Key Takeaways
- Earnings crushed by dual shutdowns: Two major outages at the SLPP lignite station in the same quarter, a rare event, slashed commercial availability and drove profit to a low level.
- Recovery is a year-end story: All plants are now running at full load, and management expects to recover under-recovered fixed costs and return profitability to pre-Covid levels by fiscal year-end.
- Khavda is the growth thesis, now moving to execution: Tenders for the critical pooling substation are out, park development has begun, and management is "very confident" of adding more than 50% of the park's capacity on its own books.
- Flat top line masks a business in transition: Revenue has stagnated since 2015 as idle gas-based stations offset renewable additions; management frames this as a necessary shift in the line of business.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 75 MW solar project receives GUVNL approval and tendering begins, crystallization of GIPCL's own capacity at Khavda once the PPA is executed, and any movement on gas prices that could revive the stranded 310 MW gas assets.
The Q2 Earnings Hole: Dual Shutdowns
- Rare double outage: SLPP Unit 1 underwent economizer beam replacement (beam was sagging, preventing full load) and Unit 4 underwent a 45-day capital overhauling pending since inception, both in Q2. Management stated this is not general practice; normally only one shutdown occurs per quarter.
- Half the lignite capacity was out: 250 MW, or 50% of SLPP capacity, was offline for approximately 45-50 days during the quarter, though not for the entire quarter.
- All plants now restored: As of the call date, all plants are running perfectly at full load, barring unforeseen circumstances. The economizer beams were procured from BHEL and replaced; the unit is now running at full load.
- Fixed cost recovery mechanism is annual: Management expects to recover whatever fixed costs are under-recovered for the year because commercial availability is counted on a yearly basis per the PPA, targeting 75% for Phase-I and 80% for Phase-II.
- No shutdowns currently foreseen: For the next six months, plants are running at full load with no issues anticipated; management expects to reach profitability at year-end at a "very reasonable and good level."
Bhatt: "This time what happened is 2 shutdowns have been taken into the same quarter which was not the general practice year-on-year basis. Generally, 1 shutdown may be there in 1 quarter. This time, both the units - unit 4 and unit 2 - are in the quarter 2 only Beam Replacement exercise and capital overhauling carried out in the Q2. That was the reason for low profit. But hopefully we will recover."
Khavda Renewable Park: The Growth Engine
- Park development underway: Tenders for the critical pooling substation have been called, other small tenders are in the pipeline and expected to be in place by December end mostly, and park development activity has already started. Cumulative CAPEX of ₹100-120 crores incurred to date.
- Phased capacity addition: The park will add capacity in four phases (600, 600, 600, and 575 MW). Management targets 50% completion by 2024 and the balance in the next two years, with full capacity addition in 4-5 years.
- Own capacity target: Management is "very confident" of putting up more than 50% of the park's capacity on GIPCL's own books; this is the "fundamental thought process." The exact amount and timeline will crystallize once the project PPA is executed, expected by the last quarter of the current financial year.
- Phase I & II deadline: Must be completed before March 2024 per MNRE guidelines to qualify for the 30% subsidy; all infrastructure activity is being completed before that deadline.
- Park economics: Total park CAPEX is around ₹1,100 crores, with a 30% MNRE subsidy received on a milestone basis. The return from the park itself is expected to be around 13% to 14%.
- Project execution timeline: Solar projects generally take 15 to 18 months; GIPCL's CAPEX will be incurred over 15-18 months starting sometime in the next financial year.
- User fee (UDC) timing: GIPCL will receive the user development charge once the project is allotted to a project developer, which happens once the park is ready; expected in FY24.
Bhatt: "I will update you once it is finalized. But anyhow, we are very confident to put up capacity in our park more than 50% on our own."
Funding Khavda: Debt, Equity, and Subsidy
- Debt-equity structure: Every project going forward will be on a 70:30 debt-equity mode; management previously put in more equity because no future projects were available.
- Equity is internally funded: Enough cash flow (cash plus depreciation) is available with the company to infuse the 30% equity portion over 4-5 years; no issue.
- Debt raising trigger: When park development spend increases to ₹400-500 crores next year, debt will need to be raised. In-principle dialogues have been initiated with various financial institutions and banks; the rate is expected at 7-7.5%.
- No restructuring of past projects needed: An analyst asked whether previous project debt-equity could be restructured to free up equity; management said it is not required because enough cash flow exists.
The Idle Gas Assets: A Waiting Game
- 310 MW stranded: Vadodara Station I & II (gas-based) have been in non-operating condition since November 2021, when international gas prices rose and APM gas availability went to zero due to the Tauktae effect.
- PPA life is over: The 30-year PPA life for the gas stations is over; the plants are fully depreciated and kept under preservation.
- Viability threshold: Gas-based plants become viable at $8 to $8.5 per MMBtu, at which electricity can be generated at a competitive rate to sell to promoters on a cost-plus mechanism. At current gas prices, running them is not viable.
- No timeline for restart: Management will watch gas price movements over the next couple of 6 months or 1 year; if prices come within range, the plants can restart and provide power to promoters as per requirement.
The Flat Revenue Reality
- Top line stuck since 2015: Revenue has not grown despite approximately ₹2,000 crores invested in renewable energy because gas-based thermal stations have more or less not been working since 2015. The revenue loss from gas stations is being offset by solar and wind, keeping the top line flat rather than growing.
- Renewable contribution: 262 MW of solar and 112.4 MW of wind operational capacity is adding around ₹100-110 crores to the bottom line every year.
- Near-term outlook: Revenue is expected to remain flat at ₹1,200-1,300 crores in the next one year; top line addition is expected one year down the line once 200-300 MW of capacity is added.
- Half-yearly EBITDA split provided: Management disclosed on the call that H1 EBITDA was ₹106 crores from renewable and ₹141 crores from thermal, though it declined to publish this split regularly in results, citing SEBI guidelines do not require it.
Bhatt: "The problem is nothing but how we look into it, that is more important, because as you know, our thermal stations (gas-based stations) are nowadays not at all working. That much revenue from the top line is being offset by the solar and wind... It is the need of the day because you have to change your line of business."
Lignite Operations: Steady and Insulated
- Captive fuel security: 100% of the lignite requirement for the 500 MW thermal station is met through own captive mines; no outside sales are permitted. The royalty paid to the government is recovered through the tariff as a variable charge.
- Price insulation: GIPCL is not affected by coal or lignite price increases because of captive mines and a GUVNL-approved price mechanism.
- Availability targets: Phase-I targets 75% commercial availability, Phase-II targets 80%, which is the PPA requirement for full fixed cost recovery. Management stated any lignite station generating more than 75-80% is "one of the best pan-India."
- Life extension: The life of the 500 MW lignite plants will be extended by another 10 years through R&M, with lignite available at the location with approval. Lignite from captive mines is sufficient for the 500 MW thermal station through the PPA life plus 10 years.
Bhatt: "For lignite-based thermal station, Phase-I, we are targeting 75% and Phase-2 we are targeting 80%. So, any station which is generating more than 75% to 80% in lignite-based technology, it is one of the best pan India."
Investor Pushback: Disclosure and Capital Allocation
- Segment disclosure refused: An analyst repeatedly requested that the company publish thermal and renewable EBITDA/revenue splits in its results as a matter of investor friendliness. Management initially stated "As per the SEBI guidelines, it is not required," but then provided specific EBITDA figures verbally on the call.
- Dividend policy questioned: An analyst noted the dividend has been constant or declining despite capacity additions and that even DIPAM policy (30% of profit or 5% of net worth) is not being followed. Management responded that dividend is declared looking at future expansions and cited Khavda as a reason for pushing back the dividend last year.
- Capital allocation debate: An analyst raised concern that the company trades at 30-35% of replacement cost and questioned whether expansion CAPEX benefits shareholders versus returning cash via dividends or buybacks. Management responded "Whatever you are saying, we will look into it" twice.
- Shutdown disclosure gap: An analyst requested that a small press release be issued whenever a big shutdown will majorly affect results, noting this has happened many times over the past 2-3 years. Management said "We have noted and we will take care in the future" but made no explicit commitment to change disclosure practice.
Shah: "No, this is not the question of SEBI guidelines. This is a question of investor friendliness, sir. If investor is asking and if there is no harm for competitive reason, you should give the details, sir."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Profitability recovery | Return to pre-Covid profitability levels | By fiscal year-end |
| Fixed cost recovery | Achieve 75% (Phase-I) and 80% (Phase-II) commercial availability to recover full fixed costs per PPA | By fiscal year-end (measured annually) |
| Khavda Phase I & II completion | Complete all infrastructure activity to qualify for MNRE subsidy | Before March 2024 |
| Khavda park capacity | 50% of total park capacity added | By 2024 |
| Khavda park capacity | Balance 50% of total park capacity added | In next 2 years (after 2024) |
| Own capacity crystallization | Exact capacity GIPCL will add at Khavda and timeline finalized upon PPA execution | Expected by last quarter of current financial year |
| 75 MW solar project | Receive GUVNL and GoG approvals, then begin tendering | "Within a short period" |
| Debt raising | Raise debt when park development spend reaches ₹400-500 crores | Next year |
| Dividend | Dividend can be increased; will look into profitability and may go back to the same level | No specific timeline |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue run rate | ₹1,200 cr to ₹1,300 cr, flat expected in next 1 year |
| H1 EBITDA | ₹220 cr |
| H1 EBITDA from renewables | ₹106 cr (wind and solar) |
| H1 EBITDA from thermal | ₹141 cr |
| H1 EBITDA from wind and solar | ~₹115 cr |
| Dividend per share | ₹2.7, down from ₹2.9 at some point |
| Commercial availability target | 75% for SLPP-1 and 80% for SLPP-2, as per PPA for full fixed cost recovery (target, not guaranteed) |
| SLPP capacity idled in Q2 | 250 MW (125 MW plus 125 MW, 50% of SLPP), Unit 1 and Unit 4 out for around 45 days each |
| Lignite requirement for 500 MW plants | 36 to 38 lakh metric tons annually |
| Operational renewable capacity | 262 MW solar and 112.4 MW wind, adding ~₹100-110 cr to bottom line annually |
| Gas-based Vadodara Station capacity | 310 MW, non-operational |
| Gas price viability for gas plants | $8 to $8.5 per MMBtu |
| Khavda park total CAPEX | ~₹1,100 cr, with 30% MNRE subsidy |
| Khavda park return expectation | ~13% to 14% on equity portion after subsidy |
| Khavda park per MW cost | ₹5.6 cr to ₹5.8 cr including everything |
| Khavda park capacity phases | 600 MW, 600 MW, 600 MW, and 575 MW over 5-6 years |
| Khavda park Phase-1 and Phase-2 completion timeline | Before March 2024 as per MNRE guidelines |
| Khavda park H1 CAPEX incurred | ~₹100-120 cr |
| Khavda park H2 expected CAPEX | ₹100+ cr |
| Khavda park next year development spend | ~₹400-500 cr |
| Own capacity CAPEX at Khavda (300 MW) | ₹1,600-1,700 cr approx, at ₹5.5-5.6 cr per MW |
| Khavda project funding | 70:30 debt-equity |
| Expected debt rate for Khavda | 7% to 7.5% |
| Revenue thumb rule from FY25 | ₹2.75 to ₹2.80 per unit, at 50% capacity and 27% to 29% CUF |
| Replacement cost of 875 MW operating capacity | ₹4,000+ cr, market cap ~₹1,300 cr implying 30% to 35% of replacement cost (per an analyst's math) |
| Last 5 years CAPEX on expansion | ₹2,000 cr to ₹2,200 cr (per an analyst's math) |