Key Takeaways
- Volume-led revenue decline, margin held: Revenue fell 8.4% YoY and volume 8.8% YoY as excess industry inventory and subdued demand weighed on primary sales, yet EBITDA margin was maintained at 20.8% through cost control.
- Inventory correction is the real story: Company inventory days improved from 150 to 105 days, and secondary sales outperformed primary, signalling the destocking cycle is past its worst phase.
- Distribution hygiene reset underway: ARS adoption is largely complete, but bloated distributor inventory is still being worked down; rationalization of post-COVID MBO expansion in smaller towns is mostly done.
- Competitive intensity remains high: Discounting pressure across the industry is "intense" and management calls it unsustainable, while holding its own line on schemes and incentives.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the festive season converts secondary momentum into primary order uplift, the pace of distributor inventory normalization, and any signal on volume trajectory improvement.
Demand & Volume Pressure
- Broad-based softness, not share loss: The 8.8% volume decline reflects macro headwinds and an industry-wide inventory glut, not competitive displacement. Management asserts the brand has not lost out to competition given its respect, products, and distribution network.
- Consumer wallet under strain: Ticket size or quantities bought have reduced as health, education, and rental costs rose without matching salary increases, and the IT sector remains stressed. This is a general spend control, not a downgrade to cheaper brands.
- Festive timing amplified the base effect: Last year's festive season fell within Q2, making the YoY comparison tougher; this year's delayed festivities pushed demand into Q3.
- EBOs as a market barometer: Exclusive brand outlets recorded de-growth, though comparatively lower than the company level because EBOs have been on ARS longer and carry healthier inventory.
- Online channel a bright spot: E-commerce grew 31% in H1, driven by changing consumer behaviour and D2C initiatives, with growth spread across categories rather than concentrated in any one segment.
V. S. Ganesh: "If you see our de-growth has been in line with the general economy and the market trend, we are not lost out to competition because of that because the brand has a respect, and we also powered by amazing products and we also enjoy a very good distribution network."
Inventory & Channel Correction
- Company inventory materially lighter: Inventory reduced from ₹1,595.3 crore at Q4 FY23 end to ₹1,361.9 crore, with days improving from 150 to 105. The reduction was achieved by cutting production and subcontracting in line with lower demand.
- Secondary sales leading the recovery: Secondaries have done well and are slightly better than primary sales, indicating inventory correction is happening at the distributor level. Management says the company has crossed the difficult phase of corrections.
- Distributor inventory still high but improving: There has been a substantial improvement in the number of days distributors are holding, though it varies by region and category. Better logistics and reduced lead times are helping distributors tighten inventories.
- ARS impact now behind: The ARS-related inventory bloat hit hardest in the first quarter. Once inventory falls below the tank size, ARS stops being a drag, and not much ARS impact was felt in Q2. Hygiene will take time to fully kick in.
- MBO rationalization largely complete: Post-COVID expansion into Tier 2/3 cities saw rapid outlet additions that reversed when consumers returned to offices. In towns below 50,000 population, the rationalization to a sustainable 3-4 outlets is more or less done.
- No extra incentives deployed: Management has not succumbed to market pressure to sweeten schemes or incentives, staying with what it usually does.
V. S. Ganesh: "We never succumb to the pressure of the market to sweeten anything and go over and beyond what we usually do."
Margins & Cost Management
- EBITDA margin defended at 20.8%: Operational expense optimization and stable raw material costs offset the revenue decline. The company remains comfortable in its stated 19% to 21% range and is confident of maintaining it.
- Gross margin lag on raw material benefit: Despite low-cost inventory on hand, gross margins are lower YoY because weighted average costing delays the P&L flow-through of lower raw material prices. Sewing efficiency improvements are providing a partial offset.
- Employee cost down via attrition freeze: Natural attrition and a recruitment freeze reduced employee costs; the normal annual increment has already flowed in. The decline is not from lower variable cost provisioning, which is done pro rata on budgeted performance.
- Subcontracting cut to match production: Other expenses fell partly because lower production meant less subcontracting conversion work, a direct consequence of managing inventory and demand.
- No price action planned this year: With stable product prices and operational cost optimization, management sees no need for price changes in the current financial year, though inflationary pressures beyond plan could force a different call.
- A&P spend to stay in the 4-5% band: Certain advertising expenses are planned for the second half, and the company will remain in its usual range of 4% to 5% of sales. The company is no longer media dark.
Competitive Landscape & Industry Practices
- Discounting remains intense: Management confirms discounting pressure has not moderated from Q1 and "even as we speak, it continues to be intense." The problem of bloated inventories spans categories, including innerwear, with peers running schemes and promotions to liquidate stock.
- Unsustainable practices called out: Management views the current industry discounting as not a sustainable long-term business practice and believes it cannot last for long.
- D2C strength as a moat: The company recognized the significance of the D2C space early and has built a very strong arm, with CRM initiatives that match any new-age D2C brand. This is positioned as a defence against digital-native competition.
- Women's innerwear gaining traction: Growth is driven by product and price positioning, the "Knows me" campaign creating awareness, and work with store associates to make them solution providers, especially for the bra category.
V. S. Ganesh: "I don't feel it is something which is a very sustainable long-term business practice. It can't last for long."
Distribution & Channel Strategy
- Network scale intact: As of September-end, the network stands at over 112,000 MBOs, 1,370 EBOs, and more than 2,400 large-format stores.
- Tremendous headroom for expansion: Men's innerwear market penetration is still in the teens, and other categories are in single digits. The company is larger than the next three competitors combined in most categories. Expansion will continue alongside work to make distributors profitable through better inventory health.
- Online mix expected to rise: Management would not be surprised if online reaches high teens or late teens as a share of revenue in four to five years, though the organization must remain agile given the volatile environment. The online business splits into B2B (largest), marketplace, and jockey.in, though no numerical breakup was provided.
- Primary-secondary gap to close: Going forward, secondary and primary sales should level out now that the difficult phase of corrections is past.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Inventory optimization | Reach optimal inventory levels | By year-end |
| EBITDA margin range | Maintain 19% to 21% | Ongoing |
| A&P spend range | Stay within 4% to 5% of sales | Second half FY24 |
| No price action | No price changes planned unless inflation exceeds plan | Current financial year |
| Distribution expansion | Continue expanding MBO, EBO, and large-format presence | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,125.1 cr, -8.4% YoY |
| Volume | 5.18 cr pieces, -8.8% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹233.5 cr, -1.8% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 20.8%, maintained YoY through operational expense optimization and stable raw material costs |
| Profit after tax | ₹150.3 cr, -7.3% YoY |
| PAT margin | 13.4% |
| H1 revenue | ₹2,357.5 cr, -7.6% YoY |
| H1 volume | 10.77 cr pieces, -10.2% YoY |
| H1 EBITDA | ₹475.4 cr, -11.2% YoY |
| H1 profit after tax | ₹308.6 cr, -16.4% YoY |
| E-commerce growth (H1) | 31% |
| Inventory | ₹1,361.9 cr, down from ₹1,595.3 cr at end of Q4 FY23 |
| Inventory days | 105 days, improved from 150 days at end of Q4 FY23 |
| Net working capital | ₹879.9 cr, compared with ₹768 cr at end of Q4 FY23 |
| Working capital days | 68 days, was 59 days at end of Q4 FY23 |
| MBO network | Over 112,000, declined ~2,300 touch points QoQ |
| EBO network | 1,370 |
| Large-format stores | More than 2,400 |
| Finished goods inventory | ₹698 cr |
| Raw material inventory | ₹270 cr |
| A&P spend guidance | 4% to 5% of sales, usual range for full year |