Key Takeaways
- Record production and profit, but cost pressure is real: Mined metal, refined metal and silver all hit best-ever Q1 volumes, driving record revenue and EBITDA, yet coal and input inflation pushed costs higher sequentially.
- Cost guidance held, with a detailed plan to get there: Management reaffirmed its $1,125–$1,175/t cost target and laid out specific levers: automation for recovery, biomass substitution, linkage coal ramp-up, and operational efficiency.
- Two new growth projects approved: The board greenlit a fertilizer plant and an additional roaster, both expected online by mid-2024, signaling a diversification bet beyond pure zinc.
- A $4,100/ton hedge book provides a floor, but forward hedging is on hold: 21% of sales are hedged at an average $4,100, yet management will not commit to new hedges, calling the strategy "opportunistic" and price-dependent.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether linkage coal materialization actually improves post-monsoon, the pace of cost decline toward the guided range, and any forward hedging action if zinc prices stay elevated.
Production & Volume: The 1-Million-Ton Milestone
- Record Q1 across the board: Mine metal, refined metal and silver production all reached their highest ever first-quarter levels, achieved by structural changes that neutralized the traditional Q1 seasonality drag.
- Finished goods inflection: Last year mined metal crossed 0.1 crore tons but finished goods fell short at ~970,000 tons; this year management is confident finished goods will also cross the 0.1 crore ton mark, closing the gap between mine and saleable output.
- Volume guidance intact: The production momentum underpins an unchanged volume outlook for FY23, with management stating it is "absolutely clear" the guidance will be met.
Misra: "This is the year where our finished goods will also cross 0.1 crore ton mark. So, that is why we are hopeful on that. We are absolutely clear that the guidance given we will live up to it."
Cost Structure: The Inflation Fight
- Coal inflation contained, not eliminated: While Australian and Indonesian coal indexes rose ~250% YoY, Hindustan Zinc held its total cost increase to ~20% YoY, with the power component now at 26% of costs.
- Linkage coal is the swing factor: Materialization from Coal India improved from ~3% in Q4 to ~8% this quarter, with a 1-million-ton backlog allocated and a Tranche 5 FSA signed; management expects supply to improve further after the monsoon in H2.
- Three-pronged cost reduction plan: Management is targeting a return to the $1,125–$1,175/t guided range through (1) automated process control across mills to lift recovery by 1.5–2%, (2) increasing biomass as a coal substitute from 5% to 10%, and (3) optimizing between high- and low-cost coal parcels.
- Sulfuric acid tailwind fading: Better auction realizations for sulfuric acid helped offset input inflation this quarter, but management noted a recent cooling in acid prices, so the benefit may not persist.
- Power cost step-change coming, but not until 2024: A 200 MW renewable power tie-up, priced cheaper than own thermal generation and fixed for 25 years, comes online in 2024; the plan is to scale this to 450–500 MW thereafter.
Misra: "As of now, it is cheaper than our own thermal coal-based production power. Best part of it is, it will be unchanged over 25 years' time."
Growth Projects: Fertilizer, Roaster & Value-Added Products
- Fertilizer plant and roaster approved: The board sanctioned both projects during the quarter, with a combined timeline of 18–24 months from order placement, targeting Q2 or early Q3 2024 for commissioning.
- Fertilizer via a separate subsidiary: The fertilizer business will be executed through a subsidiary to ensure the right focus and a culture distinct from the metals operation.
- Value-added product push: Currently 15% of product is value-added (Jumbo, CCG, HZDA); the target is 20–25%, which reduces SHG export volumes and captures a direct duty benefit. A subsidiary for alloy-based value-added products is already set up, with manufacturing facilities under construction.
- CAPEX payout back-end loaded: The next six months will focus on design and negotiation for the new projects, with material CAPEX payouts starting only from Q4 FY23 and continuing through the project period.
- Gujarat smelter on the back burner: Management is not actively pursuing the Gujarat smelter, prioritizing the 1-million-ton finished goods milestone from current assets first; the project will be redesigned based on current realities if and when a public hearing opportunity arises.
Market & Pricing: A Floor, Not a Ceiling
- Zinc demand seen as durable: Management expects zinc demand to stay strong, citing a substantial backlog of work and the EU's €2 trillion stimulus package as structural supports.
- Silver gets a green tailwind: Demand from photovoltaic cells and solar panels is expected to support silver prices over the medium term.
- Management's price framework: Stable operations are achievable between $3,000 and $3,200/ton LME; the "red line" sits around $2,200–$2,300, where all smelters would be in trouble, implying a natural floor.
- Hedging book provides near-term protection: 21% of sales are hedged at an average $4,100/ton, but management declined to disclose how much is hedged from Q2 onward or at what specific strikes, calling the strategy purely opportunistic.
- No hedging trigger disclosed: When pressed on what zinc price would prompt new hedges, the CFO said it depends on the cost base at that moment and that "there cannot be anything at this point of time I think we can indicate."
Modi: "I have to say $1,000 of the cost levels somebody may be lucrative for $3,500 and the $1,300 level somebody would be lucrative of $4,000. So we will have to continue to wait and watch."
Strategic Optionality: Renewables, M&A & the Transition
- Renewable power as a structural hedge: Management framed the move to renewables not just as a cost play but as a strategic response to shrinking coal supply, arguing that ESG-driven pressure on coal producers will keep adding cost to thermal power over time.
- Overseas zinc assets still on the map: Acquiring overseas zinc assets, including Vedanta's own Zinc International in South Africa, remains a strategic ambition, but any deal requires government permission and a maturation of the regulatory situation; no timeline was offered.
- Post-COVID transition acknowledged: Management believes the global economy is in a 6–12 month transition phase and will settle down thereafter, a framing that implicitly asks for patience on both demand and cost volatility.
Misra: "But I firmly believe that the post COVID era world is going through a transition phase. It would settle down in about 6 months to 12 months' time."
Capital Return & ESG
- Interim dividend declared: The board approved ₹21 per share (1,050% on a ₹2 face value), totaling ₹8,873 crores, with a July 21, 2022 record date.
- Cash composition undisclosed: When asked to break down the ₹24,200 crore investment book into liquid versus illiquid instruments, management called the split "quite sensitive" and would only say it is a mix.
- Safety incident and response: A business partner colleague died at Zawar mines in April 2022; an independent investigation was conducted and learnings are being implemented across all operating assets, alongside new initiatives like blasting standardization and cardiac evaluations for 12,000 employees.
- ESG milestones stacking up: The quarter saw deployment of India's first battery electric vehicle in an underground mine, a reframed biodiversity policy with IBAT assessments for all Rajasthan locations, and a 4,000 kiloliter/day zero liquid discharge plant initiated at Zawar.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume guidance | Deliver on promised FY23 volume; finished goods to cross 0.1 crore tons | FY23 |
| Cost of production | $1,125–$1,175 per ton | FY23 |
| Project CAPEX | $125–$150 million | FY23 |
| Maintenance CAPEX | $350–$400 million | FY23 |
| Fertilizer plant and roaster | Commissioned and in operation | Q2 or early Q3 2024 (18–24 months from order placement) |
| Renewable power (Phase 1) | 200 MW online, cheaper than thermal, fixed for 25 years | 2024 |
| Renewable power (Phase 2) | Scale from 200 MW to 450–500 MW | After 2024 |
| Value-added product mix | Increase from 15% to 20–25% of product portfolio | No date given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹9,387 cr, up 44% YoY and 7% sequentially |
| EBITDA | ₹5,278 cr, up 48% YoY and 5% sequentially |
| Consolidated net profit | ₹3,092 cr, up 56% YoY and 6% sequentially |
| Effective tax rate | 33.8%, marginally higher QoQ |
| Interim dividend | ₹21 per share, 1050% on face value of ₹2 per share, amounting to ₹8,873 cr |
| Zinc cost of production before royalty | $1,264 per metric tonne, up 18% YoY and 11% sequentially; up 23% YoY and 14% sequentially in INR terms |
| Zinc LME prices | +34% YoY |
| Zinc metal sales volume | +10% YoY |
| Lead sales volume | +9% sequentially |
| Silver sales volume | +10% sequentially |
| Hedging: FY23 production hedged | 21% of expected production, average hedge price $4,100 per ton; 10-11% already consumed |
| Linkage coal materialization | ~8% of consumption, up from ~3% in Q4 FY22 |
| Ore grade | 6.91% |
| Capital mine development | 14 km |
| Cash and investments | ₹24,200 cr as of June 2022; approximately ₹15,000 cr after dividend |