Key Takeaways
- Volume-led quarter, margin trade-off accepted: FY24 sales volume grew 5.45% YoY to 3.609 mmscmd, with I&C surging 12.32% as management deliberately swapped per-unit margin for absolute profit growth.
- Unison Enviro acquisition now consolidated: Two months of UEPL operations are in the Q4 numbers, bringing provisional intangible assets and one-time costs that make standalone-to-consolidated comparisons unreliable for now.
- CNG station rollout hit a record: 36 stations added in FY24, the highest ever, with a target of 50+ in FY25; the commercial vehicle segment is growing fast in percentage terms but not yet moving the needle on total CNG volumes.
- Cash deployment is accelerating: Capex of ~INR 775 crores in FY24, guided to ~INR 800 crores p.a. for MGL plus INR 150–200 crores p.a. for UEPL, alongside new ventures in LNG, CBG and an EV start-up investment.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised 1 lakh SCMD of new I&C contracts actually connect in Q1/Q2, resolution of the OMC trade margin settlement, and any sign that commercial vehicle CNG volumes are starting to materially contribute.
Volume Growth & Segment Dynamics
- CNG volume driver: 20,000+ vehicles added in Q4 (13,000 private cars, 5,400 autorickshaws, 1,400 small CVs), but private car per capita consumption is low so incremental passenger cars are not the major CNG volume driver.
- Commercial vehicle promise: Good percentage growth in >1 ton commercial goods vehicles from the coupon scheme, but absolute numbers not yet materially moving CNG volumes; expected to take a few more quarters.
- Q4 seasonality reversed: Q3 is generally strong and Q4 seasonally lower, but this year Q4 showed a net increase from Q3 (3.671 to 3.779 mmscmd) unlike last year when Q4 was lower than Q3.
- Marketing scheme design: The INR 20,000 gas coupon scheme for new car buyers was not a CNG discount; it was stopped for passenger vehicles from 1st Jan 2024 but continued for commercial goods vehicles, and promotional schemes with manufacturers are intermittent by design to maintain urgency.
Shinghal: "What we are getting from them is saying that promotional schemes have to be intermittent. They cannot track on for a long time. Otherwise, the urgency and the imminent sense of - that the customer has to feel that, okay, if I don't buy now, maybe after 2 months, I will not get this opportunity."
I&C: The Margin-for-Volume Bet
- Pricing policy unlocked demand: A policy from 1.5 years ago guaranteeing new large customers a 10% discount to furnace oil for 3 years enabled signing over 1 lakh SCMD of new contracts, many now on stream and driving the 12.32% I&C volume jump.
- Pipeline is deep: Another 1 lakh SCMD worth of industrial contracts to be connected in the coming year, mostly after the construction season starts in Oct/Nov, so Q3/Q4 additions; 1–2 may add in May/June.
- Margin mechanics: Gross margin per SCM on I&C ranges from INR 25–30 down to INR 18–20 depending on customer class; management can work with INR 4–5 margin to win volume that would otherwise stay with furnace oil.
- The trade-off math: Margin per SCM may go down with higher I&C growth, but absolute margins go up; as long as the percentage increase in volume is higher than the percentage decrease in price, the company is better off financially.
- Operating cost advantage: I&C customers have larger volume per customer, so lower overheads than CNG and domestic PNG which incur higher power, billing and collection costs; margins after direct operating expenses are comparable or reasonably good.
Management: "If you want that volume, you have to take a hit on your margin. You can't get them with keeping a INR8 or INR10 margin, I mean, but you can always still work with the INR4, INR5 margin and get that volume."
Gas Sourcing & Cost Management
- Q4 weighted average gas cost: ~$7.25–$7.3/mmbtu, with APM allocation at ~74% of priority sector and HPHT availability helping keep the weighted average under control.
- Portfolio approach: Gas procurement blends Henry Hub and other sources, with shortfall managed through spot; selling is on alternate fuel linkage (LPG target price for commercial).
- Henry Hub flexibility: Take-or-pay limited to ~60% in current contracts; new contracts could be 70–80%; management can switch between reducing term contracts and taking spot when spot prices are comfortable or lower than HPHT.
- LNG for transport: Savroli station commissioned last year, selling ~4 tons per day on average and picking up over recent months; the Baidyanath LNG JV (51:49) expects its first station commissioned in 1 month and another 4 stations during FY25.
Unison Enviro Acquisition: Early Days, Opaque Numbers
- Consolidation impact: Two months of UEPL operations (Feb–Mar '24) are in the consolidated results; intangible assets of INR 520 crores mainly from license authorization (right to market gas across 3 GAs for economic life), customer relations and workforce, all on a provisional basis pending the valuer's final report.
- One-time costs muddy the picture: Consolidated results include one-time expenditures for PNGRB transfer and management consultancy expenses; accounting standards permit ~1 year to freeze the valuation, so direct standalone-to-consolidated comparison is not meaningful right now.
- Growth ambition: Management expects double-digit volume growth from UEPL, targeting CNG volume (the main profit and revenue driver) plus I&C in Ratnagiri sectors, backed by aggressive CapEx plans; results will start showing as that CapEx deploys.
- Funding commitment: MGL expects to provide INR 150–200 crores p.a. in funding for UEPL for 2–3 years until it starts generating internal cash for its own CapEx.
New Ventures & Capex Deployment
- Capex trajectory: FY24 Capex ~INR 775 crores; expected ~INR 800 crores per annum for MGL going forward, with internal budget approval already in place.
- CBG plant: MoU signed with BMC, Board approved the investment proposal; ~INR 550–600 crores CapEx across two phases; once land is obtained, ~1.5 years to commissioning.
- LNG JV: Joint venture company with Baidyanath LNG established at 51:49 equity; construction activities started, no sales yet as of 31st March '24; first station expected in 1 month, 4 more during FY25.
- EV investment: Equity investment in 3EV Industries, a start-up manufacturing 3-wheeler cargo and passenger electric vehicles, also involved in last-mile mobility through an associate.
- Surplus cash: Management is keeping tab on new opportunities and will endeavour to deploy surplus cash to diversify or strengthen the existing business.
Regulatory & Accounting Items
- OMC trade margin settlement: Continuous engagement with OMCs; the Ministry issued broad all-India guidelines; no dispute as such, but the interim 1.5-year period numbers are yet to be frozen, expected to resolve in a few months; adequately provided for in the accounts.
- Management declined to quantify the pending settlement amount when asked, calling it "not significant, not possible to quantify accurately at this point in time."
- Q4 opex spike: Other opex rose from ~INR 168 crores to ~INR 192 crores mainly due to INR 25+ crores in marketing schemes (CNG/PNG promotion, advertising) which is one-time and not recurring, plus Q4 maintenance expenses from the Oct–May construction season and CSR unspent amounts booked in the last quarter.
- Coupon accounting: Coupons given to vehicle buyers for CNG filling are booked as marketing expense when issued; revenue is booked when the coupon is utilized; there is no direct revenue linkage, but indirect profit and gross margin accrue to the company.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | 6% to 7% overall (CNG, DPNG, commercial); internal targets more aggressive | FY25 |
| I&C volume growth | Double-digit growth; another 1 lakh SCMD of contracts to connect | FY25, mostly Q3/Q4 |
| CNG station additions | More than 50 stations | FY25 |
| CNG station additions | ~40–50 stations | FY26 |
| MGL standalone Capex | ~INR 800 crores per annum | Ongoing |
| UEPL funding | INR 150–200 crores p.a. until self-funding | 2–3 years |
| CBG plant commissioning | ~1.5 years from land possession | Undated (land not yet received) |
| Baidyanath LNG JV first station | Commissioned in 1 month | Q1 FY25 |
| Baidyanath LNG JV additional stations | 4 stations | FY25 |
| OMC trade margin resolution | Settlement expected | "A few months" |
| MSRTC CNG buses | 100 more buses | Next 1–2 quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total sales volume | 3.779 mmscmd, up from 3.671 mmscmd in Q3 FY24 |
| CNG volume | 2.666 mmscmd |
| Domestic PNG volume | 0.563 mmscmd |
| Industrial & commercial volume | 0.55 mmscmd |
| Net PAT | ₹265 cr, down from ₹317 cr in Q3 FY24 |
| FY24 Net PAT | ₹1,289 cr, up 63% YoY |
| FY24 EBITDA | ₹1,843 cr, up 56% YoY |
| EBITDA per SCM | 13.95% (FY24 average); long-term guidance 9% to 11% |
| Weighted average gas cost | ~$7.25–$7.3 per mmbtu |
| APM allocation | ~74% of priority sector sales |
| CNG vehicle additions | Slightly more than 20,000 (13,000 private cars, 5,400 autorickshaws, 1,400 small commercial vehicles) |
| CNG stations added | 28 in Q4; 347 total as of 31st March 2024 |
| Domestic PNG connections added | 1,17,279 in Q4 |
| Industrial & commercial customers added | 108 in Q4; 4,769 total as of 31st March 2024 |
| Pipeline laid | 226.04 km in Q4; 6,968 km total |
| Marketing scheme expenses | More than ₹25 cr, one-time; Opex rose from ~₹168 cr in Q3 to ~₹192 cr in Q4 |
| FY25 volume growth guidance | 6% to 7% (internal targets more aggressive) |
| FY25 CNG station addition target | More than 50 |
| FY26 CNG station addition target | ~40 to 50 |
| Final dividend proposed | ₹18 per share; total FY24 dividend ₹30 per share (300% of face value) |
| Unison Enviro (UEPL) volume | ~0.14 mmscmd in Q4 (consolidated for Feb–Mar 2024) |
| I&C new contracts signed | 1 lakh SCMD worth; another 1 lakh SCMD to be connected in coming year |
| FY24 Capex | ~₹775 cr |
| CBG plant CapEx | ~₹550–₹600 cr for two phases |