Key Takeaways
- Resilient top line, sluggish volumes: Revenue grew 9%, entirely driven by transaction growth of 9%, while volume growth was flattish amid a sluggish traditional trade environment, especially in rural markets.
- Margin progression intact despite competitive intensity: EBITDA margin of 15.6% sits above the historical ~14% average, even as the company took back-ended pricing actions to counter local competitors who returned with aggressive schemes.
- Local players are back, and the company is riding it out: As commodity inflation eased, local competitors re-entered with large schemes, a familiar cycle; management is taking corrective pricing actions without changing its strategic agenda.
- Adjacent businesses are scaling, but unevenly: Drinks delivered very high double-digit growth on the back of aseptic PET bottles, while cake showed green shoots and rusk faced heightened local competition; dairy is still ramping up with the Bell JV.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the back-ended pricing and distribution actions translate into volume recovery, the pace of dairy and rusk capacity scale-up, and any stabilization in rural traditional trade.
Demand & Volume Dynamics
- Transaction growth tells the real story: Management views transaction growth, not tonnage, as the true volume metric because grammage reductions do not prompt consumers to buy an extra pack; transactions grew 9%, matching revenue growth exactly.
- Rural and traditional trade are the soft spots: Slowness is concentrated in traditional trade, more so in rural areas; modern trade and e-commerce remain robust. The company grew rural distribution to 28,000 distributors and is scaling further, but still saw some slowdown it hopes is temporary.
- Focus states outperformed: Focus states grew at 2.2x the rate of the rest of India, validating the targeted distribution strategy.
- Price increases are done for the year: The previously expected 2% price increase will not materialize because commodity prices have softened; management expects a flattish year from a pricing standpoint, with volume growth in high single digits and potential upside.
Berry: "So that 2% will probably not happen this year. It seems that it will be a flattish year from a price standpoint. Yes. So it's not going to be a 2% increase. And the reason for that is the commodity prices."
Competitive Landscape & Pricing Actions
- Local players returned as inflation eased: When inflation was high, local players walked away; now that commodities have normalized, they have come back with large schemes for customers and consumers, a cycle the company has seen before.
- Pricing corrections were back-ended in Q1: As market leader, the company had taken first-mover advantage on all price increases; now it needed to correct where large competitors took pricing downsides or did not follow earlier increases. Most corrective actions happened late in the quarter.
- Market share was stable, gap with No. 2 widened: Management stated market share was flattish and the gap with the second-largest competitor became much larger, though local players gained share through pricing actions in their small vicinities.
- Strategic discipline over tactical reactions: The company is riding out phases of local-player irrationality without changing its strategic agenda, doing only what is necessary to not lose space in the short term.
Berry: "And in that desperation, the local players, especially, they tend to then be a little irrational in what they do. So you've got to just ride out these phases and make sure that your strategic agenda doesn't change, and you do not become tactical, and you also start to do what the local players are doing."
Adjacent Businesses: Progress & Pain Points
| Category | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Drinks (PET) | ▲ Strong | Transitioned to aseptic PET bottles; launched rich milkshakes and coconut water; very high double-digit growth. |
| Dairy | ▲ Ramping | Winkin Cow had a robust season; The Laughing Cow portion launched and doing well; INR10 cheese cases rolling out; captive SMP and butter supply to bakeries started. Bell JV commercial production began, with shortages in early months resolving by month three. |
| Cake | ▬ Green shoots | Sequentially moved up; post-COVID category still finding its feet; innovations like big Swiss Rolls and cupcakes launched; management confident it is moving in the right direction. |
| Rusk | ▼ Competitive | 2,500 local competitors, more so in the north; market growth tepid; company commissioned its own rusk plant in UP for the first time, which will give a major cost and quality advantage. Milk Rusk scaled in Kerala. |
| Bread | ▲ Profitable | Continues to grow profitably. |
| International | ▲ Strong | Middle East and Africa: high double-digit growth with much-improved margins. Rest of international: double-digit profitable growth led by Americas. Nepal: high double-digit growth with expanded margins. Egypt: started business, doing extremely well. Kenya JV: some staffing and forex trouble, but confident it will come in line. |
Cost, Margins & Efficiency
- Margin level is above historical average: The 15.6% Q1 EBITDA margin compares favorably to the ~14% average in FY21 and FY22; management sees itself moving in the right direction on a progression line.
- Commodity tailwinds are material: Palm oil deflation of almost 21%, laminates deflation of 18%, and corrugated box deflation all helped; flour inflation was a modest 3% and the company was covered, so its numbers were better than the industry. Sugar saw slight inflation of 1% YoY.
- Ad spend normalized upward: The single largest contributor to the increase in other expenses was advertising, which rose from 3.5% to 4.2% of revenue, reflecting normalization after COVID-era pullbacks; management expects it to stay in the 4% to 4.2% ballpark.
- Employee and depreciation costs rose with new units: Increases are tied to new dairy, UP, and Tamil Nadu factories plus annual increments; these were partially offset by reductions in conversion cost within other expenses.
- Cost efficiency program resets annually: The program is not carried over from the prior year; the meter starts on day one, and the FY24 target is 7x what it was in FY14. Teams are focused on fuel consumption, renewable energy, market damages recovered, distance traveled, truck utilization, and line throughput.
Berry: "And you've got to remember, once again, that this is not anything which is carried over from the last year. The meter starts on the first day of the year and ends on the last day of the year as far as this is concerned."
Capacity, Distribution & Innovation
- New factories are scaling: Barabanki (UP) is running 5 lines and starting to perform at efficiency; Perundurai (Tamil Nadu) also scaled. Both give capacity in the right places and improve freshness to market. The company is grateful to the UP and Tamil Nadu governments for incentives.
- Rusk capacity added in the north: The company commissioned its own rusk plant in UP, having never had its own rusk client in the north before; this is expected to deliver a major cost and quality advantage against 2,500 local competitors.
- Distribution runway remains: Clear opportunities exist in Hindi states and certain other states; cross-selling of new categories like drinks, flavored milkshakes, and wafers is starting to perform much better.
- Innovation contribution above 10%: Jim Jam Pops launched with advertising; Multigrain Rusk launched in the south; 50-50 Golmaal scaled up and is doing extremely well. Innovation will remain between 4% and 5% of total revenues, with products launched in the last 24 months qualifying.
- Capex for FY24: Approximately ₹400-450 crores, continuing existing projects (Ranjangaon dairy, Bihar factory with incentives, Orissa expansion); no further capacity expansion until volumes and revenues scale up in coming quarters.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | High single digits, with potential upside given the pricing growth change | FY24 |
| Pricing | Flattish year; the previously expected 2% increase will not happen | FY24 |
| Margins | More or less maintain current margins over an average of the next 3-4 quarters while growing top line and volumes | Next 3-4 quarters |
| Ad spend | Remain within 4% to 4.2% of revenue | FY24 |
| Innovation contribution | Remain between 4% and 5% of total revenues | Ongoing |
| Capex | Approximately ₹400-450 crores; continuation of existing projects only | FY24 |
| Tamil Nadu incentive quantification | Assessment likely by H1 | H1 FY24 |
| Dairy growth | Double-digit strong double-digit growth targeted | FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 9% YoY, incorporating transaction growth of 9% |
| 24-month revenue growth | 18% |
| Operating profit growth | 37% YoY |
| 24-month operating profit growth | 22% |
| Profit from operations margin | 15.6% |
| Profit before tax margin | 15.7% |
| Profit after tax margin | 11.5% |
| Volume growth | 0% YoY |
| Price reversals | 1.8% taken in Q1 |
| Market share | Stable; gap with second-largest competitor became much larger |
| Distribution outlets | 26.7 lakh total outlets |
| Rural distributors | 28,000 |
| Focus state growth | 2.2x the growth in the rest of India |
| Innovation contribution | 4% of total revenues currently; dairy innovation contribution greater than 10% |
| Advertising spend | 4.2% of top line, up from 3.5% last year |
| Inter-corporate deposits | ₹760 cr as of June 30, between Bombay Dyeing and Bombay Burmah |
| FY24 capex guidance | ₹400 cr to ₹450 cr |
| Flour inflation | 3% YoY |
| Palm oil deflation | 21% YoY |
| Sugar inflation | 1% YoY, 2% vs last quarter |
| Laminates deflation | 18% YoY, 3% vs last quarter |
| Dow Jones Sustainability score | 53, third amongst FMCG peers in India |
| Sugar reduction | 2% |
| Sodium reduction | ~8% |