Key Takeaways
- Cost leadership cemented: Q3 delivered the lowest cost of production in 10 quarters at $1,095/t, placing HZL in the first decile of the global cost curve, with a clear path toward a $1,000/t design target.
- Silver is now the profit engine: Silver segment profit share surged to over 45% of total profit in FY24, up from 27% last year, driven by a deliberate strategy to maximize silver output into a deficit market.
- Margins expanded on mix, not just cost: EBITDA margin rose from 46% to 49% sequentially, supported by prioritizing higher-margin silver production alongside operational efficiencies and softer coal prices.
- Volume and cost guidance on track: Management expressed confidence in hitting FY24 volume targets and expects to land at the lower edge of the $1,125–$1,175/t CoP guidance range, with Q4 historically the strongest quarter.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the NCLT order on the business restructuring arrives in February, the ramp-up of the newly commissioned alloy plant, and any movement in zinc prices toward the elusive $3,000 level.
Cost Structure & Operational Efficiency
- Sustained cost reduction: Q3 marked the fourth consecutive quarter of cost decline, driven by better volumes, softened coal prices, operational efficiency, and improved grades (7.36% vs 6.96% YoY), partly offset by lower acid realizations.
- Power cost transformation: Power's share of total cost dropped from 42% last year to 35%, achieved by modifying power plants to digest more domestic coal at the higher end and running at over 100% plant load factor. Domestic coal availability remains healthy though not at Q2 levels.
- Domestic coal upside: Management flagged that if domestic coal reaches 45% of the total coal mix, costs will decline further, a lever still in progress.
- Digitalization investment: Operational efficiencies are being supplemented with investments in digitalization and automation solutions, expected to drive better value accruals in upcoming quarters.
Sandeep Modi: "Though it is challenging to achieve intermittent cost reduction, however, the crucial and the more complex aspect is sustaining it over an extended period, which is one of our main strategies to navigate through a so-called LME environment resiliently."
Silver: The Strategic Pivot
- Record production into a deficit market: HZL achieved its highest-ever third-quarter silver production at 197 tons, contributing to the highest 9-month mined metal and silver output on record. The global silver market has been in deficit for a third consecutive year.
- Profit share leap: Silver now accounts for over 45% of HZL's profit in FY24, up from 27% last year, validating the strategy of proactively maximizing silver output when prices are elevated.
- Production trajectory conditional on metal scale: Management declined to give a specific peak silver target but laid out the math: at the current 0.11 crore tons metal production rate, silver reaches 800 tons requires moving to 0.12 crore tons, and 0.15 crore tons would get closer to 1,000 tons.
- Next-year outlook guarded: When asked if silver production could exceed 800 tons next year, management declined to hazard a guess, saying the answer depends on where this year closes.
Arun Misra: "During the quarter, our emphasis on proactively maximizing silver production in response to heightened prices led to attainment of our highest level third quarter silver production at 197 tons."
Market Conditions & Pricing
- Zinc: surplus despite supply disruptions: Zinc prices improved marginally on supply incidents (Nyrstar's Mid Tennessee mine suspension, Kostenko mine fire), but global production stress was insufficient to overcome faint demand, particularly in Europe, leaving a surplus of refined zinc in LME warehouses.
- Lead: volatile and surplus-driven: Prices remained volatile, consistent with a surplus driven by the secondary market, despite a modest recovery in mines and primary smelter output. Automotive demand and recent supply suspensions are expected to provide reasonable price support.
- Zinc price prediction abandoned: Management's earlier expectation of zinc moving closer to $3,000 did not materialize even in December. The current stance is contentment with prices at current levels, plus or minus $50, for another quarter.
- Domestic demand focus: HZL is increasingly prioritizing domestic sales over exports, citing the relative strength of the Indian economy. Zinc usage is expected to rise in India, Mexico, China, and Vietnam on infrastructure spending, while European and US demand is likely to remain flat.
Arun Misra: "Post-COVID world is such that it's very difficult to predict because earlier there was a firm equation between countries and one could predict what price will go up, what will come down. Today, you see even Chinese stimulus announcement, expenditure is not able to push the prices up, right?"
Growth Projects & Capex
- Alloy plant commissioned and ramping: The new alloy plant has been commissioned and is ramping up, with management expecting to report a healthy volume of special products from the plant by next quarter. An additional 25–30% of value-added product volume is targeted from this facility.
- Fumer and fertilizer projects on track: The fumer plant and alloy plants are currently under operations, while the new roaster and fertilizer projects are progressing on schedule. The Debari roaster is expected to come online by early Q4 of the next financial year (January–March 2025).
- Fumer contribution next year: Full-year fumer contribution will be factored into planning numbers for the next financial year.
Business Restructuring & Balance Sheet
- NCLT process advancing: The second-motion hearing at NCLT Jaipur on January 24 went well, lasting nearly 1.5 hours. An order is expected possibly in February, with the next hearing date set for 15 February 2024, described as procedural in nature.
- Board-level restructuring discussions ongoing: The Board has discussed the business plan restructuring, but government nominee directors are yet to communicate their agreement to the proposal. The internal timeline aims to close the restructuring before the next Board meeting, toward the end of March or April.
- Debt reduction commitment: Management expressed confidence that a minimum of ₹2,000 crores in debt reduction will occur in Q4.
Arun Misra: "Board has discussed. Now it is between the government nominee directors and the other Board members. So I think government nominee directors are yet to communicate their agreement to the proposal."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of production | Land at the lower edge of $1,125–$1,175/t guidance range | FY24 full year |
| Cost design target | Ongoing optimization toward $1,000/t designed cost | No date (aspirational) |
| Volume delivery | Confident of achieving projected volumes; Q4 historically best quarter | FY24 full year |
| Silver production | Expected to be a shred better than committed | FY24 full year |
| Debt reduction | Minimum ₹2,000 crores reduction | Q4 FY24 |
| Debari roaster | Commissioning | Early Q4 next financial year (Jan–Mar 2025) |
| Business plan restructuring | Internal timeline to close | Before next Board meeting (end-Mar/Apr 2024) |
| NCLT order | Order expected | Possibly February 2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹7,310 cr, up 8% sequentially, down 7% YoY |
| 9M FY24 revenue from operations | ₹21,383 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹3,559 cr, up 14% sequentially, down 4% YoY |
| 9M FY24 EBITDA | ₹10,040 cr, down 25% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 49%, up from 46% in the previous quarter |
| Consolidated net profit | ₹2,028 cr, up 17% sequentially, down 6% YoY |
| 9M FY24 net profit | ₹5,721 cr, down 28% YoY |
| Effective tax rate | 24% |
| Zinc cost of production before royalty | $1,095 per ton, 4% better sequentially, 15% better YoY in USD terms |
| 9M FY24 cost of production | $1,142 per ton, 10% better YoY |
| FY24 cost of production guidance | $1,125 to $1,175 per ton, management expects to be at the lower edge |
| Silver production | 197 tons, highest ever third quarter, up 9% sequentially and 22% YoY |
| Mined metal 5-year production CAGR | 4.3% |
| Refined metal 5-year production CAGR | 4.1% |
| Silver 5-year production CAGR | 3.9% |
| Silver segment share of profit in FY24 | over 45%, compared to 27% last year |
| Value-added product proportion | 18% to 20% of total product |
| Average grade realized | 7.36, YoY higher from 6.96 in Q3 last year |
| Power cost contribution to overall cost | 35%, down from 42% last year |
| Net debt | around ₹360 cr |
| Free cash flow generated during the year | ₹6,900 cr, post growth capex and RE power investment of ₹1,000 cr |
| Interim dividend paid during the quarter | ₹2,535 cr, cumulative payout of ₹5,493 cr for the fiscal year |
| Revenue mine development | around 13 km |
| Capital mine development | around 13 km |
| Global silver producer ranking | 5th largest in 2023, up from 23rd in 2014 |
| S&P Global CSA score | 85 out of 100, ranked 1st out of 238 companies in metals and mining sector |