Key Takeaways
- A cleanup quarter that reset the book but compressed profit: The sale of the SME portfolio to an ARC and the earlier corporate book resolution pulled ~INR65-67 cr of quarterly income out of the P&L, driving PAT down to INR16.9 cr. The cost base has not yet adjusted, so the drag persists.
- The used-CV engine is running hot, but the yield story has a catch: Disbursements hit INR1,074 cr at an incremental yield of 18.9%, yet the weighted average CV yield is only ~16% because the older book was priced lower. Customers routinely refinance away after 1-1.5 years once they build a credit profile, so the high headline yield is a revolving door.
- Funding cost relief is arriving, just not yet in the P&L: Incremental borrowing cost has dropped sharply from ~12-12.5% to ~10.5%, and four bank sanctions totaling ~INR640 cr came through in Q3. The Q3 average cost of funds was still an "exorbitantly high" 11.7% because the cheaper money arrived at the very end of the quarter.
- Housing finance crossed a milestone but deliberately slowed disbursements: AUM passed INR2,000 cr and the paperless loan kit went live, yet disbursements were pulled back to balance spreads, yields and liability-side constraints. Management says the liability visibility is now restored and capacity is built to grow.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the INR1,345 cr Q4 disbursement ramp-up materializes, how much of the corporate SR gets redeemed in the Jan-Mar window, and whether the 10.5% incremental funding cost begins to flow through the average cost of funds.
The Cleanup: What Was Sold, What Remains, and the Income Hole
- SME book sold to an ARC: The INR292 cr portfolio was offloaded in a part-cash, part-SR transaction. Management does not intend to grow the legacy SME book (INR1.5-2 cr ticket size) and will re-enter SME in a different avatar: INR15-25 lakh tickets in Tier 3/4 locations, possibly starting this quarter or next.
- Corporate book largely resolved: The corporate book was resolved last quarter. A marginal increase this quarter reflects old sanctions where IndoStar is the sole lender, with INR20-30 cr per quarter of commitments continuing for 4-5 more quarters.
- The income hole is ~INR65-67 cr per quarter: INR30 cr from the corporate book sale and INR7 cr from the SME sale, plus the compounding effect. The cost base did not shrink because the sales were part-cash, part-SR, so the drag will take a couple of quarters to cover as the CV portfolio grows into it.
- SR book and provisioning: Gross SRs stand at INR160 cr with a INR30 cr provision taken using the ECL method, retaining the same provision percentage as when the assets were on-book. Ind AS does not require this provision; management calls it prudent. Corporate SR redemption saw a negligible portion in December, with a significant reduction expected in the Jan-Mar quarter. SME SR cash generation will start in the coming quarter for one pool and 3-4 quarters out for the second.
Vinodkumar P.: "roughly INR65 crores, INR67 crores of income has gone away, but the cost doesn't go away because it is sold partially in cash and partially in -- by way of SR. And therefore, it would be a couple of quarters it will take for us to actually cover up for whatever we have lost."
Used-CV Franchise: High Yield, High Churn
- Disbursement momentum is strong: INR1,074 cr of CV disbursements in the quarter, with both entities confident of hitting the combined INR5,500 cr disbursement target for the full year. The Q4 ask is ~INR1,345 cr for the stand-alone entity, implying a combined Q4 disbursement close to INR2,000 cr.
- Incremental yield is 18.9%, but the portfolio yield is ~16%: The older book was written at significantly lower rates, so the weighted average lags the headline number. The 18.9% is on new disbursements only.
- Customers refinance away after building a credit profile: The typical borrower is a first-time user who pays 18-18.5% for 1-1.5 years, builds a credit history, then moves to a lower-cost lender. IndoStar does not compete on price to retain them.
- Used-CV demand is structurally supported: BS6 heavy-haulage vehicle prices have risen sharply, making used vehicles the only viable option for financially constrained operators. BS-III vehicles are being replaced with BS-IV vehicles, sustaining replacement demand even at elevated used-vehicle prices.
Karthikeyan Srinivasan: "These segments continue to buy the used commercial vehicle segments, even at a price which is much higher than what has been in the market probably 1 year back. This is predominantly because there has been a lot of change of the BS-III vehicles with BS-IV vehicles." Vinodkumar P.: "they always look out for a better -- for a lower cost, which we will not provide, so we'll go to somebody else."
Funding Cost: The Inflection Is Here, the P&L Is Lagging
- Incremental borrowing cost has dropped 150-200 bps: From ~12-12.5% in the immediately preceding quarter to ~10.5% in Q3. The transaction happened at the back end of the quarter, so the benefit is not yet visible in the average cost of funds.
- Q3 average cost of funds was 11.7%: Management calls this "exorbitantly high" and attributes it to being away from banks until end-June, forcing reliance on NCDs (~INR2,900 cr raised over 4-5 quarters at higher cost). Banks are now returning, with two sanctions in the current quarter and a changed borrowing mix that includes securitization at attractive pricing and CP.
- Four bank sanctions in Q3 totaling ~INR640 cr: Two term loans/WCDL and two securitization lines. This diversifies the liability side and should pull the blended cost down.
- Liquidity bloat at quarter-end: INR1,000 cr of liquidity arrived in the last 3-5 days of the quarter. Policy is to keep sufficient for three months of loan repayments, so this is deliberate but adds to the cost drag.
Vinodkumar P.: "in the current quarter, while the -- immediately preceding quarter in mind, borrowing -- incremental borrowing was at about 12%, 12.5%. In the current quarter, it has been -- the incremental borrowing is about 10.5%, which we believe is a very big positive."
Housing Finance: Milestones Met, Growth Paused, Now Ready to Resume
- AUM crossed INR2,000 cr, active customers crossed 25,000: A granularity milestone that management highlights as evidence of expanding reach. Portfolio yield is 15.1%, reflecting risk-based pricing, and spreads are maintained in the 5.25-5.5% range.
- Asset quality is holding up: Gross NPA 1.24%, net NPA 0.93%, 1+ DPD 4.2%, 30+ DPD 2.7%. These are healthy numbers for an affordable housing book.
- Disbursements were deliberately slowed: The slowdown balanced spreads, yields and ticket size while the liability side was constrained. Management says the liability visibility is now fully restored and capacity is built to grow.
- Profitability dipped QoQ on lower upfront income: Q2 sold an INR108 cr portfolio; Q3 sold only INR25 cr. This upfront income swing drove the major dip, not credit costs.
- Paperless journey is complete: The automated loan kit went live with e-stamping and e-signing, placing IndoStar among a select group of affordable HFCs with this capability. INR535 cr of liabilities were raised in the quarter, including two new banking relationships.
- Branch expansion for housing is done: The 60-70 branch increase was mostly for housing finance into newer territories. That expansion mode is now complete.
ROA, Leverage and the Path Back to Respectable Returns
- Stand-alone ROA is not justified for the book being carried: The drag comes from SRs that need to be redeemed and converted to cash, plus the ~INR35-37 cr quarterly income loss from the sold books. Management expects it will take 4-5 quarters for that impact to fade as the CV portfolio (at 18% yield) grows and the new SME avatar adds to the bottom line.
- FY25 ROA target of 2-2.5% is maintained: Management says it is on track, with the cost-of-funds reduction and portfolio mix shift doing the heavy lifting.
- Leverage target is 4x to 4.5x, but not in FY25: Management expects this level in FY26. No ROE target has been guided; the conversation is anchored to ROA only.
- Cost-to-income will take a couple of quarters to normalize: The revenue base shrank from the book sales while the cost base did not, so the ratio is temporarily elevated.
- Provision coverage ratio is 50%: One of the highest in the industry on an LGD/PCR basis. Management will relook at PD/LGD in the March quarter and decide whether to revise PCR as the portfolio improves quarter-on-quarter.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Full-year disbursement target | Combined INR5,500 cr (stand-alone INR4,400 cr + housing INR1,100 cr) | FY24 (by March 2024) |
| Q4 disbursement ramp-up | Stand-alone ~INR1,345 cr; combined close to INR2,000 cr | Q4 FY24 |
| Consolidated AUM target | Closer to INR9,500 cr (revised from ~INR10,000 cr due to two portfolio sales of ~INR1,200 cr) | FY24 exit |
| FY25 AUM aspiration | Stand-alone ~INR6,000 cr, housing ~INR1,400-1,500 cr, total ~INR13,000 cr | FY25 |
| ROA target | 2-2.5% | FY25 |
| Cost of funds | Trend down to 10.5% level | "Better part of the next year" (FY25) |
| Corporate SR redemption | Significant portion of reduction expected | Jan-Mar quarter (Q4 FY24) |
| SME SR cash generation | One pool starts generating; second pool 3-4 quarters out | Coming quarter / 3-4 quarters |
| New SME avatar launch | INR15-25 lakh ticket in Tier 3/4 locations | This quarter or definitely next quarter |
| Leverage target | 4x to 4.5x | FY26 (not expected in FY25) |
| Provision coverage review | Relook at PD/LGD and decide on PCR revision | March quarter (Q4 FY24) |
| Income hole coverage | Couple of quarters to cover the INR65-67 cr quarterly loss from book sales | ~2 quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated disbursements | ₹1,345 cr, +6% QoQ |
| Net interest income | ₹133.8 cr, vs ₹145.9 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Interest margin | 5.6%, broadly same as Q3 FY23 |
| Operating expenses | ₹119 cr, vs ₹120.9 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Profit after tax (consolidated) | ₹16.9 cr, vs ₹36.7 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Consolidated AUM | ₹8,037 cr, vs ₹7,726 cr in Q2 FY24 |
| Vehicle finance AUM | ₹4,850 cr, +11% QoQ |
| Housing finance AUM | ₹2,000 cr, milestone crossed |
| Stand-alone CV disbursements | ₹1,074 cr, vs ₹1,000 cr in Q2 FY24 and ₹334 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Consolidated Stage 3 assets | 5.3%, down from 3.3% net Stage 3 in Q2 FY24 |
| Consolidated net Stage 3 | 2.4%, improved from 3.3% in Q2 FY24 |
| Stand-alone GNPA | 6.5%, after SME portfolio sale |
| Housing finance gross NPA | 1.24% |
| Housing finance net NPA | 0.93% |
| Collection efficiency | 135% in Q3 FY24 |
| Capital adequacy | 30.4% |
| Debt-to-equity | 2.1x |
| Incremental borrowing cost | ~10.5%, down from ~12–12.5% in Q2 FY24 |
| Cost of funds (stand-alone) | 11.7% in Q3 FY24 |
| Housing finance portfolio yield | 15.1% |
| Housing finance spreads | 5.25% to 5.5% |
| Housing finance 30+ DPD | 2.7% |
| Housing finance 1+ DPD | 4.2% |
| Incremental funding raised | ₹1,522 cr in Q3 FY24 |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹1,312 cr at quarter-end |
| Credit rating | CARE AA- stable, upgraded from A+ |
| Housing finance PAT (9M FY24) | ₹28 cr for nine months ended Dec 31, 2023 |
| Housing finance AUM growth | 26% year-to-date |
| Housing finance loan book growth | 24% year-to-date |
| Housing finance average ticket size | ₹9 lakhs at portfolio level |
| Housing finance disbursements (9M FY24) | ₹635 cr, ~40% in Tier 3–4 towns |
| Housing finance customer base | >25,000 active customers |
| Housing finance liabilities raised | ₹535 cr in Q3 FY24 |
| CV incremental disbursement yield | 18.9% |
| CV weighted average income | ~16% (management stated 16.8%) |
| SR gross value (corporate book) | ₹682 cr, provision of ₹103 cr |
| SR gross value (SME) | ₹160 cr, provision of ₹30 cr |
| SME portfolio sold | ₹292 cr, part-cash, part-SR |
| Corporate loan book sold (prior quarter) | ₹915 cr, revenue impact ~₹30 cr per quarter |
| Revenue reduction from SME sale | ~₹7 cr in Q3 FY24 |
| Total income lost from both sales | ~₹65–67 cr |
| FY24 consolidated AUM expectation | ~₹9,500 cr |
| FY25 consolidated AUM aspiration | ~₹13,000 cr (stand-alone ~₹6,000 cr, housing ~₹1,400–1,500 cr) |
| Q4 FY24 combined disbursement target | ~₹2,000 cr |
| Branch expansion planned | 40–50 branches |
| Average branch AUM to breakeven | ₹2.5–3 cr, ~6 months |
| Provision coverage ratio | 50% |