Key Takeaways
- Intentional wholesale slowdown masks retail stability: Total disbursements fell YoY and QoQ because management deliberately pulled back on lumpy wholesale lending, while SME retail disbursement held steady at Q3 levels.
- Asset quality is a multi-quarter clean-up story: GNPA fell to 0.61% and net NPA to 0.35%, marking eight straight quarters of decline, with bad-debt recoveries of ₹2.33 crores in FY23 and provision coverage above 200%.
- NIM compressed as funding costs bit late: NII grew 43%, lagging 57% total income growth, because borrowing costs linked to MCLR and repo rates rose sharply in Q3 and Q4, pushing the weighted average cost of funds from under 10% to 11.1%.
- The platform build is done, the growth pivot starts now: After 18 months of technology, policy and team stabilization, plus lender base expansion from 4 to 15, management says the focus shifts to growth in both divisions, with scope to lever up from only 1.13x debt.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised easing in cost of funds materializes into lower borrowing rates, the pace of the wholesale book’s transition to floating rates, and the first few onboardings of the new unsecured loan product by end of Q1 FY24.
Funding Cost & Margin Dynamics
- Cost of funds trajectory: Rose from less than 10% at the start of FY23 to approximately 11.25% by Q4, with the weighted average cost of borrowing at 11.1% and the entire increase concentrated in Q3 and Q4.
- NIM pressure mechanics: NII growth of 43% trailed total income growth of 57% because higher MCLR- and repo-linked borrowing costs kicked in during the second half, compressing net interest margin in Q3 and Q4.
- Pass-through strategy: Management intends to pass higher borrowing costs on to customers over the coming few quarters, which it expects will help improve net interest margin.
- Wholesale book transition: A strategic move is underway to shift the wholesale book toward floating rates, insulating the company from future interest-rate moves; effects are expected to become visible over the next three quarters.
- Recent easing signal: Pressure on cost of funds observed through March has not been seen in the last one and a half months; management now perceives more bargaining power with new lenders to reduce the cost of borrowing compared to March levels.
Management: "Now that pressure we have not seen in the last one and half months which was there, I would say till March. Now, whatever we are speaking to a lot of new lenders for this quarter, and we are not seeing that. Now, we are seeing a little ease, now we have a little more bargaining power in telling them that to reduce the cost of borrowing as what was in March."
Asset Quality & Provisioning
- Eight-quarter clean-up streak: GNPA and net NPA have consistently decreased for the last eight quarters, with GNPA at 0.61% and net NPA at 0.35%, while the provision coverage ratio exceeds 200%.
- SME NPA turnaround: Gross NPA on the SME book fell from ₹10 crores to ₹4 crores over 18 months even as the book grew by ₹200 crores, and roughly ₹5.5 crores was recovered on written-off amounts post January 2022.
- COVID-era hangover nearly resolved: During COVID, gross NPA crossed ₹2.92 crores mostly from SME, with 65–70% of 290 school accounts becoming NPA; most have since regularized or been resolved, leaving only 15–20 accounts under ₹5 lakh, mostly unsecured.
- Pre-COVID portfolio rundown: The pre-COVID portfolio is now under ₹30 crores, roughly 12–13% of the total book, because of heavy foreclosures in the last financial year; most of the portfolio is now post-COVID originations.
- Conservative provisioning policy locked in: The company maintains a 1% provision on Stage 1 and 2 assets versus the 0.4% statutory requirement, plus 0.4–0.5% on secured assets; roughly 60% of provision growth was for standard assets, and management intends to maintain this policy going forward.
- Wholesale credit quality: Not a single account in the wholesale book is in DPD.
Management: "We are a little more conservative and so we tend to carry this policy because we have made a policy now we do not intend to change it and we like to maintain the same policy going forward."
SME Retail: Portfolio Shift & Operating Model
- Deliberate ticket-size and LTV migration: Average ticket size rose from ₹7 lakh to ₹10 lakh and LTV from roughly 27% to 34%, reflecting a post-COVID strategy shift away from marginal 5–7 lakh rural borrowers toward better-quality urban and semi-urban borrowers with multiple properties, stronger collateral, and more predictable cash flows.
- Account churn dynamics: 1,140 accounts were boarded in FY23, but many were foreclosed or taken over by other banks; net active accounts rose from roughly 1,450 to 2,076.
- Collection efficiency is structural, not uniform: Company-wide collection efficiency held at 99% for the full year, with SME at roughly 98.5%; the bouncing percentage runs 12–14%, but 80–85% is collected directly via NACH at presentation, and when one customer slips in a month another substitutes, keeping 0–90 DPD efficiency at 98–99%.
- SME DPD behavior explained: Customers in Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities sometimes miss one or at most two EMIs due to seasonality, health issues or marriages, then become regular by paying two EMIs the next month.
- Human-touch underwriting: The SME process involves 110% human touch, from the relationship manager to branch manager, credit manager, regional credit manager and journal credit manager; the leadership team meets the client irrespective of loan amount, and an exclusive audit team visits the client before cheque handover to verify policy disclosure and business assessment.
- Balance transfer risk contained: Only around 10 loans have been balance-transferred away from CSL in the past 18 months, mostly because customers needed a top-up beyond CSL’s ticket size; customers tend to stay because of the fixed rate of interest for the entire tenure, with average tenure at 24–36 months.
Management: "When you are targeting a Tier-2, Tier-3 city and small businesses all businesses are not at the same velocity every month and because of some seasonality some encountering any health issue, some go having any marriage and all those certain sometimes one can see a customer missing one or at max two EMIs which is getting regularized..."
Wholesale Book & Mix Transition
- Wholesale is lumpy by design: Disbursements and collections on the wholesale side are inherently lumpy, so management urges viewing wholesale performance on a yearly rather than quarterly basis.
- Loan book growth vs. disbursement gap: FY23 disbursements of roughly ₹760 crores translated into loan book growth of only ₹216 crores because wholesale collections are much larger than scheduled repayments, customers often prepay, and accounts close within 24–36 months versus a 48-month sanction.
- AUM mix target: Management aims to transition the AUM mix from the current 60-40 (wholesale-SME) to 50-50 by the end of the next financial year, with 50-50 to 60-40 seen as an optimum level over the next two to three years and SME as the focus area going forward.
- Geographic expansion paused in one market, pivoting to another: The targeted Chandigarh region (Panchkula, Mohali, Dera Bassi, Zirakpur) was found not matured to CSL’s parameters, so expansion there is on hold for 6–12 months; management now wants to explore parts of Uttaranchal, especially Dehradun.
- Credit rating upgrade path: Two major concerns for a rating upgrade are top-20 customer exposure and geographic concentration of wholesale; ₹1,000 crores may be an unofficial benchmark, and expansion to other areas will proceed as the company grows.
Rohit Gupta: "Further, as a strategic move we are getting more active on transitioning our wholesale book towards floating rates, which will insulate us from certain moves and interest rates going forward. You will see effects of this in the coming three quarters."
Branch Economics & Scalability
- Branch-level profitability inflection: At least 82–85% of branches have already reached ₹7.5–8 crores AUM; moving beyond this level will improve profitability because no additional manpower is being added, only replacement cost, and management intends to achieve at least 2.5x profitability in coming two to three years.
- SME retail already profitable: SME retail is already profitable when measured without imputing cost of equity; operating expenses will not increase proportionally with business scale, so incremental business will deliver higher margins, and the platform is ready to scale.
- Branch breakeven cadence: Branches are categorized A, B, C based on market potential; a Jaipur branch reaches ₹10 crores faster than smaller locations like Rajsamand or Sikar; the first three months are a ramp period, the average target is ₹80–90 lakh per branch per month, and it takes 13–14 months to reach ₹10 crores.
- Productivity target: With the platform now ready, branch average productivity is expected to move from ₹70 lakh to ₹1.25 crores, and all branches are expected to be profitable in the coming financial year without proportional OPEX increase.
- Branch expansion plan: 6–10 new branches will be rolled out in the coming financial year, with 1–2 underperforming branches possibly shut down, for a net addition of 8–10 branches; employee additions will happen only at the branch level with new branches, but at the current level the company is well placed to cater to a larger set of operations.
New Initiatives: Unsecured Product & Co-Lending
- Unsecured product design: A new unsecured loan product targets a niche, order-based segment, funding raw material purchases by discounting purchase bills rather than offering personal loans or business loans to the general public; ticket sizes start at ₹50,000 to ₹2.5 lakh, with repayment expected within 60–90 days and a completely digital platform.
- Risk framing: Management views this as far less risky than small-ticket personal loans to the public at large, because it targets a specific segment with order-backed requirements and uses weighted data of existing clients sourced from a very large company.
- Yield target: The company will target a 20%-plus yield to start with, but the dynamics of the business will ultimately determine IRR; the rate may be reduced if the segment proves extremely fine and operating and credit costs come in much lower as a percentage.
- Launch timeline: The separate platform has been built; the first few accounts are expected to be onboarded by the end of Q1 FY24, with more details to be shared once that happens.
- Co-lending and down-selling ramp: From this year onward, the company has started down-selling, completing one transaction with Kotak and one with TFCI; a co-lending partner named is Rajasthan Global Securities, a roughly ₹1,500–1,800 crore NBFC that has worked with CSL for four years, used when ticket sizes go beyond ₹15–20 crores.
- Co-lending strategic logic: The core target for next year is to do higher business while remaining within limits on the company’s own books by bringing business through co-lending mode and assigning or down-selling, which will add to gross IRR while maintaining market presence.
Management: "They are far better as compared to giving PL loans of 50,000-1,00,000 to public at large then targeting a particular segment based on that where they have been doing business for last..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM mix transition | Move from 60-40 to 50-50 wholesale-SME mix | By end of next financial year (FY24) |
| Wholesale book floating-rate transition | Effects of transition to floating rates to become visible | Coming three quarters |
| Branch expansion | Net addition of 8–10 branches (6–10 new, 1–2 closures) | FY24 |
| Branch AUM milestone | At least 50% of branches to cross ₹20 crores AUM | FY24 |
| Branch-level AUM minimum | At least ₹10 crores per branch | FY24 |
| SME new book target | At least ₹200–220 crores of new SME book | FY24 |
| Branch profitability | 2.5x profitability per branch | Coming two to three years |
| Unsecured product launch | First few accounts onboarded | By end of Q1 FY24 |
| Unsecured product yield | Target 20%-plus yield to start | At launch |
| Provisioning policy | Maintain 1% on Stage 1 & 2, 0.4–0.5% on secured | Ongoing |
| AGM scheduling | Schedule AGM earlier, not bunch during last 10 days | From FY24 onwards |
| Geographic expansion (wholesale) | Evaluate Dehradun market; Chandigarh region on hold | Dehradun: near-term; Chandigarh: 6–12 months wait |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Loan book (AUM) | ₹732 cr, highest ever, +41% YoY and +8% QoQ |
| AUM mix | 60% wholesale, 40% SME retail, highest ever in favor of SME retail |
| Total disbursement | ₹147 cr, lower both YoY and QoQ |
| Total income | ₹118 cr, +57% over FY22 |
| Net interest income | ₹88 cr, +43% over FY22 |
| PAT | ₹146 cr, +36% over previous year |
| ROE | 12.56% |
| ROA | 6.94% |
| Collection efficiency | 99% for the full financial year; wholesale at zero DPD, SME at ~98.5% |
| GNPA | 0.61%, consistent decrease for last 8 quarters |
| Net NPA | 0.35% |
| Provision coverage ratio | >200% |
| Leverage | 1.13x, vs 0.64x in FY22 and 0.98x in Q3 FY23 |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 50% |
| Cost of funds | ~11.25% as of Q4, up from <10% at start of FY23; weighted average cost of borrowing 11.1% |
| SME retail active accounts | 2,076, up from ~1,450 at beginning of FY23; 1,140 accounts boarded in FY23 |
| Average ticket size (SME) | ₹10–12 lakh, increased from ₹4–5 lakh earlier |
| Average LTV (SME) | 34%, up from ~27% |
| Branch breakeven AUM | ₹6.5–7 cr; current AUM per branch ₹7.92 cr |
| SME LAP book | ~₹85 cr, mostly in NCR, LTVs <40–45%, average yield 16.5% |
| Bad debts recovered | ₹2.33 cr in FY23 |
| AUM mix target | 50-50 wholesale-SME by end of next financial year |
| Net branch addition planned | 8–10 branches in FY24 (6–10 new, may shut 1–2 underperforming) |
| SME new book target | At least ₹200–220 cr in FY24 |