Key Takeaways
- Fraud overshadows an otherwise solid quarter: A ₹136 crores provision for extreme collusion at one branch drove a PAT swing of ₹341 crores YoY, but stress tests across all 1,300 branches found no similar evidence.
- NIM trajectory is the bright spot: Exit Q4 NIM reached 7.1%, and management is targeting at least 7% for the full year FY25, up from 6.8% in FY24.
- Asset quality levers are working: GS3 improved from 4% to 3.4% QoQ, and the structural write-off rate has dropped 100 bps from 2.6% to 1.6%.
- Mission 25 targets have been recast: ROA goal lowered from 2.5% to 2.2% and margin goal from 7.5% to 7%, with cost of funds cited as the major variable that moved against them.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q1 growth is indeed muted by elections, the pace of centralized control rollouts across branches, and any RBI action following the fraud disclosure.
The Aizawl Fraud: Detection, Provisioning & Fallout
- Extreme collusion uncovered: The fraud involved over 20 employees, five vehicle dealerships with their staff, and some bank employees conniving to open fake bank accounts and divert disbursement proceeds. Management described it as a case of "extreme collusion" involving stakeholders from three families within the organization.
- Detection mechanism: The fraud was caught through triangulation of risk-based alerts, operation-based alerts and market insights during a management review in the second half of March 2024. The branch's growth became a slight outlier only in FY24, not in FY22 or FY23.
- Provisioning and recovery: The company made a ₹136 crores provision as a worst-case scenario, moving all affected accounts to GS3. Eleven arrests have been made and the number is expected to grow. Bank employees involved were fired over the last week. Management expects recoveries as law enforcement actions progress.
- System-wide stress tests clean: Exhaustive portfolio analysis across all 1,300 branches Pan India found no evidence of similar fraud elsewhere. The review was conducted by statutory auditors and the Audit Committee.
- Geography-specific vulnerability: Northeast India, especially Mizoram, has low Aadhar penetration and is exempt from IT requirements, necessitating decentralized approvals. The company is now putting a special team there to overcome geography-level hindrances.
- Control upgrades underway: The next 50% of branches are prioritized for centralized checks and will go live in the next few months. A Fraud Control Unit head was onboarded in the last year and the team has been augmented. A new branch-head-led org structure with heavy emphasis on ops and risk controls is going live soon.
Raul Rebello: "What unfolded thereafter in the course of the investigations was a case of extreme collusion, and I repeat, 'Extreme Collusion', because this involved (+20) of our employees, 5 vehicle dealerships with their staff and even some bank employees."
Mission 25 Recast: ROA, Margins & the Cost of Funds Problem
- ROA target lowered to 2.2%: The original 2.5% post-tax ROA goal has been recast to 2.2%, which management called a reasonable base-case aspiration with possible upsides if things progress well. The biggest deviation in the ROA tree was NII, driven by cost of funds moving in a direction no one anticipated in FY22.
- Margin goal trimmed to 7%: The NIM target for FY25 has been recast from 7.5% to 7%, with management attempting to at least reach 7% for the full year by maintaining the Q4 exit level of 7.1%.
- Cost of funds the culprit: Management acknowledged that even six months ago everyone expected softening by Q3 FY24, but no relief came. There are no immediate signs of easing, and the next couple of quarters are expected to range in the 8% bucket. If the Fed and RBI get comfort on inflation in H2, some relief may come.
- Spread upside in a declining rate cycle: The company borrows decently floating but lends all fixed rates, so in a declining interest environment it stands to gain on spreads.
- Yield stagnation explained: Yields on loans have not moved meaningfully in the last 5-6 quarters because the mix is shifting toward passenger vehicles, which are growing 28% and carry a sizable prime customer component at a blended yield lower than the overall yield. Even a 20 bps pricing increase in Q4 produced no meaningful bump in overall income to average assets.
- Internal ROA bridge: Management shared an internal goal of a 25 bps lift in NII, 10 bps lift in OPEX, and 25 bps lift in credit cost to move from 1.7 to 2.2 ROA, but stressed this is not formal guidance.
Raul Rebello: "I think the major variable over there, which is something probably I don't think in Financial Year '22 anyone would have looked at the cost of funds moving in the direction in which it moved, right."
Asset Quality & Credit Cost: Structural Improvement Underway
- GS3 and GS2 both improved: GS3 decreased from 4% in Q3 to 3.4% in Q4, while GS2 slid from 6% to 5%.
- Write-off rate structurally declining: The write-off component in credit cost has shifted down from 2.6% to 1.6%, driven by continued focus on due-date collections and the performing books mix. Management expects further improvement from write-offs coming down, with provision numbers expected to stay the same. ECL model coverage stands at 63%.
- End losses muted but with a caveat: Q4 vs Q4 end losses were slightly muted because the company resorted to slightly higher settlements to clean up yards and sell repossessed vehicles at good price discovery. Overall, end losses are structurally declining quarter to quarter.
- Collections effectiveness improving: Improved through analytics, right toolkit engagement, and movement of contracts between soft bucket and hard bucket teams. No additional collection manpower has been added in two years.
- April collection efficiency dipped: April collection efficiency was 89%, below last April, attributed to minor election disruption and a combination of holidays toward month-end.
Growth, Mix & Branch Strategy
- AUM crossed ₹1,00,000 crores: A milestone quarter for assets under management.
- Segment growth secular except tractors and SME: Growth was broad-based across passenger vehicles, CV, used vehicles, and three-wheelers, with market share gained across these categories. Tractors saw degrowth due to industry-wide contraction, while SME degrowth came from vacating larger-ticket medium enterprises where bank competition made pricing unattractive.
- Used vehicle shift is deliberate: The share of incremental used vehicles went up in Q4 as part of a concerted effort. This shift, along with fee income increases and overall pricing efficiency, is an active revenue lever.
- Q1 growth expected muted: Elections in progress and sentiment drag from a muted Rabi crop in the agriculture segment are expected to weigh on Q1. Post elections, if sentiment improves and monsoons are decent, 14%-15% disbursement growth could still lead to 18% to 20% book growth.
- Branch expansion modest and light: The company is looking at close to 150 to 180 branches this year, with more to be opened in the second half. New branches will be light-mode, with very limited staff sitting in the branch; most staff are "runner boys" at the site of action. Only a couple of job families are earmarked for the branch, with the rest covering multiple branches and dealerships.
- Dealership presence matters more: The company has not prioritized many branches in the last two years. With 5,000-odd dealership points and an improving tech stack for loan origination and LMS, growth does not require prolific branch expansion. Branches solve for reputation and local presence, but partnerships and dealership presence are equally important.
OPEX, Other Income & Investments
- OPEX to average assets decreased: Driven by a rational headcount increase of under 2% for the full year. Management is looking at a maximum 10-15 bps gain from current levels and will not shy away from making investments in underwriting, fraud control, and other areas.
- Fee-based income starting to bear fruit: Q4 saw higher subvention and insurance incomes. Management is focused on "skinning the organization" for other income, and investments in fee-based income opportunities are starting to play out, which will give some data on NII.
- Talent investments: Leaders in BFSI segments joined recently in functions of underwriting, collections, and data analytics. The company will continue to spend on tech, digital properties, and manpower in underwriting, fraud control, and SME.
- Cybersecurity incident contained: The company was incapacitated for four days in March, but because they have three levels of backup, systems were brought back in full control with no material disruption to customers or servicing capability. Full disclosure was given to stock exchanges.
Subsidiaries & Partnerships
- Subsidiaries showing progress: MIBL crossed the ₹100 crore pack and is now in multiple lines including commercial lines, stores, life and health insurance. Mahindra Manulife crossed ₹20,000 AUM. The HFC is focused on asset quality correction and is close to a 9% GS3 reduction.
- Co-lending partnership with SBI is starting to show some volumes. Partnerships with various banks and entities are also being pursued on the SME side.
- Fraud at Mahindra Rural Housing Finance: A separate fraud occurred in the decentralized model at the HFC subsidiary. The company is engaging deeply with RBI and providing constant updates, and is prioritizing safeguarding designs on systems and controls, using this as a wakeup call to make systems full proof.
Raul Rebello: "We want to give everyone again confidence here that whatever happened in this one branch was an outlier and we did mention that we are making significant investments as management for this turnaround journey that we started about a year back and we are committed to make sure that the organization has the adequate amount of investments in place..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NIM target | At least 7% for the full year, maintaining Q4 exit level of 7.1% | FY25 |
| ROA target | 2.2% post-tax as base case, with possible upsides | FY25 |
| Book growth | 18% to 20% book growth, contingent on post-election sentiment improvement and decent monsoons | FY25 |
| Disbursement growth | 14% to 15% | FY25 |
| Branch additions | 150 to 180 new branches, more in H2 | FY25 |
| OPEX improvement | Maximum 10-15 bps gain from current level | FY25 |
| Centralized branch checks | Next 50% of branches to go live with centralized checks | Next few months |
| Cost of funds | Expected to sustain at Q4 levels, no immediate easing; possible relief if Fed and RBI get comfort on inflation | H2 FY25 (conditional) |
| New business contribution | 15% of overall mix | Medium term (no date) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹1,02,597 cr, +24% YoY |
| Disbursements | ₹15,292 cr, +11% YoY; full year ₹56,208 cr, +13% YoY |
| Revenue growth | +22% YoY (quarterly); +23% YoY (full year) |
| NII growth | +16% QoQ; +10% full year |
| PPOP growth | +24% YoY (quarterly); +11% YoY (full year) |
| PAT growth | -10% YoY (quarterly); -11% YoY (full year) |
| Provision swing | ₹341 cr swing between Q4 FY23 and Q4 FY24; ₹1,322 cr swing for full year |
| Cost of funds growth | +30% YoY (quarterly); +40% YoY (full year) |
| Incremental borrowing cost | ~8%, range-bound at Q4 levels |
| NIM | 6.8% for full year FY24; exit Q4 NIM at 7.1% |
| NIM target FY25 | 7% for full year, recast from initial 7.5% goal |
| OPEX growth | +2% YoY (quarterly); +8% YoY (full year) |
| OPEX to average assets | 2.8% |
| Headcount increase | Under 2% for full year |
| GS3 | 3.4%, down from 4.0% in Q3 and 4.5% in Q4 FY23 |
| Net GS3 | 1.3% |
| GS2 | 5.0%, down from 6.0% in Q3 |
| GS2 plus GS3 combined | 8.4%, down 200 bps YoY from 10.4% |
| Credit cost | 1.2% for Q4; 1.7% for full year (includes ₹136 cr fraud provision; 1.6% excluding fraud) |
| Write-off component in credit cost | 1.6%, down 100 bps from 2.6% (5-year average) |
| Stage-3 provision coverage | 63.2%; combined Stage-1,2,3 cover on Stage-3 at 97.5% |
| Performing book (Stage-1 + Stage-2) | 96.6% |
| Tier-1 capital | 16.4; Tier-2 at 2.5 |
| Liquidity buffer | 8.3% of outstanding borrowing |
| ROA | 1.7% for FY24; striving for 2.2% post-tax as reasonable goal |
| Book growth CAGR (last 3 years) | 17% |
| Aizawl fraud provision | ₹136 cr on 2,887 accounts, worst-case scenario |
| Branches | 1,300 Pan India; added 33 branches in Q4 |
| Dealership points | ~5,000 |
| Collection efficiency (April) | 89% |
| Debt-to-equity | 5:1 as of March 2024 |