Key Takeaways
- Asset quality inflection, credit cost halved: GS3 improved to 4.0% from 4.3% QoQ, and credit cost fell sharply to 1.2% from 2.4%, putting the full-year 1.5%-1.7% credit cost guidance firmly on track.
- NIMs expanded 30 bps QoQ to 6.8% as yield rose 50 bps (driven by fee income, not rate hikes) while cost of funds rose only 20 bps; management recalibrated the medium-term NIM aspiration from 7.5% to 7%.
- Tractor and SME portfolios are shrinking by design: Tractor de-grew 18% QoQ in line with industry, while SME de-growth reflects a deliberate shift away from wholesale and larger enterprises toward granular, LAP-led retail.
- The ECL model refresh added granularity but not overlays: Stage 3 coverage rose 50 bps to 62.7%, but management expects coverage to normalize lower by Q3 next year as past high write-offs roll out of the 42-month history window.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised Q4 forward-looking business model refresh delivers concrete asset quality and growth targets, the trajectory of opex-to-assets toward the 2.5% aspiration, and any stabilization in the tractor portfolio after prolonged agri stress.
Asset Quality: The Turn Is Here, but Coverage Stays Elevated
- GS3 improved to 4.0% from 4.3% QoQ, driven by better customer behavior as ground-level conditions improved; Stage 2 not growing is a clear signal that Stage 3 is not expected to grow further.
- Credit cost fell to 1.2% from 2.4% QoQ because the sharp reduction in GS2/GS3 seen last year (210 bps) did not repeat, so the provision write-back was smaller (INR121 cr vs INR343 cr); settlement and disposal losses were also significantly lower.
- YTD provisions swung by INR980 cr (from INR613 cr release last year to INR368 cr charge this year), but write-offs reduced by INR500 cr (INR1,612 cr to INR1,113 cr), showing fewer assets flowing into bad debts.
- The Q2 asset quality bump was tractor-specific, caused by unseasonal rains impacting cash flows; the company has steadily reduced exposure to the most volatile cohort in the long tail of earn-and-pay customers across vehicle categories.
- Collection efficiency is range-bound: Q3 is slightly lower than Q2 because of festive period dynamics, but on a comparable basis (Q3 this year vs Q3 last year), the range is similar.
- Bad debts coming down while terminations go up is a positive trend, meaning the company is able to reach out to customers, negotiate and settle rather than write off.
Ramesh Iyer: "I think true to our belief, the customers, we always felt as things improve on the ground, we would see them perform in a way very different from when the things are difficult. And that's been reflected in our numbers quarter-over-quarter. And they have shown their resilience and they have been able to repay very, very regularly."
ECL Model & Coverage: A Mechanical Overhang, Not a Risk Signal
- The ECL model was refreshed at a product classification level this quarter, adding granularity as individual product portfolios have grown over the last four to five years; there are no management overlays in the provision number.
- Stage 3 coverage increased 50 bps to 62.7% as a model-driven outcome based on LGD and PD; if Stage 3 stays at 4%, the higher charge will not continue because the charge only comes from book growth or if Stage 3 goes up.
- Coverage is expected to normalize lower by Q3 next year because the model uses a 42-month history, so past high write-offs keep impacting until each year rolls out; as the book continues performing well (as it has for two years), the benefit will start showing.
- Management declined to give exact guidance on PCR/LGD levels returning to previous 35%-40%, calling it tantamount to forward guidance; some stabilization of LGD is expected in the next fiscal.
Ramesh Iyer: "And therefore, in the past, if you have had higher write-offs, that is always going to keep impacting until each year starts moving out, right? So when the book starts performing well, which has been the case in the last two years, you will start seeing the benefit of it come down, and that's the time the coverage will fall."
NIMs & Yield: Fee Income Drives the Expansion
- NIMs improved 30 bps QoQ to 6.8% because income to average assets rose 50 bps while cost of funds rose only 20 bps; most of the 45 bps QoQ yield expansion came from fee-based income, not rate increases.
- A marginal rate hike of ~20 bps was taken but will be passed on mostly; the sequential yield bump also reflects Q2 trade advances converting into retail, plus other income sources where investments are now adding to the overall income level.
- The medium-term NIM aspiration has been recalibrated from 7.5% to 7% due to cost of funds movement; management says the company is moving decently well against the 7% target.
- Loans are fixed rate, so as borrowing costs start to come down, the company would get the benefit of NIMs; historically, when borrowing costs rose, the company bore that cost, and a similar reverse benefit will be seen when rates ease, though management cannot put a number or date to it.
- Other income items are not lumpy and the company plans to sustain and grow them over time.
Portfolio Strategy: Exiting Crowded Pools, Building Differentiated Ones
- Consumer durable loans have been sunset after a December decision; as a late entrant, the company found entry barriers too high and the market too crowded, so it is not going forward with that business.
- SME is shifting from wholesale to granular retail: de-growth is on wholesale business, not retail; the focus is now on enterprises with turnover below INR25 crores, with LAP as the mainstay; medium enterprises above INR25 crores are being given up where banks are aggressively pricing.
- LAP business has been restructured with a new head (joined three months back, ran LAP at scale elsewhere), a separate underwriting team, a separate FCU unit, and a separate collection vertical, all added in Q2 of this fiscal; the company sees LAP growing stronger going forward.
- Personal loans are done only on the existing customer base and are still in an early learning curve; once full conviction is achieved on scorecards, the company will amplify monthly throughput.
- Used vehicle composition is increasing every month and every quarter, driven by formalization and underpenetration; this remains a structural growth opportunity.
- Self-generated business at ~15%-20% of originations remains a big strategic differentiator when competing with banks and other NBFCs.
Raul Rebello: "We realized there is a crowding in the market, and as a late entrant, the entry barriers are too high. So we have actually sunset our consumer durable aspirations, and we're not going forward."
Growth & Demand: Tempered but Structurally Supported
- Core vehicle finance grew 10% for the quarter and 20% for the 9-month period, but overall FY25 disbursement growth will be tempered compared to FY24; the company is willing to give up some business rather than compromise on quality, having tightened all norms.
- Passenger vehicles: after good growth, inventory at dealerships is back to ~2 months, so sub-10% growth is expected; the premiumization theme (SUVs becoming the bulk of PVs) means ticket sizes are rising.
- Tractors are in a tough spot with de-growth and very low rabi sowing data, reflecting prolonged stress in the agri segment; the company is not losing market share.
- Rural market sentiment continues to be positive because the four cash flows on which rural depends (tourism, people movement, infrastructure, farm) remain positive; support prices would be adequate to cover any yield drop.
- Branch expansion of 100-150 branches is planned over the next 1-1.5 years, with the cost baked into opex assumptions; investments will continue in technology, data, and people capability, bringing temporary P&L pressure but disproportionate benefit over a 3-year horizon.
- The proportion of new-to-credit customers is coming down overall, and even within new-to-credit, the company is focusing on prime layers rather than the most volatile cohorts.
Opex & Investments: Efficiency Gains Offset Build-Out Costs
- Opex to assets did not rise in H2 as earlier expected and is being held at 2.8%; management aims to keep it there currently, with the model requiring a decline to 2.5% over time.
- The 2.5% aspiration by end of FY25 is acknowledged as aggressive; investments already made in digital transformation are starting to show results, and the company is being frugal and efficient while continuing to invest.
- Digital transformation milestones: end-to-end digital journeys have gone live for personal loans (existing customers) and fixed deposits, with part-digital/part-phygital journeys for vehicle loans.
- Funding cost has likely peaked: the liquidity environment remains tight but availability has not been an issue given the company's credit rating; regulators (Fed and RBI) do not seem in a hurry to reduce benchmark rates, so this is likely the peak cost of funds.
- Incremental cost of funds is expected to remain in the ballpark of Q3 levels, though the situation is very dynamic and difficult to estimate precisely.
Raul Rebello: "We run a very efficient shop, a very productive shop, making sure that part of the investments we've already made are starting to show results. So we are looking at keeping this 2.8% right now. And finally, the model requires us to come down to a 2.5%. So that's how we are fashioning the business model and the number on opex to be achieved at."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Full-year credit cost | 1.5% to 1.7% range | FY24 |
| Coverage ratio normalization | Expected to come down from current 62.7% | By Q3 FY25 |
| NIM aspiration | 7% (recalibrated from 7.5%) | Medium term |
| Opex-to-assets | Hold at 2.8% currently, model requires 2.5% | 2.5% aspiration by end FY25, acknowledged as aggressive |
| Branch expansion | 100-150 new branches | Next 1-1.5 years |
| Disbursement growth | Tempered compared to FY24 | FY25 |
| Forward business model refresh | More granularity on forward plans to be provided | End of Q4 FY24 |
| Housing finance | No value unlocking until basics are in place; focus on bringing down GNPA | No timeline |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Loan book | ₹97,048 cr, +25.5% YoY |
| Disbursements (cumulative YTD) | ₹40,916 cr, +14.4% YoY |
| Disbursement growth (Q3) | +7% QoQ, +14% YoY |
| NIM | 6.8%, +30 bps QoQ; YTD at 6.7%, 90 bps lower YoY |
| Income to average assets | 13.1%, +50 bps QoQ |
| Cost of funds | 6.3%, +20 bps QoQ; overall cost of funds at 7.8%, incremental at ~8% |
| PPOP (YTD) | ₹3,005 cr, +7% YoY |
| PAT (YTD) | ₹1,141 cr, vs ₹1,300 cr last year |
| ROA | 2.1%, vs 0.9% in Q2 |
| Credit cost | 1.2%, down from 2.4% in Q2; full-year guidance of 1.5% to 1.7% |
| GS3 | 4.0%, down from 4.3% QoQ; 190 bps lower YoY |
| Net Stage 3 | 1.5%, 100 bps lower YoY |
| Stage 2 | 6.0%, 240 bps lower YoY |
| Stage 3 provision coverage | 62.7%, +50 bps QoQ |
| Write-offs (YTD) | ₹1,113 cr, vs ₹1,612 cr last year, a reduction of ~₹500 cr |
| Capital adequacy | 18.3%; Tier 1 at 16.5% |
| Collection efficiency | 95%, down ~100 bps QoQ from 96% |
| M&M share of disbursements (YTD) | 45% |
| Used vehicle share of origination | 17% |
| Core vehicle finance growth (Q3) | +10% QoQ; +20% for 9M |
| GNPL as per RBI norms | ~5.5% |
| Self-generated business | ~15% to 20% of business |