Key Takeaways
- Subdued quarter, long-term confidence intact: Demand stayed muted across segments due to inflation and interest rates, but management expects a sharp FY25 rebound driven by pent-up project demand and election-year normalization.
- Bath margins sacrificed for brand building: Incremental ~INR7+ crores of World Cup advertising compressed sanitaryware margins by ~200 bps, yet nine-month EBITDA still improved 200 bps to 15.4%.
- Pipe margins hit by PVC price deflation: Resin prices fell 16% YoY, dragging realizations and revenue even as volumes held; new high-margin product categories and a Roorkee plant aim to lift EBITDA to 10-12% in 18-24 months.
- Consumer Appliances in active restructuring: The segment is exiting non-performing categories, doubling down on kitchen where it leads on Flipkart, and targeting positive EBITDA in a couple of quarters.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised FY25 buoyancy materializes, the pace of pipe new-product launches from Q1, and the Board's final decision on the loss-making retail segment.
Bathware: Brand Investment Over Short-Term Margin
- Sanitaryware vs faucetware divergence: Sanitaryware grew low single digits while faucets delivered double-digit growth, reflecting different competitive dynamics and consumer pull.
- World Cup spend compressed margins: Advertising across all 48 matches cost ~INR7 crores plus and added ~200 bps of margin pressure in sanitaryware for the quarter.
- Nine-month trend tells a healthier story: Despite the Q3 A&P spike, nine-month EBITDA margins rose 200 bps to 15.4%, with no adverse product mix and localization initiatives still on track to deliver further gains.
- Distribution push continues: The company is expanding its network and opening more brand stores in Tier 1 and Tier 2 cities to broaden reach.
- Competitive stance on tile entrants: Management dismissed tile companies entering bathware as not having achieved significant revenue, arguing the category is a consumer brand business, not a building materials commodity.
Pokhriyal: "We don't believe this business will be a building materials business. We believe this business will be a consumer business wherein brands are very important and basis the brand consumer buys the product."
Pipes: Price Deflation Masks Volume Stability
- Revenue decline is purely price-driven: PVC resin rates dropped from INR 91 to INR 76 per kg (down ~16%), reducing average metric ton realization and compressing the top line; inventory losses were controlled at only INR 1.5 crores.
- Peer growth came from categories Truflo does not yet serve: Large competitors reported volume growth by selling underground drainage, double wall corrugated pipes, fire sprinklers, and government-project HDPE pipe, segments Truflo entered only four years ago and is still building.
- New product roadmap is now funded and sequenced: Foam core (underground drainage) launches in Q1 FY25; double wall corrugated pipes and fittings plus fire sprinkler systems follow through Q3 FY25; only 3-4 players manufacture these higher-GP categories.
- Roorkee plant anchors the turnaround: Construction is underway with an operational launch targeted for December FY25; once online, management believes it can score better than competitors.
- Price correction expected near-term: Management expects PVC prices to correct around March, which would lift per metric tonne realizations.
Consumer Appliances: Portfolio Surgery Underway
- Demand weakness and destocking: Subdued consumer sentiment and inflation hit the segment; post-festive season destocking signaled weak underlying demand.
- Kitchen remains the bright spot: Chimneys hold the number one position on Flipkart and number three on Amazon (closing the gap with number two); the kitchen appliance business continues to grow and is resilient.
- Rationalization is aggressive: The company is exiting non-performing and low-performing categories, focusing on cost correction on both the product and operational sides, and putting business hygiene in place.
- Kitchen fittings exploration: Existing international partners were acquired by a global market leader but clarity now exists to continue driving the business in India; revenue is being generated though not yet at scale.
- Path to breakeven: Management expects the consumer business to reach positive EBITDA in a couple of quarters, with product rationalization completing in the same timeframe.
Retail Segment: Decision Nears on Exit Options
- Losses stem from fixed-cost drag: Sales declined, the franchising network was not expanded, and fixed costs remained, producing a negative bottom-line impact; no new initiatives are being attempted.
- Board has signaled action: The Board has given in-principle approval for the company to aggressively work on all options relating to retail, including assets held for sale.
- Final call expected soon: Management asked investors to bear with them for maybe another quarter before taking a final conclusion to the Board.
Cost & Margin Roadmap
- Manpower cost reduction identified: The company is targeting ~INR 20-25 crores of annualized savings from manpower and in-sourcing initiatives, which would add 1-1.5% to overall margins; implementation is planned over the next one or two quarters.
- Consolidated EBITDA ambition: Over the next 24 months, combined entity margins are expected to reach around 13-14%.
- Pipes margin target: Double-digit 10-12% EBITDA is expected in 18-24 months once all investments are in place.
- Capex envelope for next year: ~INR 100 crores for the Uttarakhand pipe plant, plus INR 60-70 crores for the Bathware business.
- Debt reduction path: Management expects to run off debt by about INR 100 crores with profits, though market momentum has not moved as planned.
Pokhriyal: "But on a nine-month basis, even after doing this extra spend in this quarter, we are 200 basis point higher. So there is no adverse product mix. There is no margin pressure, in fact, we're on track for our localization initiative as well, which is bound to give us further gains as we go forward."
Market Outlook: Betting on FY25 Buoyancy
- Project cycle explains the lull: Projects held up during COVID were completed in FY23; new launches got delayed in FY24, creating an air pocket that management believes will reverse sharply.
- Premium vs affordable split: The premium and luxury segment remains buoyant while affordable housing has been hit by inflation; general elections may cause a short-term cash-based market slowdown.
- Long-term growth algorithm: Management sees a market CAGR of 8-10% and expects to grow 1.25-1.5x the market; FY25 is expected to see huge buoyancy as delayed purchases and investments come through.
- Revenue growth trajectory: The company should be able to continue a growth trajectory in the range of 15-17%.
- Pipes revenue ambition: A target of INR 2,000 crores plus in pipes revenue over the next five years.
Sikka: "I think Q1, Q2 because we have seen historically, like whenever you have a muted period, after which, you get a good growth because some of the things, some of the investments which ordinary consumers have not made, then all of a sudden, it starts increasing. So we are bullish and forget about all these one or two quarters, wherein we have this muted growth. We are fairly bullish on the long-term growth."
Pokhriyal: "In my view, we can see a lot of launches right now, but for them to really start using our products, and to actually buying them, it actually got delayed. So what I believe is in FY25, we'll see a huge buoyancy in the market."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Bath business growth | Grow 1.25x the market | FY25 |
| Pipe plant operational | Roorkee plant launch | December FY25 |
| New pipe product: foam core | Underground drainage sales begin | Q1 FY25 |
| New pipe product: DWC & fire sprinklers | Machine installation and commercial production | Q3 FY25 |
| Consumer Appliances EBITDA | Reach positive EBITDA | "A couple of quarters" |
| Product rationalization | Complete portfolio cleanup | "Next couple of quarters" |
| Pipes EBITDA margin | 10-12% | 18-24 months |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | ~13-14% | 24 months |
| Revenue growth trajectory | 15-17% | Ongoing |
| Pipes revenue target | INR 2,000 crores plus | 5 years |
| Cost savings from manpower | INR 20-25 crores annualized (1-1.5% margin impact) | "Next one or two quarters" |
| Capex (pipes plant) | ~INR 100 crores | Next year (FY25) |
| Capex (Bathware) | INR 60-70 crores | Next year (FY25) |
| Retail segment decision | Board final conclusion on options including asset sale | "Maybe another quarter or so" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹693 cr |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹61.3 cr |
| Bath business revenue | ₹402 cr |
| Bath business EBITDA margin | 13.6%, impacted ~200 bps by higher A&P spend |
| Pipes business EBITDA margin | 8.5% |
| Consumer Appliances business revenue | ₹112 cr |
| Consolidated 9M EBITDA margin | 15.4%, improved 200 bps YoY from 13.4% |
| A&P spend | ~₹25 cr, ~₹9-10 cr above average due to World Cup advertising |
| New products share of Bath sales (9M FY24) | 24% |
| Bath working capital days | 117 days, improved from 122 days in Q3 FY23 |
| CPVC pipes and fittings revenue share | Over 40% |
| Pipes capacity utilization (Q3) | ~85%, YTD ~78% |
| Pipes inventory loss | ~₹1.5 cr |
| Pipes distributor and retailer network | Over 300 active distributors, ~30,000 retailers |
| Consumer Appliances kitchen online mix | 35% to 37% |
| Kitchen appliances share of Consumer Appliances revenue | 60% to 65% |
| Consolidated net debt (9M FY24) | ₹1,000 cr |
| Uttarakhand pipe plant capex planned for next year | ₹100 cr, for additional capacity of ~12,500 MT per annum |
| Bathware business capex planned (ex-pipe plant) | ₹60 cr to ₹70 cr |
| Cumulative investment in pipes business | ~₹340 cr |