Key Takeaways
- A brutal quarter, self-inflicted in part: Credit cost surged to ₹693 crore as management took accelerated provisions against rapidly deteriorating collections, while disbursements nearly halved QoQ to ₹1,661 crore after a sharp tightening of credit norms.
- The balance-sheet conversation is existential: Auditor-flagged covenant breaches on gross NPA, net NPA and a rating downgrade have put ₹5,000 crore of liabilities technically repayable on demand; management is relying on lender waivers and a ₹550 crore rights issue to bridge the gap.
- Collections discipline has broken in stressed states: Center meeting times have tripled, half of all collections now require door-to-door visits, and field-officer attrition is rising because the job has become haggling rather than group collection.
- Management calls a provisioning peak but won't guide: The CEO says provisioning has hit a peak and performance should improve from here, yet declined to provide any H2 guidance, calling the situation "dynamic."
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the rights issue files on time, whether lenders grant the next round of waivers, and whether the "green shoots" in the post-tightening book actually show up in the Q3 numbers management says will be a better assessment point.
Asset Quality: The Damage and the Denial
- Provisioning shock: The ₹693 crore credit cost was well above the earlier ₹500-550 crore estimate, driven by proactive accelerated provisions after a rapid deterioration in on-ground collections. Management says this is the peak.
- Stress geography: Pain is concentrated in Jharkhand, Odisha, Rajasthan and Gujarat, with a mix of triggers: floods, heat waves, the Karj Mukti Abhiyan in Punjab, and illegal outside agencies encouraging non-payment. Some sub-regions within these states are showing resilience.
- Over-leverage at the core: Customer indebtedness beyond ₹1,50,000, combined with relationships spanning more than four lenders, defines the worst-hit cohort. The 7% of borrowers who moved out of the 4+ lender bucket this quarter did so through loan closures, non-renewals due to guardrails, and write-offs.
- Internal failings deflected: When asked directly about internal process, control or supervisory deficiencies that made Fusion's asset quality worse than the industry, management listed only external factors and stated, "I don't think anywhere we have found any such deficiency."
- New-book green shoots, early and unquantified: The book originated after credit tightening is behaving better than similar vintages from the last two quarters, but management cautioned that months-on-book is not yet the right metric to judge it.
Sachdev: "The elevated provisioning has been due to us proactively taking accelerated provisions due to observed rapid deterioration in the on-ground collections."
Collections: A Model Under Strain
- Center meeting discipline broken: Meetings that once took 15-25 minutes now run 45-50 minutes. In half of all cases, the field officer must go door-to-door because customers know they can promise to pay later without consequence.
- Field force under pressure: Attrition is rising because the job has become haggling rather than group collection. With tightened onboarding norms, officers can source fewer new customers per month, and the company has deliberately lowered that sourcing cap. [11-12]
- Current-bucket efficiency holds: Pan-India collection efficiency on the current bucket remains at 97%, consistent across months, though management did not provide a separate zero-DPD figure when asked.
- Incentive structure redesigned: The company revamped incentive structures for the collection team and field staff, and rationalized manpower at the field level, which reduced RO productivity and pushed up the cost-to-income ratio to 40.41%.
- Customer handling reduced: Each relationship officer now handles 380 customers, down from prior levels, to improve outreach and focus on irregular attendees. A dedicated 550+ member team now focuses exclusively on the 60+ DPD bucket, with third-party agencies engaged for 90+ DPD customers.
- External influence a persistent drag: Illegal outside agencies have tried to influence customers during stress periods. Even once that influence is curtailed, customers take time to realize there is no waiver and begin paying again.
The Covenant Breach and the Going Concern Question
- Three breaches flagged: The auditor identified covenant breaches on gross NPA, net NPA, and a rating downgrade by CARE in September. These breaches make approximately ₹5,000 crore of liabilities technically repayable on demand.
- Waiver strategy: All Q1 waivers were received, and management is in active discussion with lenders for further waivers, expressing confidence they will be granted because the breaches are "temporary in nature." The top five lenders are HSBC, Axis Bank, Yes Bank, ICICI and SIDBI, with the top two or three each having exposure above ₹500 crore.
- The going-concern basis went unaddressed: When asked directly about the auditor's going-concern note and the probability of default, management discussed past waivers, the rights issue, and liquidity, but did not address the basis of the going-concern assessment or quantify default probability.
- Rights issue as confidence signal: The ₹550 crore rights issue, fully backed by promoters, is being positioned as a confidence-building measure for all stakeholders, including lenders. Filing is expected within Q3 FY25.
Sachdev: "We remain confident that similar waivers will be granted further too, and these breaches are temporary in nature."
Credit Tightening and the Path Back to Growth
- Disbursements slashed: Disbursements fell to ₹1,661 crore from ₹2,987 crore in Q1, a 44% drop, as the company tightened credit criteria and raised rejection rates. Management expects disbursements to normalize "very soon" but remain "slightly subdued."
- New guardrails, some self-imposed earlier: The sector-wide four-lender guardrail issued by MFIN is now in effect, but Fusion had its own guardrail since 2022 and has since made it more stringent. State-by-state indebtedness limits have been set at ₹1.5 lakh in pain states, below the SRO's ₹2 lakh cap.
- Onboarding rules tightened: The company will no longer onboard a customer who has gone more than 30+ DPD more than twice in the last 12 months. A "third eye" quality layer is being built, with offers made to around 60 people in the first phase.
- Income assessment remains informal: Customer income is assessed through face-to-face conversations with no formal verification method. The sector is now discussing templates to treat overlaps such as credit card minimum dues and gold loans in liability calculations.
- MSME pivot: A new in-house tech platform for the MSME vertical has been implemented, and ramping up this vertical is a stated priority to expand its share of overall business.
People, Leadership and Organizational Response
- CEO search underway: A search to appoint a new CEO is on track, with no date given. Sunil Mundra has joined as COO for the MFI vertical.
- Field-officer comp structure stable but stressed: Incentives make up 25-30% of total salary, and the company has never had a situation where a large proportion of pay is variable. During stress periods, a lower cap ensures people remain incentivized.
- Loyalty program in early days: A customer loyalty program has been launched and is showing encouraging response with improved attendance wherever rolled out, though no timeline was given for full rollout.
- IT investment flagged for medium term: Management plans to enhance IT capabilities to improve operational efficiencies, field personnel management and risk controls, though this is framed as a medium-term initiative.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Rights issue filing | File ₹550 crore rights issue | Within Q3 FY25 |
| Provisioning trajectory | Provisioning has hit a peak; improvement expected from here | From Q3 FY25 onward |
| Disbursement normalization | Return to normal disbursement levels, though "slightly subdued" | "Very soon" |
| Covenant waivers | Secure further lender waivers for NPA and rating-related covenant breaches | Ongoing; no date given |
| CEO appointment | Conclude CEO search | On track; no date given |
| H2 guidance | Management declined to provide any H2 guidance | N/A |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Credit cost | ₹693 crore, actual for Q2 FY25 |
| Capital adequacy | 24.4% as of September 2024 |
| Liquidity | ₹1,800 crore approx as of September 30, 2024; sanctions in hand of approx ₹1,500 crore |
| Disbursements | ₹1,661 crore, down from ₹2,987 crore in Q1 FY25 |
| Total income growth | +23.19% YoY, -0.42% QoQ |
| Interest income growth | +26.02% YoY, +0.77% QoQ |
| Cost to income ratio | 40.41% |
| Operating cost change | +21 bps QoQ |
| MSME AUM | ₹620 crore, 78% secured |
| Fundraising in Q2 FY25 | ₹1,513 crore, including direct assignment of ₹435 crore; H1 FY25: ₹4,060 crore including direct assignment of ₹915 crore |
| Rights issue | ₹550 crore, fully backed by promoters |
| Customers with Fusion plus 4+ lenders | 10%, down from 17% in March 2024 |
| Collection efficiency (current bucket) | ~97% |
| Overall collection efficiency | ~91-92% |
| Field officer incentive proportion | ~25-30% of total salary; average incentive ₹3,500-₹4,000 on ~₹15,000 salary |