Key Takeaways
- Revenue miss, margin compression: Q4 revenue of ₹143 cr fell well short of the ₹170 cr guided, while FY24 EBITDA halved to ₹102.7 cr as order deferments and first-article costs hit operating leverage.
- FY25 growth guided at 30-35%: Management expects a sharp rebound, with 60% of revenue back-ended in H2, driven by nuclear, space, and MNC aerospace orders.
- Bloom transition is a double drag: Bloom Energy’s product mix shift and lower procurement volumes compressed revenue, while MTAR simultaneously spent heavily on first articles to diversify its customer base.
- Order book target of ₹1,500 cr: The pipeline is anchored by ₹500+ cr in upcoming nuclear tenders and new long-term aviation agreements, but clean energy orders remain a cautious, un-banked upside.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether nuclear tenders 5 and 6 open in June as expected, the pace of Bloom’s H2 order recovery, and any conversion of the unguided electrolyzer opportunity.
The Q4 Miss: What Broke and What Didn't
- ISRO semi-cryo engine delay: A last-minute technology-related issue on ISRO’s side required corrections in sub-assemblies, shifting the dispatch and its associated revenue into FY25.
- Gross margin held at 45%: The deferred space products are carried at cost, with price escalation clauses that will crystallize upon delivery, so the margin is intact and will be recognized in FY25.
- Value addition stuck in WIP: ₹25-30 cr of value addition was created in nuclear and space projects because raw materials arrived only in H2; those raw materials are now in place for FY25 execution.
- Cash flow turned sharply positive: Net operating cash flows improved to ₹57.4 cr from ₹7.4 cr, driven by monitoring steps, while receivable days fell to 93 from 132.
Srinivas Reddy: "See one of the reasons is on the Space sector we are supposed to dispatch our semi cryo engine which we are working on with ISRO. Now, there has been a small blip in that in terms of - I can't go into the details right now but it's mostly on the ISRO side in terms of the technology-related issues."
Bloom Energy: Transition Pain and Diversification
- Product mix shift underway: Bloom is transitioning to a higher-level model (Santa Cruz), which deferred shipments and reduced procurement volumes, lowering operating leverage for MTAR.
- FY25 hot box forecast at 3,300 units: Substantial orders are expected in H2, per Bloom’s communication, but management has not banked any electrolyzer upside in its guidance.
- Electrolyzer upside is unguided: 34 electrolyzers are to be dispatched partly this quarter and next, but fresh orders depend on Bloom winning its own orders; management calls any upside “an upset for the company which we have not taken.”
- Diversification is the offset: MTAR aims to bring Bloom’s revenue share down to 35-40% or less over three to four years, and has spent the last six months developing first articles for new MNC customers.
- AI data centres seen as a Bloom catalyst: Management flagged AI data centre build-out as a real upside for Bloom over the next three to six months, and a major long-term driver.
Srinivas Reddy: "And we have not plugged that number also into our business plan for this year. So, anything happens in terms of more number of hot boxes or the electrolyzers will be an upset for the company which we have not taken into this quarter. So we have been very cautious this time about what we are saying to all of you in terms of our guidance."
Order Pipeline: Nuclear, Space and Aviation
- Nuclear tenders 5 and 6 are imminent: Expected to open in June, with a combined opportunity of ₹500+ cr; execution would flow into the subsequent financial year.
- Tarapur reactor refurbishment: Expected in H2 of this year, with an order likely by year-end.
- Space orders continue: Another ₹70-80 cr of space orders are expected in the current financial year, on top of the deferred semi-cryo engine revenue.
- SSLV program is a 4-5 year build: MTAR is working with ISRO on a launch vehicle with a liquid propulsion engine, but no material revenue is expected until 2027-28.
- Aviation long-term agreements stacking up: A 15-year agreement with Israeli Aerospace Industries (₹9-12 cr) is signed, and two to three more long-term agreements are expected to flow in over the next two quarters.
Margin Path: First-Article Costs to Operating Leverage
- First-article spending compressed margins: Significant expenditure over the last six to nine months on developing products for customer diversification weighed on profitability, but these programs are expected to yield revenue and improved EBITDA as operations streamline.
- MNC aerospace margins start low: Initial margins of 20-22% are expected to improve over the next year as cycle times reduce and shop-floor operations mature.
- Operating leverage is the recovery engine: Margins are expected to improve progressively quarter-on-quarter as volumes increase, with management guiding to 22% EBITDA for FY25 and 24%+ for FY26.
- Working capital is tightening: NWC days targeted at 230 by FY25-end, down from 252, with raw material days already reduced to 118 from 154.
Srinivas Reddy: "It is a technology-based company and such blips are expected but on long-term we are always the winners and we strongly believe in that."
New Engines: Defense, Oil Field and Fluence
- Chief Commercial Officer onboarded: Arun Ojha (ex-Schlumberger, ALSTOM, L&T) is tasked with business development and MNC supply chain, and has already initiated discussions to diversify into the oil field sector.
- Defense license obtained: R&D is working on various products, with collaboration meetings planned for June; management is looking for partners aligned on margins.
- Fluence Energy partnership is domestic-first: Fluence will start with a domestic project, bidding on three tenders; if any tender is won, orders will come to MTAR, but nothing is factored into FY25 guidance.
- Hydrogen is a decade-out story: Management sees hydrogen-related locomotives as a 7-8 year timeline, and has no discussions yet with domestic electrolyzer customers, who still need to develop prototypes.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY25 revenue growth | 30% to 35% increase | FY25 full year |
| FY25 EBITDA margin | Around 22% | FY25 full year |
| FY26 revenue growth | Minimum 30% to 35% growth | FY26 full year |
| FY26 EBITDA margin | Close to 24% plus | FY26 full year |
| Order book | Closing order book of ₹1,500 crores | By March FY25 |
| NWC days | Reduce to 230 days | By end of FY25 |
| MNC Aerospace revenue | Close to ₹72 crores | FY25 |
| Nuclear tenders 5 and 6 | Expected to open | June 2024 |
| Tarapur refurbishment order | Expected by end of this year | H2 FY25 |
| Aviation long-term agreements | Two to three more agreements to flow in | Over the next two quarters |
| Bloom revenue share | Bring down to 35-40% or less | Over the next three to four years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹580.8 cr in FY24, versus ₹573.8 cr in FY23 |
| Q4 revenue | ₹143 cr, versus earlier guidance of ₹170 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹102.7 cr in FY24, versus ₹154 cr in FY23 |
| Profit before tax | ₹73 cr in FY24, versus ₹140.2 cr in FY23 |
| Profit after tax | ₹56.1 cr in FY24, versus ₹103.4 cr in FY23 |
| Net operating cash flow | ₹57.4 cr in FY24, versus ₹7.4 cr in FY23 |
| Q4 gross margin | ~45% |
| FY25 revenue growth guidance | 30% to 35% |
| FY25 EBITDA margin guidance | ~22% |
| FY26 revenue growth guidance | minimum 30% to 35%, with EBITDA margins close to 24% plus |
| FY26 revenue guidance | a little above ₹1,000 cr |
| Year-end order book | ₹915 cr |
| Expected closing order book by March FY25 | ₹1,500 cr |
| Bloom Energy hot boxes forecast for FY25 | 3,300 units, versus 2,752 units in FY24 |
| Bloom revenue growth component in FY25 guidance | hardly about 15% |
| NWC days | 252 days in FY24 |
| Receivable days | 93 days, versus 132 days in FY23 |
| RM days | 118 days in FY25, versus 154 days in FY23 |
| Target NWC days by end of FY25 | 230 days |
| Capex guidance for FY25 | ₹70 cr to ₹75 cr, including existing POs issued last year |
| Nuclear orders expected from tender 5 and 6 | ₹500+ cr |
| Tarapur reactor refurbishment order expected | ₹130 cr to ₹150 cr |
| Space orders expected in FY25 | ₹70 cr to ₹80 cr |
| MNC Aerospace Division revenue in FY24 | ₹8 cr |
| MNC Aerospace Division revenue expected in FY25 | close to about ₹72 cr |
| IAI long-term agreement value | ₹9 cr to ₹12 cr over the next 15 years |
| Value creation deepened in nuclear and space projects in FY24 | ₹25 cr to ₹30 cr |
| Cost of capital for working capital | 6% |
| US dollar loans cost of capital | not more than 8% or 7.5% |