Key Takeaways
- Cost milestone achieved: Q1 cost of production declined sequentially for the first time in the company's recent history, defying a five-year pattern of 10–15% QoQ increases, driven by a shift to cheaper linkage coal and improved ore grades.
- Earnings hit by LME, not operations: Revenue, EBITDA and net profit fell 22%, 36% and 37% YoY respectively, overwhelmingly because of lower zinc and lead LME prices, with the cost improvement providing only a partial offset.
- Full-year cost guidance tightened: Management now expects to land near the lower band of its $1,125–$1,175 per ton cost guidance, with the bulk of restructured contract benefits still to flow through in coming quarters.
- Growth capex on track: The alloy plant, Rajpura Dariba Mill and Fumer plant are all set for commissioning in Q2, while the Debari roaster and fertilizer plant have moved to site work with clear timelines.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether zinc LME recovers toward the $2,900–$3,100 stable range management expects by December–January, the pace of further cost reduction as restructured contracts kick in, and the commissioning of three growth projects.
Cost Structure Transformation
- Historic Q1 reversal: In each of the last five years, Q1 cost of production rose 10–15% sequentially on lower mined metal and operational seasonality. This quarter broke that pattern with a 2% decline, achieved through a deliberate shift in the coal blend and operational interventions.
- Coal mix overhaul: Linkage coal share jumped from 10% to 28% of the blend, displacing more expensive imported coal. Softening global coal prices added further relief on the imported portion.
- Grade and recovery gains: Ore grades improved from 6.9% to 7.1%, and technology interventions lifted mill recovery, both contributing to the unit cost decline.
- Contract restructuring still to bite: Management has renegotiated most operating contracts with business partners, redesigning them for cost efficiency. The benefits will accrue progressively from Q2 through Q4, with the maximum impact in later quarters, meaning the full run-rate improvement is not yet visible.
Misra: "Not only coal... we have restructured most of our operating contracts, working with the business partners to bring in much more cost efficiency, redoing the contracts in a much, much different way than the way we used to do earlier."
Market & Price Environment
- Zinc LME depressed: Base metal prices were hit by rising interest rates, soaring inflation, a global manufacturing and construction slowdown, and a strengthening US dollar. Global zinc supply and demand both underperformed, dragging LME well below management's assessed stable range.
- The stable range thesis: Management believes zinc's balanced supply-demand equilibrium sits between $2,900 and $3,100 per ton, and expects a recovery toward that band by December or January, supported by US infrastructure spending, Chinese economic improvement, and India's pre-election infrastructure push.
- Cost-curve floor provides downside protection: The fourth quartile of the global cost curve sits around $2,000 per ton; 90% of mines would shut below that level. Boliden's Tara mine suspended operations when LME was around $2,250, reinforcing the floor.
- Premiums and by-products mixed: Zinc premiums improved 15% sequentially but remain down YoY, consistent with the global trend. Sulfuric acid prices fell sharply YoY on the lower sulfur index but improved sequentially. Silver prices are volatile, with management expecting a $25–$27 per troy ounce range as US inflation eases.
- Domestic demand resilient: Indian zinc demand is buoyed by the government's fiscal thrust on infrastructure and construction, while domestic lead demand is robust, supported by automotive, industrial batteries and infrastructure.
Misra: "I have always been saying that looking at global supply-demand scenario anywhere between 2,900 to 3,100 is stable. And I think the journey is towards that only."
Growth Projects & Capacity Pathway
- Three Q2 commissioning events: The alloy plant, Rajpura Dariba Mill and Fumer plant are all targeting commissioning and production in Q2 FY24. The alloy plant will significantly enhance the value-added product portfolio, while the Fumer will add a new product stream.
- Debari roaster and fertilizer plant underway: All orders for the Debari roaster have been placed and site work begins next week, with commissioning in roughly 14 months. The fertilizer plant has already started site work with orders in place, targeting commissioning in 18–22 months.
- Production pathway to 1.2 mtpa: Management sees a clear line of sight to achieving 0.12 crore tons of production capacity in approximately 18 months from FY24. Smelting capacity is targeted at 0.12 crore tons in FY25 and 0.14 crore tons in FY27.
- Mine expansions in design phase: Zawar mine is being expanded from 0.04 crore tons of ore to 0.07 crore tons, and RD mine from 0.1 crore tons to 0.2 crore tons, both with timelines of 2–2.5 years.
Misra: "So we can clearly see a pathway of achieving 0.12 crore tons in maybe another 18 months or so from FY '24 onwards."
Financial Position & Capital Allocation
- Cash generation capacity intact: Even at current depressed LME levels, management estimates the company can generate INR 8,000 crores of cash during FY24, underscoring the asset's low-cost position on the global curve.
- Hedging position unwound: The company is now completely unhedged, having closed out prior strategic hedges. Management only hedges when it believes prices have peaked, and declined to comment on any future silver hedging intentions, calling it a "very dynamic situation."
- General Reserves transfer progressing: The transfer from General Reserves to Retained Earnings has been approved by NCLT and shareholders. The second motion hearing is scheduled for July 31, and with no secured creditors, management anticipates no obstacles.
- Zinc International acquisition stalled: There has been no further movement on the acquisition; management's stance is that "whatever the rules allow, will happen."
- Debt and brand fee questions deflected: Management declined to provide guidance on comfortable debt-to-EBITDA levels or minimum cash thresholds, and did not directly address whether the 2% brand fee might rise given parent-level financing requirements.
ESG & Social Initiatives
- Science-based target for nature: Hindustan Zinc became a piloting member for science-based target for nature target setting, the only Indian company and the only metals and mining company in the cohort.
- Emission reduction targets: The company has set an ambitious target of 50% reduction in Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions and 25% reduction in Scope 3 emissions by 2030, with net zero by 2050.
- Community programs: The Kaushal Kendra skilling initiative launched three batches with 75 female trainees, achieving 100% placement for the first batch. Two players from the Zinc Football Academy were selected for the Rajasthan state team.
- Workplace recognition: The company received Great Place to Work certification for the fifth consecutive year and won HR Excellence Awards in talent management and employee relations.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of production | Near the lower band of $1,125–$1,175/ton guidance | FY24 full year |
| Alloy plant commissioning | Ready for production | Q2 FY24 |
| Rajpura Dariba Mill & Fumer plant | Commissioning and production start | Q2 FY24 |
| Debari roaster | Commissioning after site work begins next week | ~14 months |
| Fertilizer plant | Commissioning (site work already started) | 18–22 months |
| Production capacity | Achieve 1.2 mtpa pathway | ~18 months from FY24 |
| Smelting capacity | 1.2 mtpa, then 1.4 mtpa | FY25, then FY27 |
| Zawar mine expansion | 0.4 mt to 0.65 mt ore capacity | 2–2.5 years |
| RD mine expansion | 1 mt to 2 mt ore capacity | 2–2.5 years |
| Cash generation | INR 8,000 crores at current LME | FY24 |
| General Reserves to Retained Earnings | Second motion hearing July 31; no secured creditors | Near-term |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹7,282 cr, down 22% YoY and 14% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹3,359 cr, down 36% YoY and 20% QoQ |
| Consolidated net profit | ₹1,964 cr, down 37% YoY and 24% QoQ |
| Effective tax rate | ~25%, company moved to new tax regime this fiscal year |
| Cost of production before royalty | $1,194 per ton, 2% better QoQ and 6% better YoY in USD terms |
| Cost reduction over last 6 months | ~$100 per ton saved |
| Full-year cost guidance | $1,125–$1,175 per ton, maintained; trending toward lower band |
| Mined metal production | 257,000 tons, highest ever Q1, up 2% YoY |
| Silver production | 179 metric tons, highest ever Q1, up 1% YoY |
| Zinc premium | ~15% increase QoQ; down on a YoY basis |
| Linkage coal in blend | 28%, up from 10% in Q1 last year, coming 100% through rakes |
| Ore grades | 7.1%, improved from 6.9% last year |
| Mine development | ~24 km, approximately 50% capital and 50% revenue |
| Maintenance capex | $90 mn in Q1; full-year guidance $375 mn |
| Growth capex advance (roaster & fertilizer) | $50 mn paid in Q1 |
| Gross debt | ₹9,300 cr at June end |
| Cash | ₹9,700 cr at June end |
| Roaster capacity addition | 50–55 kt to production; commissioning expected in ~14 months |
| Fertilizer plant first-phase capacity | 0.05 crore ton (500,000 tons) DAP |
| Zawar mine expansion target | 0.65 crore tons ore, from current 0.4 crore tons |
| RD mine expansion target | 0.2 crore tons ore, from current ~0.1 crore tons |
| Silver price outlook | $25–$27 per troy ounce |
| Fourth quartile global zinc cost curve | ~$2,000; 90th percentile mines shut below $2,000 |