Key Takeaways
- Cost leadership strengthens despite revenue headwinds: Zinc COP fell to $1,137/tonne, the lowest in six quarters, even as revenue dropped 19% YoY on weaker zinc prices and volumes.
- Volume engine intact, maintenance masked it: Highest-ever first-half mined metal of 509,000 tonnes was delivered, but scheduled plant shutdowns pulled quarterly output lower sequentially.
- Mine flexibility is the structural advantage: Multiple mining locations within each asset, developed over 2–3 years, now allow grade and volume to be dialled up or down as conditions demand.
- Balance sheet stays fortress-grade: Cash above $1 billion, debt similar, both largely long-term; on a post-tax basis, management says there is no negative carry.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the NCLT order on the General Reserves conversion is pronounced at the November 8 hearing, any board update on the corporate restructuring evaluation, and whether H2 volumes lift enough to land cost at the lower end of the $1,125–$1,175 guidance band.
Cost Performance
- Third straight quarter of improvement: Zinc COP before royalty fell 5% QoQ and 10% YoY in USD terms, the lowest in six quarters, driven by softened coal and input commodity prices, better domestic coal availability, and higher grades.
- Coal sourcing transformed: Linkage coal consumption rose from a historical ceiling of ~30% to a 45% blend in Q2, enabled by power plant modifications at Chanderiya and Dariba that now allow nearly 100% linkage coal usage in some units. Softer imported coal prices and opportunistic parcel buying added further relief.
- Grade uplift was deliberate, not accidental: Grade improved from 7.1% to 7.4% QoQ despite lower Rampura Agucha production. Zawar mine, which normally suffers high dilution at 4–4.5% grade, managed grade well this quarter. Agucha held at 13.3%, and SK mine improved from 4.8 to 5.2. The strategy: preserve grade, minimize dilution, and reduce the development ore needed to produce the same metal in concentrate.
- Full-year cost on track for the lower end: H1 cost of $1,169 sits within the $1,125–$1,175 guidance range. With Q3 and Q4 volumes expected to rise and thermal coal landed costs holding at Q2 levels, management is confident of landing toward the lower end.
Sandeep Modi: "We delivered the third consecutive quarter of cost optimization and the lowest cost in the last 6 quarters, reflecting our resilience and adaptability in navigating the ever-changing business landscape."
Operational Flexibility & Mine Planning
- Each mine is now a portfolio of mines: Agucha operates four mining locations within a single asset; Zawar has four separate mines, each with two to three production centres. This multi-location structure, built over the last two to three years, lets management sequence ore extraction to favour grade or volume as economics dictate.
- Grade improvement was a sequencing choice: The quarter’s grade uplift came from slightly reducing ore production in favour of better-grade sections, slowing progress in one area while accelerating another. The flexibility to make that trade-off without disrupting the overall production run-rate is the payoff from the multi-location development strategy.
- Mines are ahead of smelters by design: The company expanded mines first and has produced over 0.1 crore tonnes of concentrate for two consecutive years. Smelters still hold roughly 12–13 days of metal-in-concentrate inventory. A new roaster at Debari is on track, and further debottlenecking projects are being planned to lift smelting capacity toward 0.12 crore tonnes. No bottleneck exists in the mines today.
Arun Misra: "Today, Agucha mine has 4 mining locations in the same mine; it's not 1 mine, there are 4 mines inside. Zawar has got 4 different mines. Each of them has got 2 to 3 production centers. Those flexibilities we are enjoying because we could develop so many mining locations in the same mine over the last 2 to 3 years."
Revenue & Market Context
- Revenue hit by price, not structural demand collapse: Revenue fell 19% YoY and 7% QoQ, driven primarily by significantly lower zinc LME, lower zinc and silver volumes, and differential strategic hedging impact. Better lead and silver prices and favourable exchange rates provided a partial offset.
- Zinc demand muted globally, but India holds up: Global manufacturing PMI inched up from 48.7 to 49.1, still below expansion. Sluggish economies in the US, China, and Europe kept zinc demand subdued. India’s manufacturing PMI, while down to 57.5 from 58.6, remained firmly expansionary, with infrastructure and automobile sectors as bright spots.
- Lead and silver prices found support: Lead rose to $2,170/tonne, supported by EV sales (including hybrids) from state subsidies and energy transition credits, plus supply-side constraints from mine closures. Silver oscillated around $23/oz, influenced by dollar strength, gold prices, interest-rate expectations, industrial demand, and Middle East geopolitical tensions.
- Global zinc supply stress is limited so far: Only Boliden’s Tara mine has shut down; no other major production cuts were noted. European smelters are benefiting from lower power costs. India retains a structural advantage on both power and labour, keeping Hindustan Zinc in the first decile of the global cost curve.
Growth Projects & Diversification
- Smelter debottlenecking underway: A new roaster at Debari is on track, and the company is working on additional bottlenecking projects to take refined metal capacity to approximately 0.12 crore tonnes. A more comprehensive plan will be presented in subsequent quarters.
- Fumer plant commissioned: India’s first fumer plant is now operating, using an innovative method with online support from Chinese experts. Production numbers will be reported separately within 15–20 days. Talks with technology suppliers for additional fumers are expected to conclude in a month or two.
- Fertilizer foray taking shape: A DAP/NPK plant is under construction with L&T as the construction partner and JESA (US) as the technology partner. The company is in discussions with RSMM to expand rock phosphate mining and is also building a beneficiation plant to upgrade RSMM rock phosphate. Roughly 40–50% of rock phosphate is expected to be imported in the plant’s design. Commissioning is 18 months to 2 years away.
- Renewable energy on track: A 450 MW renewable energy power delivery agreement with Serentica is progressing well. Once complete, over 50% of the company’s energy requirement will be met through green power.
- Alloy and concentrator capacity added: A 30,000 tonnes per annum alloy facility and a new concentrator at Rajpura Dariba mine were commissioned during the quarter, increasing zinc and lead metal-in-concentrate production.
Arun Misra: "In our design, we have considered a certain percentage. If I remember the number correctly, around 40% to 50% of rock phosphate would be imported."
Corporate Actions & ESG
- Corporate restructuring evaluation in progress: External advisors have been appointed to evaluate various options. The Committee of Directors will make a recommendation to the board once the evaluation is complete; no timeline was given.
- NCLT hearing on November 8: The next hearing date for the conversion of General Reserves into Retained Earnings is set. The second motion has been filed and the Registrar of Companies has filed its reply. The order may be reserved for pronouncement after that hearing.
- Safety milestone achieved: The company recorded one full year of fatality-free operations.
- Science-based targets validated: Hindustan Zinc became the first metal and mining company in India to have validated science-based targets aligned with the 1.5°C Paris Agreement target. Commitments include a 50% reduction in absolute Scope 1 and 2 GHG emissions and a 25% reduction in Scope 3 emissions by FY2030 from an FY2020 base, with net zero across the value chain by FY2050.
- Water and community initiatives: A 4,000 KLD zero liquid discharge plant was inaugurated at Zawar mines, and the company is moving toward a 5x water-positive target by 2025. Through its Kaushal Kendra CSR programme, 286 trainees were placed during the quarter.
Arun Misra: "Hindustan Zinc became the first metal and mining Company in India to have validated science-based targets in line with the 1.5-degree centigrade target of the Paris Agreement."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Production guidance | Deliver over 2,275,000 tonnes of metal; guidance unchanged | FY24 |
| Cost guidance | Confident of landing toward the lower end of $1,125–$1,175/tonne range, supported by H2 volume uplift and stable coal costs | FY24 |
| Smelter debottlenecking | Return with a comprehensive plan to take refined metal capacity to ~0.12 crore tonnes | Subsequent quarters (no date) |
| NCLT order on General Reserves conversion | Hearing on November 8; order may be reserved for pronouncement after that | November 8, 2023 |
| Corporate restructuring evaluation | Board to be updated upon completion of evaluation and Committee of Directors’ recommendation | No date (work in progress) |
| DAP/NPK plant commissioning | Plant under construction; commissioning expected in 18 months to 2 years | ~FY26–FY27 |
| Renewable energy PPA (Serentica) | 450 MW agreement progressing well and on track; over 50% of energy from green power upon completion | No date (on track) |
| New fumer plants | Working with technology suppliers; update expected in a month or two | ~1–2 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹6,791 cr, down 19% YoY and 7% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹3,122 cr, down 29% YoY and 7% QoQ |
| Consolidated net profit | ₹1,729 cr, down 35% YoY and 12% QoQ |
| Effective tax rate | ~25%, in accordance with the new regime |
| Zinc cost of production before royalty | $1,137 per tonne, 10% better YoY and 5% better QoQ in USD terms |
| H1 FY24 zinc cost of production | $1,167 per tonne, 7% better YoY; full-year guidance $1,125–$1,175, expected towards lower end |
| H1 FY24 mined metal | 509,000 tonnes, highest ever first half |
| Full-year refined metal target | Over 2,275,000 tonnes, guidance unchanged |
| Refined metal debottlenecking target | 0.12 crore tonnes, plan to be detailed in subsequent quarters |
| Overall grade | 7.4%, improved from 7.1% QoQ |
| Rampura Agucha grade | 13.3%, vs 12.5% in Q1 FY24 and 13.3% in Q2 FY23 |
| SK mine grade | 5.2%, improved from 4.8% QoQ and 4.58% YoY |
| Linkage coal in blend | 45%, enabled by power plant modifications allowing up to 100% linkage coal in some units |
| Lead average price | $2,170 per tonne |
| Silver average price | $23.6 per troy ounce |
| Retained earnings | ₹2,400 cr, as of September 30 |