Key Takeaways
- Peak stress is passing, but stabilization is incomplete: Regulatory provisions halved QoQ to ₹81 crores, and credit cost fell to 174 bps, yet the unsecured MFI book continued shrinking and collection efficiency has not returned to normal 99% levels.
- Universal bank application is the organizing priority: The bank is loading accelerated provisions to keep net NPA below 1% for a second consecutive year, a hard condition to apply in May. That provisioning is the single largest swing factor in reported profitability.
- The balance-sheet mix is being forcibly reshaped: Secured loans grew 36% YoY to 68% of the book, while unsecured declined 7%. Management wants 80% secured and is putting the residual unsecured book under credit guarantee programs.
- Cost-income is under structural pressure, not just cyclical: NIM compression from the shrinking high-yield unsecured book is driving the ratio up even though the opex-to-total-business ratio is stable. Recovery depends on unsecured stabilization, which has already slipped one quarter.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the unsecured book actually stabilizes in Q4 as promised, the quantum and pace of accelerated provision reversal guided at March results, and the CASA trajectory after October’s deliberate rate cut.
The Universal Bank Application: Provisioning Math and Trade-offs
- Net NPA below 1% is the binding constraint: The bank must deliver this for two consecutive years to apply in May. It met the condition last year and is loading extra provisions this year to ensure it meets it again.
- Accelerated provisioning is the tool: The bank is taking provisions above what the underlying asset quality requires, purely to pull net NPA under the 1% threshold. This quarter’s regulatory provision was ₹81 crores, down from ₹149 crores in Q2, confirming management’s earlier statement that Q2 was the peak.
- PCR is rising mechanically as unsecured loans are written off: Because unsecured NPAs are fully provided and technically written off, the remaining NPA pool is overwhelmingly secured. To keep net NPA below 1%, PCR on the secured book has risen from 18% at the start of the year to 48% now, and management warns it could reach 58% or 68% with further provisioning.
- The write-off mechanics matter: The bank took its first technical write-off of ₹109 crores this quarter, which reduced gross NPA optically. None was taken in Q2. Individual loans are performing better than group loans across the industry.
- Provision reversal will be gradual, not a Q1 windfall: Management stated reversals will happen over the next year, not all in Q1. Clear guidance on timing and speed will come at March results. The bank will carry roughly ₹300 crores of accelerated provision into next year.
Kanwal: "One thing you should know for sure is when you finish this year, we have right now PAT around Rs. 360 odd crores. We have one more quarter to go. You can take any reasonable addition to that, which is better than Q3. So, you know what PAT will finish with. Plus, we will carry about Rs. 300 crores of accelerated provision. So, you can do a fair estimate for next year now, which means that we will not have accelerated provision. And plus some of this provision will get released, if not all of it."
Microfinance: Stabilization Delayed, Not Abandoned
- The book is still contracting: Unsecured loans declined 7% YoY. Disbursement rose to ₹1,809 crores in Q3 from ₹1,338 crores in Q2, but the book did not grow because of the ₹109 crores technical write-off.
- Collection efficiency is stuck below normal: Collections have been running at 98.5-98.6% consistently across October, November, and December. Normally the bank reaches 99% by the 20th-22nd of the month; now it is fighting to get there by the 30th-31st. The push to reach 99% has not succeeded.
- Stabilization has already slipped one quarter: Management had hoped to stabilize the unsecured book in Q3 but could not. The field force has not yet regained confidence to increase disbursements. The new target is Q4: flat to positive, with no further decline.
- Individual loans are the structural answer: Individual loans are more urban, given to customers who have completed one cycle of group lending, with underwriter visits and cash-flow assessment. They avoid the "ganging up" and barricade problems of group loans. Management believes more of the industry will turn toward individual loans.
- Lending standards remain tight: In non-metro cities, an existing customer with more than ₹50,000 outstanding exposure with any MFI will not get a repeat loan. Rejection rates on group-loan sourcing are 70-80%. These conditions stay until the industry is sorted out.
- The cost of carrying the collection infrastructure is elevated: The bank has roughly 8,000 people in microfinance, but the book is negative 11% for the year. Those people are deployed on collections rather than new business, pushing opex growth to 19.5% against an 8-10% guidance. Industry-wide attrition also forced higher people costs.
Kanwal: "If you source group loans, your rejection rate is 70 to 80% now, batches. So, we don't want to grow and end up with problems also. So, we are very hard on what we are growing."
Secured Book: The Growth Engine, With Pockets of Friction
- Secured is now 68% of the book, up from 60% in March FY24: Growth was 36% YoY, and full-year secured growth is expected in the 35% range. The stated trajectory is 80% secured, with the residual 20% unsecured placed under guarantee programs.
- Asset quality in secured is a timing issue, not a loss issue: 79% of net NPAs are secured loans with property backing at 46% LTV. Management expects limited credit cost from this pool. The three-year model assumes 1.5% credit cost for an 80% secured book.
- Two states are causing trouble: Odisha and West Bengal are showing extra challenge in the secured book. Micro LAP and, to a lesser extent, affordable housing in two to three specific geographies are contributing slippages. MSME loans remain very stable.
- Micro LAP is structurally safer than MFI: The product is entirely SARFAESI-applicable property business with 33% LTV. There is no overlap of salesforce or credit underwriting with microfinance. Management says it would have slowed growth if it were uncomfortable.
- Credit guarantee programs are being layered on for event risk: The bank has initiated CGTMSE for micro enterprises and CGFMU for the rest of the MFI book, covering 13.3% of the unsecured portfolio now, with a target of 25-30% by March. The philosophy is insurance, not a license to take more risk.
Margins, Deposits, and the Cost-Income Problem
- Cost-income is rising because NIM is falling: The ratio is under pressure not from extraordinary costs but because the high-yield unsecured MFI book is shrinking. The opex-to-total-business ratio is stable at 0.9-0.92% per quarter, in line with AUM growth.
- Management’s recovery path: Once the MFI book stabilizes, cost-to-income should start improving. The longer-term aim is 52-53%. Recovery will come either from unsecured returning to its ₹10,000 crores level or from working harder on the secured side.
- CASA was deliberately repriced down: The bank cut CASA rates on October 3rd to shed expensive deposits. The cost dropped from 4.8% in September to 4.44%, but the CASA ratio fell to 18.43% as wholesale CASA exited. Retail CASA came in but has not yet fully replaced the outflow. Management expects CASA to turn positive in Q4.
- The CD ratio is elevated but partly optical: At 102.5%, the ratio was pushed up by unexpected ODFD growth in the last week, which was subsequently paid down. Otherwise it would be 98-99%. The bank maintains it in the 90s because it has refinance lines from NHB, SIDBI, and NABARD at good pricing.
- LCR is high and a drag on NIM: The bank tried to bring LCR down in Q2 but it rose again in Q3. When taking bulk deposits, management asks for 5-10 bps extra but makes them non-callable; 70% of bulk deposits are for more than one year. Reducing LCR through retail deposit growth would help NIMs.
- Universal bank conversion is expected to cut deposit costs: Management is budgeting a minimum 25 bps drop in cost of deposits upon conversion, and expects velocity of CASA and deposit growth to improve when "Small Finance" is dropped from the name.
Kanwal: "The challenge being the NIM is dropping because unsecured book is dropping. And that is stressing the cost-income ratio. So, the moment we stabilize our unsecured MFI book, which we expect to do in quarter four... our cost-to-income will start getting better."
Profitability: Reported vs. Underlying
- Reported PAT masks the true earnings power: Management argues that stripping out accelerated provisioning and DTA effects reveals a 2.3% ROA, which it calls the true value of the bank.
- Credit cost is already declining: Total credit cost fell from 210 bps in Q2 to 174 bps in Q3. Excluding accelerated provisioning and recoveries, net credit cost was just ₹44 crores. For the full year, credit cost is expected at 1.6-1.7%.
- Q4 PAT should be better than Q3’s ₹110-111 crores: Drivers include a larger balance sheet, unsecured stabilization, higher Q4 disbursements and fee income, and declining cost of deposits as CASA and deposits reprice.
- DTA usage is being replanned: The original plan was to use most of the DTA except the last ₹100 crores by FY27. Some will be left on the table this year. An updated plan will be shared at March results. The bank has two more years to use it.
- The three-year steady-state model: 80% secured, CASA at 30%, NIM compression of 30 bps, ROA of 1.8-2%, cost-income around 53%, ROE of 16-17%. The credit guarantee program will now be modeled into these numbers.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Universal bank application | File application with regulators | May 2025 |
| Net NPA | Keep below 1% | Two consecutive years, including FY25 |
| Gross NPA | Keep below 3% | Ongoing |
| Unsecured book stabilization | Flat to positive, no further decline | Q4 FY25 |
| Secured book growth | ~35% for full year | FY25 |
| Asset and deposit growth | 20% each | FY25; similar guidance for FY26 to be given at March results |
| CASA | Turn positive | Q4 FY25 |
| Credit guarantee coverage on unsecured | Reach 25-30% of unsecured portfolio | By March 2025 |
| Accelerated provision reversal | Unwind over next 3-4 quarters, not abruptly | Starting FY26 |
| Cost-income ratio | Return toward 52-53% | Longer-term; no specific date given |
| Secured book mix | Reach 80% secured | No date given; trajectory underway |
| DTA usage plan | Updated plan to be shared | March 2025 results |
| FY26 guidance | To be provided | March 2025 results |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY25 |
|---|---|
| PAT | ₹111 cr, vs ₹97 cr in Q2 |
| Adjusted PAT (adding back accelerated provision) | ₹204 cr |
| PBT (post regulatory and accelerated provision) | ₹105 cr, vs ₹88 cr in Q2 |
| PBT (9M FY25, after ₹208 cr accelerated provisioning) | ₹354 cr, highest ever |
| Adjusted ROA (adding back accelerated provision) | 2.4% |
| Adjusted ROE (adding back accelerated provision) | 20.7% |
| ROA (excluding accelerated provision and DTA) | 2.3% |
| Net NPA | 0.91% |
| Gross NPA | ₹753 cr closing balance, flattish QoQ |
| PCR | 66.94% |
| Credit cost | 174 bps, down from 210 bps in Q2 and 196 bps in Q1 |
| Accelerated provision within credit cost | 93 bps |
| Net credit cost (excluding accelerated provisioning and recoveries) | ₹44 cr |
| Secured loans growth | 36% YoY |
| Secured book share | 68%, up from 60% in March FY24 |
| Unsecured book growth | -7% YoY |
| Unsecured book de-growth (9M FY25) | 11% |
| CASA ratio | 18.43% |
| Cost of CASA | 4.44%, down from 4.8% in September |
| LCR | 279% |
| CD ratio | 102.5% |
| Book value per share | ₹380 |
| MFI collection efficiency (B0) | 98.5-98.6%, consistent across Oct, Nov, Dec |
| MFI disbursements | ₹1,809 cr, vs ₹1,338 cr in Q2 and ₹1,970 cr in Q3 last year |
| MFI slippages | ₹230 cr, flat QoQ |
| Affordable housing growth (9M FY25) | 25%, avg ticket size ₹11.9 lakhs |
| Micro-LAP growth (9M FY25) | 14.3%, avg ticket size ₹6.4 lakhs |
| MSME loans growth (9M FY25) | 17.4% |
| Two-wheeler loans growth (9M FY25) | 73.9% |
| Gold loans growth (9M FY25) | 104.9% |
| Unsecured portfolio under CGTMSE and CGFMU | 13.3%, target 25-30% by March 2025 |
| Accelerated provision corpus carried | ₹208 cr so far, expected ₹275-300 cr by Q4 |
| Technical write-off in Q3 | ₹109 cr, entirely from MFI |
| Interest reversals in MFI segment (Q3) | ₹18 cr |
| Secured PCR | 48.3%, up from 29% in Q2 |
| Unsecured PCR | 86% |
| BC book PCR | 98% |
| Secured loans LTV | 46% |
| Micro-LAP LTV | 32.8% |
| Gross NPA breakup: secured | ₹382 cr |
| Gross NPA breakup: unsecured | ₹225 cr |
| Gross NPA breakup: BC | ₹151 cr |
| Net NPA share from secured loans | 79% |
| Additional NHB and SIDBI refinance | ₹730 cr, 10-year and 5-year money |
| FLDG utilized during the year | ~₹110 cr |
| DTA carried from prior quarter | ₹740 cr |
| Steady-state ROA target (3-year model, 80% secured) | 1.8% to 2% |
| Steady-state ROE target (3-year model) | 16% to 17% |
| Steady-state cost-income ratio target | ~53% |
| Credit cost guidance for FY25 | 1.6% to 1.7% |
| 3-year model credit cost assumption (80% secured) | 1.5% |
| OPEX to Total Business ratio | 0.9%, 0.92%, 0.91% per quarter in Q1, Q2, Q3 |
| Gold loan penetration in home loan and LAP customers | 2%, up from 1.8% QoQ |
| TD penetration | 20%, up from 19% QoQ |
| Pre-approved business loan penetration | 16.5%, up from 15% QoQ |
| MFI book CAGR (2018 to Dec 2024) | ~1% |
| NIM | 7.6%, would have been 8% if MFI book held at March levels |
| Adjusted PAT (9M FY25, Slide #3) | ₹586 cr |
| Budgeted drop in cost of deposits on universal bank conversion | minimum 25 bps |
| PSL certificate sale benefit on universal bank conversion | ₹30-40 cr at best |
| CGFMU cost | 1% of disbursed amount for one year, first 3% of gross NPA is cost, 75% of balance paid by CGFMU thereafter |
| CGTMSE cost | 0.3%, recovery capped at 2x premium paid for that year |
| Bulk deposits with maturity over one year | ~70% of all bulk deposits |