality" rather than speculation, saying they have never experienced customer loss from price negotiations.
Anoop Bector: "This is the first time in our history that once normally it used to be one price rise and we used to adjust the price, but over here every quarter we are adjusting our prices, we are working towards how to cover up the inflation and in fact certain part of this is still lying pending."
Capex and Capacity Build-Out
- Rajpura biscuit expansion: Commercial production on the new biscuit line started in May 2022, funded partly by IPO proceeds (₹40.5 Crores).
- Tahliwal-to-Rajpura consolidation: Two biscuit lines are being shifted from Tahliwal to Rajpura to create the largest, lowest-cost production base. Investment is ~₹50 Crores, with payback in 4–5 years through transportation, labor, and gas efficiency savings.
- Khopoli bakery plant: Land has been purchased adjacent to the current Mumbai factory. The plant is finalized, equipment finalization is underway, and commercial production is proposed to start by October 2023. Total project cost is ₹70–73 Crores, with ₹25 Crores to be spent in FY23. Infrastructure is being built for three lines, with only one initially installed; future lines will come at significantly lower cost.
- Greenfield in Madhya Pradesh: The company plans to set up a new facility in MP to cater to West and South India, expanding reach in existing markets and gradually exploring newer ones.
- Cash position is strong: Cash flow from operations was ₹84 Crores in FY22. Working capital days are improving. Higher stocks on the balance sheet are characterized as "opportunity stocks" to be diluted when needed.
Leadership, Premiumization, and the Long Game
- New CEO onboarded: Mr. Manu Talwar joined approximately 40 days before the call, bringing over 30 years of experience from Coca-Cola, Pepsi, Voltas, Bharti Airtel, Viom Networks, Luxor, and Lenskart. He will lead operations, with Ishaan on the bakery side and exports reporting to him; he reports to Anoop Bector.
- Premiumization is early but promising: Premium products grew 3–4% in general trade. Modern trade performed well and, while still a small part of the business, has "immense potential." Biscuits are well accepted in modern trade.
- Marketing mix is shifting: Ad spend is expected to remain at ~8% of sales in FY23, but the mix may shift from BTL to ATL, with more focus on digital marketing: social media integration, influencer marketing, and content marketing.
- The stated ambition: Management aims to build a "very, very strong consumer company" and a "very, very strong food company in India," driven by distribution expansion, premiumization, cost-cutting, bakery growth, and professionalization of management.
Anoop Bector: "Our focus is very clear to have a profitable and a sustainable growth so it is not only about growth it has to be a profitable growth."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | ~14% growth for both biscuit and bakery segments | Going forward (no end date) |
| EBITDA margin | 13.5% to 14% for full year FY23 | FY23 |
| Employee cost | "Considerable dip" as dual running costs end and ADSR transition completes | Going forward |
| Price hikes (general) | Certain hikes happening; to be completed | End of June 2022 |
| Price hikes (CSD) | Pending price rises to be implemented | ~3 months (Q2 FY23) |
| Field Assist rollout | Full 100% rollout of new sales digitalization tool | Effective June 2022 |
| Khopoli bakery plant | Commercial production start | October 2023 |
| Rajpura biscuit expansion | Commercial production started | May 2022 (achieved) |
| Biscuit exports growth | Maintain 14% growth | Going forward |
| Ad spend | ~8% of sales, mix may shift from BTL to ATL | FY23 |
| Capex: Khopoli | ₹25 Crores investment | FY23 |
| Capex: Rajpura/Tahliwal shift | ₹50 Crores investment, 4–5 year payback | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹252 cr, +12.6% YoY |
| Biscuit segment revenue | ₹143 cr, +4.3% YoY; +27.2% over Q4 FY20 |
| Bakery segment revenue | ₹95 cr, +26.8% YoY; +40.8% over Q4 FY20 |
| Gross margin | 44.9%, down 50 bps YoY from 45.4% |
| EBITDA margin | 10.1%, down 300 bps YoY |
| PAT | ₹10.2 cr, vs ₹12.8 cr in Q4 FY21 |
| PAT margin | 4% |
| FY22 consolidated revenue | ₹988 cr, +12% YoY |
| FY22 EBITDA margin | 12.4%, vs 16% in FY21 |
| FY22 PAT | ₹57 cr, vs ₹72 cr in FY21; prior year included ₹5.5 cr entry tax reversal |
| FY22 PAT margin | 5.8%, vs 8.2% in FY21 |
| Domestic biscuit growth | ~8% YoY in Q4; higher single-digit for the quarter |
| Biscuit exports growth (FY22) | 17% YoY; flattish in Q4 due to logistics issues |
| Domestic biscuit realization | ~₹90 per kilo in Q4 |
| Price increase realization | ~10% on domestic side, 15%+ on export side in Q4 |
| ADSR count | 266, up from 65 in Dec quarter |
| Distributor count | ~543, up from 527 in Dec quarter |
| Logistics cost (% of sales) | 8.81%, vs 7.5% in Q4 FY21 |
| Power & fuel cost (% of sales) | 5%, vs 4% in Q4 FY21 |
| Employee cost (% of sales) | 14.5%, vs 13.9% in Q4 FY21; includes ~0.6–0.7% one-off hit |
| Ad spend (% of sales) | ~8% overall (ATL ~2%, BTL ~6%) |
| Final dividend per share | ₹1.25 |
| Net debt to equity | 0.1 |
| Cash flow from operations (FY22) | ₹84 cr, vs ₹110 cr in FY21 |
| Rajpura expansion project cost | ₹40.5 cr from IPO proceeds; commercial production started May 2022 |
| Khopoli bakery project total cost | ₹73 cr including land; ₹25 cr investment in FY23, balance in FY24; production targeted Oct 2023 |
| Tahliwal to Rajpura line shift investment | ~₹50 cr |