Key Takeaways
- Steady quarter, margin dilution continues: QAAUM reached ₹485,700 crore with equity mix at 54.2%, but the structural drag of higher book margins versus flow margins persisted, though the pace of dilution has slowed.
- SIP engine is the priority: Systematic transactions hit ₹1,890 crore in June 2023, and management calls growing this book the organization's number one priority, viewing it as the best way to build a future order book.
- HDFC Bank merger is the big bet: Management has a "very optimistic view" of the opportunity from the promoter changes, calling the bank a "formidable distribution machine" and noting material improvement in engagement already.
- Competitive intensity on pay-outs is easing: Management noted that competitive intensity on brokerages has come down in recent months, and explicitly stated there is no direct correlation between higher brokerage and higher market share.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the HDFC Bank channel begins to translate engagement into measurable flow share gains, the trajectory of debt fund flows as rate-cut expectations build, and any further rationalization in industry brokerages.
The Margin Math: Dilution Is Structural, But Slowing
- The core mechanism: Book margin (on existing AUM) is higher than flow margin (on new money), so every new rupee that flows in dilutes the blended yield. The impact is magnified when existing low-cost AUM moves out.
- TER formula amplifies it: As fund AUM rises, the TER charged to investors falls per regulation. For example, HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund's AUM rose from ~₹52,000 crore to over ₹57,000 crore, and its TER fell from 1.5% to 1.47%, a 3 bps hit on the entire AUM.
- Absolute profit still rises: Despite the dilution, higher AUM yields higher absolute revenue: ₹57,000 crore at 1.47% generates more than ₹52,000 crore at 1.5%. Management frames this as the trade-off they accept.
- Pace of dilution has slowed: Rationalization of brokerages in the market has meaningfully slowed the rate at which new flows dilute the blended margin.
- No commission cuts on the book: Management pushed back on the idea of cutting commissions on existing AUM to offset dilution, calling it impractical given that market movements of 5-10% can swing the math either way.
Munot: "The example that I gave a Balanced Advantage Fund, Rs 57,000-odd crores into 1.47% gives us higher revenue as compared to Rs 52,000-odd crores at 1.5%. So clearly, I mean, a higher AUM while will lead to a margin dilution given the formula, but for us, it's higher absolute profit."
The HDFC Bank Opportunity
- The structural tailwind: The promoter-level changes at HDFC Bank create an alignment of interest that management calls "a big tailwind." The bank is described as a "formidable distribution machine."
- Engagement already improving: Management stated they are "deeply involved with them across all levels" and are "seeing material improvement in the engagement."
- Confidence in gaining share: Given the range of products across asset classes and brand familiarity within the group, management is confident in capturing a share of HDFC Bank's customer base.
- Bank channel share expected to rise: Over the next several quarters, a lot of focus will be on making the most of this opportunity, and the expectation is that the bank channel's share in distribution will go up.
- Current share disclosed under pressure: When pressed, management disclosed that HDFC AMC's share in equity flows being generated at HDFC Bank is 30%.
Munot: "We already are deeply involved with them across all levels, but alignment of interest can definitely be a big tailwind for us. We are seeing material improvement in the engagement, and we'll continue to work on strengthening it further."
SIP Book: The Core Growth Strategy
- The number one priority: Management stated that enhancing the systematic transactions book is the top priority for the entire organization, calling it the best way to garner flows and build an order book for the future.
- Scale of the operation: The company processed 0.5 crore systematic transactions amounting to ₹1,890 crore in June 2023, up from ₹1,710 crore in March 2023 and ₹1,280 crore in June 2022.
- Flow share improving, AUM share lags: SIP flow market share has increased considerably, but AUM market share remains broadly flattish because the industry SIP AUM outstanding is ₹7.9 trillion, and a delta in market share from increasing flows takes time to reflect in AUM.
- Industry context: Quarterly SIP flows of ₹43,200 crore accounted for approximately 37% of the industry's gross active equity flows, and SIP momentum continues to build.
Competitive Dynamics & Distribution
- Brokerage intensity easing: Competitive intensity on pay-outs has come down in the last few months, with better margins seen on some NFOs launched recently.
- No direct link between pay-outs and flows: Management explicitly stated that one of HDFC AMC's larger funds, where they pay the least possible brokerage, is seeing the healthiest flows, disproving any assumed correlation.
- Multi-channel growth ambition: The company wants to grow across all channels: MFDs, national distributors, other banks, and the fintech channel, not just the HDFC Bank channel.
- Distributor partner count fell: The reduction from 80,000+ to 75,000 distributor partners is attributed to some merging into other entities and some moving to platforms, with nothing material to read into it.
- Market share improving across channels: Market share on equity across all channels (distributors, banks, MFDs, fintechs, direct) has been improving.
Munot: "There is not a direct correlation between paying higher brokerages and getting higher market share. So, one of our larger funds, where we pay the least possible brokerage is seeing healthiest of the flows."
Product & Passive Strategy
- Product range now "best-in-class": With all the NFOs done in the last couple of years, management believes the product range is complete. There could be some sector or thematic fund here and there, but the core range is in place.
- Passive business getting dedicated focus: A dedicated lead has been hired, and a couple of people have been brought in to focus on growing the ETF business, with emphasis on enhancing secondary market volumes and engaging with market makers.
- New launch: HDFC Defence Fund, an equity-oriented thematic/sectoral fund, was launched and garnered healthy interest. A transportation and logistics fund NFO is in the pipeline.
- Debt fund opportunity: Management sees significant scope to grow the debt side if the industry does similar work to what was done on equity. For HDFC AMC, given brand and pedigree, there is a bigger opportunity as that segment starts growing faster.
- Debt flows turning: After several quarters of outflows, the industry saw positive flows in ultra short-term and money market funds as investors positioned for declining interest rates at the front end of the curve. At some stage, confidence about downward rate movement could bring money into longer-dated duration funds.
Munot: "I think now with all the NFOs we have done in the last couple of years, we have an absolutely best-in-class product range."
Financials & Operating Metrics
- Revenue and other income: Other income of ₹158 crore included healthy mark-to-market growth on equity-oriented mutual fund investments (over ₹300 crore held for skin-in-the-game compliance) and MTM growth on fixed income investments due to downward movement of interest rates.
- Cost growth: Employee cost grew 7% to ₹83.8 crore; excluding non-cash ESOP charge, it grew 8% YoY to ₹72.8 crore. Other expenses increased 17% YoY, principally attributed to general business-related expenses and technology spends.
- Other expenses run rate: The sequential increase of ~₹4 crore (5%) in other expenses is partly due to CSR expenses; this level should be a normal expectation over the year.
- Employee additions modest: The increase from 1,280 to 1,320 employees is mostly in sales, client services, and some support staff in digital, at junior to mid-level, so the delta in people cost will not be substantial.
- Tax rate: Effective tax rate was lower primarily due to a decrease in deferred tax charge, mainly attributed to the holding period of certain investments transitioning from short-term to long-term.
- Operating revenue margin: Stood at 47 bps for Q1 FY24 versus approximately 48 bps in March 2023 and 49 bps for full FY23, a net decrease of approximately 1 bps.
- PMS and SMA AUM decline: A couple of quarters back, a large global mandate saw the client decide to take money off the table from their allocation to India long only. Over the last couple of quarters, numbers have been in line.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Other expenses run rate | Current level (~₹4 crore sequential increase partly from CSR) is the normal expectation | Over the year |
| Product range | Range is complete; only occasional sector/thematic funds may launch | Ongoing |
| HDFC Bank channel focus | Lot of focus on making the most of the merger opportunity; bank share in distribution expected to rise | Over the next several quarters |
| Passive/ETF business growth | Dedicated lead hired; focus on secondary market volumes and market maker engagement | Underway |
| Multi-channel growth | Grow across MFDs, national distributors, other banks, and fintech channels | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹732.5 cr |
| Revenue from operations | ₹574.5 cr, +10% YoY |
| Other income | ₹158 cr, largely all MTM gains on equity and debt investments |
| Profit after tax | ₹477.5 cr, +52% YoY and +27% QoQ |
| Operating revenue margin | 47 bps of QAAUM, vs ~48 bps in Q4 FY23 and 49 bps in FY23 |
| Operating profit margin | 34 bps of QAAUM |
| Employee cost | ₹83.8 cr, +7% YoY; excluding ESOP charge: ₹72.8 cr, +8% YoY |
| Other expenses | +17% YoY; sequential increase of ~₹4 cr, ~5% QoQ |
| Quarterly average AUM (QAAUM) | ₹485,700 cr; equity-oriented 54.2% of total |
| Market share in QAAUM | 11.3%; excluding ETFs: 12.6% |
| Market share in actively managed equity-oriented funds (QAAUM) | 12.1%; closing basis: 12.2% |
| Market share in debt funds QAAUM (incl. debt index funds) | 13.2%; liquid AUM: 13.7% |
| Systematic transactions (June 2023) | ₹1,890 cr from 0.5 cr transactions; March 2023: ₹1,710 cr; June 2022: ₹1,280 cr |
| Unique investor base | 0.71 cr, 18% share of industry |
| Blended equity yield | Late 60s bps; budget at 68–69 bps |
| HDFC AMC share of HDFC Bank overall flows | In the handle of 30% |
| HDFC AMC share of HDFC Bank equity AUM | A little over 8% |