Key Takeaways
- Weak agri quarter, non-agri strength: Pipes & Fittings volumes fell 10% YoY as agri demand stalled, while plumbing and sanitation grew in healthy double digits.
- Profitability improved despite volume drop: Pipes & Fittings EBIT rose ~8% YoY, and Resin EBIT jumped from INR12.43 cr to INR30.88 cr, driven by margin expansion and lower input costs.
- Inventory loss from sharp PVC price drop: An INR11/kg PVC price fall in early October hit profitability; management says the exact impact is hard to quantify because the company uses its own resin.
- Cash return to shareholders is a matter of when, not if: Management stated large cash "needs to be returned" via dividend or buyback, but no Board decision or timeline exists yet.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether agri demand recovers in the seasonally strong Q4, the pace of product mix shift toward non-agri, and any concrete progress on the land disposal mandate.
Agri Demand: The Quarter's Drag
- Delayed pickup: Agri demand weakened starting Q2 and stayed soft through Q3; management had expected single-digit growth but saw a delay because unstable PVC prices kept the market lukewarm.
- Weather compounded the problem: November brought flooding and excessive rains across large parts of India, further depressing agri offtake in the quarter.
- Channel behavior: The trade typically waits for prices to bottom before restocking; with PVC prices range-bound and falling, the market stayed cautious through most of Q3 and the first two weeks of Q4.
- Recovery hope, not a forecast: Q1 and Q4 are the strongest quarters for agri, so management is hopeful the market opens up soon, but concedes it is difficult to predict.
Venkataraman: "Correct. So we are hopeful, but it's very difficult to predict."
Non-Agri Segment: The Growth Engine
- Strong volume growth: Plumbing and sanitation volumes grew in healthy double digits on both a quarterly and YTD basis, with the construction industry growing upwards of 15%.
- CPVC outperformance: The CPVC pipe segment is growing 15–20% and the company claims to be outperforming the market; no constraint on PVC availability through imports or local supplies.
- Infra momentum: Infra is going strong, with plumbing and sanitation sales volumes up over 15% even on a YTD basis; management expects this to continue into next year.
- Strategic push into non-agri: The company is building brand visibility, running targeted campaigns to connect with plumbers, MEP consultants and builders, and has launched a plumbers app to create long-term community ties.
- Profitability profile: Non-agri carries higher profitability than agri but demands more SKUs (more capex), credit to the channel, retailer shelf stock, and a longer working capital cycle; ROCE profiles are similar across both segments.
PVC & Input Price Dynamics
- PVC prices range-bound: Prices have been oscillating between $750 and $800 per metric ton, currently at the lower end ($750–$770); management expects them to stay in this band with no specific reason for an increase.
- CPVC prices declining: CPVC prices have been on their way down and are at their lowest point yet; they are not directly correlated to PVC prices.
- Inventory loss mechanics: A sharp INR11/kg drop in PVC prices over 12 days in early October caused inventory losses; because the company uses its own resin, the exact quantum is difficult to isolate.
- Import price parity: PVC prices in India are based on import price parity; EDC prices lag PVC prices; last year, a down Chinese market led to PVC being dumped in India.
- No abnormal margin repeat expected: The very high margins of FY20–FY21 were driven by abnormal PVC prices; management does not expect those "Blackstone events" to recur.
Venkataraman: "The very high margins which you saw in between FY'20 and FY'21 were basically on the back of abnormal PVC prices. We don't expect those Blackstone events to occur again... So you cannot see or you're unlikely to see paranormal profits like that."
Resin Segment: Production Constraints, Profitability Up
- Production below capacity: The resin plant produced 60,000 tons against a potential 75,000 tons due to an extended April shutdown (20–25 days lost) and intermittent supplier force majeure events through Q1, Q2 and Q3.
- Profitability improved sequentially: EBIT per kg rose from INR5.4 to INR7 as high-cost inventory stocked before the monsoon jetty closure was consumed, replaced by lower-cost material in Q3.
- Q4 production outlook: Management sees no challenge in producing the full 75,000 tons in Q4.
- No capacity expansion planned: The company is happy with current resin capacity and will not enhance it, given the commodity nature of the business; maintenance capex of around INR100 crores annually will continue.
Kedia: "See, on the resin side, I think it's very clear that we are happy with our current capacity. And there is no plan to enhance any capacity on the resin side, especially given it is a commodity business."
Competitive Landscape & Strategy
- Pricing pressure when demand is soft: Increased competition is acknowledged, and pricing pressures emerge when the market does not open up as expected; management describes this as a routine market response.
- Backward integration advantage: The company produces resin that management calls "probably the best in the world," but it is transferred to the pipe division at market rates, so there is no cost advantage to pipes specifically; the group benefits from value addition at both stages.
- No new product categories: The company is not looking to enter infra pipe or tanks; current agri and non-agri segments are considered large enough for growth.
- Geographic expansion: There is a renewed focus on the North with aggressive market entry, while the traditionally weak East is also being strengthened.
Venkataraman: "See, there is increased competition, and there is no question about that. And when there is increased competition, there is going to be pricing pressures, especially when market is not opening up as much as we had expected."
Capital Allocation & Non-Core Assets
- Land disposal mandate: The Board has mandated disposal of the remaining ~35 acres of non-core land; discussions with buyers are ongoing but nothing is concrete.
- Prior land sale reference: The first 35 acres were sold for INR376 crores, but management gave no specific valuation for the remaining parcel.
- Cash return commitment: Management stated that large cash needs to be returned to shareholders in one form or another, dividend or buyback, whenever the Board decides.
- No trigger defined: There is no specific trigger for the cash return decision; management simply said "it will happen."
Kedia: "See, as I said, this large cash is in that point of time need to be returned to the shareholders in one form or the other, either a dividend or a buyback. Whenever the Board decides, this will probably go back to the shareholders."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth target | Double volumes from current levels | Next 3 to 4 years |
| Product mix target | Shift agri/non-agri split from 70-30 or 65-35 to 50-50 | Implied over the volume-doubling period |
| Pipes & Fittings EBIT | Achieve INR10 to INR12 per kg | FY24 |
| Resin production | Produce full 75,000 tons | Q4 FY24 |
| Resin volume sales | 200,000 to 220,000 tons (including international sales) | FY24 |
| Resin EBIT per kg | Similar to INR7/kg level | Coming quarters |
| Non-agri volume growth | 15% to 20% growth | FY25 |
| Overall volume growth | 10% to 15% growth | FY25 |
| Maintenance capex | Around INR100 crores annually | Ongoing |
| Land disposal | Dispose remaining ~35 acres of non-core land | As soon as possible; no concrete timeline |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income from operations | ₹1,119.67 cr, down 9% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹119.90 cr, up 31% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 11.76%, up from 8.17% in Q3 FY23 |
| Profit after tax | ₹89.21 cr, up from ₹72.07 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Pipes and Fittings revenue | ₹991.61 cr, down 8% YoY |
| Pipes and Fittings volume | 81,312 MT, down 10% YoY |
| Pipes and Fittings EBIT | ₹74.24 cr, up 8% YoY |
| PVC Resin segment revenue | ₹321.07 cr, down 36% YoY |
| PVC Resin segment volume | 43,737 MT, down 32% YoY |
| PVC Resin segment EBIT | ₹30.88 cr, up from ₹12.43 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Net cash surplus | ~₹1,570 cr as on 31 Dec 2023 |
| Agri to non-agri volume mix | 32:68 in Q3; YTD ~32-33% agri |
| Average PVC price | $787/MT in Q3; current ~$760/MT |
| PVC/EDC delta | $465/MT in Q3; current $410/MT |
| PVC/VCM delta | $143/MT in Q3; current $140/MT |
| PVC Resin EBIT per kg | ₹7.0 in Q3, up from ₹5.4 in Q2 FY24 |
| Pipes and Fittings EBIT per kg target for FY24 | ₹10 to ₹12, management expects to achieve |
| Capex incurred in 9M FY24 | ~₹85 cr |
| Overall volume growth expectation for FY25 | 10% to 15% |
| Non-agri segment volume growth expectation | 15% to 20% for FY25 |