Key Takeaways
- Sharp revenue contraction, margin story intact: Revenue fell 15.6% YoY as distribution was deliberately shrunk to fix credit and pricing, while retail gross margin expanded 400 bps YoY to 45% on premiumization.
- Distribution is being reset, not abandoned: The company is consolidating distributors and refusing to push low-end inventory, sacrificing near-term sales to stop price cuts and market chaos ahead of the demerger.
- Demerger is the structural catalyst: A wholly owned subsidiary, KSR Footwear, has been formed and regulatory filings are underway, with the new entity expected to start operations by June or July 2024.
- Full-year growth guide cut: Management lowered FY24 growth expectations to 7–8% from the earlier 10–12%, citing the distribution correction and muted demand for lower-segment products.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Puja-shifted retail volumes actually land in Q3, any early signal on BIS-driven cost inflation, and the pace of distributor consolidation.
The Distribution Reset
- Deliberate degrowth: Distribution saw a huge decline because management stopped pushing Hawai and PU products to distributors, choosing to protect working capital days and enforce credit discipline rather than chase volumes.
- Consolidation underway: The company is consolidating distributors to eliminate price cuts that erode demand and create market chaos, a corrective move that management acknowledges will cause some near-term sales correction.
- Geographic focus: Distributor expansion is limited to the East, with a target of 70–75 distributors, and the plan for FY25 is to work with large, district-level distributors under the new demerged entity.
- Recovery timeline: Management expects the correction to yield better results from Q4 onwards, while trying to keep distribution sales intact from the prior quarter.
Chaudhari: "So, while correcting, we have seen that there are some changes we have to do as I have already told that we are consolidating the distributor so that the price cut that happens in the market can be stopped and we can consolidate the distributor and so that the demand for a particular product remains and there is no price cut which reduces the demand and create chaos in the market."
Retail & Premiumization
- Gross margin leap: Retail gross margin hit 45% in Q2, up 400 bps YoY, driven by a favorable product mix as sub-brands now contribute 60% of sales versus 40% for the mother brand.
- Pro sub-brand traction: The sport shoe range under the Pro sub-brand is seeing strong uptake, with merchandisers attending China fairs to source designs that will be manufactured domestically because Chinese vendors will not pursue BIS certification.
- Puja timing distortion: Retail degrowth was entirely a calendar effect: last year Puja fell on 1st October, pulling COCO sales into Q2, while this year those sales shift to Q3, where management expects higher COCO growth.
- Store strategy narrowing: Future COCO openings will be limited to the eastern part of the country, at a standard 1,000 square feet, with only one or two strategic locations elsewhere.
- H2 margin outlook: Second-half retail margins are expected to improve modestly, perhaps by 1% over the first half, aided by the festive quarter.
Burman: "So yes, the premiumization trend is strongly at play, especially because we have launched a good range in the sport shoe segments, which is our Pro sub brand, so that is seeing a good traction."
Demerger: Structure & Timeline
- Entity formed: KSR Footwear Limited has been incorporated as a wholly owned subsidiary to house the distribution business post-demerger, with the goal of focused strategic attention and resource allocation for each segment.
- Regulatory progress: Applications have already been filed with BSE, NSE, and SEBI.
- Go-live target: Formalities are expected to complete by May or June 2024, with the new company starting operations from 1st June or 1st July.
- Post-demerger margin ambition: Management is planning for retail EBITDA margins of around 20% once the businesses are separated, calling 20% the normal base going forward for the retail business.
- Financial disclosure gap: PAT and PBT cannot be segregated between retail and distribution until the demerger is complete, though management offered a tentative 7–8% PAT margin for retail.
BIS Regulation Risk
- January 2024 deadline: BIS regulations on footwear become effective from January 2024, and the company is closely monitoring the market while preparing for implementation.
- Supply chain exposure: Management acknowledges potential supply chain issues and is not front-loading inventory to prevent delays, but cannot yet quantify the margin impact because the cost of BIS-compliant products from Indian suppliers is unknown.
- China sourcing pivot: Since Chinese vendors will not pursue BIS certification, the company is trying to replicate Chinese designs through domestic manufacturing, a shift that introduces execution risk on both quality and cost.
Chaudhari: "we try to manufacture them in India because there are BIS problem because the Chinese vendor are not going to take the BIS. So, we are trying to give that same type of product in India only."
Margins & Profitability
- EBITDA margin under pressure: Operating EBITDA margin for Q2 stood at 11.2%, down 80 bps YoY, while net profit fell 64% YoY to ₹1.8 crores with PAT margins contracting 160 bps to 1.1%.
- Gross margin offset: The 400 bps YoY gross margin expansion to 45% was driven by two levers: raw material price softening and a richer mix of premium sub-brand products.
- Price increase planned: Another price increase is slated for the next festive season, which should support margin defense.
- Punjab receivables: The company will attempt to collect Punjab government receivables within this financial year, alongside the ₹28 crores already received from the UP government in Q2.
Chaudhari: "See what we have seen is that the raw material price has softened and also as I told you, we are considering some premium product in the sub brands. So, this added margin is increasing the EBITDA margin."
Leadership & Governance
- CEO appointment: Whole Time Director Rittick Roy Burman has assumed the role of CEO, with no plan to bring in a professional CEO at present.
- Brand ambassador: The contract with the current brand ambassador runs through March, with a renewal decision to be made when next year's budget is finalized.
- Information asymmetry: Management declined to provide a breakup of other expenses between retail and distribution, and deferred segregation of finance costs and depreciation until asset classification is complete post-demerger.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 7–8% growth for FY24 (cut from 10–12%) | FY24 |
| Demerger completion | KSR Footwear to begin operations | 1st June or 1st July 2024 |
| Retail EBITDA margin | Target of ~20% post-demerger | Next year (FY25) |
| Distribution recovery | Better results from corrective actions | Q4 FY24 onwards |
| Retail growth | Growth to resume as Puja sales shift | Q3 FY24 |
| Distributor expansion | 70–75 distributors in East | Ongoing |
| Price increase | Next price hike | Next festive season |
| Punjab receivables | Collection attempt | Within FY24 |
| Store openings | COCO stores of 1,000 sq ft, East-focused | Next year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹157 cr, degrew 15.6% YoY |
| Gross margin | 45%, up 400 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹17.6 cr, degrowth of 21% YoY |
| Operating EBITDA margin | 11.2%, down 80 bps YoY |
| Net profit | ₹1.8 cr, down 64% YoY |
| PAT margin | 1.1%, down 160 bps YoY |
| Distribution business revenue contribution | 27% of revenues in Q2 |
| Retail EBITDA margin | ~17.5% for the current quarter |
| Total distributor count | 741 as on H1 FY24, added 19 in the quarter |
| Sub-brand sales contribution | 60% of total sales, mother brand Khadim at 40% |
| ASP | ₹650, up 4% to 5% YoY |
| Sports shoe (Pro) volume contribution | ~20% of total volume |
| COCO business festive growth | 7% to 8% growth during Puja |
| Total debt | ₹116 cr, average cost 10% to 10.5% |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | 7% to 8%, revised from earlier 10% to 12% |