Key Takeaways
- Cost relief is arriving, not yet in the numbers: Q3 EBITDA was flat QoQ at Rs. 256 crores as high input gas costs persisted, but a new government order prioritising cheaper HPHT gas for CGD entities took effect from February, promising a material cost reduction from Q4 onward.
- Volume growth story is intact but paused: 9M volumes grew 16.8% YoY, yet Q3 was flat QoQ as high selling prices dampened demand; management reiterated a 5–6% volume CAGR over five years, with FY24 growth contingent on price relief.
- Regulatory tailwind is the quarter's real news: The Kirit Parikh Committee recommended linking APM gas price to crude with a $6.5/MMBTU ceiling, a ~$2/MMBTU cut from current levels; implementation is expected around year-end or 1st April, and the HPHT priority allocation is already live.
- GA-3 (Raigad) is the next growth engine: The first City Gate Station and mother station are technically ready and awaiting statutory approvals; once commissioned, they will eliminate costly transportation from GA-2 and unlock a guided ~20% volume growth in GA-3 next year.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Kirit Parikh recommendations are accepted and implemented on time, the pace at which HPHT gas replaces spot LNG in the input mix, and the commercial start date for the Raigad CGS.
Input Gas Costs & the Policy Shift
- The cost squeeze: Domestic APM gas price for Oct '22–Mar '23 was set at $8.57/MMBTU, ~40% higher than the prior half-year, while pooled APM, CBG and HPHT allocation for the priority sector was marginally reduced QoQ, forcing MGL to use spot LNG at 0.27–0.35 MMSCMD.
- HPHT priority allocation: A new government notification reserves HPHT gas sold at the ceiling price for the priority sector (CGD first, then Fertilizer, LPG, Power), a step management called "very well appreciated." MGL began taking HPHT gas from Reliance via IGX auctions from 1st February, replacing costly RLNG in CNG and domestic PNG.
- Kirit Parikh Committee: The panel recommended linking APM gas price to the Indian crude basket import price with a dynamic ceiling of $6.5/MMBTU, an annual increment of $0.5/MMBTU for five years, and a floor of $4/MMBTU. If implemented as recommended, APM price would drop by ~$2/MMBTU from current levels, delivering better costs going forward.
- Spot LNG fading: With HPHT availability from January, the spot LNG quantum is coming down; management expects APM plus HPHT to meet priority sector requirements, with spot gas needed only minimally to balance peak demand.
- GAIL contract: Gas from the GAIL Henry Hub contract is being taken at the supply-or-pay level, not the full contracted quantity, due to supplier default and market conditions; management expects GAIL to increase supplies as spot prices soften, but there is no certainty.
Shinghal: "That if a gas which is being sold at a cap price should not go to the non-priority sector. That's a correction which the government has done by bringing in that the first HPHT gas if it is being sold on the ceiling should go to the priority sector. That's a very well appreciated step by the Government of India."
Volume Performance & Demand
- 9M strength, Q3 stall: Overall average gas sales grew 16.8% YoY in 9M FY23, driven by CNG volume growth of 22.21%, industrial & commercial growth of 5.3%, and domestic PNG growth of 3.37%. Q3 overall average sales were flat QoQ at 3.412 MMSCMD, with CNG declining from 2.541 to 2.474 MMSCMD.
- CNG competitiveness: CNG retains a ~45% discount to petrol and ~9% to diesel after a Rs. 2.5/kg price reduction effective 1st February, supporting demand; management hopes volumes will pick up after this price relief.
- Station throughput declining: An analyst noted a consistent decline in volume per CNG station; management attributed this to difficult industry conditions over the last 6–12 months due to high gas prices, making the timing inappropriate for long-distance CNG or LNG initiatives.
- Metro impact dismissed: A new Metro line opened a couple of weeks prior to the call; management saw no material change in CNG volumes and argued that reduced road congestion could even encourage more CNG car commuting.
Wagle: "If you look at the last 6 months or a year, it has been a difficult time for the whole industry. The gas prices being where they are etc. Long distance CNG or Port Trust or anybody going for LNG for that matter the timing is not really appropriate. But these are long term initiatives which will drive value in the long run for us."
Geographic Area Performance & Infrastructure
- GA-1 (mature): A very mature market after 27+ years; trunk steel pipeline is already laid, so current CAPEX focuses on security of supply (multiple looping) and last-mile connectivity, not major new network. Volume growth guided at 5–6% over the immediate 1–2 years, constrained mainly by lack of available land for new stations.
- GA-2 (growth): Relatively new (started ~2005), with more land available for CNG stations, a bigger area, and easier infrastructure laying, hence a higher growth rate than GA-1. Volume growth guided at 10% next year.
- GA-3 (Raigad, emerging): The first City Gate Station and mother filling station in Savroli are technically ready and awaiting statutory approvals. Once commissioned, the CGS will eliminate transportation cost currently incurred from GA-2 to GA-3, connect immediate industrial/commercial load, and allow daughter booster stations converted to online to nearly double sales from 3,000–4,000 kg/day to 6,000–8,000 kg/day. Volume growth guided at ~20% next year.
- GA-3 cost structure improvement: Transportation cost per kg of gas will be eliminated once the CGS is operational; depreciation will replace that recurring cost, and depreciation is a very small amount compared to recurring transportation cost. Logistics and manpower management costs will also be eliminated.
- CAPEX focus shifting: The CAPEX plan for the next few years will focus more on GA-2 and GA-3; next year, GA-3 will see planned laying of steel lines and more City Gate stations, with land being scouted. FY24 CAPEX is budgeted at a higher number, in the range of Rs. 600–800 crores, subject to permissions and land availability.
Financial Performance
- 9M FY23: EBITDA rose to Rs. 794 crores from Rs. 709 crores YoY; PAT rose to Rs. 521 crores from Rs. 465 crores YoY.
- Q3 FY23: EBITDA was Rs. 256 crores vs Rs. 253 crores QoQ, essentially flat as high input gas costs persisted through the quarter.
- Industrial vs commercial breakup: Management provided the split of 0.44 MMSCMD PNG industrial and commercial volume (0.318 industrial, 0.121 commercial) but cautioned that these categories keep changing and are not comparable with earlier periods.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume CAGR | 5–6% over 5 years, with variability (8–10% in some periods, 2% in others) | 5-year horizon |
| FY24 volume growth | 5% fair estimate; higher if Kirit Parikh recommendations accepted and prices reduced | FY24 |
| GA-3 volume growth | ~20% compared to current volume | Next year |
| GA-2 volume growth | 10% | Next year |
| GA-1 volume growth | 5–6% | Immediate 1–2 years |
| FY24 CAPEX | Rs. 600–800 crores, subject to permissions and land availability | FY24 |
| Kirit Parikh Committee implementation | APM price to decrease by ~$2/MMBTU from current $8.57/MMBTU if recommendations accepted as-is | Mostly by year-end or 1st April |
| HPHT gas substitution | ~10% of volume currently met by long-term or spot gases to be substituted by HPHT for almost all CGD companies, once Reliance and ONGC come out with next auctions | As auctions occur |
| Raigad CGS commissioning | Transportation cost eliminated, I&C load connected, daughter booster throughput nearly doubled | Awaiting statutory approvals (no specific date) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Overall average gas sales volume | 3.412 MMSCMD, flat vs 3.459 MMSCMD in Q2 FY23 |
| CNG sales volume | 2.474 MMSCMD, vs 2.541 MMSCMD in Q2 FY23 |
| Industrial and commercial sales volume | 0.439 MMSCMD, vs 0.447 MMSCMD in Q2 FY23 |
| Domestic PNG sales volume | 0.449 MMSCMD, vs 0.471 MMSCMD in Q2 FY23 |
| EBITDA | Rs. 256 crores, vs Rs. 253 crores in Q2 FY23 |
| 9M FY23 EBITDA | Rs. 794 crores, vs Rs. 709 crores in 9M FY22 |
| 9M FY23 net profit after tax | Rs. 521 crores, vs Rs. 465 crores in 9M FY22 |
| 9M FY23 average gas sales growth | 16.8% YoY, 3.4 MMSCMD vs 2.944 MMSCMD in 9M FY22 |
| CNG discount to petrol | ~45%, after factoring in Rs. 2.5 per kg price decrease |
| CNG discount to diesel | ~9% |
| Pool gas allocation for priority sector | ~91% of CGD requirements, marginally reduced QoQ |
| Domestic gas price (APM) | $8.57 per MMBTU, ~40% higher than Apr–Sep 2022 |
| Spot LNG consumption | 0.27 to 0.35 MMSCMD, depending on peak requirement |
| HPHT gas sourcing | ~0.27 to 0.275 MMSCMD, effective from 1st February 2023 |
| Total CNG stations | 301, 5 added during the quarter |
| Total industrial and commercial customers | 4,465, 82 added during the quarter |
| Domestic households connected in Q3 | 87,845, cumulative connectivity ~0.21 crore households |
| Pipeline laid in Q3 | 82.36 km, cumulative pipeline length over 6,407 km |
| Vehicle conversions in Q3 | ~16,900 total; ~12,200 taxis and cars, ~2,900 three-wheelers, ~1,700 LCVs, ~33 trucks |
| CAPEX spent up to December | Rs. 460–475 crores, full-year FY23 estimate ~Rs. 650 crores |
| FY24 CAPEX budgeted range | Rs. 600–800 crores |
| GA-1 volume contribution | 1.8 to 1.85 MMSCMD, growth expectation 5% to 6% over next 1–2 years |
| GA-2 volume contribution | 1.5 to 1.55 MMSCMD, growth expectation ~10% next year |
| GA-3 volume contribution | ~0.12 MMSCMD, growth expectation +20% next year |
| GA-3 addressable market size | 0.67 MMSCMD demand estimation |