Key Takeaways
- Asset quality stabilizes, but a monsoon hiccup hits profit: Stage 3 held flat at 4.3% and Stage 2 continued its decline, yet a temporary $300 cr tractor provision from a delayed September monsoon pushed credit costs higher, compressing Q2 profit.
- NIMs squeezed from three sides: Margins fell to 6.6% as borrowing cost relief vanished, the mix shifted toward lower-yield prime assets, and growth came from cars and CVs; management is now hiking lending rates selectively to claw back to 6.8% by March.
- Growth engine running hot, with an upside case: Disbursements grew 20% YoY in H1, AUM growth is tracking above 20%, and management says it may revisit a 25% growth target if the Diwali offtake stays strong.
- Credit cost guidance held, but the bridge has changed: The 1.5%–1.7% year-end target is reaffirmed, yet last year's 1.2% was flattered by $1,300 cr of write-backs that won't repeat; the improvement now depends on collection-led Stage 3 reduction.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the $300 cr tractor provision actually reverses, the pace of the lending-rate pass-through, and the Diwali sales number that could unlock a 25% growth commitment.
Asset Quality: Stabilizing, With a Temporary Blip
- Stage 3 held the line: GS-3 stayed at 4.3%, flat QoQ and below the March closing level, while Stage 2 continued its declining trend and forward flows were arrested.
- Stage 2 trajectory supports future improvement: A continuously declining Stage 2 pool means future slippage into Stage 3 will be lower, which management argues will automatically drive credit costs down.
- The tractor provision was a timing issue, not deterioration: A delayed monsoon in a few markets between September 15 and 30 postponed cash flows by roughly a month, triggering a temporary $300 cr provision on the tractor portfolio; management calls it very temporary and expects reversal next quarter.
- Write-offs are tapering fast: H1 write-offs of $664 cr are already 40% below last year's $1,114 cr; management expects this number to keep declining as GS-3 trends toward 3%, though it will never reach zero.
- The credit cost bridge vs. last year: Last year's 1.2% credit cost was aided by significant write-backs of roughly $1,300 cr; this year's write-backs are expected to be lower, so the 1.5%–1.7% target represents genuine underlying improvement rather than a deterioration.
Iyer: "if you have a GS-2 which shows continuous decline, the future GS-3 will be lower than where we are today. And that automatically will lead to a much lower credit cost."
NIMs: Three Headwinds, One Lever
- Borrowing cost relief evaporated: Management had expected a 25–30 bps funding cost decline around the festival season, but global rate hardening and RBI's "higher for longer" stance have killed that expectation; borrowing costs are now seen as flat through FY24.
- Mix shift toward prime is a deliberate drag: A conscious strategic move into higher-quality customer segments and products (cars, personal segment of M&M, commercial vehicles) is depressing NIMs but also lowering opex and credit cost, a trade-off management accepts.
- Pre-owned vehicle compression adds to the mix effect: Growth in the higher-yield pre-owned vehicle segment has been compressed by vehicle availability challenges, though the festival exchange program should help.
- The rate lever is being pulled now: Selective lending rate increases on certain models, geographies and products have been announced this month; the benefit will trickle through between November and December, with the larger impact visible from Q4.
- NIM path: From 6.6% currently to 6.8% by March, with the 7% ambition retained for the following year.
Iyer: "we expected that the borrowing cost would come down, and we have made that statement that our expectation was around the festival and post festival, the borrowing cost would come down, but I think that's getting challenged, and we don't now believe that, that cost is going to come down."
Growth: Running Above 20%, With Upside Optionality
- Disbursement momentum is broad-based: Total disbursements grew 13% YoY in Q2 and 20% in H1, with pre-owned vehicle disbursements outpacing the total at 20% and 26% respectively, showing the strategy is being executed.
- Rural market trend has reversed: Historically, rural markets delivered lower disbursements, weaker collections and asset quality deterioration in the first two quarters; this year, all three fronts have improved.
- Infrastructure and government spending are tailwinds: Most states are on overdrive for infrastructure and mining, labour absorption is good, and elections in various states will support rural on-ground activity.
- The Diwali trigger: Management will reassess OEM projections after the festival; if Diwali offtake continues in a positive direction, it is willing to discuss raising the AUM growth target to 25%, with a decision expected in December.
- OEM price increases are an uncounted tailwind: No meaningful price increase has been seen from OEMs yet, but management is reasonably sure that if vehicle prices are pushed up next year, the same volume will generate additional disbursement.
- Capital is not a constraint: With a comfortable Tier 1 of 12%–13%, management sees no need for a fresh capital raise for at least the next 1 to 1.5 years.
Iyer: "if Diwali continues to go that direction, then probably our confidence to say that we are even willing to look at 25% asset growth is something that we will rediscuss."
Credit Cost: The Path to 1.5%–1.7%
- The commitment is firm: Management has no hesitation committing to 1.5%–1.7% credit cost by year-end, anchored in the fact that GS-3 at 4.3% and Stage 2 at sub-6% will reduce further through pure collection, repossessions, settlements and terminations.
- Second-half cash flows are structurally stronger: Post-monsoon harvest money, infrastructure contracting payments, government budget closure by March, and tourism all concentrate cash flows disproportionately in H2, supporting the collection-led Stage 3 reduction.
- The reducing H1 trend will continue: The credit loss trajectory seen in the first half will persist through H2, with recovery-led Stage 3 reduction as the primary driver.
- Provision coverage on Stage 1 and 2 will take time: LGD cover improvement is at least 9 months away and will stabilize only in the latter part of next year, so near-term credit cost improvement must come from Stage 3 reduction, not coverage releases.
Iyer: "we don't have a hesitation to make that commitment of where we think we will end up the credit cost to be because for a very simple reason, that if the GS-3 numbers are at 4.3%, and the Stage 2 numbers are at sub-6 level, we don't expect this going down through repossession, settlements, terminations and bad debts. This will go down further from year by pure collection."
Operating Costs: Investment Mode, Payoff Later
- Opex ratio to stay elevated: The 2.8% opex-to-assets level is likely to continue for the balance of the year as management accelerates investments in technology and data.
- The payoff timeline is FY25-26: These investments will start delivering visible benefit only from FY '25-26, meaning near-term ROA expansion must come from NIM recovery and credit cost reduction, not opex leverage.
- The ROA bridge holds: Management retains its 2.5% ROA target with the math: 7% NIMs minus 2.5% opex equals 4.5%, minus 1.5%–1.7% credit cost leads to roughly 2.5%–2.25% after tax.
Borrowing Cost & Rate Environment
- The rate-cut thesis is dead for FY24: Management now believes borrowing costs are unlikely to come down in the next 3 to 6 months, and this financial year offers no visibility of a decline; any relief is pushed to next year.
- Industry-wide rate pass-through is coming: If funding costs stay elevated, management expects all players will push up lending rates post-Diwali rather than continue absorbing the pressure.
- MMFS is moving first: The company is already increasing rates selectively and is not waiting six months to act.
Iyer: "At this stage, with what we are reading, hearing, understanding, it looks unlikely that it's going to come down in the next 3 months, 6 months' time. This financial year is not visible at all to bring down. Maybe it's after that."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Credit cost | Decline to 1.5%–1.7% from current ~2.3% | By March 2024 year-end |
| NIM | Expand from 6.6% to 6.8% | By March 2024 |
| Asset growth | Upward of 20%; potential revision to 25% to be discussed | By March 2024 year-end; revision decision in December |
| GS-3 | Improve from current 4.3% toward ~3%–3.5% | Over a period (March 2025 commitment) |
| Stage 2 | Decline toward 5%–5.2% | Over a period |
| Total Stage 2 + Stage 3 | Reach 8%–8.5% | As they progress |
| ROA | 2.5% | March 2025 target, reaffirmed |
| Opex benefit from tech investments | Start becoming visible | FY '25-26 |
| LGD cover on Stage 1 and 2 | Stabilize and begin improving | Latter part of next year (at least 9 months) |
| Capital raise | Not required | At least next 1–1.5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income | Not stated |
| Net interest margin (NIM) | 6.6%, expected to inch up to 6.8% by March 2024 and aim for 7% in the following year |
| Credit cost (full-year guidance) | 1.5% to 1.7%, down from current ~2.3% |
| Return on assets (ROA) target | 2.5% retained for March 2025 |
| Profit dip due to temporary provision | ₹100-odd crores dip in Q2 FY24 versus Q1 FY24 |
| Disbursement growth (total company) | 13% YoY in Q2; 20% YoY in H1 |
| Asset growth guidance | Upward of 20% for FY24 |
| Gross Stage 3 (GS-3) | 4.3% of assets, flat QoQ from 4.3% in June; GS-3 absolute at ₹4,024 cr vs ₹3,770 cr in June |
| Stage 2 | Sub-6%, declining trend |
| Collection efficiency | 96% plus |
| Provision arising from GS-3 increase | ₹120–130 cr |
| Write-offs | ₹350 cr in Q2 FY24 vs ₹310 cr in Q1 FY24; H1 FY24 write-offs at ₹664 cr, 40% below H1 FY23 |
| Pre-owned vehicle disbursement growth | 20% YoY in Q2; 26% YoY in H1 |
| Dealer advances (trade advance) | ~₹5,000 cr, non-earning |
| Opex to assets | 2.8% in H1 FY24, expected to continue at similar levels for the full year |
| Capital adequacy (Tier 1) | 16.7% plus 2% headroom; comfortable range 12%–13% |