Key Takeaways
- Market share decline acknowledged, recovery promised: Management is "pretty sure" better market share will return over the next several quarters, citing a sharp rebound in equity fund performance and green shoots in flows over the last 3–4 months.
- Equity yield compression is structural but welcomed: A 2–3 bps drop in equity-oriented fund margins came from AUM crossing regulatory hurdles, a problem management calls "not a bad problem to have" given the industry's 9x equity AUM growth over 8 years.
- The passive and alternatives build-out is now explicit: A separate "HDFC MF Index Solutions" brand, 12 new ETF filings, a Category II AIF filing, and a GIFT City subsidiary signal a deliberate push into higher-growth and higher-margin adjacencies.
- Cost discipline holds, with a caveat: Ex-ESOP operating expenses stayed at 12–13 bps of AUM, a trend management expects to continue even as it spends more on NFOs, technology, and digital assets.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the improved equity performance converts into a measurable uptick in net flow market share, and the pace of the passive and alternatives product rollout.
Market Share & Flows
- The problem: Market share declined over the last couple of quarters, and more than half of new industry investors went into ETFs where HDFC AMC's presence has been relatively less.
- The fix: Management points to a sharp rebound in equity fund performance across most products and time periods, with feedback from partners, investors, and the sales team recognizing the improvement.
- Conversion lag: It typically takes a couple of quarters for the broader market to notice performance improvements, and the lift also depends on engagement and product approvals from channels like banks and national distributors.
- SIP market share: Management is highly focused on regaining share in incremental SIPs, stating it "deserves a much higher share" than today's level, with efforts spanning partner engagement, content, marketing, new product launches, and digital.
- Liquid fund share normalization: Market share had jumped to almost 20% in FY20–21 due to a risk-off environment; as risk appetite returned, that level was not sustainable and share has since normalized.
Munot: "We don't want to be where we are today when we look at our share in incremental SIPs. I think we deserve a much higher share compared to where we are today."
Equity Yield Compression
- The regulatory mechanics: A 2–3 bps drop in TER hits the entire AUM of a scheme when it crosses ₹5,000 crore. Nearly 70–75% of HDFC AMC's AUM crossed such hurdles in FY22, causing a nearly 2–3 bps drop in overall equity-oriented fund margins.
- The churn amplifier: High gross sales with a low gross-to-net ratio accelerate the margin drop. Gross sales were ₹6 trillion against net flows of ₹2.7 trillion on a starting AUM of ~₹13 trillion, meaning a large portion of the book reprices to current, lower yields each year.
- Brokerage pressure: Net revenue also dropped due to increased brokerages, an industry-wide challenge. Recent NFOs have been priced much better, and competitive intensity in distribution cost is settling down versus the first half of FY22, though not back to levels of a couple of years ago.
- Stabilization timeline: Margin stabilization requires the entire book to be replaced, a process management says will happen over a "long, fairly long period of time," not in the next 2–3 years. The intensity of yield fall should theoretically reduce going forward, but the pace depends on how fast the book churns.
- Management's framing: The yield decline is a consequence of AUM growth, which management calls "not a bad problem to have," pointing to industry equity AUM growing from ₹2 trillion in April 2014 to over ₹18 trillion.
Munot: "Honestly, I'm more excited with this kind of gross sales rather than getting bothered about short-term drop in margins. Indian households are quickly adapting to equity culture, which is very heartening."
Passive & Alternatives Build-Out
- Passive strategy: HDFC AMC wants to be a relevant player on the passive side while keeping profitability in mind. It launched a separate brand, "HDFC MF Index Solutions," with a dedicated monthly fact sheet, and filed for 12 ETFs in total to address the investor segment that has so far invested only in ETFs.
- Alternatives (PMS): A new portfolio manager has been onboarded, and the firm has started talking about the service to key partners and clients, with some interest visible.
- Alternatives (AIF): A Category II AIF (fund of funds investing across early to late stage) is expected to go live sometime in Q2 of the current financial year, subject to regulatory approvals. The team has interacted with over 40 funds and is in second-round diligence with several. A Category III AIF filing is also planned over the next few weeks.
- GIFT City subsidiary: The board approved setting up a wholly owned subsidiary in GIFT City, awaiting regulatory approvals. It will serve as the vehicle to attract global money into India and, over time, mobilize Indian savings through the LRS route into global products.
- Strategic logic: Management wants to build scale with profitability across all three spaces: active (moderate margins, moderate growth), passive (higher growth, lower margins), and alternative (low volume, high margin).
Munot: "We want to be a relevant player, keeping the profitability aspect in mind on the passive side, but want to have the full product book... The third, which is alternative business will also be important for us for future growth, more on the profitability side than the overall AUM."
Investment Performance
- Long-term track record intact: Key categories including Flexi Cap, Large Cap, Large and Mid-cap, Focused, Balanced Advantage, and Hybrid Equity Aggressive/Conservative are in the top decile or quartile over 1 to 5 years, though some funds may not be in a specific 3- or 4-year period.
- Style persistence: Management noted that the investment style has worked over long periods, and after periods of testing patience, the firm is now seeing rewards.
- Active management conviction: Management are big believers in active management, arguing that in India there is still material alpha on offer and broad markets will outperform over time, making a strong case for active products.
Costs & Profitability
- Employee cost: FY22 employee benefit expense rose 38% YoY, primarily due to a ₹63.3 crore non-cash charge for ESOP amortization versus ₹7.3 crore in the prior year. Excluding this, employee cost rose 13.4%.
- Other expenses: The 27% YoY increase was attributed to a low base effect from the previous year's lockdown, NFO launch expenses, and regular business promotions. The QoQ decline from ₹57 crore to ₹50 crore was largely caused by lower NFO and business promotion expenses in the last quarter.
- Cost ratio commitment: Management will try to keep the ex-ESOP operating expense ratio around 12–13 bps of AUM, a trend maintained over the last several years, even while spending more on new product launches, business promotion, marketing, technology, and digital assets.
- Non-equity margins: No material change in margin on the non-equity side of the business.
Digital & Distribution
- Digital engagement: Over 75% of transactions are executed digitally. The investor portal has over 0.13 crore users, adding 350,000 in FY22 without a drop in engagement. The app is rated above 4 on iOS and Android.
- Digital nudges: Analytics-driven interventions reduced redemptions by 2.5%, and analytics-based campaigns had 2.5x more effective conversion rates.
- Distributor platform: The Connekt app user base grew 2x with active weekly engagement over 50%, and 48,000+ partners are registered on the website with an active engagement rate of 34%.
- HDFC Bank merger tailwind: The shift from a sibling relationship to a parent-child relationship with HDFC Bank, which has a much wider network and bigger scale, is hoped to give many more distribution opportunities.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Market share recovery | "Better market share" driven by improved performance, new products, marketing, distributor engagement, and digital initiatives | "Over the next several quarters" |
| Category II AIF launch | Fund of funds investing across early to late stage, subject to regulatory approvals | "Sometime in Q2 of current financial year" |
| Category III AIF filing | PPM to be filed with SEBI | "Over the next few weeks" |
| Ex-ESOP cost ratio | Maintain around 12–13 bps of AUM while spending more on launches, marketing, and technology | Ongoing |
| Passive product expansion | 12 ETFs filed/approved; further range expansion planned | Ongoing |
| Incremental flow share | Improvement as equity performance rebound gets recognized by channels | "Over a period of time" (couple of quarters for recognition) |
| SIP market share | Close the gap versus historical absolute leadership | "As early as possible" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Profit after tax | ₹343.5 crore, +9% YoY |
| Revenue from operations (FY22) | +14% YoY |
| Operating profit from core AMB (FY22) | +10% YoY |
| Operating profit from core AMB ex-ESOP (FY22) | ₹1,600.8 crore, +14% YoY |
| Employee benefit expense (FY22) | ₹312.2 crore, +38% YoY; includes ₹63.3 crore non-cash ESOP charge |
| Employee cost ex-ESOP (FY22) | +13.4% YoY |
| Other expenses (FY22) | +27% YoY |
| Dividend per share | ₹42, vs ₹34 last year; payout ratio 64% |
| Total market share in QA AUM | 11.3% |
| Market share in QA AUM ex-ETF | 12.5% |
| Systematic flows (Jan–Mar) | ₹3,560 crore |
| Systematic transactions (March) | ₹1,230 crore across 0.36 crore transactions |
| Unique investors | 0.58 crore, up from 0.53 crore in March 2021 |
| Cost-to-AUM ratio guidance | ~12–13 bps of AUM, maintained over several years |
| Branches | 228 across India |