Key Takeaways
- Record production, record EBITDA: Mined metal crossed 1,017,000 tonnes and full-year EBITDA rose 39% YoY, driven by higher volumes and LME prices, though coal costs bit hard.
- Coal is the margin villain: Zinc COP jumped 24% YoY in INR terms as domestic linkage coal dried up to ~3% of the basket, forcing expensive imports; management sees no easing for another quarter.
- Zinc prioritized over lead and silver: The Pyro plant was switched to zinc-plus-lead mode to chase a $4,000+ LME, deliberately sacrificing lead and silver volume; debottlenecking should restore lead output by Q2.
- Hedging signals conviction: The company sold forward ~15% of FY23 projected zinc volume at prices above $4,000, locking in a floor on a material chunk of next year's revenue.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the fumer plant commissions on schedule, whether domestic coal linkage improves at all, and whether the lead circuit debottlenecking actually restores lead and silver volumes by Q2.
Production & the Lead-Silver Trade-Off
- Mined metal engine running hot: Q4 mined metal rose 3% YoY and 17% QoQ, with higher ore production across Rajpura Dariba, Sindesar Khurd, Rampura Agucha and Zawar, supported by better mining grades.
- Integrated metal up, but mix shifted: Integrated production rose 2% YoY on better plant availability and operating parameters, but integrated lead fell 19% YoY because the Pyro facility ran on zinc-plus-lead mode rather than lead-only mode.
- The deliberate choice: Management chose to prioritize zinc when LME crossed $4,000 and mined metal production crossed 0.1 crore tonnes, consuming less lead concentrate and building WIP; silver production consequently dropped 20% YoY.
- Fix is underway: Lead circuit debottlenecking work is ongoing; Q1 FY23 may still run on zinc-plus-lead mode, but the lead processing facility should be pushed up by Q2.
- Fumer plant near commissioning: Seven or eight experts have arrived with visas, most repair work is done, and commissioning is expected by end of the current quarter, with output stepping up in a phased manner thereafter.
Misra: "This year is the testing ground for smelters to be tested to produce 0.1 crore tonnes metal, in a way that maximizes revenue from the quality of metal that it produces, along with the different value-added products, along with our ratio of domestic is to exports."
Cost Structure & the Coal Problem
- Coal linkage collapsed: The company received only about 3% of linkage coal in its overall coal basket, forcing heavy reliance on imported coal at elevated prices; the situation did not improve through the quarter.
- COP inflation is real: Zinc COP rose 24% YoY in INR terms and 21% in USD terms, with full-year COP up 18% YoY; higher coal prices and higher use of imported coal were the primary drivers, partially offset by operational efficiencies, higher volume and better recoveries.
- Sequential relief, barely: Q4 COP declined 1% QoQ, attributable to higher volume, operational efficiencies and recovery improvements, but the structural coal problem remains unresolved.
- Supply-side pressure to persist: European smelter capacities are still not at full capacity due to high gas prices; management predicts input-side pressure will not ease for at least another quarter.
- ESG adds cost, not savings: Renewable power is expected to be cost accretive given the company's geographical location, which is not surrounded by domestic coal suppliers; domestic coal supply has not met the required 30% mix, with the company getting only 2-3% or sometimes nothing.
Modi: "You would appreciate this guidance comes in an extremely uncertain environment with rising imported coal prices, lower domestic coal availability quality and geopolitical tensions, which is impacting supply chain globally."
Hedging & Capital Allocation
- Forward sales lock in $4,000+ zinc: The company sold zinc forward for nearly 15% of FY23 projected zinc volume at prices above $4,000, providing a meaningful revenue floor for the coming year.
- Flexible, not formulaic: Management will continue a wait-and-watch approach based on price movements and the geopolitical situation, declining to specify any hedging threshold or cap.
- Capital reserves moved: Approximately Rs. 10,000 crore was transferred from general reserves to retained earnings; NOC received from the National Stock Exchange, SEBI clearance awaited. Management called it "an enabling provision" and declined to elaborate on whether it signals dividend flexibility.
- Debt repayment on track: Rs. 700 crore of NCDs mature in September 2022, with the remaining Rs. 2,100 crore due in September 2023; no plan to take any new loan.
- Dividend question deflected: When asked about inorganic expansion plans, management pivoted to dividends, saying only that it is a matter for the Board to consider and approve, with no specific timeline.
Growth Projects & Expansion Pathway
- 0.1 crore tonne metal sales first: The immediate target is achieving 0.1 crore tonnes of metal sales; smelting already has 0.1 crore tonne-plus capacity, and guidance is based on a "100% confidence factor." Balance facilities needed to produce saleable product with maximum return are under design.
- Mine expansion seeded via sustenance CAPEX: Work on expanding Zawar mine from 0.4 to 0.8 crore tonnes and Rajpura Dariba mine from 0.1 crore to 0.4 crore tonnes has been launched through sustenance CAPEX, including new portals, underground tunnel widening, and hydro-geological studies for deep floor entry at Rajpura Dariba.
- 1.2 mtpa as an intermediate step: Management expects to cross 1.2 mtpa intermediately while launching the program for 1.35 mtpa and then 1.5 mtpa; no specific timeline was given.
- Board-approved debottlenecking and alloys: CAPEX was approved for debottlenecking current smelters to push up capacity, and for forming a subsidiary to add 30 kT of value-added products.
- Custom smelter on hold: The public hearing for the custom smelter has not yet been held; management will return with a project proposal only after that milestone.
- New mine exploration waiting on policy: The company is waiting for the sector to be thrown open like the bulk mineral category, expecting more blocks for prospecting and mining lease; it is in touch with the Rajasthan state government and says it will be the first participant when blocks are opened.
- Zinc International merger studied, not imminent: The company has done homework on understanding properties, resources, how to upgrade them, and a project plan; management noted the current status of Zinc International is similar to Hindustan Zinc at the time of its first disinvestment, but inorganic expansion is not imminent.
Disinvestment & Governance
- Disinvestment cleared, modalities underway: The disinvestment has been approved by the Supreme Court; procedural issues are being cleared, and the government is working out whether to execute it in one go or in tranches.
- Government presence not blamed for growth constraints: Management pushed back on the idea that government board presence restricts expansion, noting the company grew from 100,000 tonnes to 0.1 crore tonnes with the government still on the board.
- Disinvestment seen as an accelerator: A successful disinvestment would throw up more opportunities; a company with cash reserves could grow both organically and inorganically with speedier decision-making, though certain articles of the shareholder agreement and limitations would need to be addressed.
Misra: "No, there's no timeline. I think the sooner the better. And you know, as a citizen, I can say all of us expect that government has no business being in business. So, the sooner they do it, the better it is."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Mined metal production | 1,050 to 1,075 thousand tonnes | FY23 |
| Refined metal production | 0.1 crore tonnes to 1,250,000 tonnes | FY23 |
| Saleable silver production | 700 to 725 tonnes | FY23 |
| Zinc COP | $1,125 to $1,175 per tonne (includes higher mine development expenditure) | FY23 |
| Project CAPEX | $125 to $175 million | FY23 |
| Fumer plant commissioning | Completed, then phased ramp-up | End of Q1 FY23 |
| Rajpura Dariba mill revamping | Commissioning | Q3 FY23 |
| Lead circuit debottlenecking | Lead processing facility pushed up | By Q2 FY23 |
| Renewable energy share | 50% of power mix | Within three years |
| Net Zero | Company-wide | By 2050 |
| Debt repayment | Rs. 700 crore NCD | September 2022 |
| Debt repayment | Rs. 2,100 crore NCD | September 2023 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹8,797 crore, up 27% YoY and 10% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹5,007 crore, up 29% YoY and 14% QoQ |
| Consolidated net profit | ₹2,928 crore, up 18% YoY and 8% QoQ |
| Zinc COP before royalty | $1,136 per tonne, down 1% QoQ, up 24% YoY in INR terms |
| Mined metal production | 295,000 tonnes, up 3% YoY and 17% QoQ |
| Integrated zinc production | 211,000 tonnes, up 8% YoY, down 1% QoQ |
| Integrated lead production | 49,000 tonnes, down 19% YoY, up 5% QoQ |
| Integrated silver production | 162 tonnes, down 20% YoY and 6% QoQ |
| Full year revenue | ₹29,440 crore, up 30% YoY |
| Full year EBITDA | ₹16,289 crore, up 39% YoY |
| Full year consolidated net profit | ₹9,629 crore, up 21% YoY |
| Full year refined metal production | 957,000 tonnes, up 4% YoY |
| Full year silver production | 647 tonnes, down 8% YoY |
| Primary zinc domestic market share | 83%, highest ever, for FY22 |
| Zinc forward sales hedged for FY23 | 15% of projected volume, at prices above $4,000 per tonne |
| FY23 mined metal production guidance | 1,050 to 1,075 thousand tonnes |
| FY23 refined metal production guidance | 1,000,000 to 1,250,000 tonnes |
| FY23 saleable silver production guidance | 700 to 725 tonnes |
| FY23 zinc COP guidance | $1,125 to $1,175 per tonne |
| FY23 project CAPEX guidance | $120 to $150 million |
| Coal cost as percentage of total cost | ~35%, up from 25-28% historically |
| Linkage coal received in overall coal basket | ~3% during Q4 |
| Capital mine development | 13 kilometers during Q4 |
| Effective tax rate | ~31.7% for FY22, expected to remain at similar level for FY23 |
| Outstanding NCDs | ₹2,800 crore, ₹700 crore maturing Sep '22, ₹2,100 crore maturing Sep '23 |