Key Takeaways
- Festive quarter, weak profit optics: Revenue grew 4.9% YoY, lifted by a festive-season shift into Q3, but reported net profit fell 62% YoY solely because a one-off factory-sale gain of ₹3.2 crores in the base quarter was absent this year.
- Retail gross margin jumped 410 bps YoY to 45.7%, driven by a richer retail mix and prior price hikes, while distribution losses persisted for a third straight quarter.
- Volume degrowth is easing: from early double digits in Q2 to early single digits at the YTD level in Q3, confirming the festive season worked, but non-festive demand remains sluggish.
- Demerger is delayed: stock-exchange approval is still pending, pushing the expected completion to August 2024, with the separate listing of the loss-making distribution business now a month after the NCLT order.
- What to watch next quarter: whether the muted Q4 retail outlook materialises as guided, any further slippage in the demerger timeline, and whether the distribution business can stop bleeding without management pushing sales.
Retail Engine: Festive Lift, Muted Q4 Ahead
- Festive shift inflated Q3: Puja sales moved into Q3, so COCO stores grew ~21% while franchisee sales had already occurred in Q2, leaving overall retail growth at 8%, in line with the guided 7–8% band.
- Volume story improving, not yet healthy: Volume degrowth narrowed to early single digits YTD in Q3 from early double digits in Q2; COCO volume grew 17% in the festive period, and franchisees saw double-digit secondary sales growth, but the non-festive market stayed sluggish.
- Sports shoes gaining share: contribution moved from 17% to 20%, with ladies sports shoes and higher-range products (₹1,500 to ₹2,500) performing well in COCO stores.
- Q4 set to soften: management expects retail to be muted with no festivity and demand subdued outside the festive window; the end-of-season sale has already begun, so retail margins will be lower sequentially.
- Store expansion funded: 15 new stores opened in Q3, taking the count to 864; next year’s plan is ~25 COCOs (mostly East, some South) and 65–70 franchisees, backed by ~₹12 crores of capex from the ₹15 cr preferential allotment.
Indrajit Chaudhuri: "In retail, we have made a growth of 8% because the distribution has gone down by 3%, so the overall growth is 5%. But retail, we have grown by 8%. So that we have told around 7% to 8%. But in the fourth quarter, I think retail will be muted."
Distribution Business: Still a Drag, Turnaround Not Priced
- Loss-making for three quarters: the distribution business continued to lose money; management is deliberately not pushing sales or increasing debtors, focusing instead on cost control and debtor reduction.
- Pockets of improvement exist: positive results are emerging from Bihar and UP, but the company is not going "whole hog" on a broad recovery push.
- Breakeven is conditional: management will try to make distribution EBITDA breakeven once the demerger happens, but any move into positive territory depends on demand improvement, with no quarter committed.
- BIS transition managed, cost impact contained: stock purchased before the 31 December 2023 deadline can be sold without BIS registration; from 1 January, all factory-made products are BIS-registered, and vendors are supplying BIS-compliant goods with only nominal cost increases. Management aims to hold MRP to protect volume growth, expecting no significant margin impact.
Indrajit Chaudhuri: "If the business improves. We are now working on the demand of the business. If it's -- the demand improves, then we can get a positive EBITDA. But we are not pushing for the sales and increasing our debtors."
Demerger: Process Creep, New Timeline
- Stock-exchange approval is the bottleneck: three of four bank NOCs are in hand; the in-principle approval from stock exchanges is taking longer than estimated because of ongoing questions and answers.
- Timeline has slipped: the initial target was June 2024; management now expects completion by August 2024, with the distribution business listing effective the first of the month after the NCLT order.
- Delay is procedural, not performance-linked: management explicitly denied that the distribution business’s losses are causing the delay.
- Post-demerger levers: once separated, the company can explore OEM outsourcing or other capacity-utilisation moves to reduce fixed costs, though no specific plan or timeline was given.
Indrajit Chaudhuri: "It is the process because there are lots of questions and back-to-back answers are going on. And also, we got the NOC from the bankers. So it is taking time from the NOC. We have got 3 NOCs from the bank. One is required. Once we give that, then the, in principle, approval will come from the stock exchanges. It is taking more time -- it is taking a little bit more time as compared to what we have estimated."
Margins: Mix-Driven Gain, Promotional Spend Offset
- Gross margin up 410 bps YoY to 45.7%: the improvement came entirely from a higher retail contribution producing a favourable product mix, plus the flow-through of price hikes taken in Q1; no further price hikes were taken in Q3.
- Distribution gross margin also improved: raw material prices became more stable, giving some lift to the distribution business.
- Retail EBITDA margin softened to ~16% from 17%+ last year, because festive-season schemes, promotions and gifting offers in COCO and franchisee stores were all booked in Q3.
- Q4 margin headwinds: retail margin will be lower sequentially as the end-of-season sale has started; distribution margin is expected to stay at the same level.
Capital & Strategic Moves
- ₹15 cr preferential allotment underway: 4,08,768 warrants issued at ₹365 each to one promoter and two non-promoter entities; 25% application money received, with the balance 75% due on conversion within 18 months. Funds are earmarked entirely for next year’s retail expansion and store refurbishment, not for the current year.
- Bangladesh exit confirmed: the subsidiary has no operations; management has decided to exit Bangladesh to focus on fixing the Indian business first, and will only revisit the geography once the Indian and distribution businesses are settled.
- E-commerce ambition is modest: the plan is to reach 4–5% of business through e-commerce.
- Punjab receivable stuck in litigation: the matter is pending in the high court, with a judgment expected in around 6 to 8 months.
Indrajit Chaudhuri: "There is no operation in Bangladesh company because now we are rectifying the Indian business. So we decided to just go away with the Bangladesh business operation. Once our Indian business and our distribution business settles, then only we look forward for the Bangladesh."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Demerger completion | NCLT process concludes; distribution business listed the following month | August 2024, listing by September 2024 |
| Retail EBITDA margin target | 18–20% achievable | Next 3 years, if retail grows 10–12% |
| Q4 retail performance | Muted, trying to hold volume at Q4 FY23 level | Q4 FY24 |
| Q4 retail margin | Lower sequentially due to EOSS | Q4 FY24 |
| Store additions | ~25 COCOs (East and South), 65–70 franchisees | Next year (FY25) |
| Retail capex | ~₹12 crores for new COCOs and refurbishment | Next year, funded by preferential allotment |
| E-commerce share | 4–5% of business | No date; stated as a plan |
| Punjab receivable resolution | High court judgment expected | 6 to 8 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹156.2 cr, +4.9% YoY |
| Gross margin | 45.7%, +410 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹18.2 cr, +8.7% YoY |
| Operating EBITDA margin | 11.7%, +50 bps YoY |
| Net profit | ₹1.8 cr, −62% YoY |
| PAT margin | 1.2%, −200 bps YoY |
| Revenue from operations (9M FY24) | ₹471.3 cr, −5.9% YoY |
| EBITDA margin (9M FY24) | 11.5%, +30 bps YoY |
| Retail sales contribution | 68% of revenue in Q3, 67% in 9M FY24 |
| Distribution business contribution | 28% of revenue in Q3, 30% in 9M FY24 |
| Retail store count | 864 as on 9M FY24, 15 new stores opened in Q3 |
| COCO store count | 221 as on 9M FY24 |
| Franchisee store count | 643 as on 9M FY24 |
| Distributor count | 747 as on 9M FY24, 6 added in Q3; East Zone: 481 |
| COCO volume growth | 17% in Q3 |
| Retail pairs sold | ~19 lakhs in Q3, ~20 lakhs in Q2 FY24 |
| Sports shoe contribution | 17% to 20% of revenue |
| E-commerce turnover (9M FY24) | ~₹18 cr, target 4% to 5% of business |
| Debt on balance sheet | ~₹122 cr, ~₹100 cr attributable to retail post-demerger |
| Factory utilization | Hawai 55%–60%, PU 80%–85%, PVC 40%–45% |
| Advertising spend (9M FY24) | ~₹6 cr |
| Retail capex planned (next year) | ~₹12 cr, funded via preferential allotment of ~₹15 cr |