Key Takeaways
- PAT surges on JV profits, not operations: Standalone PAT rose 16.6% YoY in Q2, but the real driver was a jump in JV profit share from ₹120 crore to ₹1,082 crore, while total income declined slightly.
- Coal security is tightening: Coal materialization against ACQ slipped to 95.8% from 99.9% YoY, and station coal stocks are a thin 8.5 days, though captive production hit a record 16.1 MMT in H1.
- A 25.2 GW thermal pipeline is taking shape: Management plans to award 11.2 GW of new thermal capacity by next fiscal, on top of 10 GW already under construction, with orders for 5.6 GW expected by September 2024.
- Renewables are scaling but the listing is distant: 7.3 GW of RE is under construction with a visible pipeline exceeding 20 GW, yet the green entity listing is still 1.5 to 2 years away, timed to a critical mass of commissioned capacity.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether coal stocks recover from end-October as guided, the pace of order placement for the 11.2 GW thermal pipeline, and any update on the FY26 capex number before the budget.
The JV Profit Surge: A One-Off or Structural Shift?
- JV profit share exploded: NTPC's share of JV profit rose from ₹120.57 crore in H1 FY23 to ₹1,082.25 crore in H1 FY24, a jump of nearly ₹961 crore that single-handedly drove the consolidated PAT outperformance.
- BIFPCL commissioning was a key contributor: The Bangladesh-India Friendship Power Company plant, which achieved COD effective 23 December 2022, added materially to the consolidated results this year.
- Subsidiary profits also climbed: Subsidiaries profit increased 28.78% YoY, contributing roughly ₹250 crore of the consolidated vs standalone PAT gap.
- The gap should normalize at 15-20%: Management estimates the consolidated-to-standalone PAT gap will settle in the 15-20% range going forward, including FY25, though it cautioned that yearly interplays make precision difficult.
Management: "It would only be fair to assume it would be around 15-20% but depends on several factors."
Coal: Record Captive Output Meets Tight Inventory
- Captive production hit an all-time high: NTPC produced 16.1 MMT of coal in H1 FY24, an 83% jump from 8.76 MMT in H1 FY23, as the mining subsidiary ramps up for greater fuel security.
- But external supply is slipping: Coal materialization against ACQ fell to 95.80% from 99.93% YoY, and total coal supply was flat at 113 MMT despite a sharp drop in imported coal from 10 MMT to 4 MMT.
- Station stocks are uncomfortably thin: Coal inventory stands at around 8.5 days across NTPC stations, with non-pithead stations particularly tight, though management expects a pickup from end-October onwards.
- Grid restrictions are worsening: Generation loss due to grid restrictions rose to 4,600 crore Units from 4,000 crore Units YoY, while fuel-related loss became negligible.
- NML won a new coal block: NTPC Mining Limited was declared preferred bidder for the North Dhadu (East) coal mine with an estimated geological reserve of 439 MMT, adding to the fuel security pipeline.
Thermal: A 25 GW Build-Out Is Taking Shape
- 11.2 GW of new thermal capacity to be awarded by next fiscal: Management is actively considering awarding this capacity, split 50:50 between NTPC standalone and JVs, with tendering to happen progressively over the next 12 months.
- Order placement timeline is specific: Singrauli 1,600 MW by December 2023, Sipat 800 MW by February 2024, Darlipalli 800 MW by June 2024, and Meja 2,400 MW by September 2024, with Telangana Phase-II, Obra Expansion and Anapara to follow progressively in FY25.
- Commissioning schedule is back-end loaded: This year will see a further 1,480 MW, next financial year 5,240 MW, and FY26 roughly 1,764 MW of thermal capacity added.
- Execution faces structural headwinds: The first two years of a thermal project are dominated by civil work, and four months of rainy season effectively removes eight months from the schedule; logistics issues like a generator stator stuck for eight months add further unpredictability.
- Talcher Thermal is a bright spot: Awarded last year, the project is running four months ahead of schedule after 14 months of work, showing that acceleration is possible.
Management: "As an optimist project manager I am saying it is there, the scope is always there, and we will try everything to do it. But in Indian context, I will tell you, there are some basic problems that we face."
Renewables: Scaling Fast, Listing Later
- 7.3 GW under construction, 20 GW visible pipeline: NTPC has secured tenders and bilateral tie-ups for another 10 GW beyond the 7,258 MW already under construction, with a near-term visible pipeline exceeding 20 GW.
- Target is 15 GW by FY26, 60 GW by FY32: The company aims to add roughly 5 GW of renewable capacity every year, with all 50 GW of bid completion targeted by end-March.
- Q2 renewable addition was nil: Clearances for sourcing modules from outside India were obtained only towards the end of Q1, delaying commissioning; under-construction projects are targeted for completion within a maximum of 24 months.
- Green entity listing is 1.5-2 years away: Management is working toward unlocking value via stake sale or IPO but will time it only when a critical mass of commissioned capacity is on the ground, exploring market conditions before deciding.
- Multiple MoUs signed for RE and Green Hydrogen: Partnerships with UPRVUNL, HMEL, and a consortium of ONGC and OIL cover renewable projects, Green Hydrogen derivatives, and even geothermal exploration.
Management: "We will be working on that and by year and a half or two years there should be a substantial capacity on ground, but when we reach a certain critical mass, we will time it."
Pumped Storage: A 14 GW Ambition with a Long Fuse
- 14,000 MW of pumped storage at various stages: About 6,000 MW has been identified by the Government of India, with NTPC targeting 5,300 MW of that; the company has self-identified another 8,500 MW across Himachal, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Meghalaya, Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat.
- 4,100 MW is "agreed de facto": Tamil Nadu is going for cabinet approval, and MOUs have been signed for projects including ~3,100 MW in Meghalaya.
- THDC's 1,000 MW pump hydro is imminent: The first unit is expected by January or latest February, with the entire 1,000 MW commissioned by FY25.
- Construction timeline is 6-8 years: Initial work takes two to three years for studies, and construction takes 3.5 to 4.5 years; the most conservative view is 7-8 years from today, the most optimistic up to six years.
- Development model is cost-plus with regulated ROE: Projects will follow the same return on equity as allowed under regulation for hydro projects, keeping storage costs at ₹3.50 to ₹4.00 per unit depending on project type and location.
Management: "Storage is the cost which is in my control. So that will be of the order of ₹3.50 to ₹4.00 depending on the type of project and location."
Financial Health: Capex Rising, Borrowing Costs Creeping Up
- Capex is on an upward trajectory: FY24 group capex target has been revised up to ₹28,373 crore from the ₹27,000 crore mentioned in Q1; FY25 will remain almost in the same range and then "zoom further."
- H1 capex was lower YoY: Group capex in H1 FY24 was ₹13,203.60 crore, down from ₹16,664.19 crore in H1 FY23, implying a significantly back-end loaded second half.
- Average borrowing cost is rising: The cost of borrowing increased to 6.67% from 6.22% YoY, though NTPC signed a ₹5,000 crore term loan with HDFC Bank in the quarter.
- Fixed cost under recovery is manageable: Q2 saw ₹381 crore of under recovery due to scheduled overhauls being taken during the season, but management expects this to narrow to around ₹200 crore by year-end as generation catches up.
- Dividend income declined: Dividend income fell to ₹549.98 crore from ₹640.94 crore YoY, a headwind partially offset by the JV profit surge.
Management: "Yes, we keep on going upwards only and that is a growing company."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Thermal capacity award | 11.2 GW to be tendered (50% standalone, 50% JVs) | Progressively over next 12 months |
| Thermal order placement | Singrauli 1,600 MW, Sipat 800 MW, Darlipalli 800 MW, Meja 2,400 MW | Dec 2023, Feb 2024, Jun 2024, Sep 2024 respectively |
| Thermal capacity commissioning | 1,480 MW this year, 5,240 MW next FY, ~1,764 MW in FY26 | FY24, FY25, FY26 |
| Renewable bid completion | All 50 GW bids to be completed | By end-March |
| Renewable capacity target | 15 GW commissioned | By FY26 |
| Renewable capacity target | 60 GW commissioned | By end-FY32 |
| Pumped storage (THDC) | First unit of 1,000 MW project | January or latest February |
| Pumped storage (THDC) | Entire 1,000 MW commissioned | By FY25 |
| Fixed cost under recovery | Narrow to ~₹200 crore | By FY24 year-end |
| Consolidated vs standalone PAT gap | 15-20% range | FY25 and going forward |
| FY24 capex | ₹28,373 crore (group) | FY24 |
| FY25 capex | Remaining almost in same range as FY24 | FY25 |
| Green entity listing | Stake sale or IPO after reaching critical mass | 1.5 to 2 years |
| FGD systems | Commission for entire operational and under-construction capacity | Over next 3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total Income (standalone) | ₹41,517.87 cr, vs ₹41,810.96 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| PAT (standalone) | ₹3,885.01 cr, +16.62% YoY vs ₹3,331.20 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Adjusted PAT (standalone) | ₹3,497 cr, vs ₹3,601 cr in Q2 FY23 and ₹3,794 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| Group PAT (H1 FY24) | ₹9,633.53 cr, +30.26% YoY vs ₹7,395.44 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Regulated equity (standalone) | ₹81,498 cr as on 30 Sep 2023 |
| Regulated equity (group) | ₹98,050 cr as on 30 Sep 2023 |
| Average cost of borrowing (H1 FY24) | 6.67%, vs 6.22% in H1 FY23 |
| Group CAPEX (H1 FY24) | ₹13,203.60 cr, vs ₹16,664.19 cr in H1 FY23; FY24 target ₹28,373 cr |
| Fixed cost under recovery | ₹381 cr in Q2; full-year estimate near ₹200 cr |
| Commercial capacity (standalone) | 57,838 MW as on 30 Sep 2023 |
| Commercial capacity (group) | 73,824 MW as on 30 Sep 2023 |
| Group generation (H1 FY24) | 21,200 crore Units, +4% YoY vs 20,400 crore Units in H1 FY23 |
| PLF of coal stations (H1 FY24) | 76.62%, vs National Average of 68.75% |
| Coal production from captive mines (H1 FY24) | 1.61 crore MT, +83% YoY vs 8.76 MMT in H1 FY23 |
| Renewable capacity commissioned | 3,314 MW; 7,258 MW under construction; visible pipeline of more than 20 GW |
| Renewable capacity target | 15 GW by FY26, long-term target 60 GW by end of FY32 |
| Thermal capacity addition planned for award | 11.2 GW by next fiscal, in addition to 10 GW already under construction |
| Pumped storage capacity identified | ~14,000 MW across multiple states, at various stages of development |