Key Takeaways
- Equity market share stabilizes, adjusted for NFOs: Overall equity market share was flat QoQ, but management argues it improved across the board when excluding the impact of large NFOs it chose not to participate in, which collected over ₹10,000 crores for competitors.
- SIP market share recovery underway: After losing share for several quarters, systematic transaction market share is now improving across all channels and among the top 10 industry entities, driven by better scheme performance.
- Yield improved on mix, not pricing: Revenue yield rose from 50 bps to 51 bps sequentially, entirely because equity's proportion of AUM increased; debt yields were stable and equity yields saw a small TER-linked dilution.
- Debt outflows persist, but a retail opportunity is forming: Rising rates drove industry-wide debt outflows, costing HDFC AMC ~1% of debt AUM market share YoY. Management sees elevated yields as a catalyst for retail debt fund adoption once rates stabilize.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Business Cycle Fund NFO lifts reported equity market share, the pace of debt index fund launches, and any sign of rate stabilization that could stem institutional debt outflows.
Market Share Dynamics
- Equity share flat on the surface, better underneath: Reported overall equity market share was flat for two straight quarters, but management points to visible improvement when adjusted for large NFOs it skipped.
- SIP share recovering after a multi-quarter slide: HDFC AMC lost systematic transaction market share over the last couple of years for reasons discussed in prior quarters; efforts to reverse this were stepped up a couple of quarters back and are now showing results.
- SIP improvement is broad-based: Market share rose YoY across all channels (fintechs, national distributors, MFDs, banks, direct) and across all of the top 10 entities, which together account for ~60% of industry new SIP count.
- Debt market share eroded by institutional money: YoY debt AUM market share fell from 14.6% to 13.7%, driven by large corporate, treasury and institutional investors pulling money as rising rates made debt funds unattractive. QoQ share was flat.
- Debt ex-index funds holding on: Excluding debt index funds and ETFs, market share in the rest of the debt categories is "pretty decent and holding on."
Munot: "Even adjusted for that if you see our market share, it's pretty visible that we are improving across the board."
Flows & Channel Mix
- SIPs now dominate inflows: 75% of flows are purely from SIP, meaning lump sum flows have clearly slowed down as markets turned volatile.
- Fintech is the largest SIP origination channel: In H1 FY23, fintechs accounted for almost one-third of new SIPs, followed by national distributors (~20%), MFDs (~15%), direct (~10%), with the remainder from banks and RIAs.
- Fintech persistency likely lower: Management assumes SIP persistency is lower on the fintech channel relative to most other channels, but declined to provide granular retention data.
- Lump sum slowdown is market-driven: The decline in lump sum flows reflects investors pulling back amid volatility, not a structural shift unique to HDFC AMC.
Munot: "75% of flows are purely from SIP which means that lump sum flows have come down. So, maybe some of the investors who are putting the lump sum flows are not putting now."
Revenue Yield & Margins
- Yield uptick is purely mix-driven: The sequential improvement from 50 bps to 51 bps came from a higher equity proportion in overall AUM; fixed income and liquid yields were stable.
- Equity yield saw a small TER drag: A couple of schemes crossed the ₹5,000 crore AUM threshold, triggering the sliding-scale TER adjustment and shaving a couple of basis points off equity yields.
- Flow margins are well below book margins: New business is being written at substantially lower margins than the existing book, a structural headwind that management expects will be offset by favorable asset mix and volume growth over the longer term.
- Yield dilution pace may slow: Statistically, the pace of dilution could ease going forward because gross flows as a percentage of AUM may be lower compared to the prior year.
- OPEX investment is deliberate: The OPEX-to-AUM ratio sits at 13–14 bps, with travel expenditure rising and ongoing investment in technology, people and business promotion. Management is keen to invest now to gain market share and sees scope for ratio improvement as AUM scales.
- Talent retention is a cost priority: Healthy demand for high-quality talent across financial services means retaining people is a key focus; management will "try our best to balance" between cost discipline and keeping good talent.
Munot: "It would not be prudent to let good talent go away. So, we will try our best to balance between the two."
Debt Funds: Outflows Today, Opportunity Tomorrow
- Rising rates drove outflows, as expected: Debt fund outflows over the last several months are historically typical behavior in a rising interest rate environment.
- Elevated yields could attract retail: Management sees a "great opportunity" emerging: once rates start stabilizing, elevated yields could drive acceptance of debt funds by a much larger set of individual investors.
- Product innovation is part of the plan: Approvals have been received to launch various debt index funds, including open-ended target maturity funds investing in GSecs, SDLs and highly rated corporate bonds with specific maturities, equivalent to erstwhile FMPs.
- State development loan supply a near-term headwind: Higher SDL supply, which has been muted, is likely to pick up in coming quarters, putting further upward pressure on yields.
- Industry needs to promote fixed-income SIPs: Management believes SIP in fixed income funds should be promoted for hardcore debt investors, and that yields at current levels, combined with product innovation and investor education, can drive much greater penetration.
Munot: "If you have a rising interest rate environment, that's when you get outflows from the debt fund historically. We have seen that in past as well. But if you ask me going forward, I see a great opportunity emerging out of this."
Product Launches & Alternatives Build-Out
- Active equity NFO coming: A Business Cycle Fund (thematic) is planned for launch in November.
- Passive pipeline is filling: Six ETFs were launched during the September quarter, including a Silver ETF, and two more Smart Beta ETFs were closed in October. Several debt index funds will launch in the next few months.
- Alternatives activity ramping up: A Category-II AIF fund-of-funds investing across VC and PE funds was launched, and a second PMS strategy (India Ascent) was added alongside the All Cap Strategy launched last quarter.
- PMS AUM dipped on a single institutional exit: One large global institutional client closed a mandate, causing a sharp decline in PMS AUM; the financial impact on overall revenues is not material.
- International ambitions via GIFT City: Management is working through various modes to build the international business and sees the GIFT City setup as a big step; more details will be shared over the next few quarters.
- Alternatives are a multi-year focus: PMS and AIF are the priority areas on the non-mutual fund side, with ambitious plans, though management says it is premature to give AUM targets for the next two to three years.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Active equity NFO launch | Business Cycle Fund (thematic) | November 2022 |
| Debt index fund launches | Multiple open-ended target maturity funds (GSec/SDL/corporate bonds) | Next few months |
| Equity market share reflection | Improved adjusted market share to show in reported overall equity share | Possibly with a quarter lag |
| Alternatives activity | Enhanced level of activity in PMS and AIF space | Next several quarters |
| International business update | More details on GIFT City setup and international build-out | Next few quarters |
| OPEX-to-AUM ratio improvement | Scope for improvement as AUM increases over time | No date; investing now for market share |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | Flat YoY |
| Profit after tax | Up 6% YoY |
| Operating profit margin | 36 bps of AUM, H1 FY23 |
| Operating revenue margin | 50 bps of AUM, H1 FY23 |
| Revenue yield | 51 bps, improved from 50 bps QoQ (per an analyst's math) |
| H1 FY23 revenue | ₹1,181.8 crore, up 3% YoY |
| H1 FY23 PAT | ₹678.3 crore, down 2% YoY |
| H1 FY23 employee cost (ex-ESOP) | ₹140.6 crore, up 23% absolute vs H1 FY20, 7% CAGR |
| H1 FY23 ESOP cost | ₹21.2 crore (vs ₹34.3 crore in H1 FY22) |
| Full year FY23 ESOP cost guidance | ~₹40 crore |
| Closing AUM | ₹422,200 crore |
| Quarterly average AUM market share | 11% overall, 12.3% excluding ETF |
| Actively managed equity-oriented AUM market share | 11.5%, flat QoQ |
| Debt and liquid quarterly average market share | 13.7% and 13.2% respectively |
| Systematic transactions (Sep 2022) | ₹1,430 crore from 0.39 crore transactions, up from ₹1,280 crore in Jun 2022 |
| New SIP channel mix (H1 FY23) | MFDs 15%, national distributors ~20%, direct 10%, fintechs ~33% |
| Industry quarterly equity net flows | ₹50,400 crore, down from ₹78,300 crore QoQ |
| Industry debt fund outflows (incl. index/ETF) | ~₹6,000 crore net outflow |
| Industry SIP flows (Sep 2022) | ₹12,976 crore |