Key Takeaways
- Raw material costs crushed margins: A more than ₹50 crores raw material cost increase, driven by a super-alloy-heavy product mix and high nickel prices, directly hit PBT and PAT this quarter.
- Order book tilts hard toward defense: Defense now dominates at ~70% of the order book, while the space segment has dipped significantly to ~15-16% as major supplies are completed.
- 25% growth target reaffirmed: Management expects not less than 25% year-on-year growth if the trend continues, and is planning for a similar trajectory in FY25 and FY26, capacity permitting.
- Working capital is a persistent choke point: Inventory and receivables are both under pressure from high raw material costs and slow government payments, creating a "tremendous" finance challenge even without taking working capital loans.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the expected second-half margin recovery materializes as raw material consumption is minimized, and if the projected ₹700 crores in new orders actually lands.
Margin Pressure: The Raw Material Bite
- Super alloy mix drove cost surge: Production of super alloys, which require virgin pure raw material for aerospace-grade heats, went up this quarter, directly inflating raw material consumption costs.
- Nickel price is the main villain: Nickel, a very costly raw material, saw a substantial price increase from FY23 to FY24, with LME-driven fluctuations that are too big for the company to stock against when prices dip.
- Fixed-price contracts offer no relief: Orders are booked on fixed prices with no variable costing for raw materials, and customers like HAL and aircraft manufacturers cannot absorb raw material fluctuations in their own fixed-price projects.
- Hedging is off the table: Hedging is not allowed for the company, and management argues that even if it were, a bet on rising prices could backfire if prices fall.
- Second-half margin hope: Management expects the second half to be better because raw material consumption was substantial in the first half, and they are trying to minimize it going forward.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "If we add up so much price for the raw material itself, probably we will not get the order itself. That is the first thing. Now next that we are -- whatever the margin you have to keep, you have to keep from that particular time. You cannot go for predicting that raw material price will be 30% higher, 40% higher."
Order Book & Demand Outlook
- Defense fills the space gap: The order book has shifted composition, with defense now at ~70% while space has fallen to ~15-16% because supplies to space are mostly completed and the customer holds good inventory levels.
- ₹1,400-1,500 crores order book target: Management expects to build the order book to this level by year-end, with another ₹700 crores of orders "definitely" coming in the second half.
- PSLV orders in execution: Five PSLV orders from the L&T and HAL consortium have been received and are already being executed, with the entire supply to be finished this financial year.
- Space segment to stay quiet: Very few requirements are left in the space segment; management does not expect new orders until the customer consumes existing inventory.
- Gaganyaan nearly done: 90% of supplies for the Gaganyaan program are already completed, with only limited requirements still being executed.
Growth & Capacity Constraints
- 25% growth is the baseline: Management expects not less than 25% year-on-year growth if the trend continues, and believes similar growth is possible in FY25 and FY26.
- Capacity is the ceiling: Future growth is gated by existing capacity; capex has been invested and is ongoing, but any step-up in output will also require a step-up in working capital.
- Export ambition, domestic priority: The export target is around ₹200 crores this year, about 15% of expected turnover, but management is clear that meeting domestic strategic requirements comes first and exports will only scale with additional capacity.
- OEM supply chain entry initiated: The company has begun efforts to enter the supply chain of international aerospace OEMs, a key long-term growth vector.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "I think Midhani is strategically important for the country. So, I think our requirements come first."
Working Capital & Inventory Strain
- Inventory value inflated by raw material costs: Inventory increased by ₹248 crores, driven not just by tonnage but by the rising cost of raw metals; even maintaining the current tonnage level will keep inventory value elevated.
- No secondary market for strategic materials: Many materials produced have no secondary market or source to sell, and piled-up strategic materials like nickel and cobalt from inception are a persistent challenge to offload responsibly.
- Receivables stuck in government pipeline: Receivables are taking a long time because payments must come from the government, causing processing and submission delays, though the company is not taking any working capital loan despite this.
- No near-term inventory relief: Management does not see an immediate future improvement on inventory due to uncertainty, and some raw material inventory must be maintained to avoid production suffering.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "That's a big challenge because these are the strategic value, I rightly word put the strategy. And today, the world is very in a difficult critical situation. So these are strategic materials. First of all, you have to find out the buyer. And the buyers will be having no bad intention, which would be used for a constructive purpose."
Strategic Positioning & Transformation
- Aiming to be a leading aerospace material supplier: Management sees the company in complete transformation, targeting a position as a leading material supplier for aero engines and aerospace, both domestically and internationally.
- Market potential is large but competitive: Of an estimated ₹12,000 crores addressable market, management believes hardly 20-25% is for very exclusive products, and the rest will see significant competition.
- Titanium sponge supply is a single-source risk: Titanium sponge has a single supply source, demand is on the higher side, and indigenization efforts are underway but will take time and will not come at a low price initially.
- Nickel price may have cooled: Management notes that nickel prices have cooled down and expects this to continue for some time, though the geopolitical situation makes prediction tough.
Sanjay Kumar Jha: "I see that MIDHANI will be in the right place. But one thing is there that this industry is now and in very, I say, transformative state because of the change in the requirement of the materials in the different types. So we have to see that, and this is a time where investor has to put the confidence on us."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | Not less than 25% year-on-year growth | FY24, and similar for FY25/FY26 if trend continues |
| Order book build-up | Reach ₹1,400-1,500 crores | By FY24 year-end |
| Second-half order inflow | ₹700 crores of additional orders expected | Second half of FY24 |
| PAT recovery | Close the year at pandemic/pre-pandemic PAT levels of ~₹130 crores | FY24 year-end |
| Export revenue | Achieve ~₹200 crores in exports, ~15% of turnover | FY24 |
| PSLV supply completion | Entire supply for 5 PSLV orders finished | Within FY24 |
| Defense order book share | Defense to represent ~80% of orders | FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹227.48 cr, +25–26% YoY |
| H1 FY24 revenue growth | ~40% YoY |
| Value of Production (VOP) | +16% YoY |
| H1 FY24 VOP growth | +21% YoY |
| PBT/PAT | Decline vs Q2 FY23 and H1 FY23 |
| Raw material cost impact | >₹50 cr incremental impact in H1 FY24 |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | ~25% YoY |
| Order book | ~₹1,500 cr |
| H1 FY24 order inflow | ~₹720 cr |
| H2 FY24 expected order inflow | ~₹700 cr |
| Order book breakup: defense | ~70% |
| Order book breakup: space | ~15–16% |
| Revenue breakup: defense | 50–55% |
| Revenue breakup: space | 25% |
| Revenue breakup: energy | ~4% |
| Revenue breakup: export | 4% |
| FY24 export target | ~₹200 cr, 10–15% of expected turnover |
| Nickel price | ~₹2,100/kg in H1 FY24, up ~20% from ~₹1,700/kg in H1 FY23 |
| Titanium sponge price | ~₹1,300/kg, up from ₹700/kg previously |
| Wide Plate Mill sales | >₹100 cr in H1 FY24 |
| Rohtak armour factory revenue | ~₹60 cr in H1 FY24 |
| Working capital loan | ₹350 cr |
| FY24 capex | ₹100 cr drawn; balance ~₹80 cr to be done |
| Customer advances | ₹360 cr on books, of which ₹200 cr received in H1 FY24 |
| Inventory increase | +₹248 cr vs last year |
| Payables increase | ~₹150 cr, mostly raw material |
| Naval orders received in Q2 | ₹289 cr |
| Aero orders received in Q2 | ₹80 cr |
| Missile orders received in Q2 | ₹54 cr |
| Booked orders: special steel | ₹252 cr |
| Booked orders: superalloy | ₹171 cr |
| Booked orders: maraging steel | ₹151 cr |
| Booked orders: titanium alloy | ₹128 cr |