Key Takeaways
- Exceptional quarter despite policy shock: Revenue grew 16% YoY to ₹309 crores and PAT rose 30% YoY, achieved even as a surprise $1,200/ton MEP briefly froze basmati exports.
- Margin story has two gears: EBITDA margin expanded 176 bps YoY to 11.5% on freight savings and operating efficiency, while gross margin compressed on high-cost old-crop rice; management expects gross margin recovery next quarter.
- Procurement timing is the hidden alpha: The company bought heavily when the MEP was cut to $850 and again at $950, building inventory at prices that should lift Q3 profitability.
- Domestic pivot is now a formal strategy: After the MEP episode exposed export-only fragility, the company is hiring a domestic team and targeting a 70/30 export/domestic mix within one year.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the gross margin recovery materializes from lower-cost procurement, the pace of domestic distributor appointments, and any further MEP or trade-policy surprises.
The MEP Shock: What Happened and What It Changed
- The ban: On August 25, 2023, the Ministry of Commerce restricted basmati exports below USD 1,200 per metric ton, a price far above the prevailing market of $850–950. Management called it a "big jolt" and the first export interruption since 1980.
- Why it hurt: The government set the MEP using a wrong average price figure, and rectification took time. Pakistan gained significantly during the window while Indian shipments were blocked.
- How the company navigated it: Advance permissions from APEDA provided initial cover, but a prolonged ban would have been "fatal for every company." The episode ended when the MEP was relaxed to $950 in October.
- The strategic consequence: Management concluded that relying almost entirely on exports (89–90% of revenue) is too fragile. The company is now actively building a domestic sales team and distribution network.
Rajeev Setia: "For this quarter, I truly speaking, I was not expecting what we have achieved truly speaking the way I am very candid with you, this 1200 was a big jolt to us because initially we assumed that it is not going to affect us at all because we got the permissions for number of days immediately in advance."
Procurement: The Quarter's Defining Move
- Old-crop drag on gross margins: Gross margin fell to ~21% this quarter because old 1121-variety rice was in high demand and had to be procured at elevated prices, squeezing the spread on those sales.
- The opportunistic buy: When the government cut the MEP to $850 on September 25, the company bought aggressively at competitive prices, including a large volume of pesticide-free rice. A further round of buying followed when the price was cleared to $950. This inventory cushion is expected to boost Q3 profitability.
- Procurement timing repeated: Management noted that 50% of this year's procurement was already done at an excellent time, matching last year's well-timed buying pattern.
- Pricing secrecy: Management declined to share whether procurement pricing is higher, lower, or flat versus last season, calling it trade-sensitive information.
- Crop outlook supports the strategy: A satellite survey across the entire GI area projects approximately 15% more basmati crop this year. Higher crop volumes at procurement time typically mean cheaper prices, and the company "always makes more money" in such years.
Export Performance and Geographic Mix
- 20% YoY export revenue growth, with significant progress in Yemen, the US, Mauritius, Egypt, and Canada. Sales to Israel remained stable despite the conflict, with orders and payments continuing.
- Country disclosure declined: Management refused to name the top five countries contributing 62% of business, stating that trade competitors chase each other's business and "it's better not to ask." Only the US, Canada, and Africa were confirmed as strong performers.
- China base effect: The prior-year quarter included broken-rice exports to China, which were stopped in September, creating a favorable comparison base for this quarter's growth rates.
- Average realization rose 5–6% sequentially, driven by mix and pricing. Pre-COVID realizations were Rs. 60–70/kg; they now stand at Rs. 80–90/kg because paddy prices have structurally risen post-COVID as food security gained global importance.
Rajeev Setia: "Normally we desist disclosing the names of country where we're doing good. Maybe market knows it, but market means our trade people must be knowing it. They chase each other's business, so it's better not to ask."
Domestic Market: The New Frontier
- Current state: Domestic sales are ~₹150 crore annually, roughly 10% of the business. They did not increase this quarter because the domestic team build-out only began after the MEP episode.
- The target: Management aims for a 70/30 export/domestic revenue mix within one year, implying domestic sales would roughly triple from current levels.
- Distribution strategy: The company will first appoint distributors across India, who will then sell to mom-and-pop stores. Online channels (Amazon, Flipkart, JioMart) are already live and "picking up gradually."
- No advertising blitz: Management explicitly ruled out burning ₹30–40 crore on advertising, opting instead for a slow, steady distributor-led build.
- Brand visibility timeline: Management expects Maharani brand visibility "everywhere" in India to start materializing "in a year or so."
Rajeev Setia: "In any case, after this MEP episode, we realized that need of the hour is to start domestic business. Also, we are hiring the team, good people who can give us at least good business because it Rs.150 crore, 100 around 150 crore is the domestic business annually, which comes through almost 10% of the entire. So, it is need of the hour. India is a big market, people are paying the price for the quality and India is growing country now. You can't leave it up."
Brands, Value-Added Products, and Pesticide-Free Strategy
- Proprietary brands surged 91% YoY and now account for approximately 11% of overall sales. Value-added products (diabetic-friendly rice, quick-cooking brown rice) tripled during the period.
- Pesticide-free inventory built: The company has 10,000 tons of pesticide-free paddy ready in Karnal, targeted at Europe and other markets with stringent pesticide checks.
- Branded sales ambition is directional, not committed: Management said it is their "endeavor" to grow branded sales and offered a loose assumption of 25–30% growth over 2–3 years, but declined to give a percentage-of-revenue target.
- UK FTA opportunity: If the India-UK free trade agreement covers basmati rice duty-free, it would be "very good" for the company. Currently, only unpolished basmati enters at lower duty, which management argues disadvantages Indian millers.
Ankit Setia: "I have ready stock 10,000 tons, which is pesticide free, ready to be exported to Europe. It can go to the hardest country where they're checking pesticides."
Profitability Mechanics and Cash Flow
- EBITDA margin walk: Margins expanded 176 bps YoY to 11.5%, driven by operational efficiency and freight cost savings.
- Gross margin compressed to ~21% this quarter on high-cost old-crop rice, but management expects recovery in the coming quarter as lower-cost procured inventory flows through.
- Per-kg profitability: Ankit Setia noted the company sold ~35,000 tons and made ₹10 per kilo, calling it "remarkable" for the quarter.
- Structural margin advantage: The company earns more than peers because it pays vendors in 3–4 days and deducts 2%, effectively buying cheaper, while its marketing team sells under both private labels and the company's own brands globally.
- Cash flow transformation: H1 cash flow from operations surged to ₹253 crores from ₹71 crores in the prior-year period, driven by profit growth and prudent working capital management. Inventory, which was ~₹400 crores in March, was drawn down to minimal levels by September-end ahead of the new season.
- Working capital discipline: The company works within limits, avoids selling on credit except to very long-standing buyers, insures all exports with ECGC, and does not age rice for prolonged storage. An ECGC claim of ₹2.85 crores was received this quarter for a Chinese buyer default.
Rajeev Setia: "I make payment to my vendor in three to four days and deduct 2% when I deduct 2% and give them payment without asking. I know I get one or two percent higher in this value. I mean they sell me at a cheaper price relatively. You see, so 3-4% is the gain at the point of purchase and the rest is our marketing team, Ankit and Sankesh run around the world, and they go to very far places, and they sell there in the private label, in our own label. So, this is easy to attain, achieve not something, we can continue like this."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue target | ₹1,400 crore, with potential to exceed | FY24 |
| Export/domestic mix | Shift to 70/30 from current ~90/10 | Within one year |
| Gross margin recovery | Gross margins to increase from ~21% this quarter | Q3 FY24 |
| Q3 profitability | Q3 expected to be "even more favorable"; next quarter results "going to be even better" | Q3 FY24 |
| Domestic brand visibility | Maharani brand visibility to start appearing "everywhere" in India | "In a year or so" |
| Pesticide-free exports | 10,000 tons of pesticide-free stock ready for Europe | Current year |
| MEP policy stance | Government indicated MEP will not be set this way again; will be based on paddy prices and market conditions | No date (policy intent) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹309 cr, +16% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹36 cr, +37% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 11.5%, expanded 176 bps YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹26 cr, +30% YoY |
| Gross margin | ~21%, down from normalized 24–25% |
| H1 revenue | ~₹570 cr, ~45% of FY23 full-year revenue of ₹1,400 cr (per an analyst's math) |
| H1 EBITDA | ₹74 cr, +26% YoY |
| H1 PAT | ₹54 cr |
| H1 cash flow from operations | ₹253 cr, vs ₹71 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Export revenue growth | +20% YoY |
| Export share of revenue | 89% (approx 90%), domestic 10% |
| Average realization | ₹90 per kg, +5–6% QoQ (management estimate); prior quarter ₹83–85 per kg |
| Volume sold | ~35,000 tons |
| Profit per kg | ₹10 per kg (EBITA of ₹35 cr on 35,000 tons) |
| Proprietary brand sales share | 11% of overall sales, +91% YoY |
| Net cash position | ₹196 cr as of Sep 2023 |
| Return on capital employed (H1) | 20% |
| Return on equity (H1) | 17% |
| Top 5 countries contribution | 62% of Q2 business |
| Pesticide-free raw material stock | 10,000 tons ready in Karnal |
| Procurement progress (new season) | 50% already completed |
| Basmati crop estimate (new season) | ~15% higher than preceding year, per satellite survey |