Key Takeaways
- Unsecured stress drove a deliberate H1 contraction: Management chose to de-grow the unsecured book by 7% H1, sacrificing revenue and fees to secure asset quality; the peak of that stress is now declared behind the bank.
- Secured pivot accelerated: The secured book grew 16% H1 and reached 65% of assets, with Affordable Housing crossing INR 10,000 crore to become the largest business; the target is now 80% secured, faster than before.
- Profitability absorbed a one-time provision hit: ROA of 1.6% and ROE of 14.5% were muted by an additional INR 115 crore provision taken to keep net NPA below 1%, a line management intends to hold going forward.
- Deposit franchise strengthened while costs held firm: Deposits grew 31% YoY, the CD ratio fell to ~100%, and LCR stood at 261%, but cost of funds remained at ~8.1% as the bank repaid INR 800 crore of low-cost SLTRO borrowings.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether unsecured growth resumes as guided, whether the SARFAESI backlog clearance actually improves secured GNPA, and whether the promised H2 revenue and cost-income recovery materializes.
The Unsecured Reset: Stress, Sacrifice & the Declared Peak
- Deliberate contraction: Management chose to de-grow the unsecured book by 7% H1 rather than chase growth into visible stress, a decision that cost INR 100-120 crore in revenue and pushed up the cost-income ratio.
- BC network the epicenter: The de-growth and NPA increase concentrated in the BC-sourced portfolio, where one BC became significantly challenged due to CSP-point collection breakdowns and two others grew too fast; service guarantees cover disbursals, not the portfolio, so the credit risk sits with the bank.
- Tightened norms already in place: Off-us exposure per customer capped at INR 50,000, total exposure for new-to-bank customers reduced to INR 1.25 lakhs from INR 1.5 lakhs, and for existing customers cut from INR 2 lakhs to INR 1.25 lakhs; CSP points banned for BC collections.
- Peak declared, normalization promised: Management stated unsecured stress and credit costs peaked in Q2, reasoning that the toughest BC customers have already slipped, the BC book has shrunk from INR 2,500 crore to INR 1,950 crore, and no new unsecured customers were added in H1, so fresh slippages should be minimal.
- Recoveries sacrificed to protect the front book: Recoveries dropped from INR 80 crore to INR 44 crore YoY because collection staff were diverted to keeping early buckets at 98-99% in MFI rather than working deeper delinquencies; teams now refocusing on deeper buckets for H2.
Kanwal: "Our first half attempt, seeing the strength in the system, is to de-grow, get clear what the environment is really showing to all of us, and then decide to grow, which is why the policy has been conservative, and our strategy has been conservative to that extent."
Secured Book: The Accelerating Engine
- Affordable Housing the new flagship: The book crossed INR 10,000 crore and became the largest business in the bank, growing 16.9% half-on-half with LTVs among the best in the industry at 50%.
- Frontline built ahead of demand: Field force increased ~16% in anticipation of a sizable H2 scale-up, the traditionally growth-heavy period for housing and Micro LAP.
- Micro LAP and MSME steady: Micro LAP grew 8% H1 at a 36% LTV; MSME loans grew 12.9% H1, supplemented by a supply chain business that nearly doubled from INR 378 crore to INR 597 crore.
- Gold and two-wheeler fill the MFI team pipeline: Gold loans grew ~80% YoY driven by the MFI team channel, while two-wheeler expanded from 90 to ~180 cities; both offer career paths for microfinance staff as that book is managed down.
- CGTMSE guarantee book ramping: From INR 120 crore currently to a target of INR 800-1,000 crore by March, aimed at micro enterprises.
- Secured GNPA uptick is operational, not credit-driven: An extra 20-30 bps of gross NPA came from slowness in SARFAESI and Section 13(2)/13(4) activities during Q1 due to election-related delays; 60% of the backlog cleared in Q2, the remaining 40% expected in Q3.
Kanwal: "This small bump in the road doesn't change our strategy. Our strategy always has been going a secured business and if anything, this 6 months has again proven that we have been on the right track as a strategy for the last 6.5 years."
Asset Quality: Provisions, Slippages & the Below-1% Net NPA Line
- Gross NPA at 2.86%, net NPA at 0.95%: The increase was largely MFI-led, with an additional INR 115 crore provision taken proactively to hold net NPA below the 1% threshold, a line management commits to maintain.
- PCR elevated as a buffer, not a loss forecast: Secured PCR jumped to ~29% from ~18% in March, a move management described as responding to analyst requests and ensuring no doubt about provisioning adequacy, not reflecting anticipated losses.
- MFI slippage disclosed at ~10% for Q2: Total H1 slippage figures were not provided when asked.
- Flow rates expected to decline: Management advised against extrapolating Q2 flow rates forward, arguing the worst customers have already slipped and the shrinking unsecured book limits fresh NPA formation.
- Universal bank application depends on these numbers: Gross NPA must stay below 3% and net NPA below 1% for the application next year.
Deposit Franchise & Cost of Funds
- Deposit growth outpacing the industry: 31% YoY and 10% H1 versus industry growth of 12%, bringing the CD ratio down from 110% to ~100%.
- CASA stable, product innovation underway: CASA ratio held at ~20.1%, supported by new launches: Legend for senior citizens, an NRI product, Exclusive Premium, and Liquid Plus FD.
- Cost of funds sticky at ~8.1%: The bank repaid INR 800 crore of 4% SLTRO borrowings and carries LCR at 261%, well above the industry average of ~130%; management plans to reduce LCR over the next six months to ease costs.
- Deposit rates already cut: Fixed deposit rates reduced in July, savings bank rates in October; both expected to bring down cost of deposits further.
- New borrowing sanctions expected: Refinance institutions likely to sanction new limits at competitive rates late October or early November, supporting ALM for affordable housing and micro-housing.
Revenue, NIM & the H2 Recovery Bet
- NIM held at 7.7% despite headwinds: A 7% drop in the high-yielding MFI book and interest reversals from slippages were absorbed without NIM compression.
- PPOP dropped on lower PSL sale income and unsecured revenue loss: PSL sale income fell from INR 40 crore in Q1 to INR 10 crore in Q2; combined with the INR 100-120 crore revenue loss from negative unsecured growth, PPOP declined from INR 355 crore to INR 298 crore.
- The H2 case rests on three reversals: No further 7% unsecured portfolio drop, so fees and revenue improve; elevated provisions do not repeat; and recoveries rise as teams return to deeper buckets.
- Unsecured disbursements halved YoY: From INR 4,000 crore last year to INR 2,975 crore this year; the first 21 days of October show encouraging signs for a rebuild.
- Secured yields disclosed at 13.41% for MSME, Home Loan and Micro LAP combined; unsecured yields at ~19.9%.
Kanwal: "I wouldn't extrapolate that for the next two quarters because we don't anticipate a 7% drop in portfolio. So, obviously, fee will get better, revenue will get better, and at the same time, cost income will get better."
The MFI Model Question & Strategic Direction
- Jana's MFI book is structurally different: 50-60% of the book is individual loans migrated since 2017-18, so batch-discipline breakdowns are less relevant; 100% e-KYC eliminates KYC concerns.
- Customer leverage monitored across all bureaus: Jana checks total exposure including unsecured and MFI across all credit bureaus, a practice management claims is rare.
- Account-to-collector ratio improved: Reduced from ~350-360 in March to 290-295, giving collectors more bandwidth.
- Geographic diversification progressing: Top three states' share reduced from 35% to 30%, rest of India up from 32% to 41%, aligned with branch expansion.
- The model itself is under review: Management acknowledged that even when this stress cycle ends, returning to the same MFI model is not the answer; the business will be more guarded in future and the bank is actively thinking about what the next model looks like.
Management: "I do think there will be a bit of a question of the model which is okay even if this stress is over, what next? And we can't go back to the same model because this model causes stress, so then what is the next model?"
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Net NPA ceiling | Maintain net NPA below 1% | Ongoing |
| Secured PCR retention | Hold secured PCR at ~29.7% | Ongoing |
| Secured asset mix | Reach 80% secured assets; "mind is to get there faster" | No date; accelerated intent |
| CGTMSE guarantee book | Grow from INR 120 crore to INR 800-1,000 crore | By March 2025 |
| Unsecured normalization | Revenue, fees and cost-income ratio to normalize as unsecured de-growth ends | Next two quarters (H2 FY25) |
| Credit cost decline | Lower credit flows, lower provisioning demand, better recoveries vs Q2 | Q3 FY25 |
| SARFAESI backlog clearance | Clear remaining 40% of backlog from Q1 election-related delays | Q3 FY25 |
| LCR reduction | Reduce LCR from 261% to ease cost of funds | Over next 6 months |
| Universal bank application | Gross NPA below 3%, net NPA below 1% required | Application next year |
| AUM growth | 20% target not at risk; H1 at ~10%, H2 expected to close the gap | FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Post-tax profit (H1 FY25) | ₹267 cr, after additional provision of ₹115 cr and ₹19 cr added to DTA |
| Net Interest Margin | 7.7%, despite 7% drop in MFI book; cost of funds stable at 8.1% for Q2, 8% for H1 |
| Cost of funds | 8.1% for Q2, 8% for H1 FY25 |
| Return on assets | 1.6%, slightly muted over Q1 due to provisioning |
| Return on equity | 14.5% |
| Advances growth | 17% YoY, 7% H1; secured grew 16% H1, unsecured de-grew 7% H1 |
| Deposit growth | 31% YoY, 10% H1; CASA grew 12% H1, time deposits grew 9% H1 |
| CASA ratio | 20.1%, up from 19.7% in March |
| Credit-deposit ratio | ~100%, down from 110% |
| Gross NPA | 2.86%, largely MFI-led |
| Net NPA | 0.95% |
| Provision coverage ratio | 67.2%; secured PCR elevated to 29.7% from ~18% in March |
| Capital adequacy | 18.8%, Tier 1 at 17.8%; would strengthen to 20.3% after adding H1 PAT |
| Liquidity coverage ratio | 261%, vs industry average of 130% and peer group 100–150% |
| Secured book proportion | 65% of total book, up from 60% in March |
| Affordable Housing & Micro LAP book | Crossed ₹10,000 cr mark |
| Microfinance gross NPA | 4.97%; net NPA 0.49% |
| Microfinance book de-growth | 7% H1; BC book de-grew 11% |
| BC book gross NPA | 9.7%, net NPA 0.7%, PCR 93.4% |
| BC book size | ₹1,900 cr, down from peak of ₹2,500 cr in March |
| Gold loan growth | ~80% YoY, 67% H1 |
| MSME loan growth | 16.5% YoY, 12.9% H1 |
| Two-wheeler book size | ₹651 cr |
| Supply chain book | ₹597 cr, up from ₹378 cr |
| Unsecured disbursement | ₹2,975 cr in H1 FY25, down from ₹4,000 cr in H1 FY24 |
| MFI collection efficiency | 98.5% to 98.7% in Q2, similar to Q1 |
| MFI slippages in Q2 | ~10%, largely led by BC book |
| Average MFI ticket size | ₹36,000, among the lowest in the industry |
| Secured book yield (MSME, Home Loan, Micro LAP) | 13.41% |
| Unsecured book yield (microfinance) | ~19.9% |
| Recoveries | ₹44 cr in H1 FY25, down from ₹80 cr YoY |
| PSL income | ₹55 cr in H1 FY25, up from ₹42 cr YoY |
| Processing fee | ₹104 cr in H1 FY25, down from ₹118 cr YoY |
| PPOP | ₹298 cr in Q2, down from ₹355 cr in Q1; decline driven by lower PSL sale (₹10 cr vs ₹40 cr in Q1) |
| Revenue loss from negative unsecured growth | Estimated ₹100–120 cr in H1 (per management estimate) |
| Per-employee deposit | ₹9.13 cr, stable for last three quarters |
| Branches added | 22 in last one year, 4 in current financial year with 16 in pipeline |
| Customer count | 0.45 cr; ~24,000 employees |
| CGTMSE guarantee book | ₹120 cr currently; target ₹800–1,000 cr by March end |
| Restructured book | ₹79 cr, down 10% QoQ; ₹73 cr secured with LTV of 38% |
| SLTRO borrowings repaid | ₹800 cr at 4% cost; cost of funds held at 8% for H1 |
| Cash on hand | ₹1,400 cr as of September end |