Key Takeaways
- Revenue degrew 5% YoY but gross margin expanded 360 bps to 45% on raw material softening and a richer retail mix, while PAT halved on higher costs.
- A demerger unlocks the story: the board approved separating the distribution business into a listed mirror entity, a move management says will make the retail company a 16% EBITDA, ~5% PAT performer.
- Volume is the soft spot: retail pairs sold fell 10% YoY to 18 lakh, pinned on a subdued sub-₹1,000 MRP market and a post-COVID disposable-income squeeze in the core middle-income customer base.
- The Eastern zone is the growth engine: West Bengal stores turn profitable from month one, so the company is pushing to open as many stores as possible there for the next 2–3 years.
- What to watch next quarter: whether festive orders actually convert at the promised 4–5% price increase, the pace of store openings against the raised 90–100 target, and any segment-level margin disclosure that lets investors model the two future entities.
The Demerger: Structure, Logic & Timeline
- Two listed entities: the distribution business will be carved into a separate independent listed company, with Khadim India shareholders receiving proportionate shares in the new entity. The retail business stays in the existing listed vehicle.
- Post-demerger financial profile: management expects the retail company to deliver 16% EBITDA and around 5% PAT, while the distribution company will be restructured to be lower in volume but more profitable.
- Asset split: machinery, moulds and the leased factory move to the distribution company. The Panpur factory land stays with a group company, Khadim Estate, and does not transfer. Only distribution debtors, distribution stock, factory stock and factory creditors migrate; all other assets and the already-received UP government receivable remain with the main company.
- Debt follows retail: the existing debt will sit in the retail entity post-demerger, with a plan to reduce it by ₹8–10 crores this year from internal accruals and ₹15–20 crores annually thereafter from retail free cash flow.
- Timeline: the process will take 9 to 12 months; detailed formal board approval is expected next month. Segment-level EBITDA disclosure for retail and distribution will begin in Q2 presentations, but management declined to publish ROCE or capital employed until the demerger is finalized.
Burman: "this decision that has been taken by the team and the promoters, we really believe in it that it will make Khadim a very performance and growth oriented Company in the near future, quite soon it will be like that."
Volume Weakness & the Price-Sensitive Consumer
- Retail volume dropped 10% YoY: pairs sold fell from 20 lakh in Q1 FY23 to 18 lakh in Q1 FY24, a level that also held in Q4 FY23. Management attributes the decline to a subdued market, noting Q1 FY23 was an elevated base following the third COVID wave.
- The sub-₹1,000 MRP segment is in a slump: the weakness is visible across both retail and distribution, with small retailers facing the same demand compression. The company is introducing entry-level price points specifically to arrest pairage degrowth.
- Distribution volume grew: distribution pairs rose to 63 lakh from 58 lakh YoY, providing a partial offset to the retail volume decline.
- The macro headwind is structural for now: management flagged that middle and lower-middle-class disposable income has gone down post-COVID, directly hitting the core customer base. Volume is expected to return to the 20-lakh range only once the broader economy improves.
- Product design had drifted: management acknowledged that designs had become alienated from customers and has spent the last year reworking the range toward more saleable products, with festive orders from franchisees now running well ahead of last year.
Burman: "the designs had become a little alienated from our customers, so we are making those products which are more saleable to our customers and I can say that the designs are working well because right now our festive orders are going on and it's a very good compared to last year."
Margin Walk: Raw Material Tailwind, Volume Headwind
- Gross margin jumped 360 bps YoY to 45%: the expansion was driven primarily by raw material softening, with ASP in retail holding flat year-on-year. A higher contribution from retail sales improved the product mix.
- EBITDA margin rose 130 bps to 11.6%: EBITDA grew 7% YoY despite the 5% revenue decline, showing operating leverage on the gross margin gain.
- PAT margin compressed 100 bps to 1%: PAT halved year-on-year, implying higher depreciation, interest or tax charges ate into the gross margin improvement.
- Sub-brand mix is a multi-year margin lever: sub-brands carry slightly higher gross margins than the Khadim brand, and management sees scope to shift the mix from 60:40 to 65:35 over the next 2–3 years, creating a double impact on gross margin as the richer mix compounds.
- ASP growth of 4–5% expected: value addition through design improvements across merchandise categories is expected to lift ASP, with a further 4–5% price increase planned for the festive season.
- Full-year margin ambition: management aims to improve margin by 100–115 bps YoY this year and at a similar pace next year, with PBT margin targeted to improve around 100 bps annually for the next 2–3 years.
Store Expansion & the Eastern Zone Bet
- Eastern zone is the priority: stores in West Bengal generate profitable sales from the first month, so the company is pushing to open as many stores as possible in the Eastern zone for the next 2–3 years.
- Store opening target raised: the plan has moved from 70–80 new stores to 90–100, with 13 already opened in Q1 FY24. Eleven underperforming stores were closed in the same period.
- Renovation as an SSG lever: store renovation drives SSG growth of around 7–8%, and management plans to accelerate renovations once the demerger frees up cash flow. Premiumization of products through sub-brands is the other SSG lever.
- No owned real estate going forward: the company has shifted to a rental model for warehouses and retail properties, having sold a warehouse in 2022. The Panchla warehouse serves retail, while Serampore serves distribution.
Burman: "if you open a store in West Bengal, it just starts giving a good profitable sales from the very first month itself. So, that's why we want to focus on that also."
Product & Competitive Positioning
- Sport shoes launched across price points: new designs span ₹999 to ₹3,000 MRP and have started reaching shops, with management confident about festive season sales.
- BIS quality control orders are a moat: the government's BIS norms for footwear, effective July 1, 2023, benefit established players with compliance infrastructure over new entrants. The company confirms it is fully compliant.
- Retail competitive position: management asserts that the reach and geographical presence Khadim enjoys in retail cannot be easily replicated by a new company, framing the store network as a durable barrier.
- A&P spend guided at ~₹15 crores for the full year, weighted toward Q2 for the festive season, with flexibility to spend more if sales grow.
- CAPEX also ~₹15 crores for FY24, consistent with the asset-light rental model.
Chaudhuri: "in the retail business, we don't have any fear from other Company because the reach and the geographical presence that we enjoy, a new Company will not be able to have that presence"
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Retail revenue growth | 10–12% growth | FY24 |
| Distribution revenue growth | 12–15% growth | FY24 |
| Store openings | 90–100 new stores (raised from 70–80) | FY24 |
| EBITDA margin improvement | 100–115 bps YoY expansion | FY24 |
| PBT margin improvement | ~100 bps annual improvement | Next 2–3 years |
| Debt reduction | ₹8–10 crores from internal accruals | FY24 |
| Annual debt reduction thereafter | ₹15–20 crores per year from retail free cash flow | FY25 onwards |
| Debt target | Reduce total debt to ~₹50 crores | Next 3 years |
| ASP increase | 4–5% price increase | Festive season (Q2/Q3 FY24) |
| Sub-brand mix shift | From 60:40 to 65:35 (sub-brand:Khadim) | Next 2–3 years |
| Demerger completion | Process takes 9–12 months from formal approval | 9–12 months from formal board approval |
| Segment EBITDA disclosure | Retail and distribution EBITDA in presentations | Starting Q2 FY24 |
| Retail volume recovery | Return to 20-lakh-pair range | When economy improves (no date) |
| Distribution restructuring | Run distribution company profitably, sales may reduce | FY25 (post-demerger) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹158 crores, degrown 5% YoY |
| Gross margin | 45%, up 360 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹18 crores, up 7% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 11.6%, up 130 bps YoY |
| PAT | ₹1.6 crores, down 51% YoY |
| PAT margin | 1%, down 100 bps YoY |
| Retail growth guidance (FY24) | 10% to 12% |
| Distribution growth guidance (FY24) | ~12% to 15% |
| EBITDA margin improvement guidance (FY24) | ~100 to 115 bps YoY |
| Retail ASP | ₹627 |
| Retail volume | 18 lakh pairs, vs 20 lakh pairs in Q1 FY23 and 18 lakh pairs in Q4 FY23 |
| Distribution volume | 63 lakh pairs, vs 58 lakh pairs in Q1 FY23 |
| Retail stores opened | 13 |
| Retail stores closed | 11 |
| Store opening target (FY24) | 90 to 100 stores |
| CAPEX guidance (FY24) | ₹15 crores |
| Advertising & promotion spend | ₹4 crores, 85% offline, 15% online; full-year guidance ₹15 crores |
| Retail EBITDA margin (post-demerger target) | ~16% |
| Distribution EBITDA margin (current, if segregated) | ~5% to 6% |
| Debt reduction target (FY24) | ~₹35 crores, including ₹25 crores from government receivables and ₹8-10 crores from internal accruals |
| Sub-brand mix | 60% sub-brands, 40% Khadim brand; scope to increase sub-brands to 65% |