Key Takeaways
- New CEO sets a category-growth agenda: In her first 100 days, MD & CEO Prabha Narasimhan committed to restoring volume growth by driving daily brushing in rural India, a journey she acknowledges will take time because moving consumer behaviour is difficult.
- Premiumization is now a three-pronged science play: The strategy leans on upgraded family health (Colgate Total), a new Oral Beauty pillar (Whitening) that is less price-elastic, and dentist-led indication-based solutions, though management warns inflation may make this a slow burn.
- Personal Care is a declared investment zone: The company intends to build a viable Palmolive business in hand, body and face care, and is open to inorganic opportunities, but EBITDA will be much lower than the company average during the investment phase.
- Distribution and digital tools are the growth engine: Gains in north, central and east India have been fuelled by a four-year distribution push, while tools like the AmaZing merchandiser app and the Smile Stores platform are automating last-mile sales decisions.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the whitening and charcoal launches sustain their early traction, any sign of a turnaround in declining category volumes, and concrete steps on the Dentist FIRST platform ahead of its 2023 go-live.
Category Growth & Volume Strategy
- The core problem: Category volume is declining this year, and outside a distribution-led expansion phase, volume growth has been muted despite attractive macros. The primary task is to drive category development, particularly in rural India, by exhorting consumers to brush daily.
- The behavioural challenge: Management views growing penetration as easier than growing consumption, requiring the right product at the right price point in the right place, executed consistently over long periods. The commitment is to restore the growth seen two to three years back, driven by the category.
- Pack-size architecture: The evolution of pack sizes has allowed consumers to trial core brands like Colgate Strong Teeth rather than staying with Cibaca, and these price points have truly driven trials of core brands. Management does not believe it needs to go below the Rs. 10 price point, which is represented across the entire core portfolio.
- Distribution muscle: A huge push over the last four to five years has built significant strength in north, central and eastern India, and that is where distribution gains and business growth have come from. Technology like Smile Stores keeps outlets active and continuously stocking, while digital tools guide the salesman on what to sell day-to-day, coupling distribution with the right affordability pack sizes.
Narasimhan: "Our first and primary focus is really for us as leaders of the category to drive category volume growth. I do realize that this is a task and a journey that will take some time because moving consumer behavior is never the easiest thing in the world, but it is a task that we are committed to."
Premiumization & Innovation
- Three-pronged premiumization strategy: (1) Family health and protective oral care with better technology, moving consumers from Colgate Strong Teeth into Colgate Total; (2) Oral Beauty, a brand-new play distinct from hygiene and protection that tends to be much less price-elastic; (3) leveraging dentist and professional partnerships to drive indication-based solutions that are also price-inelastic. Management cautions that inflation and pressures might make premiumization a relatively slow burn.
- Whitening gaining traction: The Colgate Whitening launch, a big foray into oral beauty, is seeing great traction and mix improvement alongside the base Visible White product. Colgate owns 70% of the whitening segment, and the product has been taken into the Rs. 30 and Rs. 35 price segments.
- MaxFresh Charcoal: Recently launched, combining MaxFresh equity with the charcoal ingredient, and has gone into the market beating early estimates.
- Naturals market plateau: The naturals market grew 900 bps from 2016 to 2019 but has plateaued from 2020 to 2022, growing only about 40 bps. Consumers are starting to differentiate between Ayurveda ingredients and more scientific-based positioning.
- Toothbrush innovation: The Gentle toothbrush range has been by far the most successful, seeing phenomenal results through 2022. The Super Flexi toothbrush launched this year after a decade with strong distribution and visibility uplift, while the Visible White O2 toothbrush was launched to enhance whitening impact in conjunction with toothpaste. Electric toothbrushes remain nascent but are expected to become quite large, with a play across the ProClinical range, kids range, and adult launches.
Narasimhan: "I think we have 3 prongs to it. One, there is this idea of family health for protective oral care... Then, of course, we have this whole idea of Oral Beauty and Oral Beauty opens up a vast vista of things that we can do to drive premiumization. It is very distinct from the hygiene and protection play of Oral Care. It's a brand-new play, tends to be much less price elastic than the core business... And then the third one... is for us to leverage our partnerships with dentist and the professionals to make sure that we're able to drive indication where once again, when you have a real problem, you need a real solution. And there, again, you tend to be quite price inelastic."
Personal Care Build-Out
- Declared ambition: The intention is to build a viable personal care business with cornerstone brand Palmolive, and also to look at inorganic opportunities to build this viable business. Between body care, hand care and face care, management sees enough room to play in large markets where Colgate is relatively very small.
- Current footprint: Palmolive hand and body holds about a 20 share of market in some key e-commerce customers. Palmolive Face Care launched through 2022 as a pilot and is in a learning phase before scaling.
- Investment economics: Personal care typically tends to be high gross margin but low EBITDA, especially at the investment stage. Management is willing to commit to the investment, with gross margins at reasonable levels but EBITDA much lower than the rest of the company because of investing behind the brand.
- Portfolio scope: Right now the focus will be hand, body and face, though management is not closing the door to doing more than that. The company is also not saying no to further expansion into areas where Colgate plays globally, but at this moment Oral Care and Personal Care will be the focus.
Narasimhan: "Our intention is to build a viable personal care business, with our cornerstone brand, Palmolive, but also to look at inorganic opportunities that will allow us to build this viable business."
Channels & Digital Infrastructure
- Future-facing channels: Shares in e-commerce and modern trade are usually higher than shares in traditional trade, and management expects these channels to grow faster and faster. The D2C site cpbrush.co.in, launched towards the back end of last year, has done really well through this entire year.
- Revenue Growth Management and Funding the Growth: RGM uses analytics to drive premiumization, promotional efficiency and pricing, while FTG takes cost out of the system with cross-functional teams generating cost-saving ideas beyond their normal responsibilities. Both have driven efficiencies and allowed reinvestment behind brands.
- Digital tools in the field: The AmaZing tool, rolled out six months back and scaled up rapidly, has saved significant time for merchandisers and automated in-store execution. An in-house digital lab is creating digital assets at faster turnaround times, saving 87% in production costs versus external agencies.
- Last-mile automation: Technology and automation are being used to take decision-making away from the last-mile salesman and assist him digitally, making it foolproof to drive what the company wants to drive. Different techniques guide the salesman on what to sell on a day-to-day basis, coupling distribution with the right pack sizes.
Professional & Social Impact Platforms
- Dentist FIRST platform: Launched and in beta testing, expected to go live in 2023. The platform will give dentists access to information and products from Colgate, with a plan to expand the portfolio of products targeted at dentists and consumers of dentists, bringing more products from Colgate global into India.
- Bright Smiles, Bright Future: Management intends to double down on this program, which has reached 17 crore children. The company is utterly 100% committed to the oral health of the country, and the program has evolved and will continue to evolve. A new BSBF module is being rolled out in Andhra Pradesh based on all learnings of how to drive behaviour change.
- Project Chirunavvu: A recent tie-up with the Andhra Pradesh government on oral health, tobacco spitting, and setting up dental infrastructure in the state, reaching about 0.4 crore children.
Narasimhan: "That one chart which says the 17 crore children reach is probably the chart that makes me smile at night before I go to sleep, and it is something that I hope that we will make stronger and stronger."
Organization, Talent & Sustainability
- New leadership: Prabha Narasimhan joined as MD & CEO, bringing about 24 years of experience from HUL. In her first 100 days, the mandate from global has been to drive growth in India because everybody sees the headroom opportunity, and she reports seeing no constraints on local decision-making.
- Talent build: A new Head of Technology, Swati, has been appointed, bringing experience from HUL, J&J and Reckitt. The organization is focused on getting external skills in digital marketing, commerce, data and analytics, and automation and robotics in the supply chain, while also exploring partnerships and the gig talent pool. Programs like LEAP and Evolve are geared toward developing deep expertise and new skills internally.
- Culture and simplicity: The idea is to keep the business simple, free of unnecessary sludge, digitized end-to-end, and have people energized and fit to compete in a new world. Initiatives are focused on driving 'Feed' (focused, empowerment, experimental and digital) to build a performance-oriented and agile organization.
- Sustainability milestones: The maiden ESG report was published this year. A few products have already been launched in recyclable tubes, with a commitment to go to 100% of the portfolio in recyclable tubes in the near future. The KEEP toothbrush concept, with a metal handle and replaceable head, aims to reduce plastic.
Narasimhan: "...the idea is really for us at an entire organization level to make sure that we continue to keep what is a simple business, simple free of unnecessary sludge as I have been reading about in a book, make sure that we are digitized end-to-end and make sure that we have our people energized and fit to compete in a new world."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Category volume growth | Drive category development, particularly in rural India, with the idea "brush teeth every day" | Acknowledged as a journey that will take some time; no date given |
| Dentist FIRST platform | Platform for dentists to access information and products; expand portfolio from Colgate global | Go-live in 2023 |
| Recyclable tubes | 100% of portfolio in recyclable tubes | "In the near future" |
| Personal care investment | Build a viable Palmolive business; willing to accept lower EBITDA during investment phase | No date; scaling awaits a proven model |
| Premiumization strategy | Three-pronged approach: family health, Oral Beauty, dentist-led indications | "Over a period of time will give results"; inflation may make it a slow burn |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹5,066 cr (FY22 full year), crossed ₹5,000 cr mark |
| Gross margin | 67.1% (FY22) |
| Advertising spend | 12.7% of sales (FY22) |
| Profit to sales ratio | 21.3% (FY22) |
| EBITDA growth | Up 900 bps over 10 years |
| EPS growth | Up 2.4x over last 10 years |
| Dividend per share growth | Up 3.2x over last 10 years |
| Working capital | Minus 29 days |
| Shareholder value CAGR | 24% since inception |
| Premium portfolio contribution | Close to double digit overall, high double digits in e-commerce and modern trade, slow build in traditional trade |
| Store reach | 0.17 crore stores, 95% active every quarter |
| Toothpaste market volume | ~250,000 tons currently |
| Rural consumers not brushing daily | 55% |
| Naturals market share growth | ~40 bps from 2020 to 2022, plateauing after 900 bps growth from 2016–2019 |
| Whitening segment share | 70% owned by Colgate |
| Bright Smiles, Bright Future reach | 17 crore children reached |