Key Takeaways
- A quarter defined by extreme volatility: Revenue fell 31% YoY to INR817 crores as soda ash realizations and volumes both dropped, driven by a global oversupply shock management says it never saw coming.
- Margins compressed sharply, with more pain ahead: EBITDA margin contracted to 27.5% from 34.9% YoY, and management guided it could fall another 100–200 bps in the near term before recovering.
- The import surge is the core problem: Resilient Indian demand is being met by a flood of imports from the US, Russia and Turkey, forcing domestic prices down and making import parity the ceiling for local realizations.
- The medium-term story is intact, but timelines are slipping: The greenfield project, vacuum salt, and limestone integration are all progressing, while new demand from solar glass and flue-gas treatment is delayed by a quarter or two.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the October maintenance shutdown and continued import pressure push margins below the guided 25–26% floor, and whether environmental clearance for the greenfield project actually arrives.
The Oversupply Shock
- A global glut materialized fast: Soft demand from Europe and the US (inflation) plus a weaker-than-expected Chinese real estate recovery collided with new production capacity in China and the US. The result was a supply overhang that crushed prices globally.
- Imports swamped the Indian market: Even though domestic demand stayed relatively resilient, a surge of imports from the US, Russia and Turkey created an oversupply that forced Indian prices down toward import parity. Management expects higher imports to continue.
- The speed and depth surprised everyone: Management stated flatly that six months ago they never anticipated this scenario, calling it volatility beyond anything in a long career. Prices and import volumes changed in ways not forecast.
- Production setback compounded the volume hit: A plant breakdown cost roughly 7% of production versus the same quarter last year, and while the issue is now resolved, it also limited CO2 availability for the new sodium bicarbonate plant, holding utilization to 65–70%.
R S Jalan: "Honestly, like Raman said, in his opening remarks, that we never expected this kind of a scenario change 6 months back. And I think in my career of long years, I have not seen this kind of volatility in my such a long career. It has gone beyond our expectations."
Margin Trajectory
- The Q2 margin walk: Realization fell roughly 15% sequentially, and while input costs (coal, salt) also declined, the realization drop far outweighed the cost relief. EBITDA margin landed at 27.5%, down from 30% in Q1 and 34.9% a year ago.
- Near-term guidance points lower: Management expects a slight further reduction in pricing and guided that EBITDA margin could dip another 100–200 bps from the current 27.5% in the next quarter or two.
- The 30% long-term anchor: Management insists 30% EBITDA margin is a sustainable number over the cycle, arguing that without it no new capacity would be built. Historical EBITDA per ton CAGR supports the claim: 8% over 20 years, 6% over 15 and 10 years, 4.5% over 5 years.
- Cost-side levers are in motion: Coal prices have dropped roughly $25/tonne, salt prices are expected to stay soft into the next season, and captive salt production has improved. Management also hinted at out-of-the-box cost reduction concepts under discussion but declined to share details.
R S Jalan: "30% is a very sustainable number. And without this number, no new capacity will also come in."
Demand Drivers: Delayed, Not Derailed
- Detergent demand is the steady anchor: Expected to keep growing at 4–5%, tied to economic growth, with a seasonal pickup after the monsoon.
- Solar glass: a 6-month delay: Investments in Indian solar glass manufacturing have slipped, with plants now expected on stream in the next quarter or next six months. Once running, this segment is projected to grow from ~1% of Indian soda ash demand to 5% by 2030.
- Flue-gas treatment: installations underway, demand lagging: FGT installations are happening, including at additional NTPC sites, and demand is expected in the next six months. Management sees FGT growing from zero to 2% of a 0.7 crore-tonne Indian market by 2030.
- Global demand growth of 2.5–3% is the base case: Management's 2030 view of global demand moving from 6 crore to 8 crore tonnes still stands, assuming no further macro deterioration. India is expected to grow not less than 5–7%, from 0.43 crore tonnes toward 0.7 crore by 2030.
China: The Swing Factor
- New Inner Mongolia capacity is real and running: Management confirmed the ~0.3 crore tonnes of capacity is operating at reasonably good levels, though with quality issues. How much is actually onstream is hard to pin down precisely.
- China may get more aggressive in the medium term: At the World Soda Ash Conference, Chinese producers signaled they could become more assertive in global markets over the next few quarters.
- But the long-term logic points the other way: Management's read is that China does not want to be a long-term net supplier to the world. The likely path is either running new capacity at low utilization or shutting older, inefficient, environmentally unfriendly plants.
R S Jalan: "In the medium term to long term, they would not like to be supplying to the world. On one side, they have added the capacity or they're likely to add the capacity. However, on the other side, either they will run at the lowest utilization or they will be closing the inefficient or the smaller plants, which are not environment-friendly."
Strategic Projects: Progress Update
- Greenfield soda ash project: Basic engineering, detailed engineering, and pipeline work have started. All environmental clearance paperwork has reached the Ministry of Environment in Delhi; management hopes for approval in the next few months but cannot guarantee timing.
- Vacuum salt project: On schedule for March 2025 commissioning. Basic engineering is underway, salt clearances have started, and machines are being ordered. The plant will use complete waste heat recovery, making it green salt.
- Limestone mines: Acquired reserves are expected to begin producing next year, securing a key raw material input.
- Salt yield improvement: Benefits have started flowing and yields are exceeding initial assumptions, which will further improve as the program matures.
- Product basket expansion: Evaluation and discussions are ongoing, but management is not in a rush to select something. No timeline was offered.
R S Jalan: "I will not be able to tell you that when this from Ministry of Environment, we will certainly get that approval. But we are hoping that in the next few months, we will get it because all the formalities have been completed."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | Sell what is produced, with 4–5% growth | FY24-25 |
| Near-term EBITDA margin | May fall 100–200 bps from current 27.5% | Next 1–2 quarters |
| Long-term EBITDA margin | 30% is a sustainable number | Over the cycle |
| Vacuum salt project | Commissioning | March 2025 |
| Greenfield project environmental clearance | Approval from Ministry of Environment | Next few months (hoped, not guaranteed) |
| Limestone mining from acquired reserves | Production start | Next year |
| Solar glass demand uplift | Plants on stream, increasing soda ash offtake | Next quarter to 6 months |
| Flue-gas treatment demand uplift | Demand from installations including NTPC sites | Next 6 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹817 cr, compared to ₹1,183 cr in Q2 FY23 and ₹1,029 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| EBITDA | ₹224 cr, compared to ₹413 cr in Q2 FY23 and ₹310 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| EBITDA margin | 27.5%, compared to 34.9% in Q2 FY23 and 30% in Q1 FY24 |
| PAT from continuing operations | ₹143 cr, compared to ₹291 cr in Q2 FY23 and ₹426 cr in Q1 FY24 (including exceptional items) |
| Cash profit after tax (H1 FY24) | ₹426 cr for the half year ended 30 September 2023 |
| Net cash | ₹343 cr, gross debt at ₹268 cr and cash balance at ₹612 cr, after ₹166 cr dividend payment |
| Realization decline QoQ | ~15% down compared to Q1 FY24 |
| Sales volume decline YoY | 13% down compared to Q2 FY23 |
| Sales volume decline QoQ | 4% down compared to Q1 FY24 |
| Production volume decline YoY | 7% down compared to Q2 FY23 |
| Production volume growth QoQ | 6% up compared to Q1 FY24 |
| Capacity utilization | 91% for Q2 FY24; H1 FY24 average 89%; full-year expected 91–92% |
| Spot sales share | ~70% of total sales |
| Sodium bicarbonate capacity utilization | 65–70% on 120,000-tonne capacity |
| Planned maintenance shutdown impact | ~20,000 metric tons production shortfall in October |