Key Takeaways
- Profit crossed ₹600 crore, but the real story is stabilization: Q4 profit exceeded ₹600 crore and full-year profit neared ₹1,000 crore, driven by a complete provisions write-back and aggressive repossession strategy. The quarter marks a pivot from survival to rebuilding the growth engine.
- Asset quality is healing, but the GNPL number is being withheld: Gross Stage III has come down significantly from Q1 peaks, and management calls it a "6% gross NPA business." Yet the company declined to disclose the current IRAC GNPL number, saying it wants to report the actual figure as the correction pans out.
- AUM-doubling ambition rests on rural, pre-owned, and new engines: Management targets doubling AUM in three years, leaning on rural infrastructure spend, pre-owned vehicle leadership, and new secured SME/LAP/leasing verticals that will contribute 15% of the growth story.
- ROE is "just not acceptable" at current levels: ROA improved to 1.3% from 0.4%, but management's first happiness milestone is 12% ROE, progressing to 15% and then 18%, built on a 3% ROA model with cost of credit and opex each capped at 2%.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the withheld GNPL number is disclosed and how much of the ₹500–1,500 crore worst-case provision actually materializes by the September RBI deadline; the pace of AUM growth now that the book has stopped shrinking; and any update on the co-lending partnership with a large bank.
Asset Quality: The Knowns and the Undisclosed
- Gross Stage III trajectory: Gross Stage III assets have come down significantly from Q1 levels, with every quarter after Q1 showing improvement. Collections efficiency has been very good, and Stage II has moved on substantially.
- The 6% conviction: Management states the business is fundamentally a 6% gross NPA business and has clear ways to get there, starting with stabilizing the book so that number is not breached again. If adjusted for 100% provision on 18+ accounts, gross NPA is already below 6%.
- Denominator pressure: The book not growing at all creates denominator pressure on the GNPA ratio; even 10–15% book growth would mechanically deliver a 1% gross NPA correction.
- IRAC GNPL gap: The company is using the six-month RBI window until October 1 to reduce the gap between IRAC NPAs and IndAS NPAs, aiming to minimize the difference by Q3 next year. The entire effort is to catch customers early at 30 DPD and 60 DPD using reminder notices, recall notices, and swift repossession if behavior is intentional.
- The undisclosed number: Management declined to disclose the current GNPL number, stating they see a correction happening and want to come back with the actual figure as it pans out. Their belief is that by the September-end deadline, they may not have to make any provision if the market continues as it is; worst-case provision is ₹1,500 crore, best case is ₹500 crore.
- Provisioning stance: The company changed its bad debts policy and made aggressive provisions, taking a view on 18+ accounts and making 100% provision without writing them off. Provisions were completely written back by the end of the year; what shows in credit costs is primarily bad debts written off, some aggressive calls taken, and losses from an aggressive repossession strategy of almost 55,000 vehicles repossessed versus 38,000 the previous year.
- Loss given default: Has remained in a range, with no sudden increase or decrease experienced.
Ramesh Iyer: "we believe that we have now come to a situation where we can clearly feel that it's a 6% gross NPA business."
Growth Roadmap: Doubling AUM in Three Years
- Core vehicle growth: Management expects core vehicle volume growth of 10–12%, with vehicle prices rising 5% and then another 5% over three years, contributing to disbursement growth. Market share in the non-Maruti car segment is targeted to grow from 3–5% to 7–9% via rural sales.
- Pre-owned vehicle engine: Pre-owned vehicle financing is a definite growth engine, with demand coming from consumers wanting a vehicle but unwilling to invest in new, and from operations where a new vehicle is uneconomical. The company is the #1 NBFC in pre-owned vehicles and next to HDFC overall. Incrementally close to 20% of sourcing comes from used vehicles, giving an advantage on NIMs.
- New verticals: New businesses including SME, LAP, leasing, and Digi FinCo will contribute 15% of the total growth story. NPAs in these segments are down and incremental business is coming in at a good clip. Bill discounting, largely within the Mahindra ecosystem, was one of the largest upsides for the year.
- SME strategy: Largely on the secured side, with term loans in three specific industries: Auto, Engineering, and Agri processing. The portfolio is being extended to micro-LAP as a new product.
- M&HCV approach: The company will play in the tipper segment for contracting customers who also use tractors, but will give up the large fleet operator segment. It may play in the midsize 3–5 vehicle segment.
- Cross-sell ambition: Management sees a great opportunity in short-term personal loans to existing customers who currently borrow from family, friends, or local traders, plus fixed deposits and mutual funds for customers with surplus. Personal loan penetration is increasing every month via pre-approved lists. Having many more products per customer is actively a goal for all employees this year.
- Partnership pipeline: The company signed up with three vehicle aggregators in the last quarter, with end-to-end digital journeys created but not yet launched, offering huge potential to scale.
- Co-lending: Interesting conversations are underway with one of the biggest banks in the country; progress to be announced soon.
Ramesh Iyer: "even to say it is very difficult. It's not easy said and difficult to do. Both ways it's difficult."
Rural Demand & Customer Behavior
- Sentiment has turned positive: Customers have money but are cautious about spending all of it due to health and medical contingency concerns from the last one to two years. Need-based products like vehicles and tractors are being bought as productive assets; aspirational products are not being invested in. Two-wheelers are not doing as well as vehicles because people are trying to graduate to pre-owned vehicles.
- Farm cash flow held up well: Monsoons were good, yields were good, support prices were good. Cash flow came in two to three installments on time, unlike prior years with more installments and delays. Reports say the coming monsoon is likely to be average, which is very good news from a rural point of view.
- Output prices vs input costs: Management is seeing better terms of rate overall for rural customers because while inflation is going up on some input costs, output prices are far higher, creating bullishness in rural.
- Fuel price impact: Freight rates and passenger fares will move up and get adjusted, though it may come with a lag of a quarter where operators suffer.
- Land and gold wealth effect: Rising land and gold prices improve wealth on paper but do not translate to immediate cash flow improvement because customers hold these assets forever. During the pandemic some pledged them; now they have released them back.
- All segments performing: Tourism picked up, schools started, temples and religious tourism restarted, people movement started big time, infrastructure is doing well, farmers held up. No segment today can be complained of as not doing well.
- Vehicle inventory shortage: Disbursements grew 50%+ for the quarter and 45%+ for the full year, but could have been even better if not for vehicle inventory shortages. Demand is high and footfalls at dealers are high, but inventory is a short-supply item.
Dr. Anish Shah: "And we are actually clearly seeing in better terms of rate for them, overall, because while inflation is going up on some of their input costs, their output prices are far higher. And that's what's creating the bullishness that you see right now in rural."
Margins, Profitability & the ROE Roadmap
- NIM stability: NIM remained stable at about 7.6%. While the company consciously took a knock on lending rates to onboard better-quality, affluent customers, low borrowing costs helped maintain NIMs at a healthy level. Management is confident of retaining 7.5% NIM, supported by the product mix of pre-owned vehicles and tractors at high yields, plus borrowing at best price.
- Opex ratio: Ended the year at 2.7%. FY21 was an abnormal year on opex; FY22 had reasonable mobility except for Q1. Opex ratios will likely remain slightly elevated before starting to come down once the balance sheet reaches a certain size, because capacity is already invested and not fully utilized. As volumes pick up, the company may not have to add further cost.
- Credit cost normalization: Credit costs are expected to normalize to a much lower level going forward.
- The 3% ROA model: The business is built on a simple model: 7–8% NIMs, with cost of operation and cost of credit each restricted to 2%, yielding a 3% ROA. This was demonstrated in the 2010–2014 period. Current ROA improved from 0.4% in FY21 to 1.3% in FY22.
- ROE target: Current ROE levels are "just not acceptable." The first step of happiness is reaching 12% ROE, then showing progress towards 15% going up to 18%. If leveraged at 5.5x and earning 2.5–3% ROA, getting to that roadmap should not be a challenge if market volatility is addressed.
- Rural affluent trade-off: Yields on the rural affluent segment may be lower, but cost of operation and provision costs will be lower because these customers do not require physical collection visits. At the ROA level, the company will not lose anything; it is just a line-item readjustment.
- Capital adequacy: At 27.8%, capital adequacy is very high because capital was raised during pandemic uncertainty to ensure extreme financial discipline and stability. Management acknowledges this means low leverage but also means enough capital to grow without raising further capital for at least the next couple of years. The intent is not to keep very high capital adequacy and not leverage it.
Ramesh Iyer: "I think our first step of happiness would be as we reach a 12% ROE and show a progress towards 15% going up to 18%."
Organizational Reset: People, Tech & Risk
- Senior leadership rebuild: Raul Rebello joined from Axis as COO of Core Business; Vivek Karve joined from Marico as CFO; Atul joined as HR Head from M&M System; an independent Chief Risk Officer was hired from HDFC Bank, where she helped build retail credit policy for 20 years; Dinesh joined as CTO; Mohit Kapoor, Group Tech Head, spends 50%+ time with Mahindra Finance; Amit Raje from Goldman Sachs is building the digital part.
- Independent risk function: The CRO has built a fully independent credit policy and risk team that is being further strengthened. She has sessions directly with the Board without management present.
- Technology investments: The company is upgrading core systems, appifying the core system, and has onboarded an API tech platform. Digitization of various legs of loan journeys including acquisition and fulfillment has started. Dealer apps and dealer frontends are being built. Recruitment is heavy for data engineering and data analytics teams. Legal tech solutions have been onboarded for granular visibility of litigation across the country.
- Multi-bureau engagement: Significantly upped in the last nine months, used for micro-market segmentation, monitoring, and customer alerts.
- Collection War Room: Uses analytics for early warning signals. A specific team has been commissioned for full curing and stabilizing contracts from flowing forward from each age bucket (Age-I, Age-II, Age-III).
- Branch-level transformation: Recruiting people locally who understand local challenges and language, many from farming families. Building capabilities for affluent financing with a different consumer-handling approach. Training on technology tools and effective use of data combined with local knowledge.
- Phygital philosophy: The business will be "phygital": branches and people will play their role, technology and data will play their role. The company is not transforming to digital-only.
- Strategy differentiator: Using 0.2–0.3 crore live customers in 400,000 villages to generate more inquiries; the ambition is to know when anybody wants to buy a vehicle much before anybody else, becoming a self-generating and converting company.
Ramesh Iyer: "we will be a self-generating and converting company. And that's going to be our strategy differentiator out there."
Regulatory & External Factors
- RBI inspection observation: The RBI observed that IRR was not indicated to customers. Management made a provision as observed and started refund to customers. When asked why this is coming now if it is business as usual, management deflected, saying it would be discussed later. Dr. Anish Shah stated the company takes everything the RBI says very seriously and is making sure it is fully in compliance in both letter and spirit.
- Banking license: As an industry house, current regulation does not permit banking. The Mahindra Group will always look at this opportunity, explore, analyze, and see the route. Management will be conscious not to destroy value while building a new line and will have to translate existing value into new value.
- Competitive landscape: Management stated that before choosing a vehicle, nobody chooses a finance, and that today nobody is unable to get credit. All players are jointly expanding the market.
- Customer repayment behavior: Customers think they have to pay a monthly installment and choose to pay any time in the month. Discipline is required internally to reach the customer before the due date. Product design may need to be relooked at to suit customers better.
Dr. Anish Shah: "We obviously take everything the RBI says very seriously. And it's something that we are just making sure that we are fully in compliance with RBI's guidelines, in both letter and spirit."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM doubling | Double AUM from current levels, driven by core vehicle growth, pre-owned, and new verticals contributing 15% | Next three years (Vision 2025) |
| Gross NPA target | Bring gross NPA to 6% | No specific date; stabilization underway |
| ROE roadmap | Reach 12% ROE as first milestone, then progress to 15% and up to 18% | No specific date; conditional on market volatility being addressed |
| ROA target | Achieve 2.5% ROA to start with, on path to 3% | No specific date |
| IRAC GNPL provision | Minimize gap between IRAC NPAs and IndAS NPAs; belief that no provision may be required by deadline | By September-end RBI deadline (Q3 next year) |
| Capital raise | No further capital raise needed; current capital sufficient for growth | At least the next couple of years |
| Cost ratios | Higher cost-to-AUM ratio in the shorter run due to investments; operating leverage to bring ratios down as balance sheet grows | FY22/23 elevated; improvement as scale comes |
| Co-lending partnership | Announce progress on co-lending with a large bank | "Soon" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Disbursements growth | Upwards of 50% YoY |
| Full-year disbursements growth | More than 45% YoY |
| Total income | Down YoY, primarily due to provisions for refund of excess interest |
| Profit | Exceeded ₹600 cr for the quarter |
| Full-year profit | Just fell short of ₹1,000 cr |
| Net Interest Margin (NIM) | 7.6%, stable for the current year |
| Opex ratio | 2.7% for the full year |
| Credit costs | Provisions completely written back by year-end; remaining charge is primarily bad debts written off and losses from aggressive repossession |
| Vehicles repossessed | Almost 55,000 during the year, vs 38,000 in the previous year |
| Return on Asset (ROA) | 1.3% in FY22, up from 0.4% in FY21 |
| Capital adequacy | 27.8% |
| Used vehicle share of sourcing | Incrementally close to 20% |
| Life-to-date customer base | Close to 0.7 crore |
| Branch network | 1,400 branches, physical presence in 3,500 dealerships, servicing four of the six lakh villages in the country |
| Gross NPA (adjusted view) | Already below 6% after adjusting for 100% provision on 18+ accounts |