Key Takeaways
- Record volumes, but resin drags: Pipes and fittings hit a record >3 lakh tons for FY23, yet the resin segment PBT collapsed from ₹722 Cr to ~₹92 Cr YoY on VCM supply disruptions and narrower spreads.
- Mix shift is the margin story: A deliberate pivot to non-agri pipes and faster-growing fittings has lifted pipe segment margins from ₹7-₹8/kg to ₹10-₹11/kg, a structural improvement management expects to continue.
- PVC prices have found a floor: Prices have been stable since November at pre-COVID levels, and management expects this to hold barring a major shock, removing a key source of volatility.
- Capacity added, more to come: A new 12,000 MT fittings plant in Talegaon is ramping up, and ₹150-₹200 Cr of capex is planned for FY24, mostly replacement and maintenance.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Talegaon plant reaches full capacity within the promised 3-6 months, the pace of non-agri volume growth toward the 15-20% target, and any clarity on the PVC import quota restriction mechanism.
Volume & Demand Dynamics
- Record year for pipes: FY23 delivered record volume growth of more than 3 lakh tons in the pipes and fittings segment, with Q4 also described as fairly robust despite Q3 being an all-time high quarter.
- Pull-forward effect in Q3: Q4 volumes of roughly 81,000-82,000 tons were more or less at pre-COVID levels; some demand that would have otherwise landed in Q4 may have been pulled back into Q3 due to the huge demand surge that quarter.
- Channel inventories are lean: With dropping PVC prices, inventory levels at the retail level are quite low, which management views as a positive if prices continue to fall. Production was slightly higher than sales in Q4, but overall inventory levels remain at lower levels.
- Government demand is invisible to the company: Management does not deal directly with government tenders for programs like Nal Se Jal; those flows go through dealers and retailers, so the company has no split on what is supplied to government programs and does not track government tenders.
Ajit Venkataraman: "With the dropping PVC prices the inventory levels at the retail level is quite low, but there is a significant amount of demand."
Segment Profitability: The Two-Speed Business
- Resin segment suffered a near-total profit wipeout: Resin segment PBT fell from ₹722 Crores to ~₹92 Crores YoY, driven by a ~10% drop in annual PVC resin production versus pre-COVID levels after one supplier had a force majeure and plant issues in Q3 and Q4, preventing VCM sourcing as envisaged.
- PVC spreads narrowed sharply: Q4 FY23 PVC prices averaged $920 with a PVC-EDC delta of $632 and PVC-VCM delta of $473; current spreads are much narrower at $470-$480 and $120-$130 respectively.
- Pipe margins structurally improved: Pipe segment margins have moved from the ₹7-₹8/kg bracket to ₹10-₹11/kg, driven by substantial inroads in CPVC and non-agri segments over the last 3-4 years, plus fittings growing faster than pipes. Management hopes margins gradually rise further to ₹12-₹14/kg.
- Long-term resin margin target set: Management stated that ₹14-₹15/kg EBIT margin for the resin segment is the number to strive for and should be acceptable over the long term.
Niraj Kedia: "Long term Rs.14, Rs.15 should be the number which we should all strive for and that should be an acceptable number."
Product Mix & Capacity Expansion
- Non-agri is the growth engine: Management expects 15% to 20% growth in the non-agri segment, with CPVC growth projected to be faster than overall non-agri. The agri segment is likely to grow 8% to 10%.
- Talegaon fittings plant now online: A new state-of-the-art manufacturing facility for PVC fittings at Talegaon, Pune, with per annum capacity of 12,000 metric tons, was added in the March 2023 quarter. The ₹100 Cr capex was funded entirely through internal accruals. Operations are ramping up as per plan, with full capacity expected in three to six months.
- No Greenfield plants on the immediate horizon: Management believes sufficient capacity exists currently; the trade-off between transportation cost and setting up a new plant has been resolved in favor of paying transportation cost for now. Wherever existing capacity is reached, they will add capacities, but nothing concrete is planned.
- New product segments are wait-and-watch: On composite pipes, DWC pipes and other new segments, management noted these are fairly small and most manufacturers are in a wait-and-watch mode to see whether they actually gain traction.
Ajit Venkataraman: "These new segments which are coming up are fairly small and it is a wait and watch for most of the manufacturers to see whether they actually take traction."
PVC Pricing & Import Policy
- Prices stabilized at pre-COVID levels: PVC prices have almost come to pre-COVID levels and have been fairly steady since December. Management expects these levels are likely to continue unless there is a major shock.
- Quota restriction on PVC imports introduced, but details are absent: A guideline has been issued on quota restriction for import of PVC with higher than 2 EPM of content. However, the industry is not clear on how it will be implemented, what the tracking mechanism will be, or what the implications are if the quota is breached. No start date has been set. Management views it as a positive move since cheap PVC was being dumped.
- Price volatility driving consolidation: Management noted that given the price volatility, it is difficult for smaller players to survive, so consolidation among organized players is likely to intensify. Organized players already represent approximately 55% to 60% of the industry.
Niraj Kedia: "There is a guideline which has come on this quota restriction, this applicable for import of PVC which have higher than 2 EPM of content. While it has come even in industry we are also not very clear how this is going to be implemented and we do not know what is the tracking mechanism of the government going to be and how to track when the quota is getting completed..."
Working Capital & Costs
- Receivable days rising with the non-agri mix: Receivable days have increased from 10-15 days to ~25 days because the non-agri portfolio demands credit; credit days of 30-60 days are given depending on customers. Management expects debtor days to remain in the current range, staying below 30 days at the company level.
- Other expenses reflect revenue deflation, not cost bloat: The increase in other expenses as a percentage of revenue is a result of following PVC prices, meaning revenue was lower despite volume growth due to reducing PVC prices. On a standalone basis, power expense increased because of power and fuel costs, and there was a forex loss due to rupee weakening. These expense levels are sustainable, and if coal prices cool down, there will be some reduction in power cost.
- Employee cost is flat and normal: There were no one-offs in employee cost during the quarter; employee cost is normal and flat year-on-year for FY23 over FY22.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Talegaon fittings plant ramp-up | Reach full capacity of 12,000 MT | 3 to 6 months |
| PVC resin production recovery | Back to normal, 250,000 to 260,000 tons (rated capacity 270,000) | FY2024 |
| Non-agri segment growth | 15% to 20% growth | Ongoing |
| Agri segment growth | 8% to 10% growth | Ongoing |
| Pipe volume growth | 10% to 15% annually | Next 2 to 3 years |
| FY2024 capex | ₹150 to ₹200 Crores, largely replacement and maintenance | FY2024 |
| Pipe segment margin target | Gradually rise to ₹12 to ₹14/kg | No date |
| Resin segment EBIT margin target | ₹14 to ₹15/kg | Long term |
| Debtor days | Remain below 30 days at company level | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total income from operations | ₹1,141 cr, down 28% YoY from ₹1,594 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹217 cr, down 18% YoY from ₹265 cr; up 137% QoQ from ₹92 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 19.26%, up from 16.6% in Q4 FY22 |
| Profit after tax | ₹158.35 cr, down from ₹493.8 cr in Q4 FY22; up from ₹72.07 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Pipes and fittings revenue | ₹1,102 cr, down 14% YoY from ₹1,277 cr |
| Pipes and fittings volume | 81,452 MT, up 4% YoY from 78,629 MT |
| Pipes and fittings EBIT | ₹90.32 cr, down 4% YoY from ₹94.2 cr |
| PVC resin revenue | ₹501 cr, down 52% YoY from ₹1,044 cr |
| PVC resin volume | 58,132 MT, down 27% YoY from 79,182 MT |
| PVC resin EBIT | ₹117.25 cr, down from ₹156.46 cr in Q4 FY22; up significantly from ₹12.43 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Net cash surplus | ~₹1,500 cr as on March 31, 2023 |
| Pipes and fittings production volume | ~87,000 MT |
| PVC resin production volume | 65,000 MT |
| Non-agri volume share | ~35% of overall volumes |
| Non-agri segment growth expectation | 15% to 20% |
| Agri segment growth expectation | 8% to 10% |
| FY24 capex plan | ₹150 cr to ₹200 cr, largely replacement and maintenance |
| Dividend recommended | ₹1.5 per share, 75% |
| PVC-EDC delta (quarter average) | $632 |
| PVC-VCM delta (quarter average) | $473 |
| Forex loss for the year | ~₹30 cr |
| Receivable days | ~25 days, up from 10–15 days earlier |
| Pipes and fittings EBIT per kg | ₹10–₹11, expected to gradually rise to ₹12–₹14 |
| Resin EBIT per kg long-term target | ₹14–₹15 |