Key Takeaways
- Record production, lower revenue: FY24 revenue fell 15% YoY on weaker LME zinc, even as mined metal, refined metal and silver all hit all-time highs.
- Costs dropped sharply: Zinc cost of production improved 11% to $1,117/t for FY24, with Q4 hitting $1,051/t on better grade and cheaper coal.
- Demerger stalled by government: The Centre said timing is not appropriate due to its ongoing 29% stake sale, though management still sees a standalone silver entity unlocking $3–4 bn in market cap.
- Bold zinc price call: Management expects LME zinc to breach $3,000/t by August–September and reach $3,200/t by December, citing tight concentrates and supply disruptions.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the demerger logjam breaks, the pace of the 0.1→0.2 crore ton capacity expansion study, and if zinc prices actually track management's bullish curve.
Production & Cost Performance
- Record volumes across the board: Highest ever mined metal, refined metal and silver production, driven by efficient asset utilisation and well-planned mining; silver output now ranks HZL as the third largest silver producer globally.
- Cost tailwinds converged in Q4: Zinc COP fell to $1,051/t, helped by the best grade in recent quarters (7.62%) and highest-ever linkage coal consumption at 46% in Q4 vs 37% for the full year, partly offset by lower acid realisation.
- FY25 cost guidance embeds giveback: The $1,050–$1,100/t range assumes linkage coal moderating to 40%, deeper mining and higher mine development costs, plus a $15/t extra cost from running pyro in zinc-lead mode rather than lead mode.
- Silver growth lags metal growth by design: FY25 silver guidance of ~2% vs refined metal ~5% because operating in zinc+lead mode reduces lead production and the silver attached to it; the Fumer plant (3 of 30 tons potential) partly bridges the gap.
- Long-term cost ambition intact: Management continues to work toward a $1,000/t cost of production, though this is a vision, not FY25 guidance.
Misra: "I am elated to share that Hindustan Zinc after recording its highest ever silver production in FY'24, has become the third largest silver producer globally, making India proud."
Demerger, Disinvestment & Exploration Subsidiary
- Demerger on hold: The government wrote to the company saying timing is not appropriate due to the ongoing disinvestment process of its 29% stake via OFS; management believes both can happen simultaneously and that a separate silver entity could unlock $3–4 billion in market cap, but board consensus is needed before any decision.
- Exploration subsidiary incorporated: Hindmetal Exploration Services Private Limited will explore self-earmarked blocks under a new government scheme where part of the expenditure is returned; data generated can be used to bid when blocks become auctionable.
- Scope extends beyond base metals: The subsidiary will cover rare earth, atomic minerals and all critical minerals enlisted by the government, positioning HZL to grow beyond lead, zinc and silver.
- Reserve replenishment underway: Reserve increased despite depletion of 0.03 crore tons; focus is on converting resource to reserve to sustain 0.1 crore ton+ mining at ~7% grade; Zawar exploration is prioritised to move ore production from 0.4–0.45 crore tons toward 0.8 crore tons.
Misra: "Government is coming up in a new scheme that would allow exploration companies to explore areas or block that they can earmark themselves... we feel that we have a larger chance, one, to succeed with exploration and second, use that data to bid fruitfully in auctions and gather further leases."
Growth Projects & Capacity Expansion
- Debottlenecking first, then a step-change: Near-term debottlenecking takes capacity from 1.123 to 0.12 crore tons in 12–16 months; the longer-term vision is to reach 0.2 crore tons metal-in-concentrate production as quickly as possible.
- Global consultants engaged for the 2x plan: Two mining consultants already ordered, with a smelter and infrastructure consultant being onboarded; the target timeline is 2.5–3 years to go from 0.1 to 0.2 crore tons, though the final number could be 0.17 or 0.2 crore tons after designs are complete.
- Fertiliser plant on track: The 5.1 lakh MT DAP and NPK plant (project cost ~₹1,800 crores) carries a double-digit IRR and EBITDA of ₹350–400 crores at current prices; commissioning is expected in FY26.
- Bamnia Kalan mine cleared: All regulatory approvals received (mining plan, consent to operate, consent to establish); site activities to start soon, with portal and initial mining potentially entering main operations in the next year.
- Waste-to-resource pilot live: Tie-ups signed with an undisclosed American company; the pilot targets recovery of 0.1 crore tons of metal and 3 kt of silver from accumulated waste stockpiles.
Misra: "we are in the process of engaging global consultants... we are keeping ourselves a timeline anywhere between 2.5-3 years' time to take this company from 0.1 crore tons to 0.2 crore tons."
Market Outlook & Operating Strategy
- Zinc price call is aggressively bullish: Management expects LME zinc to breach $3,000/t by August or September and reach $3,200/t by December, citing the last 20–30 days of price movement; global steel demand is forecast to grow in FY25 with India contributing most at 8.2%.
- Concentrate market is tight: Teck Resources and Korea Zinc settled TC-RCs at $165 while spot is at $75, signalling concentrate supply is constrained by higher costs closing smaller mines.
- Operating mode shifts to zinc+lead: After running lead-only mode last year to capture silver, the strategy for FY25 is zinc+lead mode given the improving zinc price environment; management can dynamically change based on price movements.
- Silver demand story building: Indian industrial silver consumption is expected to increase significantly with developing use-cases like EVs and 5G; silver prices surged in April 2024, touching all-time highs in INR terms.
- Domestic market share dominant: Seventh consecutive quarter of 80% primary zinc market share, backed by highest-ever quarterly domestic sales; value-added portfolio sales also hit a record at about 20% of the mix.
Misra: "if I follow last 20-30 days of movement of price, it looks like we will breach that mark of $3,000 per ton much earlier than December. Maybe somewhere closer to August or September... By December, I'm very hopeful that we will be closer to the mark of $3,200 or so."
Mine Lease Renewals & Risk Management
- Key leases expire in 2030: Rampura Agucha and Zawar mines, which together account for 65% of mined output and 50% of profitability, have leases expiring in 2030; SK mine runs to 2048, Bamnia Kalan to 2035, Kayad to 2048.
- Brownfield auction precedent missing: Management noted that deep-seated mineral auctions on brownfield sites have not happened yet, making the renewal outcome uncertain; internal scenario calculations suggest profitability can be maintained close to current levels even with an extra premium.
- GR to RE court case nearing end: The next hearing is scheduled for 17 May 2024 and is expected to be the last.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Mined metal production | 1,100–1,125 kt (up 4–6.5% YoY) | FY25 |
| Refined metal production | 1,075–1,100 kt (up 4–5% YoY) | FY25 |
| Saleable silver production | 750–775 tons (up 0.5–4% YoY) | FY25 |
| Zinc cost of production | $1,050–$1,100/t (mid-range ~$1,075) | FY25 |
| Growth capex | $270–$335 million (roaster, fertiliser, RE power, debottlenecking) | FY25 |
| Debottlenecking capacity | 1.123 to 0.12 crore tons | 12–16 months |
| 2x capacity expansion study | Engage global consultants; target 0.17–0.2 crore tons | 2.5–3 years |
| Fertiliser plant commissioning | 5.1 lakh MT DAP/NPK capacity; EBITDA ₹350–400 crores | FY26 |
| Bamnia Kalan mine | Portal and initial mining to enter main operations | Next year |
| LME zinc price | Breach $3,000/t; reach $3,200/t | Aug–Sep 2024; Dec 2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹7,549 cr, up 3% QoQ, down 11% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹3,637 cr, up 2% QoQ, down 14% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 47%, industry-leading, maintained despite 25% YoY fall in zinc prices |
| Consolidated net profit | ₹2,038 cr, flat sequentially, down YoY in line with EBITDA |
| Zinc cost of production | $1,051 per MT, 12-quarter lowest, down 4% QoQ and 13% YoY |
| Mined metal production | 1,079 kt (FY24), highest ever |
| Refined metal production | 1,033 kt (FY24), highest ever |
| Saleable silver production | 746 tons (FY24), highest ever, company became 3rd largest silver producer globally |
| FY25 mined metal production guidance | 1,100–1,125 kt |
| FY25 refined metal production guidance | 1,075–1,100 kt |
| FY25 saleable silver production guidance | 750–775 tons |
| FY25 zinc cost of production guidance | $1,050–$1,100 per ton |
| FY25 growth capex guidance | $270–$335 million, mostly for roaster, fertilizer, RE power, debottlenecking |
| Domestic primary zinc market share | 80%, seventh quarter highest, backed by highest ever quarterly domestic sales |
| Average zinc price (LME) | $2,450 per ton, zinc prices plunged 25% YoY |
| Average lead price (LME) | $2,077 per ton, down 2% QoQ and 3% YoY |
| Average silver price | ~$23.3 per troy ounce, up 10% YoY for full year |
| Total zinc stocks (LME) | 386,000 tons at end-March 2024, vs 243,000 tons at end-December 2023 |
| Domestic zinc consumption growth | 20% YoY |
| Ore grade | 7.62%, highest grade in last couple of quarters |
| Linkage coal consumption | 46% in Q4, highest ever; full year 37% |
| Total R&R | 45.63 crore tons with total metal content of 3.08 crore tons, mine life 25-plus years |
| Cash flow (FY24) | ₹9,000 cr, after post-growth capex and RE investment of ~₹1,200 cr |
| Total dividend payout (FY24) | ₹5,493 cr |
| Contribution to exchequer (FY24) | ₹13,197 cr in royalty, direct and indirect taxes |
| Effective tax rate | ~25% |
| Net debt / cash position | GR ₹10,384 cr; including GR and RE, ₹15,000 cr as on March 31 |
| MSME vendor payment cycle | 29 days, 37% better than statutory requirement |
| Capital and revenue mine development | 26 km, 50-50% capital and revenue |
| Bamnia Kalan mine resource | ~0.1 crore tons metal, 700 tons silver; annual potential revenue ₹1,000 cr+ at current LME |
| Fertilizer plant capacity | 5.1 lakh MT DAP and NPK, project cost ~₹1,800 cr, commissioning FY26 |
| Waste-to-value recovery potential | 0.1 crore tons of metal and 3 kt of silver from accumulated waste stockpile |
| Fumer plant silver contribution | 3 tons out of 30 tons potential; without Fumer, silver would have been 730–735 tons |
| Zinc alloy value addition | ₹40–50 cr; plant capacity 30 kt matching total Indian market |
| Pyro zinc-lead mode cost impact | $15 per ton extra compared to lead mode |
| Sustenance capex (annual run-rate) | $300–$400 million |
| India manufacturing PMI (March 2024) | 59.1, 16-year high |
| Global steel demand growth forecast (India, FY25) | 8.2% |