Key Takeaways
- Record shareholder returns, steady operations: Total return per share of ₹387, a 133% return on the previous fiscal year's closing price, while revenue grew 12% YoY on better metal volume and prices.
- Cost of production fell 7% YoY to $1,107/t: Softened coal and input commodity prices, better linkage coal availability, the start of RE power from Serentica, and better metal grades all contributed, keeping the company within its guided range.
- A fatal safety incident marred the quarter: A pedestrian was fatally injured by an underground vehicle at Rampura Agucha, triggering an in-depth investigation and a renewed emphasis on safety as the key priority.
- Growth projects are advancing on schedule: The 160 ktpa roaster at Debari was preponed to Q3 FY25, the 510 ktpa fertilizer plant is on track for Q2 FY26, and strategic partners are now working on the conceptual design for the 0.2 crore ton per annum metal ambition.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the zinc price recovery materialises in the January-to-March window as management now expects, any revision to cost guidance in Q3, and the pre-feasibility report for the 0.2 crore ton growth plan due by mid-September.
Operational Performance
- Revenue driver: Total revenue up 12% YoY, supported by a stronger dollar and partly offset by lower silver volume due to a normal-course WIP accumulation after moving to a late mode of pyro operation from June 2024.
- Silver WIP: Saleable silver production dropped 7% YoY, but the WIP will be liquidated in subsequent periods, keeping the company committed to its 3-5% silver volume growth guidance for the year.
- Domestic market share: Primary zinc market share in India expanded to 78% from 75% last year, driven by healthy zinc demand from robust public expenditure on infrastructure projects.
- Hedging gain: The company sold forward 90 kt of zinc production for the fiscal year, around 10% of annual production, to lock in elevated zinc prices, demonstrating what management called agile decision-making.
- Power mix shift: 45% of coal is now domestic, almost double last year's share, after two coal-based power plants were revamped to consume 100% domestic coal; RE power reached 8.5% of the overall requirement during the quarter, with a full-year target of 13%.
Misra: "Only the time for that optimism to come to fruition has shifted from December to maybe January to March. Nothing else has changed."
Cost & Margin
- COP achievement: Cost of production of $1,107 per ton was down 7% YoY, landing inside the guided range of $1,050-1,100, partly on account of softened coal prices and the preponed start of RE power from Serentica in May 2024.
- Margin expansion: Margin expanded from 46% to 49% on the back of the lower COP and stronger metal prices.
- Guidance stance: Management declined to revise cost guidance downward despite being near the top of the range, calling a revision "not prudent," and committed to the existing band while stating attempts will be made to beat it; any correction, if needed, would come in Quarter 3.
- Power cost delta undisclosed: When asked for the marginal cost difference between renewable and the highest-cost power, management said it was not part of standard disclosure and declined to quote a figure.
Modi: "I don't think it's a prudent like to say that we are being conservative. We have given the guidance as a lower quartile of a 1,050 and to 1,100. We achieved $1,107... So, we remain optimistic and confident to remain, it's better to remain 1,050 to 1,100 and at the same time if we deliver 1,050 or below that I think it will be good to close the year."
Growth Projects & Strategic Initiatives
- Debari roaster: The 160,000 ton per annum roaster commissioning was preponed from Q4 FY25 to the end of Q3 FY25.
- Fertilizer plant: The 510,000 tons per annum fertilizer plant remains on track with commissioning targeted by Q2 FY26.
- 0.2 crore ton ambition: Strategic partners for the conceptual design have been appointed and studies are under progress; a global mining consultant is already on the ground, and a plant consultant for the smelter and mills was arriving in Udaipur the week of the call.
- Pre-feasibility report: Expected by the end of August or middle of September; it will determine the reality and basic needs of the project before going to the board for sanction.
- Bamnia Kalan mine: Consent to operate was received in the last quarter, ground clearance has started, and infrastructure activities have begun; development of the decline will take around 1.5 years, with the first ore body hit expected about two years from now.
- EcoZen launch: Asia's first low-carbon green zinc was launched, with a carbon footprint of less than 1 ton of carbon equivalent per ton of zinc, almost 75% lower than the global average, designed for customers exporting galvanized steel to the European market.
- AEsir Technologies partnership: Signed as a preferred supplier of zinc for the US-based company's Nickel Zinc batteries.
Market Environment
- Zinc market: Global zinc prices closely traced the copper trend, with production cuts across Chinese smelters due to a tight concentrate market; LME zinc stocks dropped 12% during the quarter.
- Lead market: The quarter started with neutral sentiment and ended at a higher level with an 18% reduction in LME stocks, though domestic demand for primary lead dropped 10% in line with automobile sales.
- Silver market: Prices rallied along with gold, and the Indian industrial sector is shifting towards renewable energy and EVs, which is expected to expand domestic silver demand beyond jewellery and physical investments.
- India demand: India remains the fastest-growing major economy, continuing to drive healthy zinc demand through robust public expenditure on infrastructure projects.
- Lead demand outlook: India's share in global lead demand is expected to increase from 9.2% in 2023 to 9.9% in 2026, driven by increasing digital transactions and growing data centres.
Legal & Contingent Liabilities
- Supreme Court cases: Management declined to quantify any contingent liability related to the environment and health cess or the royalty judgment, stating the need to wait for the Supreme Court order and that the company has multiple grounds to protect itself.
- Worst-case scenario: When an analyst floated a worst-case figure of ₹150 per ton of ore produced, management called it an immaterial amount from a profitability and balance sheet point of view.
- Retrospective impact: Management pointed out that larger mining companies, including government entities, would be affected by any retrospective judgment with numbers "much much larger" than what Hindustan Zinc could even think of.
Misra: "So, you have to appreciate that we are not the only mining Company, there are larger mining companies including government entities which are also likely to be affected if the judgment was to be effective on a retrospective effect and the numbers would be much much larger compared to the numbers that we can even think of."
Safety & People
- Fatal incident: A pedestrian was fatally injured by a passing underground vehicle at the Rampura Agucha underground mine on May 29, 2024, in what management described as a man-machine interaction; an in-depth investigation was carried out.
- All-women rescue team: The company trained India's second all-women underground mine rescue team, following the success of the first batch.
- HR recognition: Won PeopleFirst HR Excellence Awards in categories of leading practices in employee management, talent acquisition, and technology deployment in HR. [3-4]
- General reserve to retained earnings: NCLT approval was received on July 16, the scheme was made effective, and all necessary approvals have been obtained, providing the board flexibility for shareholder rewards.
Misra: "At the outset, I deeply regret to inform you all that despite all the efforts and constant emphasis on safety as our key priority, we had an extremely unfortunate incident in our Rampura Agucha underground mine on 29th May 2024 where we witnessed a man-machine interaction as a pedestrian was fatally injured by a passing underground vehicle."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Metal production growth | 5% to 7% growth over last year | FY25 |
| Silver production growth | 3% to 5% growth over last year | FY25 |
| Cost of production | Remain in $1,050 to $1,100/t range; any revision in Q3 | FY25 |
| Debari roaster commissioning | 160 ktpa roaster preponed to Q3 | End of Q3 FY25 |
| Fertilizer plant commissioning | 510 ktpa plant on track | Q2 FY26 |
| Pre-feasibility report for 0.2 crore ton plan | Report to determine reality and basic needs before board sanction | End of August / mid-September 2024 |
| Bamnia Kalan first ore | Decline development takes ~1.5 years | ~2026 |
| RE power share | Reach 13% of overall power requirement | FY25 |
| Near-term EBITDA | $2.7 billion with 1.2 Mtpa metal, 800 tons silver, $1,000/t COP | Favourable LME and silver price environment |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹8,130 cr, up 12% YoY and 8% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹3,946 cr, up 17% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 49%, expanded from 46% last year |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹2,345 cr, up 19% YoY |
| Effective tax rate | 25% |
| Zinc cost of production | US$1,107 per ton, down 7% YoY, up 5% QoQ |
| Mined metal production | 263,000 tons, highest ever first quarter |
| Refined metal production | 262,000 tons, highest ever first quarter |
| Saleable silver production | down 7% YoY on WIP accumulation |
| Domestic primary zinc market share | 78%, up from 75% last year |
| Zinc hedged forward | 90 kt for the fiscal year, ~10% of annual production, at $2,906; open position at June end 85 kt at $2,910 |
| Renewable power share | 8.5% of overall power requirement during the quarter |
| Cash and debt | Cash ₹10,885 cr, debt ~₹11,200 cr |
| Dividend paid | ₹4,225 cr during the quarter |
| Mine development | 25 km during the quarter, 50% capital and 50% revenue split |