Key Takeaways
- AUM target met, mix shifting retail: AUM grew 38% YoY to Rs. 1,030 crore, hitting the FY24 target, with the SME retail share moving to 44% from 40% a year ago.
- Asset quality improved, provisioning conservative: GNPA and NNPA fell 17 bps and 10 bps YoY respectively, while the company maintained a flat 1% provision on the loan book, well above the regulatory 0.4%.
- Suvidha unsecured loan product paused for re-engineering: Disbursements and collections slowed in Q4 due to on-ground challenges, prompting a deliberate reset of systems and processes before a planned Q2 FY25 relaunch.
- Credit rating upgrade unlocks cheaper funding: An upgrade to A- is expected to lower the cost of borrowing by 50-75 bps over the next 2-3 quarters, primarily by opening access to PSU banks.
- What to watch next quarter: The July relaunch of the re-engineered Suvidha loan platform, the pace of branch expansion, and whether the rating upgrade benefit begins to flow through to NIMs.
Suvidha Loan: The Pause and the Relaunch
- Product challenges surfaced in Q4: The Suvidha loan, an unsecured product for a Muslim-dominated fabricator community in the North, saw a slowdown in disbursements and collections, partly due to the Ramadan festive month and partly due to on-ground issues with loan account behavior.
- Intentional ticket size reduction: Management deliberately reduced the ticket size over the last two quarters to treat the initial phase as a pilot, focusing on learning customer behavior and building a repayment history before scaling.
- System re-engineering underway: Learnings from the pilot include the need to capture e-way bills, prevent disbursements to the same address or co-applicant, and improve real-time MIS, all of which are being incorporated into a new loan origination and disbursement platform.
- Platform launch delayed to July: The rollout of the dedicated new platform, built by vendor Synoriq, was delayed due to complexities on both sides: the vendor was busy with a beta2 version integrating accounting and an LMS for wholesale settlement, while CSL itself made frequent change requests.
- Relaunch with higher IRR target: Post-relaunch, the company will charge interest from day one, moving beyond the APL Apollo subvention model, and can now target an IRR 300-400 bps higher than the initial 20-22% to cover credit costs.
- Long-term potential framed, near-term target avoided: Management sees a 10-15% penetration opportunity among 150,000 fabricators over 2-3 years, implying a Rs. 150-200 crore AUM, but declined to quantify the book size a year from now, calling it "difficult to quantify."
Rohit Gupta: "I want to reiterate that our utmost focus is on first establishing robust production systems, followed by growth. We do not want to lend loosely, especially given that this is our first unsecured product offering."
Funding & Liability Strategy
- Rating upgrade is the quarter's structural win: The credit rating upgrade to A- from BBB+ unlocks PSU banks that had a minimum A- threshold, a segment where loan sizes are larger and not always available from small finance banks or larger NBFCs.
- Cost of borrowing to fall 50-75 bps: Management expects the benefit to flow from all lenders, but especially from the PSU front, over the immediate 2-3 quarters.
- NIM impact will be gradual: Only 25-30% of the benefit will be realized in the first year because it applies only to incremental borrowing; the net addition to NIMs is estimated at 0.25-0.3% in year one, with higher figures in years two and three.
- Lender base expanding: Two new lending partners, DCB Bank and Indian Overseas Bank, were added in Q4, taking the total to 23 from 15 a year ago, with future focus squarely on PSU banks and larger private sector banks.
- Off-book AUM building: The company accumulated Rs. 104 crores in off-book AUM through direct assignment, co-lending and down-sell models, and expects this to grow, generating sustainable fee-based income.
Rohit Gupta: "the rating definitely will help us on the PSU front, especially because certain banks have put a threshold of A-. In spite of that, they were keen to lend us and that was one limitation for us and with this coming first, a lot of PSUs will get open for us and secondly the size which you can get from the PSUs are sometimes not available from the small finance bank or the larger NBFCs."
Asset Quality & Collections
- Portfolio quality improved across the board: GNPA and NNPA improved by 17 bps and 10 bps respectively over FY23, with zero NPAs in the wholesale segment and a strong recovery mechanism recovering 65-70% of bad debt in the SME segment.
- Provisioning remains conservative: The company provisions a flat 1% of the loan book against a regulatory requirement of 0.4%, maintaining a provision coverage ratio of 270%, and recovered Rs. 2.34 crores from earlier write-offs this quarter.
- In-house collection model defended: For SME, the sales team works hand-in-hand with the collection team for up to 6 months, and 93% of collections come digitally via NACH, UPI, and RTGS, with only 6-7% in cash.
- External agencies rejected outright: Management dismissed outside collection agencies as unhelpful for their segments, arguing they only appoint telecallers with no feet on the street, so neither party knows the customer.
- Suvidha collections tied to sourcing: For the shorter-tenure Suvidha loan, the same RO and RM who source the business are given collection targets and incentives, with the aim to collect within 60 days of the 90-day loan.
Rohit Gupta: "Any company telling you I will never buy that argument. They are not at all helpful. It is helpful arrangement of that kind. But in a segment of a secured product every company has to have their own collection team."
Growth & Branch Expansion
- AUM aspiration of Rs. 1,450 crore for FY25: The target is subject to a conducive macro environment on both the fund-raise front and the general business environment.
- Branch network to grow 50% in FY25: Management plans to add significantly more branches, with a goal to double the network over the next two years, subject to market conditions.
- SME retail mix target of 55:45: The company aims to shift the AUM mix further toward SME retail from the current 44:56, though the wholesale real estate book will also grow in absolute terms, primarily through co-lending and direct assignment to keep on-book wholesale AUM in check.
- Leverage headroom available: The book can be levered from the existing ~1.0x debt-to-equity to ~2.5x over the coming two years, providing scope to fund growth without immediate equity dilution.
- Employee cost growth capped: Management expects employee cost growth not to exceed 20-25% in FY25, with the larger portion of IT spend already behind them and existing middle and senior teams able to handle 2-2.5x the SME business.
Profitability & Margins
- NII dipped 4% QoQ on liquidity drag: Despite 3% QoQ growth in total income, NII fell because sanctioned receipts arrived toward the end of the quarter and could not be deployed immediately, creating a negative interest carry on higher liquidity.
- Net profit up 57% YoY for the quarter: For the full year, NII rose 38% to Rs. 120 crores and net profit grew 39% to Rs. 63 crores, with robust yields in both verticals as the majority of the portfolio repriced to prevailing interest rates over the year.
- Fee income nearly doubled: Fee and commission income grew from Rs. 5 crores to Rs. 9.5 crores YoY, driven by retail direct assignment (6-7% spread), wholesale direct assignment (1.5-2%), and co-lending (1-1.25%), with wholesale co-lending at roughly Rs. 500 crores.
- ROE target of 15-16% in two years: Management expects ROEs to improve further from the current trajectory, with the improvement already visible on a quarterly basis as of Q4.
Competitive Positioning & Segment Strategy
- SME retail competitors are smaller NBFCs: Management named MAS Financial, Usha Financial, and some smaller NBFCs as competitors, but did not provide market share context, framing domain expertise in the fabricator segment as the key differentiator.
- Sourcing is primarily direct with a DSA tail: While the primary model is direct, 25-30% of business can come through connectors or small DSAs; the company avoids large loan aggregators because they target bigger ticket sizes of Rs. 45-50 lakhs and above, not the Rs. 20 lakh segment.
- Unsecured lending environment is cautious: Management acknowledged that unsecured books are not being viewed positively by lenders or rating agencies right now, which partly explains the deliberate, slow approach to scaling the Suvidha product.
- Retailer segment deferred: The company will remain focused on the fabricator segment for the next year before looking at retailers, where ticket sizes of Rs. 25 lakhs to Rs. 1 crore at 15-18% would be unsecured, a risk the current company size does not permit.
Rohit Gupta: "there is nobody else. And when you do the same segment again and again, you do help for domain knowledge and we as a company think that is the key to our differentiator compared to others."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM growth | Reach Rs. 1,450 crore AUM | FY25, subject to macro environment |
| AUM mix | Achieve 55:45 SME retail to wholesale mix | "Coming years" |
| Branch network | Increase branch count by 50% | FY25 |
| Branch network | Double the branch network | Next two years |
| Suvidha platform relaunch | New loan origination and disbursement platform go-live | July (Q2 FY25) |
| Cost of borrowing | Reduction of 50-75 bps from all lenders, especially PSUs | Immediate 2-3 quarters |
| NIM impact from rating upgrade | Net addition of 0.25-0.3% to NIMs | First year; higher in years two and three |
| ROE | Reach 15-16% range | Coming 2 years |
| Employee cost growth | Not to exceed 20-25% | FY25 |
| Leverage | Increase debt-to-equity from ~1.0x to ~2.5x | Coming two years |
| Suvidha AUM potential | Rs. 150-200 crore from 10-15% penetration of 150,000 fabricators | Next 2-3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹1,030 cr, +9% QoQ and +38% YoY |
| Loan book | ₹926 cr as of FY24 |
| Net interest income (FY24) | ₹120 cr, +38% YoY |
| Net profit (FY24) | ₹63 cr, +39% YoY |
| Net profitability (Q4) | +11% QoQ and +57% YoY |
| Total income (Q4) | +3% QoQ |
| Net interest income (Q4) | -4% QoQ, due to higher liquidity and negative interest carry |
| Fee and commission income (FY24) | ₹9.5 cr, up from ₹5 cr in FY23 |
| GNPA improvement | Lowered by 17 bps over FY23 |
| NNPA improvement | Lowered by 10 bps over FY23 |
| Provision coverage ratio | 270% |
| Write-off recoveries (FY24) | ₹2.34 cr |
| Cumulative disbursements (FY24) | ₹1,052 cr, +39% YoY |
| SME retail to wholesale AUM mix | 44:56, a shift of 4% in favor of SME retail over FY23 |
| Off-book AUM | ₹104 cr accumulated |
| Lending partners | 23, up from 15 in FY23 |
| Credit rating | A-, upgraded from BBB+ by Acuite Ratings & Research |
| Leverage ratio | ~1.0x debt to equity, scope to reach ~2.5x over two years |
| Team strength | 421 employees, up from 257 in FY23 |
| Dividend per share | ₹2.5 recommended by the board |
| FY25 AUM aspiration | Up to ₹1,450 cr |
| FY25-26 ROE target | 15% to 16% |
| Suvidha active clients | ~900 |
| Collection acceptance ratio | 75% to 77%, with 23% bouncing |
| Digital collection share | ~93% via NACH, UPI, RTGS; ~7% cash |