Key Takeaways
- A broad-based 50% disbursement surge: Q4 disbursements jumped 50% YoY, with full-year growth at 80%, driven by positive sentiment across every single state without exception.
- Asset quality transformed in one year: Gross Stage-3 fell from 8% to 4.5% and Stage-2 halved from 14.3% to 6%, a result of deliberate cuts to vulnerable customer segments and upgraded underwriting and collection toolkits.
- NIMs held steady at 7.6% despite rate pressure: Stability came from a product mix shift toward higher-yield used vehicles and tractors, plus improved cost of funds through granular PSL coverage and a new AAA rating.
- The turnaround is explicitly only halfway done: Management is targeting a 2.5% ROA, a cost-to-assets ratio of ~2.5%, and 15% AUM from new businesses within 3 years, but warns the OPEX journey will take longer than one year.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the OPEX ratio has truly peaked as guided, the pace of the housing finance clean-up, and any early signs of the rate cycle easing that management is watching carefully.
The Turnaround: Asset Quality Reset
- Stage-3 and Stage-2 collapsed: Gross Stage-3 improved from 8% in Q1 to 4.5% by year-end, while Stage-2 reduced from 14.3% to 6%, an absolute reduction of roughly 50%. IRAC gross NPA was brought below 6% to 5.9%.
- The mechanism was segment excision, not just recovery: A small part of the book that contributed very heavily to GNPAs was cut out, while the majority remains in the core portfolio. The composition of the most vulnerable customer segment in new acquisitions has started to come down over the last year.
- Toolkit upgrades made it stick: Underwriting scorecards, risk policies, and a collection war room described as "best in category" were all upgraded. The new book originated in the last 1.5 years is showing "pretty immaculate credit cost."
- Provision reversal exceeded commitments: The company reversed 106% of provisions taken in Q1 F'21 within the next 3 quarters, beating the 80-90% commitment it had made.
- Provision volatility is expected to fall: GNPA is now at a low number, 60% covered, with net at 1.9%. No overlays are being carried; all Stage-3 provisions are model provisions, and the restructured book is running down.
Ramesh Iyer: "You must look at it that if the GNP is already at such a low number and it's 60% covered for and your net is at 1.9, you don't expect volatility in these numbers to happen."
Growth Engine: Where the Book Is Heading
- Disbursements are firing across the map: Q4 disbursements were up 50% YoY and the full year up 80% YoY, with management noting every state performed well with no exception, a breadth not seen in past cycles.
- Preowned vehicles are the priority growth engine: The category ticks all boxes on NIMs, distribution ability, and very high ROAs. Demand in the preowned segment is very high, which also protects loan principal through strong collateral values.
- Market share was gained in every product: Deep local presence and self-generated business, which contributes 15-20% of volumes by bringing customers to dealers, helped the company "nibble a higher market share" across most asset categories last year.
- New businesses are being built for a 15% AUM target: SME, LAP (with a separate team and "some of the best leadership from the industry"), and Digi Finco (consumer and personal loans to the existing base) are being scaled to contribute 15% of overall AUM by the end of 3 years.
- Vehicle growth will be range-bound, so diversification is structural: Overall growth beyond vehicle will come from preowned vehicle, SME, and other line items; the company will "nibble much more market share" in vehicle asset categories that are inherently more attractive.
Ramesh Iyer: "At least in the past, we have seen some of the geographies don't perform as good as some others, but in this round, we have seen every state is doing well with no exception."
Margins & NIM Protection
- NIMs held at 7.6%, matching last year: Stability was delivered despite rate headwinds through a deliberate product mix shift toward used vehicles (PV, CV, tractor) where spreads are attractive, and toward tractor finance where yields and NIMs are very good and credit costs have come down to attractive ROA levels.
- Cost of funds is structurally improving: Improved ability to capture granular PSL (small marginal farmer, weaker section) makes assets attractive for securitization or on-lending. The newly obtained AAA rating provides borrowing benefits that help protect against a potential 20-25 bps rate increase.
- Credit cost stayed low at 1.2%: The reduction in both GS3 and GS2 enabled a healthy post-tax ROA of 2.3%.
- Borrowing cost outlook is uncertain but managed: Management's working hypothesis is a short-term pause in rate hikes, meaning the current rate trajectory may continue for a longer period; early signs of some easing are being watched carefully.
OPEX: Elevated Now, a Long Bridge Lower
- OPEX remained high by conscious choice: Investments in legal toolkits and IT developments kept costs elevated. The OPEX ratio may have peaked in FY'23 and is expected to remain range-bound for at least one year before starting to come down.
- The bridge from 3.2% to the 2.5% target will take longer than one year: The journey is not complete, and the model change for the long run will come through less collections effort (better customers), technology, and use of data. As investments complete, that will cause the bridge.
- Cash collection has already dropped sharply: From 80-90% historically to around 35-40%, because more customers are paying through ACH mandates or digital means. Management is confident this will go down further.
- Collection headcount has been stable for 18 months: No headcount has been added on collections; many collection folks moved to bad debt recovery or into the business. Going forward, the collections team is expected to remain stable.
Customer Strategy: Moving Upmarket, Staying Rural
- The vulnerable segment is being deliberately shrunk: The proportion of the customer segment that caused grief during COVID has started to come down in new acquisitions. The company is acquiring more rural and semi-urban affluent customers at lower price points but also lower OPEX and credit cost.
- PrimeX is a bottom-up ROE play: The approach targets a 2.5% ROE from that customer, who comes at roughly 1% OPEX or lower. PrimeX will be a certain percentage of the business, not the whole book; the core portfolio is not going away.
- Metro markets are explicitly off the table: Management stated clearly they would not come and compete in metro markets where they see no huge value proposition. The focus is on participating end-to-end in all other markets: high, mid, and earn-and-pay segments.
- Customers are bringing 20-25% margin money: This indicates sales are not driven by very high LTV or push sales, and customers allocate cash flows to earning assets, making them careful to repay.
- The model's historical perception is acknowledged: Management recognizes that inherent NPA volatility is why investors and analysts "have not liked this model a whole lot," and that the turnaround is about proving the franchise can deliver stable asset quality.
Anish Shah: "We are halfway through this turnaround. We're not completely there as yet. But we've got to be able to get to better asset quality, a much better customer experience than we deliver right now, lower costs than we have right now as well."
Housing Finance: A Deferred Question, a 3-Year Reset
- The business went through disruption in its geography: Customers hit by that disruption take much longer to recover. The business made good money in initial years, and current losses are only out of past profits.
- A strategy reset is underway: Segments to eliminate have been identified; the business has entered the affordable space; the strategy has been rewritten to cut the tail causing problems and underwrite appropriately.
- An IPO is the aspiration in 3 years: Management expects the business to show "a very different color" in the next 3 years, with the first step being to clean the book, the second to cut the tail, and then to underwrite appropriately in the affordable segment.
- A direct question on housing finance was deferred: When an analyst noted the business had not been discussed at all, management responded, "We'll come back to you," and the question was not answered in the call.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM growth | Double the book, built on solid risk practices; deliver 20% growth to get there | 3 years |
| Diversification | Other businesses (SME, LAP, Digi Finco) to contribute 15% of overall AUM | End of 3 years |
| NIM target | Consistently at 7.5% level | Ongoing |
| Cost-to-average-assets | Bring down to ~2.5% from current elevated level; OPEX ratio to remain range-bound for at least 1 year before declining | Longer than 1 year |
| ROA target | Overall ROA of 2.5% (closed at 2.3% in FY23) | Not specified |
| Branch expansion | Add 200 more branches in deep rural, high-pot locations | Up to 2025 |
| Core tech stack revamp | Revamp most core tech stacks including LOS, LMS, and digital front ends | Next 8 months |
| Housing finance IPO | Aspiration to IPO the housing finance business | 3 years |
| Credit cost guidance | No specific guidance provided; expectation is asset quality and provision stability will be better than the past | Once changes settle |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total income | Up 24% YoY for Q4; up 14% YoY for the full year |
| Disbursements | Up 50% YoY for Q4; up 80% YoY for the full year |
| PAT | Almost reached ₹2,000 cr, grew almost more than 100% YoY |
| NIM | 7.6%, maintained at the same level as last year |
| Credit cost | 1.2%, kept quite low thanks to reduction in both GS3 and GS2 |
| Post-tax ROA | 2.3% |
| Gross Stage-3 | 4.5%, improved from 8% in Q1 and 7.7% at the start of the year |
| Net Stage-3 | 1.9% |
| Stage-2 | 6%, down from 14.3% at the beginning of the year, almost a 50% reduction in absolute terms |
| Gross NPA (IRAC norms) | 5.9%, below the 6% mark; IRAC NPAs were as high as ₹3,700 cr at Q3 reporting |
| Provision coverage ratio | Almost 60% |
| Book growth (FY23) | 27% |
| New business contribution to AUM | 6%, target of 15% in 3 years |
| OPEX ratio | Around 3.2% for FY23, may have peaked out; target to bring down to 2.5% |
| Cash collection as a percentage of total collections | 35%, down from 65% pre-pandemic |