Key Takeaways
- Two-speed quarter: The soda ash (chemicals) business delivered strong demand and higher realizations, while the textile business saw revenue fall and EBITDA halve as cotton and yarn spreads contracted sharply.
- Textile pain is margin-led, not volume-led: The plant ran at 99% utilization, but the margin collapsed to 11.3% from buoyant peaks; recovery hinges entirely on US home textile demand destocking.
- Soda ash pricing: short-term softness, long-term conviction: Management expects some near-term pressure from Chinese exports, but no new global capacity for 2–3 years against 6–7% demand growth, which should push pricing.
- Greenfield soda ash project advancing: The public hearing is complete, environmental clearances are targeted by March 2023, and the plant is slated for March 2025 completion with a ~17% IRR.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether textile margins stabilize or deteriorate further, the magnitude of any soda ash price softening from Chinese volumes, and the NCLT demerger approval on 20 December 2022.
Soda Ash (Chemicals): Strength & Pricing Outlook
- Strong Q2 performance: Higher realizations (9% over Q1) and a 9–10% production increase versus the same quarter last year absorbed higher input costs, driving better margins.
- Domestic demand drivers: Glass industry demand remains strong; an extended monsoon moderated detergent segment demand, which is expected to recover.
- Global demand picture: Barring China, where real estate weakness has softened demand and increased exports, demand in the rest of the world is strong.
- Europe supply retreat: European producers face elevated energy costs and lower demand; management expects the ~1.5 million tons Europe historically exported to other regions to largely disappear, tightening the global market.
- Short-term pricing risk: Domestic prices have not softened through October, but management expects some softening may occur as increased Chinese volumes flow into India and the region, though not significantly.
- Long-term pricing conviction: No new capacity is expected globally for the next 2–3 years while demand grows 6–7% annually, so the demand-supply balance will favor producers and push pricing.
- Margin history as anchor: Soda ash margins have been very consistent in the 34–35% range over the last 11–12 years, barring the COVID-impacted FY21–22; management expects this to be sustainable with only small quarterly blips.
R S Jalan: "Next two years, three years we are not seeing any new capacity coming in whereas the demand will continue to grow. So therefore, definitely the demand supply situation will be slightly in favor of the supply and that will push the pricing."
Textiles: Margin Collapse & Recovery Bet
- Q2 pain points: Revenue fell from ₹275 crore to ₹260 crore QoQ; EBITDA halved from ₹65 crore to ₹29 crore; margin contracted to 11.3% as cotton and yarn price spreads collapsed from peak levels.
- Utilization is not the problem: The textile plant ran at 99% peak utilization; the pain is entirely in margins, not volumes.
- Demand dependency: Recovery depends on demand for customers' finished products, particularly home textiles in the US, where inventory levels remain high.
- Segment severity: The drop in sales is across all segments, but more severe in home textiles than garments; weaving is slightly better than knitting.
- Cotton inventory drag: Some cotton coverage occurred when prices were at their peak last quarter, contributing to the margin squeeze.
- Near-term outlook: Q3 performance is expected to be similar to Q2 or slightly lower; recovery may start in Q4, with the unfavorable scenario potentially continuing through H2.
- Normalization target: Management expects normalized margins of 17–20% to revert in the next fiscal year.
R S Jalan: "Pain is in terms of the margin, Prerna, not in terms of the utilization. Of course there could be few percentage of utilization could be here and there, but we are running the plant at the peak of 99%."
Greenfield Soda Ash Project & Growth Capex
- Project milestone achieved: The environment-related public hearing has been successfully completed, moving the project "one step closer."
- Clearance and construction timeline: Complete environmental clearances are expected by March 2023; plant construction is estimated at two years, targeting completion by March 2025.
- Project economics: The IRR is roughly 17%, calculated on longer-term reasonable pricing, not current peak prices. Management notes the capital turnover ratio is unfavorable but these are 100-year assets.
- Cost recalculation underway: The project cost is being recalculated due to technological changes for a more environment-friendly approach; a revised number is expected next quarter.
- Financing position: The company is in a cash surplus situation and likely to remain so by year-end, with a 2–3 year timeframe to implement the Greenfield capex.
- FY23 capex: Total roughly ₹360–370 crore, ~50% already spent, with the remainder to be spent in the next six months, primarily on textiles with some on soda ash.
- FY24 capex: Expected around ₹800–1,000 crore, of which ₹500–700 crore is allocated to the new Greenfield project.
- Salt productivity expansion: A project to expand salt production from the same land by more than 100% is progressing well; some impact possible in February–March, with major impact from Q1 of next year and full impact over 2–3 years.
R S Jalan: "This project has to be seen in slightly longer terms because here the capital turnover ratio, as you know, that capital turnover ratio is unfavorable on the soda ash, but these projects are meant for maybe more than 100 years."
Demerger, Expansion & Inorganic Strategy
- Demerger update: The NCLT date is set for 20 December 2022; the delay was due to reports from the ROC and RD not yet received by the court.
- Sodium bicarbonate expansion: On schedule; projects will be completed by the end of Q3 FY23, with benefits starting in the next quarter.
- Textile spindle expansion: A 40,000-spindle project will expand the product basket, giving access to a wider range of premium customers not currently in the basket.
- Inorganic acquisition criteria: Management is evaluating opportunities in the chemical space with synergy, a better capital turnover ratio than current, sustainable growth opportunities, and quality professional management.
- Acquisition size: Probably around ₹1,000 crore, though management is flexible for the right opportunity.
- Chlorine-based derivative project: Still in the thought process, linked with caustic and chlorine, and likely to sit at the same Greenfield site as the soda ash plant.
Margins, Costs & Energy
- Q2 margin drivers: Higher soda ash realizations and production volumes absorbed higher input costs; Q2 margin was higher than Q1.
- Q3 margin outlook: Could be slightly lower than Q2, but normalization margins will be much better than historical normal margins.
- Energy costs: Q2 power and fuel cost was ₹236 crore; raw material pricing softened slightly in Q2, so barring inventory adjustments, product cost will be slightly cheaper in Q3.
- Coal strategy: Management is mixing Russian coal to help neutralize increases in other raw material and coal prices.
- Margin blip philosophy: Management acknowledges that quarterly blips can happen, with one quarter slightly lower and then recovered aggressively the next, and says the company must always be prepared for that.
- Working capital: Soda ash working capital increased by ~₹550 crore, while textile working capital decreased by ₹180–200 crore; the major increase is soda ash only.
R S Jalan: "I will not say that it's going to be a big challenge. But yes, like I said, this kind of a blip, not today, this kind of a blip may happen in the longer term also. Some maybe one quarter could be slightly lower and then it may be recovered very aggressive next quarter."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NCLT demerger approval | Court date set for approval | 20 December 2022 |
| Sodium bicarbonate expansion completion | 60,000 MT capacity addition; benefits to start | End of Q3 FY23 |
| Greenfield environmental clearances | Complete clearances received | By March 2023 |
| Greenfield plant completion | Construction to begin post-clearances | By March 2025 |
| Greenfield project IRR | Roughly 17%, based on long-term reasonable pricing | Project lifetime |
| Textile normalized margin recovery | Revert to 17–20% margin range | Next fiscal year |
| Textile Q3 performance | Similar to Q2 or slightly lower | Q3 FY23 |
| FY23 total capex | ₹360–370 crore (~50% remaining) | Next six months |
| FY24 total capex | ₹800–1,000 crore (₹500–700 crore for Greenfield) | FY24 |
| Salt expansion major impact | Significant bottom-line contribution begins | Q1 next fiscal year |
| Soda ash production | Full capacity production committed | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,389 cr, +73% YoY |
| Chemical business realization | +9% over Q1 |
| Chemical business revenue | ₹1,123 cr, up from ₹1,091 cr in Q1 |
| Chemical business profitability | ₹400 cr, up from ₹353 cr in Q1 |
| Textile revenue | ₹260 cr, vs ₹233 cr YoY and ₹275 cr QoQ |
| Textile EBITDA | ₹29 cr, vs ₹65 cr YoY and ₹65 cr QoQ |
| Textile EBITDA margin | 11.3%, contracted from normalized 17–20% range |
| Textile normalized margin expectation | 17% to 20%, expected reversion next fiscal |
| Soda ash production growth | 9–10% higher vs same quarter last year |
| Soda ash Q3 production impact | 15,000 metric ton reduction due to October plant maintenance |
| Textile plant utilization | 99%, running at peak |
| Net debt | ₹230 cr, after reducing cash; gross debt ₹400 cr soda ash, ₹90 cr textile |
| Power and fuel cost | ₹236 cr, includes textile business contribution |
| FY23 capex guidance | ₹360–370 cr, ~50% spent, ~50% in H2 |
| FY24 capex guidance | ₹800–1,000 cr, of which ₹500–700 cr for Greenfield project |
| Greenfield project IRR | ~17% |
| Indian soda ash demand growth (H1) | ~6% |
| Sodium bicarbonate capacity addition | 60,000 metric tons, completion by end of Q3 |