Key Takeaways
- Volume engine protected at a cost: Nestlé India chose to absorb extraordinary commodity inflation rather than risk hollowing out its volume growth, compressing operating margins from 21% to 18.2% sequentially.
- Broad-based double-digit growth: First-half value growth of 13.3% was built on a roughly 50-50 mix of pricing and volume, with confectionery, beverages, and prepared dishes all growing strongly.
- Rural strategy is gaining traction: While off a low base, villages and small towns are now accepting Nestlé brands, delivering double-digit growth after years of investment in distribution and brand-building.
- Pet care and Gerber signal portfolio ambition: The proposed Purina business acquisition and the Gerber launch mark a deliberate expansion beyond the core, with pet care positioned as a future growth engine.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the early softening in edible oils and packaging materials translates into a margin recovery, and if the monsoon sustains rural demand momentum.
Volume-Led Growth Model Under Inflationary Stress
- Penetration-first philosophy: The company has pursued penetration-led volume growth for seven years, believing that without penetration there is no volume, no growth, and no sustainability.
- Volume protection trade-off: In the face of "quite extraordinary" inflation, management prioritized protecting its engine of growth over managing for the quarter, sustaining volume and mix-led growth despite steep input cost increases.
- Value growth composition: First-half value growth of 13.3% comprised a 6.3% consumer price impact and approximately 7% volume growth, reflecting a deliberate 50-50 balance rather than aggressive pricing.
- Pricing restraint logic: Management consciously chose not to go more aggressive on pricing to avoid triggering significant down-trading or consumers moving out of brands during heightened economic distress, using analytics to assess elasticities and transaction losses.
- Commodity inflation at 5X normal: Commodity inflation hit 15% in 2022 versus a 3% CAGR during 2018 to 2020, causing a short-term impact on profit from operations that management describes as a necessary cost of protecting the long-term growth model.
- Margin compression: Profit from operations margin declined sequentially from 21% to 18.2%, with management declining to give forward guidance on margin evolution by quarter or category.
- Margin recovery path: Management stated that when sitting at 5X inflation and maxing out on the balance between margin and price increases, the only way to increase margins significantly is when prices also start to relent, not just by playing the cost efficiency game. If softening continues on a sustained basis and good monsoons arrive, that will have a salutary impact on milk, wheat, and other crops.
Narayanan: "It is not managing for the quarter, it is managing for the long term and as you know very well Nestlé is a long-term company, we are not a short-term company we are not here for a quarter, we have been here for over a hundred years."
Category Performance
| Category | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Confectionery | ▲ Strong | Grew 24.4%; KitKat (80-year-old brand) growing double digits, as is Munch and the rest of the portfolio. |
| Beverages | ▲ Strong | Nescafe and associated brands grew 21.7%. |
| Prepared Dishes & Cooking Aids | ▲ Strong | Maggi continues strong at 13.9% growth. |
| Milk Products & Nutrition | ▲ Solid | Grew 7.2%; Milkmaid (156-year-old brand) had one of the fastest growth rates in the first half, driven by brand resilience and ecommerce salience. |
| Dairy Nutrition | ▲ Double-digit | Grew in double digits this quarter; brand Milkmaid "really took off." |
| Innovation contribution | ▬ Modest | Products launched since 2015 contributed approximately 5.6% of sales in the first half, as focus during this period was on protecting the core rather than significantly expanding the portfolio. |
- Premium brands resilient: Some premium brands are doing extremely well in the post-pandemic context, contrary to expectations that they would perform miserably.
- Ceregrow traction: One of the fastest growing brands in the toddler segment because it offers credible nutrition with perceptible performance changes in the child's overall health as seen by mothers.
Rural and Geographic Expansion
- Mega cities normalizing: Mega cities (population above 0.4 crore) were adversely affected in 2021 due to pandemic impact on markets and distribution; they are now normalizing with growth on the uptake.
- Metros and small towns: Cities between 0.1 crore to 0.4 crore population are showing double-digit growth, while town classes 1 and 2 (below 10 lakhs and below 6 lakhs population respectively) are also growing handsomely in double digits.
- Rural markets gaining acceptance: Villages covered (70,000 to 80,000 out of a target of 120,000 villages with above 2,000 population) are showing an uptick, with growth rates of 9%, 15%, and 30.7%. Brands are getting accepted in rural markets over the last three to four quarters, building traction through infrastructure, investments, brands, and communication.
- Rural activation model: The company has kickstarted rural activation using 'haats' and other rural activities, with starter packs, mid-sized price packs, and larger packs being deployed for rural geographies.
- Exports dialling up: Third-party exports grew about 10% during the second quarter, with good traction on the portfolio relevant to the Indian diaspora. The company will be dialling up exports of the relevant South Asian portfolio to key markets such as Maggi noodles and Maggi sauces to the US.
Narayanan: "I have a lower base in rural markets, and I think we have accelerated our rural strategy that is beginning to uptake and penetration is happening in those markets. But what you need to read in this is the acceptance of Nestlé in rural markets to accelerate the growth. Please do not get carried away by percentage numbers because I am speaking of a low base."
Portfolio Expansion: Pet Care and Gerber
- Purina business scale-up: The pet care business grew from INR 11.5 cr in 2018 to INR 31.2 cr in 2021, with 2022 expected at INR 46.3 cr plus, built on infrastructure across 46 towns, 50 distributors, and 185 suppliers. Growth accelerated from 68% in 2021 to 51% in H1 2022.
- Purina acquisition proposed: Nestlé India will take on the Purina pet care business from Nestlé SA's wholly owned subsidiary Purina Petcare India, after the parent invested INR 126 cr to establish it. All executive directors abstained from voting on the proposition.
- Distribution acceleration logic: Acceleration will happen by consolidating pet shop presence and leveraging Nestlé India's distribution heft across modern outlets and traditional trade, which is far more than what Purina Petcare India could create in the next five years.
- Pet care market opportunity: The category is INR 4,000 cr growing at 25%, with pet ownership growing at 11% across town classes. Dry dog food represents 75% of the segment, while wet cat food is growing at 35%.
- Gerber launch in India: The Gerber brand launched in 2022 with a product that is 'made in India' at a nutrition factory and 'made for India,' customized to Indian toddlers' nutrition needs. The range combines cereals, legumes, milk, fruits, and vegetables with age-appropriate fortification.
- Gerber community ambition: The brand seeks to build communities around cohorts of nutrition-interested mothers, with an ambition for co-creation with consumers rather than unilateral brand communication.
- Nestlé Health Science on the horizon: The company will dial up adult nutrition products for diabetics, protein supplementation, and obesity, but will start small and choose which categories to invest in because it cannot invest in 20 different categories at the same time.
Narayanan: "I think a hallmark of trust and transparency of organization is the capability and the shedding of its ego to revisit the assumptions of its original business case. And that is what we're doing today."
Commodity Outlook and Cost Management
- Early softening in select inputs: Some softening observed in the edible oil complex and packaging materials.
- Persistent firmness elsewhere: Fresh milk, fuels, wheat, grains, and green coffee are expected to remain firm. Wheat is reaching all-time high prices due to low stocks and a question mark on monsoon quality.
- Cost efficiency continues: There is an unrelenting focus on "shark savings" and operational efficiency savings; none of that has stopped.
- Monsoon as a swing factor: If a good monsoon continues, the company can look forward to some exacerbation of commodity cost hopefully, but also demand generation that will be fairly encouraging. A sustained softening plus good monsoons would have a salutary impact on milk, wheat, and other crops.
Narayanan: "It does not mean that suddenly margins will become magical as you go forward. We have to live through this for a while."
Brand Equity and Pricing Philosophy
- Brand equity over pricing power: Management does not call the company's ability to take price the brand's pricing power; it calls it the power of brand equity that sustains the company over time.
- Growth resilience on a higher base: 16.4% growth was achieved on an earlier higher base because of brand equity and sophisticated decision-making models using analytics to assess elasticities and transaction losses from price increases.
- Brand architecture working: The existing brand architecture seems to be working quite well; brands are robust and elastic enough to take into account different purchasing powers, income segments, and opportunities. No recruiter brands are planned as of now, but if an opportunity arises in any category, the company may look at it.
- Rural portfolio customization: As the company moves forward, there will be opportunities for customization in terms of pack sizes for rural geographies, but it is "first best and prudent to work with the portfolio that you have got and then modify it over a period of time."
Narayanan: "The day we start having volume declines that are sharp, irrespective of the value growth that I will show, irrespective of the profit growth that I will show, I will be having a system that is getting hollowed out and is getting eaten from within."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Village coverage expansion | Cover 120,000 villages with above 2,000 population, up from current 70,000 to 80,000 | No date given |
| Purina distribution acceleration | Leverage Nestlé India's distribution heft across modern outlets and traditional trade to accelerate growth | Post-acquisition completion |
| Gerber community building | Build communities around cohorts of nutrition-interested mothers; co-creation with consumers | Ongoing from launch |
| Nestlé Health Science rollout | Dial up adult nutrition products, starting small and choosing categories selectively | No date given |
| Export expansion | Dial up exports of South Asian portfolio to Indian diaspora in key markets | Ongoing |
| Margin recovery condition | Margins increase significantly only when input prices also start to relent, not just from cost efficiency; sustained softening and good monsoons required | Conditional on commodity cycle |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Domestic sales growth | 16.4%, 8.5% pricing and 7.9% volume |
| Consolidated sales growth | 12.7% (first half) |
| Value growth | 13.3% (first half), 6.3% pricing and 7% volume |
| Volume and mix CAGR | 8.1% (last 5 years) |
| Profit from operations | Down 2.9% (first half) |
| Profit from operations margin | 18.2%, down from 21% sequentially |
| Net profit | Down 2.7% (first half) |
| Earnings per share | Down 2.7% (first half) |
| Milk Products and Nutrition growth | 7.2% (first half) |
| Prepared Dishes and Cooking Aids growth | 13.9% (first half) |
| Confectionery growth | 24.4% (first half) |
| Powdered and Liquid Beverages growth | 21.7% (first half) |
| Innovation as a percentage of sales | ~5.6% (first half), from products launched since 2015 |
| Commodity inflation | 15% in 2022, 5X the CAGR of 2018–2020 |
| Purina pet care growth | 51% in H1 2022, accelerated from 68% in 2021 |
| E-commerce contribution | 6.4% of Nestlé overall sales, 14% for Purina |